Any way to restore this data..?

Syribo

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Mar 9, 2008
Messages
1,515
I'm pretty sure I won't be able to do this, but if there's even a 3% chance that I can do it, I will try.

Recently my sisters Dell desktop had a ton of problems. It got to the point where it wouldn't even load anything after you tried to login to XP. One of her husbands friends said that he had a copy of all of her pictures from the last time he fixed their computer, so I went ahead and reformatted since I saw no other option.

Well, that was two weeks ago.. Now my sister finds out that her friend was wrong, he doesn't have the pictures. She lost a ton of family pictures for the past 6 years. She lost all of her pictures from during her pregnancy and even sonogram pictures from the past year. She was so upset, she was crying.. and she's really mad at the guy for not looking well enough in the first place to see if he really did have the pictures or not before it was too late.

Is there still a way I could try to recover some files from her computer? I think there's a program that you can put on a bootable flash drive that may help? I'm not sure... I understand it's very hard to recover data, especially after being reformatted, and that the best thing would be to send it to a company who would try to get the data off (And charge what... $1000? None of us can afford that).. but I want to at least try for her.

Any advice? Tips? Prayers? ;)
 
I'm pretty sure I won't be able to do this, but if there's even a 3% chance that I can do it, I will try.

Recently my sisters Dell desktop had a ton of problems. It got to the point where it wouldn't even load anything after you tried to login to XP. One of her husbands friends said that he had a copy of all of her pictures from the last time he fixed their computer, so I went ahead and reformatted since I saw no other option.

Well, that was two weeks ago.. Now my sister finds out that her friend was wrong, he doesn't have the pictures. She lost a ton of family pictures for the past 6 years. She lost all of her pictures from during her pregnancy and even sonogram pictures from the past year. She was so upset, she was crying.. and she's really mad at the guy for not looking well enough in the first place to see if he really did have the pictures or not before it was too late.

Is there still a way I could try to recover some files from her computer? I think there's a program that you can put on a bootable flash drive that may help? I'm not sure... I understand it's very hard to recover data, especially after being reformatted, and that the best thing would be to send it to a company who would try to get the data off (And charge what... $1000? None of us can afford that).. but I want to at least try for her.

Any advice? Tips? Prayers? ;)

That data's gone.

Helpful hints for the future:

  1. If someone says they have backups, verify
  2. DD the "corrupt" drive anyway. You can always mount it later if you just need to grab files.
  3. Multiple backups, multiple locations (home, safety deposit box, server in a datacenter)
 
Its only a reformat, you can certainly recover SOME data, especially if it hasn't been overwritten yet. Try GetDataBack or something similar. I've used Get Data Back before and recovered 90% of files after a reformat. ;) Good luck!
 
Its only a reformat, you can certainly recover SOME data, especially if it hasn't been overwritten yet. Try GetDataBack or something similar. I've used Get Data Back before and recovered 90% of files after a reformat. ;) Good luck!

It was a reformat, with I assume a new OS install. The MFT tables are gone, the inode data is gone. That software works well if the machine hasn't been touched, but once you start reformatting, and overwriting blocks, it's gone for good. You could give it a try, but don't expect anything.
 
It was a reformat, with I assume a new OS install. The MFT tables are gone, the inode data is gone. That software works well if the machine hasn't been touched, but once you start reformatting, and overwriting blocks, it's gone for good. You could give it a try, but don't expect anything.

Yes, what is recoverable depends on how much was already overwritten. As lundrog said, whatever you do, stop using the device.
 
Yes, what is recoverable depends on how much was already overwritten. As lundrog said, whatever you do, stop using the device.

BTW, too add if you did a "quick format" in XP, it's your only chance...a normal format will wipe it beyond "Forensicator Pro" will do for you.
 
ontrack can recover a lot, they have software, or you can pay to send them the device.
 
Yeah I think I might have done the full format.. it took a long time to do it, I don't remember the option I chose. So then it's definitely gone?

