Regular Cars Getting Black Boxes?

lol you guys are FUNNY!

OBDII based cars have been logging the last 5 seconds prior to Air bag deployment since just about it's inception.

The critical things it keeps tracks or all all engine vitals (oil psi, engine temp, RPM), ground speed, wheel speed (different if the ground speed is based on the wheels with power v. the wheels that are just along for the ride), steering angle, throttle position, brake pressure and the cars with stability control, yaw rates, lateral G, Longitudal G's and vertical G's.

This is NOTHING new.

Invasion of privacy. No as the only time that information is stored is after Air Bag deployment. So if you were screwing around @ 150 mph on the street and have an accident that deploys the air bag/s. The computer will tatle on you ;)
 
lol you guys are FUNNY!

OBDII based cars have been logging the last 5 seconds prior to Air bag deployment since just about it's inception.

The critical things it keeps tracks or all all engine vitals (oil psi, engine temp, RPM), ground speed, wheel speed (different if the ground speed is based on the wheels with power v. the wheels that are just along for the ride), steering angle, throttle position, brake pressure and the cars with stability control, yaw rates, lateral G, Longitudal G's and vertical G's.

This is NOTHING new.

Invasion of privacy. No as the only time that information is stored is after Air Bag deployment. So if you were screwing around @ 150 mph on the street and have an accident that deploys the air bag/s. The computer will tatle on you ;)
Read the article, the GT-R is logging it over several days.
 
As a guy who recently bought a $30,000 BMW only to have Carfax (and Carmax) report A YEAR LATER that it had been in a crash with the previous owner that neither I nor (supposedly) the dealer knew about, I welcome this.

This would be great for car rental companies as well, to keep people from peeling out and burning up the brakes, etc just because they bought insurance on the vehicle.

If you are planning on keeping your car forever, you shouldn't worry about it.

If you are planning on selling it, then if you are driving it appropriately you also shouldn't worry about it.

As long as the government keeps their filthy hands off of it, it can only help the consumer.
 
As long as the government keeps their filthy hands off of it, it can only help the consumer.

If they do, and the insurance does, then yeah everything would be fine. Except that doesn't happen. Even if laws are passed that it is illegal for law inforcement to view this info, that only keeps it out of the court room. It doesn't stop the renegade cop, or the cop that wants some dirt on his neighbor.

It doesn't stop the insurance company from using it against you, even if it is malfunctioning. There are processes in place to get bad stuff off your credit report, but have you actually tried getting something that is legitametly wrong taken off your credit report?

There is also nothing stopping the goverment from deciding to pass a law in 10 years that lets them suddenly have access to all that data to "fight terrorism". Oh wait, didn't they just do that with telecoms?
 
Read the article, the GT-R is logging it over several days.

Yes, but after that period it "forgets" the information. If you let your car sit there for 5 days (lets use 5 days as an exaple), it would have forgotten all the previous data. The data is only logged during a crash, so here is an idea, don't crash.. and if it isn't your fault, this is a valuable tool to have.

If they do, and the insurance does, then yeah everything would be fine. Except that doesn't happen. Even if laws are passed that it is illegal for law inforcement to view this info, that only keeps it out of the court room. It doesn't stop the renegade cop, or the cop that wants some dirt on his neighbor.

So what is this "dirt" going to do when you can't use it in court? LOL.

Also, you can't dig this "dirt" on anyone without breaking a lot of laws, renegade cop or not.. he now becomes a criminal. Secondly, the information is only tapped when the car is wrecked and the police have reason to believe that something may be more serious involved (remember steffan erikson anyone? remember the explorer rollovers?). Also, as all law extraction tools, chain of custody must be excersized and you can't just sieze anything you want.

This isn't the movies.

It doesn't stop the insurance company from using it against you, even if it is malfunctioning.

If it's malfunctioning, you most likley would be dead, as your airbags wouldn't have deployed.

Also, insurance companies don't have access to this information, but thats not stopping them from trying. The logs only provide a small sample of information.

There are processes in place to get bad stuff off your credit report, but have you actually tried getting something that is legitametly wrong taken off your credit report?

This isn't a credit report....

There is also nothing stopping the goverment from deciding to pass a law in 10 years that lets them suddenly have access to all that data to "fight terrorism". Oh wait, didn't they just do that with telecoms?

