4870 2GB vs 4890 1GB

chronox12

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 18, 2008
Messages
127
I'm planning to buy this monitor for gaming http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824254026 with a budget of $300 and I was wondering which video card to purchase. My options are http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814102826 or any 4890. Just wondering which would you choose and why. I was previously counting the 4850 X2 as an option but I'm tired of hearing about it being a hit or miss card. My pal got one last Saturday and he's been having issues constantly with it. Thanks in advance for the input.
 
I think 2GB would be a waste for a single GPU 4870.

Also costco has the hannsg 28" for sale, I just bought one in January.
329.99 + Shipping & Handling $19.99

http://www.costco.com/Browse/Product.aspx?Prodid=11236988&search=hannsg&Mo=2&cm_re=1_en-_-Top_Left_Nav-_-Top_search&lang=en-US&Nr=P_CatalogName:BC&Sp=S&N=5000043&whse=BC&Dx=mode+matchallpartial&Ntk=Text_Search&Dr=P_CatalogName:BC&Ne=4000000&D=hannsg&Ntt=hannsg&No=2&Ntx=mode+matchallpartial&Nty=1&topnav=&s=1

This way if you get any dead pixels, etc, it is very easy to return to your B&M costco.
 
I think 2GB would be a waste for a single GPU 4870.

This way if you get any dead pixels, etc, it is very easy to return to your B&M costco.

Just wondering how is the 2GB a waste for a single GPU? I thought the extra memory would come in handy especially for games like GTA IV. The 4850 X2 has 2GB in crossfire so is that better? Also I'm purchasing the monitor from outside the US so I'm not sure if it'll make a difference where I order it. Thanks for the extra info though :) Much appreciated.
 
I would go for a 4890. With the vast majority of games it will win over a 4870 2GB. The only reason to go with a 4870 2GB is if you're someone who plays only GTA IV. I wouldn't bother with the 4850X2 either.
 
The HD 4870 2gb isn't useless for Crossfire setups as you'd actually get 2gb of useful ram then vs 2x 1gb cards giving you 1gb of useable ram. If you plan to go Crossfire down the road the HD 4870 2gb may be the way to go as you'll then have a way to make both those GPU's pull thier weight with a proper ammount of mem to put those GPU's to good use @ high res.
 
The HD 4870 2gb isn't useless for Crossfire setups as you'd actually get 2gb of useful ram then vs 2x 1gb cards giving you 1gb of useable ram. If you plan to go Crossfire down the road the HD 4870 2gb may be the way to go as you'll then have a way to make both those GPU's pull thier weight with a proper ammount of mem to put those GPU's to good use @ high res.

QFT
I wouldn't pay more for a 2gb 4870 though. If your playing at a high res and like AA, like we all do that 2gb 4870 would be sweet. Those 4870s pull off an insane amount of AA as well and imo have better image quality than a Nvidia card.
 
QFT
I wouldn't pay more for a 2gb 4870 though. If your playing at a high res and like AA, like we all do that 2gb 4870 would be sweet.
That's why I was considering a 2GB card to begin with. 4850 X2 was my first option until it received so much bad reviews in terms of issues with the card and well the vapor x was the only other ATI card I've seen with 2GB within my budget. The monitor is 28" so I'm definitely going to be using AA to hide those jagged edges.
 
That's why I was considering a 2GB card to begin with. 4850 X2 was my first option until it received so much bad reviews in terms of issues with the card and well the vapor x was the only other ATI card I've seen with 2GB within my budget. The monitor is 28" so I'm definitely going to be using AA to hide those jagged edges.

I should have added in crossfire. In some cases the 2gb card will be better by itself and in most cases the 4890 will be better as a single card based on the very few benches that I've seen with the 2gb 4870. I'll look up some more.

I know the feeling I picked up the 25" HansG 1920x1080 and that thing needs AA, That 27" should be along the same lines. I would be a little nervous about running 4850s in cf, myself I've heard more complaints about 4850s in cf than any other multi gpu setup other than the Nvidia sandwichs.
 
Ye, I'm one of those 4850x2 horror stories. I got one during the xmas rush and the thing had driver issues out the wazzou with windows disabling one vga adapter. Ye, I'd probably get a 4890 the oc capabilities are crazy, though i've seen some review sites show that the oc'd cards show little to no improvements, where as other sites show modest gains in OC performance on pre-oc'd cards.
 