I, myself, keep backups of everything. I keep my pictures folder (It has over 50 albums going back to 2002) on all three hard drives on my newest computer, on both hard drives on my old computer, and on two CDs... just in case :p My sister just wanted her computer to work, she was so sure of herself that her pictures were safe with her friend. I wouldn't have done it otherwise.

I should have made an image of the drive, you're right.. I've never done it before, so I didn't know exactly how to go about it or even think of it.
 
Yeah I think I might have done the full format.. it took a long time to do it, I don't remember the option I chose. So then it's definitely gone?

Probably. But give it a try nonetheless.
 
Yeah I think I might have done the full format.. it took a long time to do it, I don't remember the option I chose. So then it's definitely gone?

I, myself, keep backups of everything. I keep my pictures folder (It has over 50 albums going back to 2002) on all three hard drives on my newest computer, on both hard drives on my old computer, and on two CDs... just in case :p My sister just wanted her computer to work, she was so sure of herself that her pictures were safe with her friend. I wouldn't have done it otherwise.

I should have made an image of the drive, you're right.. I've never done it before, so I didn't know exactly how to go about it or even think of it.

If you did a full format it gone for good.

You have nice backups, but you might want to keep one off site just in case. If my house burns to the ground, insurance replace all my belongs, but it can't replace my digital photos.

As far as imaging a drive, DD is great on Linux and there is a Windows port, plus it free.
 
damn... I made a big long post about system rescue CD and spinright thinking that all that had happened was that the computer wouldnt boot.... but you formatted the thing. I was really hoping I could swoop in and help you out...

uhh... yeah... the file systems been obliterated, and it sounds like most of the data's been over-written. And if its true that you started installing things (such as an OS) afterward... its done.

One of the rules I live by is if the data only exists in one place its as good as gone.

When Amazon charges pennies a gigabyte for storage on their S3 servers (these servers... if theres a nuclear hollocost, you and me will be gone, but my Lab Report for Febuary 3 2009 will still be around), its an easy rule to live by.

god that really sucks. I'm really sorry I can't help.
 
Like I said, ontrack can recover a device from just about anything, full format is no big deal, but your going to have to pay for this. However, pictures are priceless. Call them, they will tell you what you need to do to get this data.

But you need to stop using that device if you are serious about this data recover.
 
full format is no big deal

It's a very big deal. Data is not gone until it has been deleted, and then the sectors holding that data are written over. Consider he states he did a full format, and reinstalled Windows, even if the new files didn't overwrite the data, the full format did.

Plus if by chance he didn't do all the formatting and reinstalling, foremost would have been his friend as it's both free, and designed to do one wonderful thing, pull file types from a (forensic) image and save them.

Hell most all those consumer grade "recovery" software packages do is run a version of foremost.
 
Yes, she learned her lesson the hard way. Though, it won't hurt to at least try.
 
You could also slave the C: drive to another computer, then try to recover the old partition info with Active Partition Recovery. I've used it myself, it's pretty good. Again, you'll still be hampered by how much has been overwritten. And again, quick-format only.

Oh, and the "friend" should be flogged with a rubber hose.
 
Oh yes, I've learned my lesson indeed :p Definitely making copies of corrupted drives for now on when I need to reformat and reinstall OS.

I actually have another CD with all of my pictures at my friends house too, since he wanted a copy for himself.. being as he's in almost every picture with me. So that's at least one safe copy away from home.. but I'm going to look into uploading them to some backup server or something, because I can't afford to lose my high school memories like my sister lost her pregnancy memories.. So terrible.

I will try everything you guys have said, even if there's a .0001% chance of recovery because my sister is still so very upset about this.. And yes, her 'friend' should be smacked in the head for being an idiot indeed! God if he wouldn't have said he was sure he had a copy of her pictures I wouldn't have let her talk me into the reformat...

You know what I've never understood? I've been working with computers since I was 10.. managed to put one together myself.. fix multiple computers a year.. but I can never figure out the purpose of the whole HP Recovery or Dell Recovery things that come with the computers you buy usually from.. well.. HP or Dell or whatever. It shows up like a separate drive in My Computer.. but what is it exactly? And how the hell does it come in handy?
 