Uhhh, so you think these things logs for 10 years or so?
 
guess 2012 is the last year I can buy a new car.

waddup classic cars! ;)

this isn't a bad thing in itself, but it has way too much potential to be abused, thus nuking any good it could possible do. you were doing 1 over the limit in an accident? raised premiums! you were having a little fun a couple minutes or days before that accident? oh damn, there go your premiums, and oh hey tickets! waddup??

good idea, no possible way to execute it well.
 
It's no ones business whether I drive slow or if I drive fast unless I'm endangering others. Sorry, but when I get off work at midnight and theres no one on the highway, it is not your business whether I'm going the speed limit or not. Why the hell should that be?

So apparently everyone that doesn't want a black box in their car must be an idiot that drives like a maniac?


Given that breaking the speed limit is a crime -- yes, yes it is our (law enforcement agencies) business whether you're going the speed limit or not. Speed limits are in place for a reason, they are not friendly suggestions.

There is no issue of privacy here. You are on public roads, in plain sight. Nothing you do in your car on the road is private, least of all your driving performance.

And yes, everyone that is rabidly opposed to these black boxes for "privacy" concerns is an idiot that drives like a maniac. There is no other reason to be opposed to them. If you're going down the road and your axel drops out, causing you to run into another vehicle, these boxes might be able to record this information and show a mitigating circumstance. There is nothing private about how fast you're going, how much you're turning, or any other driving/vehicle performance data.
 
I assume he means 60 is too slow. Here in Atlanta, the speed limit on highways inside the perimeter is 55, but most people drive about 80. I've tried driving 55 before and it was downright terrifying with all the cars coming up that fast behind me and having to swerve around at the last second.

Actualy, "most people" drive about 65 on the inner/outer loop. And if you'll notice, metro cops don't pull people over for doing 65, which is keeping with the flow of traffic. Somebody doing 80 who's slaloming between cars will get picked up, yes.

No court is going to bust you for keeping up with traffic. You can make the very valid case that traffic is moving at 65 and you must keep up for safety reasons, as long as you're not passing people. As a general rule of thumb, don't pass somebody if you're going above the speed limit.

This thread is mostly people complaining that insurance companies are evil (a well-known fact), not that the box is an invasion of privacy. Because it isn't. The actual complaint is what insurance companies will do with more accurate data about your public driving performance, and that's an entirely separate issue. What cops do with your driving data to ticket/arrest you is also a different story, but the bottom line there is that if you're breaking the law you don't have a leg to stand on.
 
Just finished watching Lakeview Terrace, didn't you? :p

Havn't seen the movie, don't plan to. However I know people who have gotten on the wrong side of thier neighbor cops. The fact is a significant (notice I don't say all, or most, just a siginficant) amount of people become cops for the power.
 
It's no ones business whether I drive slow or if I drive fast unless I'm endangering others. Sorry, but when I get off work at midnight and theres no one on the highway, it is not your business whether I'm going the speed limit or not. Why the hell should that be?

Breaking the law in a public area is, by definition, The People's business.
 
And yes, everyone that is rabidly opposed to these black boxes for "privacy" concerns is an idiot that drives like a maniac. There is no other reason to be opposed to them.

I'm rabidly opposed to them.

But I am not an idiot and I do not break the law while behind the wheel of my vehicle.

I'm opposed to them because they represent yet another instance of the erosion of our privacy. I don't want my actions constantly recorded for later viewing by law enforcement, government officials, friends, or family members.
 
Yes, but after that period it "forgets" the information. If you let your car sit there for 5 days (lets use 5 days as an exaple), it would have forgotten all the previous data. The data is only logged during a crash, so here is an idea, don't crash.. and if it isn't your fault, this is a valuable tool to have.
First off, WHY are they logging the past 5 days? 5 mins before an accident would be irrelevent to the accident.

So what is this "dirt" going to do when you can't use it in court? LOL.
There are a lot of ways for private information to hurt you outside of court.
Also, you can't dig this "dirt" on anyone without breaking a lot of laws, renegade cop or not.. he now becomes a criminal. Secondly, the information is only tapped when the car is wrecked and the police have reason to believe that something may be more serious involved (remember steffan erikson anyone? remember the explorer rollovers?). Also, as all law extraction tools, chain of custody must be excersized and you can't just sieze anything you want.