Im not sure if you said what resolution you are running, but I'd guess that you'd be better off with a 4890 in every case unless you were planning to build a 4870 2gb crossfire, but then it would probably still be outclassed heavily by a 4890 cross fire which wouldnt be all that much more anyway. So I vote for the 4890.
 
yeah, the 4870 2gb is a marketing ploy.

Hmm, interesting comment considering noone has compared 4890 crossfire to 4870 2gb crossfire yet. I wonder what will happen in high res when the 4890 has 1gb ram to use vs the 4870's 2gb of useable ram. . . . hmmmm can't wait to see that benchmark.

Oh, GTA4 is simply the first game to make use of more than 1gb vram and you can bet your sweet ass it won't be the last so I guess if you absolutely hate patches that let you use more than 1gb ram you can get owned in the first FPS that lets you get scoped by someone you can't even see because your view distance sux compared to the guy with the 2gb 4870 thats getting ready to pop your head like a zit in "CoD6 : WWIII Apocolypse now ( Directors cut super special frag your neighbor edition )"

seriously though, I want to see a 4890 xfire vs 4870 2gb Xfire review that proves the 4890 is the better route to take.
 
Last edited:
Oh, GTA4 is simply the first game to make use of more than 1gb vram and you can bet your sweet ass it won't be the last so I guess if you absolutely hate patches that let you use more than 1gb ram you can get owned in the first FPS that lets you get scoped by someone you can't even see because your view distance sux compared to the guy with the 2gb 4870 thats getting ready to pop your head like a zit in "CoD6 : WWIII Apocolypse now ( Directors cut super special frag your neighbor edition )"

what?

even in crysis, the most graphic intensive game on the market and it can play perfectly fine on 1gb vram, you dont need anything more because by the time games start using 1.5gb ram, something more powerfull will be out.
 
what?

even in crysis, the most graphic intensive game on the market and it can play perfectly fine on 1gb vram, you dont need anything more because by the time games start using 1.5gb ram, something more powerfull will be out.

dot
 
what?

even in crysis, the most graphic intensive game on the market and it can play perfectly fine on 1gb vram, you dont need anything more because by the time games start using 1.5gb ram, something more powerfull will be out.

You sure about that? I thought that was FC2 now? And considering GTA IV uses more than 1gb with all the settings 100% Maxxed out at hi res proves that you specifically are wrong and your arguments are nullified.

To anyone else though I still say, show me the benchmarks with Crossfire 4890's and Crossfire 4870 2gb's and we'll see.
 
well.....i understand what you mean, but GTA IV is a console port. The fact that it can use more than 1 gig of vram means that there is something fishy going on in the conversion from console to PC. Bad example. So far the benchmarks show that a 4870 1gb and 4870 2gb yield pretty much the exact same results. By the time 2gb of VRAM will be utilized, there will be much better GPU's out.
 
You sure about that? I thought that was FC2 now? And considering GTA IV uses more than 1gb with all the settings 100% Maxxed out at hi res proves that you specifically are wrong and your arguments are nullified.

To anyone else though I still say, show me the benchmarks with Crossfire 4890's and Crossfire 4870 2gb's and we'll see.


and to you i say go read the difference between an 8800GT with 512MB and 1GB, neither have any difference (just like what you will see with the 4870)
 
After doing some reading it seems the 4890 1GB would be the better purchase. Now it's just a matter of which one :) I'm staying far from the Sapphire brand though. I've had bad experiences in the past.
 
show me the benchmarks with Crossfire 4890's and Crossfire 4870 2gb's and we'll see.

When the 4890 1GB is consistently significantly faster than the 4870 2GB, it is highly unlikely that crossfire will change the situation.

It's like claiming that 4850 1GB in crossfire is going to be faster than 4870 512MB in crossfire. While I'm not able to find that comparison anywhere besides the wildly invalid Toms Hardware charts, I don't think anyone believes that. More RAM just doesn't have as much impact on performance as higher clock speeds do, especially when you're starting with such a large amount as 1GB.
 
a 4870 2GB in crossfire is not going to be any better than a 4870 1GB in crossfire because not even a single card is going to use all 1GB so why would 2 be able to use it. There's simply not enough power there to max one set of memory, 2 cards isn't going to matter since the other card has it's own memory. I've read people saying that "you need to run 2 cards to max the memory" ... if the picture is cut in half and the memory pool isn't even shared, how is it going to make a difference? If 1 card runs at maximum of resolution X and you just double that resolution and run 2 cards, you're not using anymore memory per card.

