Think Linux Rules on Netbooks? Think Again

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Well the official numbers are out and it seems that all that talk about Linux dominating the netbook market was just that…a lot of talk.

There's been a lot of talk -- including from me -- that Linux is hurting Microsoft because of its big market share in netbook sales. But recent figures from the research firm NPD Group show that it's a myth. Windows now has more than 90 percent of all netbook sales. The game is over.
 
Even just 10% would help the overall Linux desktop market share since it is so tiny.

Maybe Nicholas Negroponte can help out. :p
 
Works great on the S10. Tried to use XP on it, but was just too slow and clunky.
 
I don't doubt that the average John and Jane Doe feel more comfortable running Windows but there's another side to it. If the price difference isn't much, you can order the netbook with windows and later have 'nix for free. Not so the other way around unless you want to be a pirate.
 
Some of the netbooks have Windows tied to better features. So if you want a whole gig of memory, or a bigger SSD, or whatever, you have to buy Windows. If this weren't the case I think people would rather not pay for Windows and get the better hardware with Linux.
 
I'm not surprised by this. *looks at his netbook running Windows*.
 
I don't doubt that the average John and Jane Doe feel more comfortable running Windows but there's another side to it. If the price difference isn't much, you can order the netbook with windows and later have 'nix for free. Not so the other way around unless you want to be a pirate.

Do what you want cause a pirate is free!
 
Some of the netbooks have Windows tied to better features. So if you want a whole gig of memory, or a bigger SSD, or whatever, you have to buy Windows. If this weren't the case I think people would rather not pay for Windows and get the better hardware with Linux.

I think this may be causing some linux users to be counted as windows purchases, but the rate of returns on linux netbooks is unreasonably high. Which would indicate folks not familiar with linux are not happy with it.

I've worked with a lot of operating systems as my desktop. And currently my preferences are windows, OSX, linux, solaris, pretty much in that order. I could place AmigaOS, and BeOS in there someplace, but their extinction pretty much makes trying to justify any position I'd put them in pointless.

As far as desktops go, windows is ergonomic and reasonably consistent. OSX is VERY consistent (except for installing and uninstalling software), but not particularly ergonomic unless you ignore the fact you have a GUI and go to using all hotkeys. Linux is neither consistant, nor ergonomic, but it does have a lot of neat toys for the self starter, and with regards to the web is relatively fully functional. Solaris is consistant and stable, but slow, ugly, no frills, and poorly supported.

IMO Linux has improved a lot. It used to be if you gave a linux disc to someone who was marginally familiar with computers, the result is that they though linux sucked because a plastic circle makes a shitty OS. Then they improved it so that person could install the os, and it was bad because a pretty desktop is useless without apps. Now you can get applications pretty easily, and the fact that the desktop is pretty is secondary to the fact that a lot of choices about how to implement it are batshit insane. Like detachable toolbars that can float anywhere and no means to readily identify which app window they belong to. It's cool, but actually reduces functionality.

I think linux on lighter weight computing platforms has a real chance, but if it succeeds, it will be because of some folks who want to achieve a specific money making goal wrapping it with a useful lightweight interface. Kind of like HP has been impressing folks with the touch based interface on some of it's new PC products.
 
the more powerful netbooks get the more likely OEMs will put Windows on it to mainstream it for the general public

and i've already heard rumors Microsoft is pushing for Windows 7 to be pre-installed on some of the higher end netbooks coming out later this year
 
How is this news? The market share numbers for netbooks are radically different from week to week.
 
How is this news? The market share numbers for netbooks are radically different from week to week.

Don't know why I can't edit...but I meant to add: "at least the reports are different."

What I mean is, the numbers don't ACTUALLY change radically, but depending on who you ask and when, you will get different answers.
 
2nd is still a winner.

Obviously Microsoft couldnt stand for GNU/Linux getting a unique market, they had to be the big company.

Dispite this, the GNU/Linux releases are still really good. Doesn't necessarilly mean it's for everyone. My father certainly likes his netbook, and it's a Linux flavor. He's may not be up to speed with lots of tech stuff lately, but he's no fool either. He's been a computer user on and off for a while, but on a more casual basis. He certainly hasn't turned back for 6ish Months.