This isn't the movies.
No it's not. I would have assumed warrentless wiretapping would have been something that was only in the movies too, but look where we are today.

If it's malfunctioning, you most likley would be dead, as your airbags wouldn't have deployed.

Also, insurance companies don't have access to this information, but thats not stopping them from trying. The logs only provide a small sample of information.
Your only 1 step away from this being recorded for the life of the vehicle. As a "feature" so show people that you really drove your car how you said you did.
This isn't a credit report....
No, but the amount of red tape would probably be the same.

Uhhh, so you think these things logs for 10 years or so?
Your right, the way it is implemented now your probably at risk. Your 1 step from it though. Onstar now has a "feature" that they are rolling out this fall that lets onstar disable your accelerator remotely. Now I'm sure the authorities will only use that with a proper warrant and your permission, just like they did before they tapped peoples phone lines.... oh wait... that's right. :rolleyes:
 
First off, WHY are they logging the past 5 days? 5 mins before an accident would be irrelevent to the accident.


There are a lot of ways for private information to hurt you outside of court.

No it's not. I would have assumed warrentless wiretapping would have been something that was only in the movies too, but look where we are today.


Your only 1 step away from this being recorded for the life of the vehicle. As a "feature" so show people that you really drove your car how you said you did.

No, but the amount of red tape would probably be the same.


Your right, the way it is implemented now your probably at risk. Your 1 step from it though. Onstar now has a "feature" that they are rolling out this fall that lets onstar disable your accelerator remotely. Now I'm sure the authorities will only use that with a proper warrant and your permission, just like they did before they tapped peoples phone lines.... oh wait... that's right. :rolleyes:

one word: paranoid.

Sorry vengence, but you're just being paranoid. It's just a black box, not the Echelon spy satellite.
 
I'm no conspiracy theorist. I'm not paranoid.

But I am concerned about privacy. Our privacy has been slowly eroded bit by bit for a long time. This is just another affront to our ability to keep our lives and activities private.
 
First off, WHY are they logging the past 5 days? 5 mins before an accident would be irrelevent to the accident.

The GTR is a complicated machine, you can't get a 30 second window of the cars actions and performance... you need a nice long record so you can tune your car. The GTR type guys are the guys who's going to be plugging computers into them (like the corvette guys) and tuning their car accordingly.

There are a lot of ways for private information to hurt you outside of court.

Bad driving not being one of them.

No it's not. I would have assumed warrentless wiretapping would have been something that was only in the movies too, but look where we are today.

This is isn't wiretapping.... wiretapping is a proactive approach, this is a reactive approach (you wrecked for example).

Your only 1 step away from this being recorded for the life of the vehicle. As a "feature" so show people that you really drove your car how you said you did.

Actually I like this, because then I wouldn't have gotten ripped on a car I bought a long time ago... and I would get a good return on investment because I don't tear it through my ass.

No, but the amount of red tape would probably be the same.

Replace computer. Not much red tape there ;)

Your right, the way it is implemented now your probably at risk. Your 1 step from it though. Onstar now has a "feature" that they are rolling out this fall that lets onstar disable your accelerator remotely. Now I'm sure the authorities will only use that with a proper warrant and your permission, just like they did before they tapped peoples phone lines.... oh wait... that's right. :rolleyes:

I'm all for theft recovery, nothing is worse than having your pride and joy being on the 11 o clock news trashed by some kids.

The current features allows you to locate your car, so not much diffrent. Also keep in mind, most police respond units do not use onstar location because some departments deem it as a privacy violation. Search google and you will see a few hits where onstar or the police department refused to pursue a theft location. Kinda sucky.
 
Yes. I will say it bluntly, you're an idiot.

Speed limits exist for a reason, for the small percentage of something out of the norm occuring, causing you to brake suddenly and spin/flip/fly off the road. You may not care about what happens to your own life, but others do, someone has to pull the steering well out of the gouged out portion of your intestines when you've slammed a solid object at well over 100km/h (60mp/h).

Yes, they exist (at least here in america) to curb the use of oil. (for the most part)
 
one word: paranoid.

