Building near $3000 gaming computer

Nice little build. Anyone know where they are selling the Intel i7 at yet?? I see pre-orders but nothing "solid"
 
Here is his questions:

1. Should he go 64bit on the OS?
2. XP or Vista
3. Would 2 22" monitors be overkill or should he stay with his existing 2 19" monitors?
4. How much memory (3x1GB or 3x2GB)

Setup is like before

CPU - i7 940

CPU Cooler - Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme HSF with Scythe fan

Motherboard - ASUS P6T Rampage Extreme

Memory - ? but will have to be DDR3 1066 due to the i7 940 chip only being able to handle this

Video Card - VisionTek HD 4870X2

Power - Corsair 1000HX Modular PSU

Hard Drives - VRaptor 300GB and a WD Green Power 1 TB

SamSung DVD Burner

Monitor - LG L227WTG-PF Black 22" 2ms Widescreen LCD Monitor - Retail (2)

Planar 997-5253-00 Black Dual Monitor Stand for LCD Displays - Retail

Case - Antec Twelve Hundred case from FrozenCPU
 
1) 64 Bit OS, yes. Absolutely. No question.

2) Vista. Again no question, because of the 64 bit. 64 Bit XP is not pretty.

3) His preference based on value to him.

4) 3x2 GB, watch which kit you get though, Ithought I read some things about wanting low voltage mem for the i7. Maybe someone else could elaborate. Oh and if for some dumb reason he goes with a 32 bit OS, he'll want to go with 3x1 because 32bit can only address 4 GB of mem. Since your looking at a card with 1 GB of video memory (it has 2 GB, but it mirrors the data.)

Setup looks good, except really for the 22" monitor 4870x2 is overkill. A single 4870 or 260 would make more since. Also, any reason for the 940? The 920 isn't exactly slow, and kyle was getting 3.5Ghz on it at stock voltages.
 
The rest of the OP's initial build didn't make sense. But I actually liked that case! It's subjective and if someone wants to get a "special" $600 case that would last them for the next several years, that's up to them.

But anyway, the latest build looks reasonable (even with that generic Antec case with the blue lights). But I'd go with the i7 920 as it's better value for money than the 940 IMHO. And I wouldn't bother with the WD Vraptor and instead go for three 1 TB F1 Samsungs (i.e. two in Raid 0, and one for backup or similar...) that would outperform the VRaptor setup and have a lot more space for just a bit more. But that's no big deal so don't worry about that.

Previous poster's suggestions all make sense: 3x2GB DDR3 is the way to go with Vista-64.... And I agree that 4870x2 is overkill.... 260GTX, 4870 or maybe even the 280GTX makes more sense...
 
Echn111,

The case he is going with is the Antec Twelve Hundred from FrozenCPU.com with additional features such as sound dampening, etc. The case would probably come to around $400 or so but the case would last for a long time. You can pretty much customize what you want including getting the PSU and getting UV sleeves if you really want to play with the colors.

As for the 64bit OS Vista I do agree about the 3x2GB but will have to double check on the voltage issue that vengence referred to.

Any thoughts on the monitors being overkill for a desktop and or the video card?
 
The Antec 1200 is a nice functional case. It going to cost $179.99. Maybe $10-$20 more for sound dampening... But it's not in the same league as a $400+ class case. Btw: that Lian Li tyr PC-X2000 (aka ABS Canyon 695) is now $450 with the discount on NewEgg - and, although, I probably wouldn't buy it myself, I can understand why someone would. Even if someone makes fun of you for spending $450 on a case.

As for thoughts on the monitors, you really should ask your friend. I can offer the unhelpful opinion that dual 22" is certainly not overkill for a desktop and if he can afford dual 30" monitors, likes it, go for it. In general people normally want something at least as good/big as they are currently used to. Best thing to do is just ask him. I suspect he'd be ok with dual 22" as it's bigger than 19".

Anyway, for anything less than 24" and you're ok with a 260GTX or 4870. But nothing wrong with the 4870x2 or 280GTX if you've got extra cash...
 
I think its better to go with a Fujitsu SAS Drive for OS loading + favorite game & get a 2nd drive such as WD Black or even another SAS drive if you have money to burn.

My New Rig list
CPU
I7 920

RAM
G.SKILL 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600

Mobo
ASUS P6T Deluxe Does the rampage version have SAS ports?

Primary HD
Fujitsu Fujitsu MAX3147RC
SAS Hard Drive 147GB 15000RPM 3.5 In. new with 5yr. Manufacturer Warranty

Secondary HD
WESTERN DIGITAL - CAVIAR BLACK 750GB 7200RPM SATA HARD DISK DRIVE. 32MB BUFFER 3.5inch

Video Card
4870 1GB GDDR5 Maybe get a 2nd one later for xfire or see what the next gen brings...