Let the fools have their tar tar sauce!
 
I've been seeing far more MacOS netbooks than linux, and strictly among geeks, more MacOS than either linux or windows.
 
I've been seeing far more MacOS netbooks than linux, and strictly among geeks, more MacOS than either linux or windows.

I have a hard time believing that. I would imagine if anything there are more geeks running Windows 7 beta on their netbooks (guilty) than OS X.
 
NPD data is VERY limited. Typically relies on sales from Best Buy, Target, Wal-Mart, etc. All markets that would have consumers that would have customers "afraid" to try something other than Linux.

I'm still not going to say that Linux "dominates" Netbooks. I doubt it does. But I doubt Windows occupies 90% of the units out there.
 
Talking to the choir here. I bought my netbook about three weeks ago. Just looking at what Best Buy, Walmart and NewEgg have to offer, there stocks are 10 to 1 Windows over Linux, so goes to figure that Windows is outselling Linux in this market by that factor.

At some point I would think that the Linux people need to take a good look at themselves and figure out why an 8 year old OS is kicking them in the nuts. I tire of all of the MS stole this or bribed that crap. Maybe the Linux community doesn't care about market share and that fine. But at some point the MS hate needs to stop and you either accept being a minor part of the market or you do something about it other than whine.
 
NPD data is VERY limited. Typically relies on sales from Best Buy, Target, Wal-Mart, etc. All markets that would have consumers that would have customers "afraid" to try something other than Linux.

I'm still not going to say that Linux "dominates" Netbooks. I doubt it does. But I doubt Windows occupies 90% of the units out there.

So you're saying that these retailers, the biggest out there don't accurately reflect market conditions, at least in the US? Think again.

Look around for yourself. Windows offers are 10 to 1 over Linux, even places like NewEgg have about a 5 to 1 ratio, and I just have a funny feeling that WalMart and Best Buy sell a hell of a lot more.

Eight year old XP beat the latest and great Linux distros. The Linux community needs to either work on this or let it go. Period.
 
Talking to the choir here. I bought my netbook about three weeks ago. Just looking at what Best Buy, Walmart and NewEgg have to offer, there stocks are 10 to 1 Windows over Linux, so goes to figure that Windows is outselling Linux in this market by that factor.

At some point I would think that the Linux people need to take a good look at themselves and figure out why an 8 year old OS is kicking them in the nuts. I tire of all of the MS stole this or bribed that crap. Maybe the Linux community doesn't care about market share and that fine. But at some point the MS hate needs to stop and you either accept being a minor part of the market or you do something about it other than whine.

Well, the Linux community is divided. Some are elitist (not that it's a bad thing), and don't care about what others think, as long as it works perfectly for them. Some try to promote the easy-to-use distributions. There really is no organized movement, just tidbits of everyone wants to do this and that (though arguably, Ubuntu is a large organized movement in itself). I think if Linux ever becomes like Windows in that it captures as big of a market share, the hardcore users will essentially segregate themselves further, and it will be Linux vs. hardcore Linux like Windows vs. Linux today. You can never satisfy everyone.

Apart from that, the general Linux philosophy of choice will never be widely accepted, since choice is only good insofar as you care about choice. If you don't care about it, it's a hindrance. What Windows does is encapsulate only the choices you need to make and are easy to understand, and leave the rest to the system, and it's only heading more and more in that direction. As machines get more powerful, the system is better able to analyze metrics and make its own optimal choices (so the user no longer has to intervene and use his brain to figure it out himself).
 
So you're saying that these retailers, the biggest out there don't accurately reflect market conditions, at least in the US? Think again.

Look around for yourself. Windows offers are 10 to 1 over Linux, even places like NewEgg have about a 5 to 1 ratio, and I just have a funny feeling that WalMart and Best Buy sell a hell of a lot more.

Eight year old XP beat the latest and great Linux distros. The Linux community needs to either work on this or let it go. Period.