Sorry vengence, but you're just being paranoid. It's just a black box, not the Echelon spy satellite.

I don't think that this little black box is going to do anything for my privacy. I don't think it is going to affect me ever. However, it is one more step down the slippery slope.

This brings us to the point where all we need to have everyone's car/position being constantly recoreded/monitored is a connection to the car or internet. Well, Onstar already has that. Congragulations, you've just done the hardware install for the goverment. Now they just have to write the software. Or just demand Onstar give up the location for that "terrorist".
 
its-a-conspiracy.jpg
 
oy vey.

Darwinism's gonna catch up with you some day.

Um, what?

Do you know why speed limits are what they are? How old are you?

Look up the 1974 Emergency Highway Energy Conservation Act. That's the act that imposed the 55 mph national speed limit for the express purposes of limiting fuel consumption.
 
I don't think that this little black box is going to do anything for my privacy. I don't think it is going to affect me ever. However, it is one more step down the slippery slope.

This brings us to the point where all we need to have everyone's car/position being constantly recoreded/monitored is a connection to the car or internet. Well, Onstar already has that. Congragulations, you've just done the hardware install for the goverment. Now they just have to write the software. Or just demand Onstar give up the location for that "terrorist".

You do realize that onstar is optional right? You also realize you can disable onstar by either unplugging the unit, the antenna, or simply removing the communications box? It takes less than 5 mins to disable an Onstar vechicle.... You also realize that onstar is only available for GM products right? Other companies have similar offerings on a very limited selection and for a very different purpose.

But I'm sure you knew that.....
 
Um, what?

Do you know why speed limits are what they are? How old are you?

Look up the 1974 Emergency Highway Energy Conservation Act. That's the act that imposed the 55 mph national speed limit for the express purposes of limiting fuel consumption.

Don't throw books in my face, and come on, you can do better than attacking people's age. If oil was the only reason for speed limits, then why the fuck are there 100 different speeds posted on different streets?

Speed limits are set for your safety. Oil concerns are secondary.

And if you must know, I turned 36 last week, so piss off.
 
Don't throw books in my face, and come on, you can do better than attacking people's age. If oil was the only reason for speed limits, then why the fuck are there 100 different speeds posted on different streets?

Speed limits are set for your safety. Oil concerns are secondary.

And if you must know, I turned 36 last week, so piss off.

It was originally designed for oil consumption, however, when they did this, they realized how much less problems occurred and how effective it was at curbing fatalities.

I love it when people say that they can speed because it used to be a speed free zone and thats how it was in the past. I wonder how this argument will change when I mention slavery, religious persecution, trail of tears, Salem witch trials, etc.... things changes and a lot of times it's for good reasons.

The last thing I want is a no speed limit with some of the nut bags we have on the road today, holy crap.
 
You do realize that onstar is optional right? You also realize you can disable onstar by either unplugging the unit, the antenna, or simply removing the communications box? It takes less than 5 mins to disable an Onstar vechicle.... You also realize that onstar is only available for GM products right? Other companies have similar offerings on a very limited selection and for a very different purpose.

But I'm sure you knew that.....

I can stop from being wire tapped by just unplugging my phone too.
 
I can stop from being wire tapped by just unplugging my phone too.

You are really stuck on that wiretapping thing aren't you? Straw man.

Your phone you need, just like a car, but you can't use the phone when it's unplugged can you? You don't need onstar in the car if you don't want it, you can either unplug it and use your car or buy any of the other brands out there that does not feature onstar.


Btw, costco sells heavy duty tin foil on the cheap, you can buy a 300' roll of it.
 
All you guys arguing that "it's no big deal" are just enabling the government and other entities to erode our rights.

It's exactly that attitude that lets them slowly whittle away at us.
 
Oh, and saying that everyone who cares about privacy and has the intelligence to see the path we're on paranoid idiots does yourself more of a disservice than anyone else.
 
All you guys arguing that "it's no big deal" are just enabling the government and other entities to erode our rights.

It's exactly that attitude that lets them slowly whittle away at us.

Oh, and saying that everyone who cares about privacy and has the intelligence to see the path we're on paranoid idiots does yourself more of a disservice than anyone else.

Actually, we're defending our actual rights, and not breaking out the tinfoil over rights we don't actually have in the first place.