Case
Antec 1200

PSU
PC Power & Cooling Turbo Cool 860
 
I think its better to go with a Fujitsu SAS Drive for OS loading + favorite game & get a 2nd drive such as WD Black or even another SAS drive if you have money to burn. ...

I'm confused. Are you suggesting your build to the OP or are you asking for opinions on your build? If the latter, please start a new thread. If the former, yes, the P6T has 2 onboard SAS connectors, but I'm not sure a single SAS drive is worth the price premium over SATA drives.

http://www.storagereview.com/php/be...&devID_4=361&devID_5=309&devID_6=345&devCnt=7

The Caviar Black and Spinpoint F1 would outperform a 15k SAS drive, according to storagereview.com's benchmark.

SAS drives are enterprise class hardware. Such hardware isn't necessarily faster than mainstream counterparts, but simply more durable/reliable. They are designed to have low failure rates, good error correction, and for optimal performance within redundant arrays (RAID arrays).

I am suggesting the OP think about SAS over the velociraptor.

The VRaptor outperforms a 15k RPM SAS drive, according to SR.
 
I am suggesting the OP think about SAS over the velociraptor.


They are comparing a Maxtor SAS to WD Raptor lets see some Raptor VS Fujitsu SAS...I cannot seem to find it but I did read while back that Fujitsu sas kicks ASS of Raptor somewhere.
 
Here is a question.

He was looking for 3x2GB DDR3 1066 (due to the 940 chip only handling 1066 vs 1333 or 1600) but could only find dual channel 2X2GB on newegg. Can you just add another 2GB chip to make this 3 channel or is this a certain configuration within the memory when you buy this way versus buying 3 separate 2GB DIMMS? There are ones labeled Triple channel (3X1GB) but can you just buy 3 separate GB DIMMS and create this tri channel or is this something built into the memory itself?

i.e. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820134828

He would like 3x2GB while he will be running Vista 64bit.
 
I think I found the answer. It says that there will be a triple (3x2GB) Triple Channel memory out there (i.e. Kingston KVR1066D3N7K3/6G) but not until 19 Nov. Hopefully there will be others.

What is the max memory for Vista 64 bit?
 
I think I found the answer. It says that there will be a triple (3x2GB) Triple Channel memory out there (i.e. Kingston KVR1066D3N7K3/6G) but not until 19 Nov. Hopefully there will be others.

What is the max memory for Vista 64 bit?

Theoretically 17.2 billion gigabyte. The max RAM on the X58 chipset is 12GB. You can also use DDR3 1333 RAM which are already out with 3x2 sets:
Corsair TR3X6G1333C9 3 x 2GB DDR3 1333 RAM - $249
 
The faster RAM will just run at 1066. It isn't that they won't work at all.
 
Danny Bui,

I think, according to Wikipedia and I have not researched this anymore than that, is that the 920 and 940 chips can only accept DDR 1066 RAM. Is this correct?

Not really. If you had looked at HardOCP's previews for the Core i7 920, you would have clearly seen that DDR3 1600 RAM was being used in the previews. Since the Core i7 920 system was working pretty damn stable, it looks like higher speed RAM is supported.
 
Holy jesus, $3k and it's not even i7?
My rig cost me below $600 after a year of deal hunting. If you want to spend it all, get yourself a Planar 24'' LCD and blow the rest on an i7 rig.. take advantage of the live.com cashback, and shop outside of newegg. If you're in the tri-state area like I am, taxes can be a hoe waiting to be slapped.
 
Holy jesus, $3k and it's not even i7?
My rig cost me below $600 after a year of deal hunting. If you want to spend it all, get yourself a Planar 24'' LCD and blow the rest on an i7 rig.. take advantage of the live.com cashback, and shop outside of newegg. If you're in the tri-state area like I am, taxes can be a hoe waiting to be slapped.


No I think he has a new spec list some where in this thread with an I7.

Hey OP which video card did you decide on? Also why a 22 inch monitor? Why not a 24 or above? Benq gotta a sale going...
 
He wants 2 monitors, preferably of the same size. He has 2 19" ones right now and was thinking of upgrading to 2 22" ones. I am not sure if he would want to look at 2 24" or a 24" and a 19 or 22" monitor. Looks better when they are the same size.
 
This was the latest Specs

CPU - i7 940

CPU Cooler - Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme HSF with Scythe fan

Motherboard - ASUS P6T Rampage Extreme

Memory - ? but will have to be DDR3 1066 due to the i7 940 chip only being able to handle this......According to others this might not be an issue to use 1333 memory but what is everyone's opinion on this.