This goes right back to people buying a 9600GT 512 over a 8800GT 256. Just because there is more memory doesn't mean it's all of a sudden a better card.
 
Last edited:
a 4870 2GB in crossfire is not going to be any better than a 4870 1GB in crossfire because not even a single card is going to use all 1GB so why would 2 be able to use it. There's simply not enough power there to max one set of memory, 2 cards isn't going to matter since the other card has it's own memory. I've read people saying that "you need to run 2 cards to max the memory" ... if the picture is cut in half and the memory pool isn't even shared, how is it going to make a difference? If 1 card runs at maximum of resolution X and you just double that resolution and run 2 cards, you're not using anymore memory per card.

This goes right back to people buying a 9600GT 512 over a 8800GT 256. Just because there is more memory doesn't mean it's all of a sudden a better card.


K, don't think you quite understand how Crossfire works as far as how the memory is used and such.

As far as the 512mb or 1gb question in cards not making a difference, look at some GTS 250 reviews. The GTS 250 is a renamed 9800GTX+ and the extra 512mb on the 1gb versions comes out to play @ 1900 and up resolutions so you can't tell me there is no bennefit to be had there.
 
GTA4 is a pretty badly optimized console port... Par for the course with ports. Neither the PS3 nor the Xbox have more than a gig of memory AFAIK (and they do 1080p), so there's something screwy going on in the way GTA4's memory usage is translated to the PC version (the xbox even has a shared memory architecture and the PS3's memory is split evenly, so it's not like at 'least one of the two isn't analogous to the PC architecture).

Anyway, CF is never a very good upgrade path regardless, by the time you're needing more performance a new faster GPU will have come out and 4870 cards w/2GB might not even be easy to find... So buy for the here and now, go for a 4890 (or two) which will excel in all current games and worry about the future in a year or so when the next gen is out.
 
GTA4 is a pretty badly optimized console port... Par for the course with ports. Neither the PS3 nor the Xbox have more than a gig of memory AFAIK (and they do 1080p), so there's something screwy going on in the way GTA4's memory usage is translated to the PC version (the xbox even has a shared memory architecture and the PS3's memory is split evenly, so it's not like at 'least one of the two isn't analogous to the PC architecture).

Anyway, CF is never a very good upgrade path regardless, by the time you're needing more performance a new faster GPU will have come out and 4870 cards w/2GB might not even be easy to find... So buy for the here and now, go for a 4890 (or two) which will excel in all current games and worry about the future in a year or so when the next gen is out.

Both the PS3 and 360 are 1080p compatible, but GTA4 does not run at 1080p on either console. There is a huge difference on the draw distance, shadows, post processing, resolution, etc between the PC version and the consoles. It is a demanding game, but is still a poor port.

Edit: After looking around a bit, apparently the PS3 version only runs at 630p and the 360 version runs at 720p which is far below 1680x1050 even.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, I'm not a console gamer... Well, I used to be (Sega Master System right up to the N64, PS1 & Dreamcast, heh), and I still play a lot of Wii at my friends' houses (Mario Kart, Smash Bro, etc) but that's about the extent of it. I didn't know games on the current-gen consoles were coded to run at such a low res tho, 'specially blockbuster tittles, I figured they all ran at 720p at the very 'least with big budget tittles going 1080p. That's probably an even bigger reason why GTA4 runs so poorly at higher res on the PC though, it was never even intended to scale that way to begin with.
 
Interesting, I'm not a console gamer... Well, I used to be (Sega Master System right up to the N64, PS1 & Dreamcast, heh), and I still play a lot of Wii at my friends' houses (Mario Kart, Smash Bro, etc) but that's about the extent of it. I didn't know games on the current-gen consoles were coded to run at such a low res tho, 'specially blockbuster tittles, I figured they all ran at 720p at the very 'least with big budget tittles going 1080p. That's probably an even bigger reason why GTA4 runs so poorly at higher res on the PC though, it was never even intended to scale that way to begin with.

Running 720p doesnt mean that all the texture settings are all the way up. You can run a game at 1920x1080 with all other settings at their lowest but you're still running high definition. It's based on resolution, not quality.

K, don't think you quite understand how Crossfire works as far as how the memory is used and such.

As far as the 512mb or 1gb question in cards not making a difference, look at some GTS 250 reviews. The GTS 250 is a renamed 9800GTX+ and the extra 512mb on the 1gb versions comes out to play @ 1900 and up resolutions so you can't tell me there is no bennefit to be had there.