If the government tries to put a Federal Camera in our house or our bathrooms (as you folks are so fond of pointing to), we cite our privacy rights and keep them out. When they try to monitor the speed of our cars, which they already do with radarguns, we acknowledge that the authorities have the right to know whether or not we are obeying the traffic laws.

These boxes don't have cameras in your car, they don't record your voice conversations. They record your driving and performance data. This information is not private information, as it is data anyone can see by watching you drive on the public roads you are using. If a police officer is behind you on the road, you have no right to tell him to stop following you because he's invading your privacy -- primarily because he's not.

No, we are not allowing our rights to be eroded. The second these boxes start recording video of what happens inside your vehicle and broadcasting that to youtube, then we will rightfully protest them. But as long as they are recording basic performance data, we're not going to FUD all over the place like some of you seem to think is necessary. It is, despite what you may think, entirely possible to stand up for your rights without flipping your wig every time a new technology comes along that streamlines and optimizes the enforcement of the law.

Calling you all paranoid is no more a disservice to us than you saying we don't care about our rights is to you. You're employing just as much hyperbole as anyone else is here.

To reiterate, because so many don't seem to get it: Data on how fast you are driving and other driving style information is not private information. Your privacy is not being invaded. It is just as non-private as if you were to stand in the road and pull down your pants. You are on public property and your actions on this public property are public information.

Not that your data is even being broadcast to the public. It is being used, when deemed neccessary, by law enforcement agencies and insurance companies.
 
I think that there are those possiblities that it coule be used against you.
However, I have an MSP running 24PSI on pump gas and it has two piggy backs in it allready so I feel that the aftermarket will rise up to meet this challenge and those in the know will be able to defeat it.
 
I think that there are those possiblities that it coule be used against you.
However, I have an MSP running 24PSI on pump gas and it has two piggy backs in it allready so I feel that the aftermarket will rise up to meet this challenge and those in the know will be able to defeat it.

Actually, the aftermarket groups are not rising up to it, they are embracing it... the unit can be tapped by performance enthusiasts and it shows you much greater detail the vital statistics of your car.

The only way it can be used against you is if you killed another motorist while you were breaking the law (drunk for example). It's your word against a dead mans word, not anymore.
 
Personally speaking I want the government to do as much for me and monitor me and my family as much as possible. I want an RFID implanted in my head and on every form of ID. I want my kids tagged too in case they try to run away or get kidnapped. I want my RFID chip to have all my banking info, drivers license number, social security number, allergies and medical history, what I like to have for breakfast as well as my favorite products. I want companies like Johnson & Johnson and AT&T to have instant access to the info too. I want all ISP's to use deep packet inspection to constantly gather data and monitor my surfing habits and let me know if I'm starting to get out of line. The other added benefit of that is they know how to market directly to my likes and needs making me a better and more productive member of this great free democratic country we call the United States Of America. A black box in my car is just icing on the cake in my opinion. Why not have one in my home too? That way if there's an accident they can tell what happened. Or if I justa had a ruff day at the office and want to come home and beat my wife and kids my government can stop me and send me to a two week social rehabilitation program.


Fitter, happier, more productive.
 
Personally speaking I want the government to do as much for me and monitor me and my family as much as possible. I want an RFID implanted in my head and on every form of ID. I want my kids tagged too in case they try to run away or get kidnapped. I want my RFID chip to have all my banking info, drivers license number, social security number, allergies and medical history, what I like to have for breakfast as well as my favorite products. I want companies like Johnson & Johnson and AT&T to have instant access to the info too. I want all ISP's to use deep packet inspection to constantly gather data and monitor my surfing habits and let me know if I'm starting to get out of line. The other added benefit of that is they know how to market directly to my likes and needs making me a better and more productive member of this great free democratic country we call the United States Of America. A black box in my car is just icing on the cake in my opinion. Why not have one in my home too? That way if there's an accident they can tell what happened. Or if I justa had a ruff day at the office and want to come home and beat my wife and kids my government can stop me and send me to a two week social rehabilitation program.


Fitter, happier, more productive.

Oh brave new world, that has such people in it.
 