Video Card - VisionTek HD 4870X2

Power - Corsair 1000HX Modular PSU

Hard Drives - VRaptor 300GB and a WD Green Power 1 TB

SamSung DVD Burner

Monitor - LG L227WTG-PF Black 22" 2ms Widescreen LCD Monitor - Retail (2)

Planar 997-5253-00 Black Dual Monitor Stand for LCD Displays - Retail

Case - Antec Twelve Hundred case from FrozenCPU (Below)
Antec Twelve Hundred Full Tower Gaming Case
Select A Cold Cathode Kit: Dual UV Cold CathodeDual UV Cold Cathode ($9.99)
Professional Sound Dampening Installation: ($49.99)
Select Fan Control Unit: Variable Speed RheoBus v.3Variable Speed RheoBus v.3 ($27.99)
Select Fan Contoller Installation: Regular Installation ($24.00)
Install Cold Cathode Switch On Side Panel: Yes (Blue Full Lense LED) ($12.49)
 
He is about to purchase many of these items except the ones that are out of stock, which are only a couple.

Please let me know if you think the 4870x2 is overkill or not for 2 22" monitors or if he should go with the GTX280 or a 4870 as I have seen some comms concerning this in this thread.

Also, on the memory, can I get an answer if you can use the 1333 memory with the 940 chip or do you have to get the 1066 triple channel?
 
Gigabyte site says 24GB for their X58 boards. :confused:

EDIT: MSI site also says 24GB for theirs. Asus site says 12GB for theirs.

Ok, I had thought I had heard of a 12GB limit on a mobo and I think it was the ASUS that [H]ard reviewed, looks like it's not cross manufacture though. 12 GB is a lot of memory, even if your making ram disks.
 
Plus ASUS is a great board as is Gigabyte but he has had an ASUS board for some time now and has had no issues. ASUS A8N SLI I believe
 
Memory - ? but will have to be DDR3 1066 due to the i7 940 chip only being able to handle this......According to others this might not be an issue to use 1333 memory but what is everyone's opinion on this.

DDR3-1333 is fine if he wants some room to OC. This is a work in progress, and someone will correct me if my calcs are wrong...

/*------------- <cut n paste> -------------*/
Formulas for Intel Core i7 platform @ default settings:
c × [Host Clock] = CPU speed (c = CPU Multiplier)
r × [Host Clock] = RAM speed (r = RAM Multiplier)
q × [Host Clock] × 2 = QPI speed (q = QPI Multiplier)
Default Host Clock is 133Mhz for the current i7 chips.

i7.940:
22×133 = 2.9GHz Core; [6|8]×133 = DDR3-800 /1066; 18×133×2 = 4.8GT/s; << STOCK speeds
22×166 = 3.6GHz Core; [6|8]×166 = DDR3-996 /1333; 18×166×2 = 5.9GT/s; << Nice OC
22×173 = 3.8GHz Core; [6|8]×173 = DDR3-1038/1384; 18×173×2 = 6.2GT/s; << Great OC; Near max on good air.
/*------------- </cut n paste> -------------*/

EDIT: Just make sure the RAM you choose operates at the advertised speed at 1.65v or lower!!!

From what I've read so far, there's not a huge performance difference at the different RAM speeds as long as you're using triple channel. So if DDR3-1066 is significantly cheaper, he can go with that if he's on a tight budget, since you have a choice with the memory multiplier.
 
DDR3-1333 is fine if he wants some room to OC. This is a work in progress, and someone will correct me if my calcs are wrong...

/*------------- <cut n paste> -------------*/
Formulas for Intel Core i7 platform @ default settings:
c × [Host Clock] = CPU speed (c = CPU Multiplier)
r × [Host Clock] = RAM speed (r = RAM Multiplier)
q × [Host Clock] × 2 = QPI speed (q = QPI Multiplier)
Default Host Clock is 133Mhz for the current i7 chips.

i7.940:
22×133 = 2.9GHz Core; [6|8]×133 = DDR3-800 /1066; 18×133×2 = 4.8GT/s; << STOCK speeds
22×166 = 3.6GHz Core; [6|8]×166 = DDR3-996 /1333; 18×166×2 = 5.9GT/s; << Nice OC
22×173 = 3.8GHz Core; [6|8]×173 = DDR3-1038/1384; 18×173×2 = 6.2GT/s; << Great OC; Near max on good air.
/*------------- </cut n paste> -------------*/

EDIT: Just make sure the RAM you choose operates at the advertised speed at 1.65v or lower!!!

From what I've read so far, there's not a huge performance difference at the different RAM speeds as long as you're using triple channel. So if DDR3-1066 is significantly cheaper, he can go with that if he's on a tight budget, since you have a choice with the memory multiplier.

iirc, because the memory controller is integrated in the CPU, you don't need to match RAM speeds to a multiple of the FSB.
 
Get a 4870 with 1 Gb of ram....but why not a 24 inch wide screen? Imagine how much more efficient it will be using a bigger monitor in excel & Far Cry!
 
I think I am going back to my original pick on the video card...BFG 260 MaxCore
 
Back
Top