You know what I've never understood? I've been working with computers since I was 10.. managed to put one together myself.. fix multiple computers a year.. but I can never figure out the purpose of the whole HP Recovery or Dell Recovery things that come with the computers you buy usually from.. well.. HP or Dell or whatever. It shows up like a separate drive in My Computer.. but what is it exactly? And how the hell does it come in handy?

That's the recovery partition. Basically if the system is so fragged with viruii, stupid user mistakes and installations, etc, you just press a key during the PC's bootup and it'll restore the Dell, HP, Gateway, and other OEM PCs back to the exact same installation from the day you bought it. Note that this will wipe out any and all data on the PC.
 
I did a chat with ontrack sales to prove my point, here is what the sales said, I replaced his name with vendor. Chat live now is here
"
Chat InformationPlease wait for a site operator to respond.

Chat InformationYou are now chatting with 'Vendor'

Vendor: Hello. How may I help you with your data loss situation?

visitor: I have a client that did a full format of the drive, and has pictures they would like to recover, is this something that can be recovered? If so by which product?

visitor: They reinstalled windows on to the drive before they knew what happended

Vendor: You can try our software first, if that does not work we can do a recovery with our proprietary tools in lab or online.

visitor: So, either way there is a solution?

visitor: Worst case senerio, if they have to send it in, what cost range we talking about?

visitor: sorry typo

Vendor: Consumer software maybe. Our in lab or Remote Services most likely.

Vendor: ok, to send in;

Vendor: Is this a desktop, laptop or external drive?

visitor: Desktop internal drive

Vendor: What operating system are you using?

visitor: XP is what they were using.

Vendor: What is your drive capacity?

visitor: that is unknown, assuming 200 - 500 gb.

Vendor: What kind of data are you looking for? You said ""has pictures they would like to recover""

visitor: six years of pictures

Vendor: I have 2 options.

Vendor: 1. Standard Recovery where we get everything.

Vendor: 2. Photo Only, we only recover (*.JPG, *.JPEG, *.JPE, *.JFIF, *.BMP).

visitor: I'll have to get more information, but I wanted to see if it was even a option, and if you could give me a rough price field, as they are within a budget.

visitor: ok

Vendor: what option do you want to hear 1st?

visitor: walk me through both

Vendor: 1. Standard Recovery where we get everything.

Vendor: We start with an evaluation. This is a $100 fee.

Vendor: Once we complete the evaluation, we will provide a detailed file list indicating what data can be recovered. We also quote a firm price for the recovery at that time.

Vendor: The recovery fee falls between $500 and $2500 depending on what we need to do to overcome the damage.

Vendor: We will put the data on another type of media. Our options include DVD's or an external hard drive.

Vendor: The standard service level averages 3-5 business days from the time we receive the drive. We do have accelerated levels if you need it sooner.

Vendor: We send you a certificate that you can take to any UPS Store. They will package and ship, via overnight, the drive to Ontrack at no charge.

Vendor: next

Vendor: 2. Photo Only, we only recover (*.JPG, *.JPEG, *.JPE, *.JFIF, *.BMP).

Vendor: For the fee of $995.00 USD, Ontrack will recover all digital photo files possible (*.JPG, *.JPEG, *.JPE, *.JFIF, *.BMP) from a single laptop hard drive, single desktop hard drive, single external hard drive, CD, DVD, CompactFlash, Memory Stick, Microdrive, MultiMediaCard, SD Memory Card, SmartMedia Card or USB Stick.

Vendor: Photo recovery service will be performed during normal business hours and typically takes 7 days to complete.

Vendor: The recovered files will be copied to DVD media and returned to you.



"
 

Oh my... Thank you so much for this! I'm going to get in touch with my sister ASAP and let her know about this... I am going to go to her house some time this week, I will try the software and tell her to stop using the computer ASAP (I bet she will have a problem with this, even though I'm going to tell her that every moment she uses the system the less likely it will be to get the pictures back).

If I can't do it, I will tell her about the picture recovery option.. Unfortunately, since they just had a baby and she's out of work they aren't making as much money (..Even though her husband, my brother in law, works about 80 hours a week AND he also works as a bodyguard for the singer Ciara when she goes to certain events [Super Bowl, Pro Bowl, Fashion shows, MTV Music Awards].. so if she REALLY wants them, she should be able to afford it).