It is true that alot of cars have come with them for quite some time. But dealers and Mfg's use them a majority of the time for something else. Denying warranty work. Dealership my buddy worked at was a licensed Lotus dealer. I use to see all the printouts they took from the onboard blackboxes from elises when something went wrong. It keeps track of how many clutch dumps you have done, how many hole shots, how many times you have gone over a certain speed, the fastest you have had it up to, logs of when you have had it at or over redline, etc. All logs were with timestamps. I've seen quite a few cars have issues, most likely from the owner, who had their warranty denied. Even revoked where they never have a warranty on the car again.

I guess having to personally fight with a mfg (subaru) for warranty work, I view this differently than most. Almost all cars have onboard systems that record when an accident happens. Adding black boxes is just a way for them to monitor the way you use your car and possibly hold it against you when the time comes. I can't say this is why they were designed, but thats how it gets twisted around to be used against the owner.
 
It is true that alot of cars have come with them for quite some time. But dealers and Mfg's use them a majority of the time for something else. Denying warranty work. Dealership my buddy worked at was a licensed Lotus dealer. I use to see all the printouts they took from the onboard blackboxes from elises when something went wrong. It keeps track of how many clutch dumps you have done, how many hole shots, how many times you have gone over a certain speed, the fastest you have had it up to, logs of when you have had it at or over redline, etc. All logs were with timestamps. I've seen quite a few cars have issues, most likely from the owner, who had their warranty denied. Even revoked where they never have a warranty on the car again.

I guess having to personally fight with a mfg (subaru) for warranty work, I view this differently than most. Almost all cars have onboard systems that record when an accident happens. Adding black boxes is just a way for them to monitor the way you use your car and possibly hold it against you when the time comes. I can't say this is why they were designed, but thats how it gets twisted around to be used against the owner.


It's almost as if warranties are on the workmanship of the car under normal use, and not on it breaking when you deliberately stress the parts beyond their intended limits. Computer part manufacturers void your warranty when you OC your parts, car manufacturers/dealers void your warranty when you redline it extensively or subject it to obscene power transfers. Sounds about right.
 
It's almost as if warranties are on the workmanship of the car under normal use, and not on it breaking when you deliberately stress the parts beyond their intended limits. Computer part manufacturers void your warranty when you OC your parts, car manufacturers/dealers void your warranty when you redline it extensively or subject it to obscene power transfers. Sounds about right.

Yet no one bitches how a computer has a record of what they have done to it... but they freak out when a car has that record. It's essentially the same thing.

Heh, I'm surprised we find all these tin hats here on a computer enthusiast forum...
 
It's almost as if warranties are on the workmanship of the car under normal use, and not on it breaking when you deliberately stress the parts beyond their intended limits. Computer part manufacturers void your warranty when you OC your parts, car manufacturers/dealers void your warranty when you redline it extensively or subject it to obscene power transfers. Sounds about right.

I'm sorry... Correct me if I'm wrong. But, are you trying to say that lotus expects people to drive the car "normally". That sounds like an exercise in futility. a good majority of the engines they use are either superchared or turboed from the factory. that alone will stress the poor little honda 1.8 or toyota 1.8s they put in there.

You do realize that companies like Ferrari don't consider the L.A. bumper to bumper stop and go traffic "normal". I've heard of plenty that have over heated in that "normal" driving condition. so normal is subjective and dealers are always looking to save a buck where they can by deeming your "normal" driving destructive or out of the spec range.
 
I'm sorry... Correct me if I'm wrong. But, are you trying to say that lotus expects people to drive the car "normally". That sounds like an exercise in futility. a good majority of the engines they use are either superchared or turboed from the factory. that alone will stress the poor little honda 1.8 or toyota 1.8s they put in there.

You do realize that companies like Ferrari don't consider the L.A. bumper to bumper stop and go traffic "normal". I've heard of plenty that have over heated in that "normal" driving condition. so normal is subjective and dealers are always looking to save a buck where they can by deeming your "normal" driving destructive or out of the spec range.

Actually yes, I would never burn out on an exotic like that and never have. Those people who can obviously afford to trash an exotic car can afford to pay for repairs.

Just because the car has a lot of power and was racing inspired, it doesn't mean its meant to peel rubber around every turn, redline at every light, dragged, and dropped into gears hot.
 
Back
Top