To early for I7?

MunchMouth

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
65
Do you guys think there are still to many issues with X58 Mother boards to consider upgrading to the new 1366 platform? I think the new platform REVIEWS well across all boards, but I have read a growing number of posts from users that there systems are giving them all sorts of head aches. I have posted about my needs for a new PC, and I have received a lot of input from forum members. I think though that the new X58 mother boards are still to problematic for me and my limited knowledge with bios settings and tweeks.
One thing I haven't been able to find through my searches is a feed back thread about stability, other then during a specific bench test or review. Am I wrong but does there seem to be a lot of problems coming a few weeks or a month later with far to many systems? If you guys that own X58 based systems would like to comment on this let me know. Reply with Motherboard and how long you have owned and overall stability.

Thanks, Munch
 
shit no. i'm 2 i7 builds in, and i'll build another as soon as the new evga nf200 supported board appears on the market. i think what you're seeing are people who held onto fast amd systems for a long time and skipped building anything in between. they just don't know what the fuck they're doing. i built my first i7 at launch with a 920, msi platinum x58, and 6gb of corsair 1333. i've experienced zero issues with it. the chip is sitting pretty at 3.4ghz and using less voltage than the cpu vid.
 
I'm sure there are probably a few minor compatibility issues with different video cards, or memory, etc. to be ironed out, but nothing major. You should be fine. You might even wait for 2nd gen boards to come out. Might have fixed anything that couldn't be fixed with a bios update and needed hardware changes.
 
I've had an Asus P6T Deluxe with a Core i7 920 @ 4.005GHz for the last ~3 months and except initial OCing I've never had a single issue with it, I don't know who told you there are issues but they obviously didn't set something up right.
 
Thanks for the replies. I am researching still, but it seems that bob may be right. I noticed most problems have been reported by do it yourselfers. So it may be that those with issues might not understand how to build a system properly.

thanks guys, Munch
 
I've had one running on a P6T (non deluxe) for about 2 weeks now and so far (fingers corssed) it has been solid. Least for everything I do, it was a noticable change in speed over the C2D system I had before it.

I can understand people's budget issues. I think once the motherboards get cheaper is will appeal to more people. To me that was the really the only ridiculous cost.
 
No problem so far with my i7 920 , P6T Deluxe and 6 gb of OCZ 1600 I use at work
I tired to OC to 3.8, at first it gave me some problem with memory timing but that was easy to fix.
I do alot of video / 3d renders
it might be a bit slower than my 2.8 8-core Xeon with 8gb (MacPro) at home... but not by much
(btw brenchmark don't mean anything in real work usage from my experience, alot of factors comes into play such as hard drives and the tools you use)

I am very impress with the i7
is very stable and haven't had any problem so far
as for gaming, I am not sure, I rarely play...
 
As time moves on, the motherboard, memory and CPU will get cheaper, not to mention faster and more matured. If one can hold out for a little while longer I would. That is what I'm doing. Also, my system, unknown about yours, can handle any game or application out there, so no need to rush.

:)
 
The 'TLB bug' that they were supposed to suffer from was corrected with a BIOS patch... dont know if that means they aren't operating at full like the patch the phenom's got for the same problem, or if its a real fix. Either way, they seem to work.

I was planning on making one myself right away, but I just cant justify the expense, and Im not just 'being cheap'... I just know they will get cheaper too soon and that will tick me off. The 920 and 940 are reasonable, and the mobos are coming down rather fast (but they were absurd at first), but that RAM is still out there. I would say that in 6 months we should see some nice drops as well as the p55 chipsets. This should nail the coffin shut on LGA775 as well though... so when you see prices drop like bombs on that stuff... its time to buy in.

Im waiting for less 'fancy' boards to come out I suppose. I dont want the complexity of all the 'built in gamer friendly junk'. I would never use 'software' RAID or 'built-in'. I dont need xfire or SLi (I have done SLi twice, and I dont think I will ever do it again... just not 'worth it'), and I have an X-Fi PCI-E card already. So all those fancy $$$ add-on's are just useless to me. I WOULD prefer a simple board that is less clutter, less 'gadgets', but performs like a champ and is rock solid stable. Maybe even a mini-ATX format (what do I need the extra slots for anyways?). Something to consider.
 
Thanks for the comments. My delima is, My main PC(Family) went belly up. It was a little old(7 years), so I guess I shouldn't complain. I need to replace it soon, as in next week when tax returns come back. I am afraid I won't upgrade my system again for at least 4-5 years(I too have small pockets), so I wanted to at least get in on the latest tech. My budget is $1400 and I found a good build at Cyberpower. I decided to search the new tech out and inquire from users of this new platform as to the stability of their systems. I am not the most tech savy person with computers so I need something that won't require endless fixing and tweeking to stay running.


Thanks again guys, Munch
 
Thanks for the comments. My delima is, My main PC(Family) went belly up. It was a little old(7 years), so I guess I shouldn't complain. I need to replace it soon, as in next week when tax returns come back. I am afraid I won't upgrade my system again for at least 4-5 years(I too have small pockets), so I wanted to at least get in on the latest tech. My budget is $1400 and I found a good build at Cyberpower. I decided to search the new tech out and inquire from users of this new platform as to the stability of their systems. I am not the most tech savy person with computers so I need something that won't require endless fixing and tweeking to stay running.


Thanks again guys, Munch

Well, what do you use it for? You are posting at [H], so many here are going to suggest the Ferrari of systems even if its just to 'get the groceries'.

IMO, one of the best deals out there is an AM2+ system... 780G or 790GX motherboard chipset with a phenom 2 proc and 4gb DDR2 1066 can be done for dirt cheap. Add in an ATI 4870 or a Geforce 280, and you have one mean little setup on the cheap. It might not be a 'barn burner', but it will handle anything current (except crysis, but everything chokes that code back up like rotten salad). As a 'stop gap' solution, its pretty hard to beat. Im thinking all the components w/o PSU & HDD should be just over $500 (4870).

It might be all you need... and then in 6-9 months when the prices drop on DDR3, 1366 mobos, and the procs... thats when Ill be jumping on it as well.
 
I think that you should wait for benchmarks vs prices to see whats the cost effective system to buy .
 
I've had an Asus P6T Deluxe with a Core i7 920 @ 4.005GHz for the last ~3 months and except initial OCing I've never had a single issue with it, I don't know who told you there are issues but they obviously didn't set something up right.

That is good to know. I am starting to build a new rig (my excuse is that my Wife needs a new computer so she will get my QX6700 box :D )
I already have the case (Tt Armor+) and the PSU (HX1000W) and some odds and ends but I have to decide on the MObo before I go further. My choices so far are all Asus, the P6T Deluxe, The P6T Deluxe OC Palm and the P6T Deluxe Version II as well as the Rampage II. I will be overcloicking near max just to see what it will do but then I will back down to about a 20% overclock for 24 7 use.
STability and reliability are more important to me than a few cycles as this will become my main ork and fun rig. Cost is only a very minor factor.
Do you guys have suggestions?
 
Back
Top