I believe what he is trying to get at is that though the majority have windows on them, it isn't taking into consideration as to who is throwing Linux on them after purchasing it. It probably wouldn't help the numbers by much, but at the same time, it'd show a more accurate telling of who is actually using what OS.

But I will concede your second point. The community does need to work at this more. I'm going to give Ubuntu or Slackware another go once I get my system upgraded.
 
Do what you want cause a pirate is free!

you_are_a_pirate.jpg
 
Talking to the choir here. I bought my netbook about three weeks ago. Just looking at what Best Buy, Walmart and NewEgg have to offer, there stocks are 10 to 1 Windows over Linux, so goes to figure that Windows is outselling Linux in this market by that factor.

At some point I would think that the Linux people need to take a good look at themselves and figure out why an 8 year old OS is kicking them in the nuts. I tire of all of the MS stole this or bribed that crap. Maybe the Linux community doesn't care about market share and that fine. But at some point the MS hate needs to stop and you either accept being a minor part of the market or you do something about it other than whine.

I must say I that I agree with you 100%. No only is Linux simply inferior to the sheer awesomeness of the Redmond shovelware but to even be in the presence of Win32 demands supplication. Personally, I feel that you're right on the mark. The sales figures relating to Netbook Win32 versus Linux are not because say the product offerings for the larger HDDs, battery mAh, and RAM are only for Win32. No, all sales of Win32 NetBooks are certainly used for Win32 only.

Please don't tell the HardOCP servers...

Code:
meowsiferous@meowbox:~$ curl -I http://www.hardocp.com
HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Date: Wed, 04 Mar 2009 21:28:28 GMT
Server: Apache
X-Powered-By: PHP/5.2.1
Vary: Accept-Encoding
Content-Type: text/html

Should I have s/Apache/IIS 6\.0/gi the output for you?
 
I must say I that I agree with you 100%. No only is Linux simply inferior to the sheer awesomeness of the Redmond shovelware but to even be in the presence of Win32 demands supplication. Personally, I feel that you're right on the mark. The sales figures relating to Netbook Win32 versus Linux are not because say the product offerings for the larger HDDs, battery mAh, and RAM are only for Win32. No, all sales of Win32 NetBooks are certainly used for Win32 only.

Please don't tell the HardOCP servers...

Code:
meowsiferous@meowbox:~$ curl -I http://www.hardocp.com
HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Date: Wed, 04 Mar 2009 21:28:28 GMT
Server: Apache
X-Powered-By: PHP/5.2.1
Vary: Accept-Encoding
Content-Type: text/html

Should I have s/Apache/IIS 6\.0/gi the output for you?

Did you just compare servers to desktop, never mind netbooks? Really?
 
Apart from that, the general Linux philosophy of choice will never be widely accepted, since choice is only good insofar as you care about choice. If you don't care about it, it's a hindrance. What Windows does is encapsulate only the choices you need to make and are easy to understand, and leave the rest to the system, and it's only heading more and more in that direction. As machines get more powerful, the system is better able to analyze metrics and make its own optimal choices (so the user no longer has to intervene and use his brain to figure it out himself).

Nail on the head
 
Did you just isolate and insult the entire Linux community based on Linux on the desktop? Really?

Sounds like you tend to read too much into other people's replies. But that's ok because you reflect what someone else above us said about Linux elitism.
 
Sounds like you tend to read too much into other people's replies. But that's ok because you reflect what someone else above us said about Linux elitism.

Reverting to Ad Hominem attacks simply indicate your assertion has been shown to be inaccurate.
 
Reverting to Ad Hominem attacks simply indicate your assertion has been shown to be inaccurate.

Let me put it so you can understand where I'm getting at: I in no way "insult the entire Linux community" in my post which you've quoted. Your feelings got hurt because you're a Linux fanboy who defends them to the death. Get over yourself.

So Windows sell better in the desktop market. It's not the end of the world.
 