Again, thank you so so so much for all of your help (All of you). I will keep updating on what's going on. Also, the drive is a 250GB drive.. not sure of the make or model though. I'm crossing my fingers for something good!
 
Oh my... Thank you so much for this! I'm going to get in touch with my sister ASAP and let her know about this... I am going to go to her house some time this week, I will try the software and tell her to stop using the computer ASAP (I bet she will have a problem with this, even though I'm going to tell her that every moment she uses the system the less likely it will be to get the pictures back).

If I can't do it, I will tell her about the picture recovery option.. Unfortunately, since they just had a baby and she's out of work they aren't making as much money (..Even though her husband, my brother in law, works about 80 hours a week AND he also works as a bodyguard for the singer Ciara when she goes to certain events [Super Bowl, Pro Bowl, Fashion shows, MTV Music Awards].. so if she REALLY wants them, she should be able to afford it).

Again, thank you so so so much for all of your help (All of you). I will keep updating on what's going on. Also, the drive is a 250GB drive.. not sure of the make or model though. I'm crossing my fingers for something good!


just go pick up a $50 drive, or give her a used one, and reinstall on that.
 
just go pick up a $50 drive, or give her a used one, and reinstall on that.

..Oh duh, good idea. I could actually use one of my 3 drives for now. I can just move all of my files off of it and then install it in her system with XP.. Thanks for reminding me of this!
 
I did a chat with ontrack sales to prove my point, here is what the sales said, I replaced his name with vendor.

I'm sure the sales people have nothing to gain...but as a forensics first responder, what do I know.


Oh my... Thank you so much for this! I'm going to get in touch with my sister ASAP and let her know about this... I am going to go to her house some time this week, I will try the software and tell her to stop using the computer ASAP (I bet she will have a problem with this, even though I'm going to tell her that every moment she uses the system the less likely it will be to get the pictures back).

If I can't do it, I will tell her about the picture recovery option.. Unfortunately, since they just had a baby and she's out of work they aren't making as much money (..Even though her husband, my brother in law, works about 80 hours a week AND he also works as a bodyguard for the singer Ciara when she goes to certain events [Super Bowl, Pro Bowl, Fashion shows, MTV Music Awards].. so if she REALLY wants them, she should be able to afford it).

Again, thank you so so so much for all of your help (All of you). I will keep updating on what's going on. Also, the drive is a 250GB drive.. not sure of the make or model though. I'm crossing my fingers for something good!

Good Luck....
 
I have used ontrack for drives that wouldn't even spin before, with damaged platter's.

They seem to do what they say, and have a good rep.
 
I have used ontrack for drives that wouldn't even spin before, with damaged platter's.

Damaged data and non spinning drives are VASTLY different then full formats, and neither can really be done from a off the shelf solution alone. Hell I've replace controller boards in my home office to get a drive spinning again.

A full formats writes 0's to every. single. sector. Since hard drives can only write 1 & 0's, even if by chance the software didn't bother writing 0's to all the bits currently flipped to 0's, you have at best half the data needed to recreate the file. I know from experience that even trying to recreate a partial file via hex editor is a very long and expensive process. NO ONE has ever recovered data that has been written over, period! The person who theorized that you could use a electron microscope, Peter Gutman, never even actually did it himself. And hell, the method Gutman theorized would work, wouldn't work on disk platters now due to hard drive density.

I'm not saying this to be a dick, I'm saying this to keep someone who has already lost something losing money too. If he says it was a low level format, and he did, the data is GONE.

Don't want to believe me, fine...Take it from a Director of Ontrack themselves


Can data be recovered from erased hard disk drives?
What do data recovery experts have to say? I asked Jim Reinert, senior director of software and services for Ontrack Data Recovery whether any of this was possible. His answer was a blunt "No."

Erasing hard disk drive data: How many passes are needed?
 
I totally agree with you, but a full format in Windows XP, is not a low level format.
 
Back
Top