Hard and Confused, based on your arguments all you have proven is that you don't fully understand how software and hardware work. In this case games, ie "software", are designed to run specifically with hardware. When you buy a new videocard, what is the first thing that you have to do in order to use it properly? Yes, that's right...install a driver. A driver is a piece of software that is able to interact with hardware and help it do its job. It doesn't just magically work. That's why when ATI or Nvidia release new drivers, people keep their fingers crossed hoping that they fix some particular issue (like 4850 crossfire working properly) or help them run crysis .4 fps faster.

The reason GTA IV is such a bad example for the defense of the 2gb 4870 is because it's a game that was targeted for console gamers. It was optimized to run on an XBOX 360 and PS3 but NOT PC. That's similar hardware which is why it's possible, but not entirely the same. PC gamers would only account for a small percentage of its total sales so it isn't worth the developers time to optimize it like crazy. It's worth a few tweaks here and there but porting is never 100%. I can guarantee that if had originally been designed for PC, an x800 could max it out. I mean come on...it looks like crap compared to some other games... Now how about a game like Bioshock, designed for PC but also available on console? Decent on console, beautiful on PC.
 
Last edited:
Running 720p doesnt mean that all the texture settings are all the way up. You can run a game at 1920x1080 with all other settings at their lowest but you're still running high definition. It's based on resolution, not quality.

What are you trying to say here?

Hard and Confused, based on your arguments all you have proven is that you don't fully understand how software and hardware work. In this case games, ie "software", are designed to run specifically with hardware. When you buy a new videocard, what is the first thing that you have to do in order to use it properly? Yes, that's right...install a driver. A driver is a piece of software that is able to interact with hardware and help it do its job. It doesn't just magically work. That's why when ATI or Nvidia release new drivers, people keep their fingers crossed hoping that they fix some particular issue (like 4850 crossfire working properly) or help them run crysis .4 fps faster.

This rant makes no sense and dosen't even prove a point, although Im not even sure it has one.

The reason GTA IV is such a bad example for the defense of the 2gb 4870 is because it's a game that was targeted for console gamers. It was optimized to run on an XBOX 360 and PS3 but NOT PC. That's similar hardware which is why it's possible, but not entirely the same. PC gamers would only account for a small percentage of its total sales so it isn't worth the developers time to optimize it like crazy. It's worth a few tweaks here and there but porting is never 100%. I can guarantee that if had originally been designed for PC, an x800 could max it out. I mean come on...it looks like crap compared to some other games... Now how about a game like Bioshock, designed for PC but also available on console? Decent on console, beautiful on PC.

What do you know about optimization? I hate that buzzword. Look at the draw distances that you can pull off and the quality of the textures, although the game needs AA bad. You would have to be out of your mind to say Bioshock looks better than GTA4. Also Bioshoce is a UE3 game and is just as much of a port as GTA4, it has some of the shittyest mouse control out of any FPS that I have ever played. I can't think of too many games that look better than GTA4 (aliasing aside) and not one that has so much going on in the background.


I'm not defending GTA4 it is a pretty shitty port but is it really that much worse than Fallout 3 which has crashed on me much more than GTA4 or Far Cry 2? The lack of anti-aliasing pisses me off the most though.
 
fallout 3 runs beautifully for me. 1920x1080 full settings with 4x AA. Never dips below 60fps. Just rename the exe to Oblivion.exe...problem solved....at least mine were
 
fallout 3 runs beautifully for me. 1920x1080 full settings with 4x AA. Never dips below 60fps. Just rename the exe to Oblivion.exe...problem solved....at least mine were

Really, I may have to give that a shot. It has been a couple of months since I've played it, fun game but the bugs kept me from playing trough again.
 
Really, I may have to give that a shot. It has been a couple of months since I've played it, fun game but the bugs kept me from playing trough again.

Oooh, I just noticed you have a GTX280. The oblivion.exe trick works for ATI cards. I'm not sure if nvidia had the same issue but it completely fixed the stutter problem for my 4870x2. Sorry for wasting your time if you already tried it. Besides, the console version has it's own share of bugs. Fallout 3 crashed maybe twice total for me on PC and I've played it all the way through having done maybe 50% of the side quests.
 
Just a year ago you could take the screen width*height*4*3 for an estimate of needed video memory for a 32-bit color+depth buffer with double-buffering. Whatever was left after that was basically available for textures.

With more and more games moving from forward- to deferred rendering and to floating point buffers, people need to realize the multipliers have grown.
 
Back
Top