Apart from that, the general Linux philosophy of choice will never be widely accepted, since choice is only good insofar as you care about choice. If you don't care about it, it's a hindrance. What Windows does is encapsulate only the choices you need to make and are easy to understand, and leave the rest to the system, and it's only heading more and more in that direction. As machines get more powerful, the system is better able to analyze metrics and make its own optimal choices (so the user no longer has to intervene and use his brain to figure it out himself).

This people is while ultimately windows succeeded in the days versus the Mac world because it brought the ease of getting things done at once, as opposed to mac where sure it had superior programs, but you needed a lot of superior programs to accomplish the one task. Linux is the same thing. Sure it works, but does it work in the mass consumer market.
 
Let me put it so you can understand where I'm getting at: I in no way "insult the entire Linux community" in my post which you've quoted. Your feelings got hurt because you're a Linux fanboy who defends them to the death. Get over yourself.

So Windows sell better in the desktop market. It's not the end of the world.

Conversely, as a Windows apologist I'm certain that you're equally as annoyed with the growing Linux adoption and drum your chest at the opportunity to nod your head in silent agreement with the others who think like you.

As we all know, demographics and market share are all easily measured and again, I'm certain that all sales of netbooks bundled with XP (your panacea of an Operating System) never see a Linux installation.

Consequently, if you could also post browser market share values derived from hits to http://www.microsoft.com I would also be appreciative as it would clearly show the market dominance of Internet Explorer.

In the interim the clarity in direction provided by your posts have forced me to tear down my existing Linux infrastructure and empty my wallet towards Redmond in hopes of the utopia you've embraced. I eagerly await the euphoric lemming-like bliss I shall experience at the release of Windows 7.

Thank you sir, not only have you converted me but likely many others who simply love the lack of decision and control exercised by a close-source Operating System; remember not only is it secure but it's just plain good. I hope you don't use Firefox or any of these other silly and inferior browsers.
 
Conversely, as a Windows apologist I'm certain that you're equally as annoyed with the growing Linux adoption and drum your chest at the opportunity to nod your head in silent agreement with the others who think like you.

As we all know, demographics and market share are all easily measured and again, I'm certain that all sales of netbooks bundled with XP (your panacea of an Operating System) never see a Linux installation.

Consequently, if you could also post browser market share values derived from hits to http://www.microsoft.com I would also be appreciative as it would clearly show the market dominance of Internet Explorer.

In the interim the clarity in direction provided by your posts have forced me to tear down my existing Linux infrastructure and empty my wallet towards Redmond in hopes of the utopia you've embraced. I eagerly await the euphoric lemming-like bliss I shall experience at the release of Windows 7.

Thank you sir, not only have you converted me but likely many others who simply love the lack of decision and control exercised by a close-source Operating System; remember not only is it secure but it's just plain good. I hope you don't use Firefox or any of these other silly and inferior browsers.

Once again you've made things up to suit your reply. I never said I don't use Linux either.

:rolleyes:
 
The Macbook Air is not a netbook.

1: It just runs like one
2: you wont see any geeks with airs, just smug poseurs.
3: lots of people have put OSX on actual netbooks.
 
Once again you've made things up to suit your reply. I never said I don't use Linux either.

:rolleyes:

I hope you purchased explicitly a computer which was not OEM licensed for Microsoft Windows else this would skew your extraordinarily accurate demographic for determining market share.

More so, I hope this wasn't done on a NetBook.
 
The MacBook Air is an "ultraportable" class laptop based on the size and weight. Netbooks are smaller and lighter.
 
Thanks Steve, another honey pot for foaming at the mouth extreme minority OS fanatics to buzz around.

LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA Linux owns the netbook market LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA I can't hear anything else LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA :p
 
i installed ubuntu on my dell just for kicks and due to a bug that affected just about everyone with a keyboard and a mouse, it was unusable after all the security updates were applied.

so I just put the hdd containing vista back in and all was well :p
 
I would prefer to use linux, but its too complicated to install drivers, update programs, and get my hardware to work. This may not be linux's fault because the manufacturers provide the drivers... but this is what stops most people = consumers from dipping their toes into the Linux water.
 
Back
Top