Monitor size for a Radeon HD 4870?

Brose

n00b
Joined
Jul 2, 2008
Messages
33
I currently have a 19" LCD monitor and was told that a Radeon HD 4870 wouldn't run much better than a Radeon HD 4850 because of the lower resolution.

So would a 22" Widescreen 1680 x 1050 resolution LCD monitor take advantage of the 4870's higher speeds? Or would I still be better off with the 4850?
 
Well, both cards are 512MB, which is about perfect for 1680 x 1050.
Monitor size really has nothing to do with it, just the resolution.
 
I am sure it does, but a 22" 1680x1050 resolution monitor is as much as I am willing to spend on atm.

So, I am still wondering if I am going to notice that much difference with a 4870 over 4850 at 1680x1050 resolution.
 
i would say with new games around the corner get the better video card you can afford within reason. the 4850 will run any game out now decent at that rez u may just have to tweak settings to get the fps you want, the same goes with the 4870. these cards will only drop in price in the next few months as newer cards come out of course. Also if you do not plan to up grade to a 24" monitor in the next year or so i would say the 50 is fine, if you want to be futureproof get the 70.. or crossfire the 50 when u need 2.

gl have fun..
 
i don't get it. some one about to drop 300 bones on a video card but not spend 300 bones on a 19x12 to let that card shine.
 
I recommend buying a 19x12 monitor and getting the 4850. The monitor will last much longer than the video card, and the 4850 will play most anything at nice settings at that resolution.



$300 24"s are crap

Yes, but there are some (relatively) nice ones to be had at $350-$400
 
1920x1200 rocks.

Yes.

i don't get it. some one about to drop 300 bones on a video card but not spend 300 bones on a 19x12 to let that card shine.

Yes!

I recommend buying a 19x12 monitor and getting the 4850. The monitor will last much longer than the video card, and the 4850 will play most anything at nice settings at that resolution.


Yes, but there are some (relatively) nice ones to be had at $350-$400

YES!!!
 
I beg to differ. I paid 270 out the door for my MVA soyo 24" and couldnt be happier. It blows away the 400 dollar Acer 24" monitor i have sitting next to it.

QFT. I have that $300 Soyo and I must say, it's one of the best bang-for-buck monitors out there.
 
a- the cheapest 19x12 monitor is the soyo, an MVA, but since ALL the 22" are TN, it is no use say that cheap 24" are crap, all 24"are at least as bad as the 22" around.

b- considering that a 4850 is almost $120 cheaper than a 4870, one can ask what is better: a 22" using a 4870 or a 24" using a 4850. If gaming pleasure is the goal i must say that once you go BIG you never go back:D The 4850 can run (over 30fps minimum) quite a few games at 19x12 if you leave aside Crysis on high and Age of Conan with Blurr. the 4870 showed gains with the better memory mostly at 2560x1600.

c- since ATI do not have great stepups programs you can overclock the hell out the 4850, by simply removing the plastic cover of the card and attaching 2 small fans ( a sub $10 solution) and reach 4870 clocks

d-if you choose the 4870+22"" solution now and in Black friday another 24" below $250 appears (like the Soyo and the Scepter last year) i pretty much doubt you could resist the temptation.
 
I am sure it does, but a 22" 1680x1050 resolution monitor is as much as I am willing to spend on atm.

So, I am still wondering if I am going to notice that much difference with a 4870 over 4850 at 1680x1050 resolution.

What about the rest of your PC....do you have 2 gigs of decent ram, do you have a fast C2D?
Btw, the difference between 16x10 and 1920x1200 is meaningless on tiny little PC monitors.....you should be more concerned about eventually upgrading to a 8 bit 24-27in LCD rather than excess pixels sqeezed inside a tiny weeny panel.
 
i don't get it. some one about to drop 300 bones on a video card but not spend 300 bones on a 19x12 to let that card shine.
What's there to get? If I had $600-$700 laying around I wouldn't be asking this question. But, unfortunately I don't, so I want to know if it is worth upgrading to a 4870 on a 1680x1050. And I am not about to drop 300 "bones" on a GPU if its not going to shine on the 22", which is what I am trying to figure out.

If it makes more sense, I am building a whole new computer around a Q9550. I currently, have a 19" monitor that I would be more than happy with keeping. But, my father mentioned that he would buy my 19" for $220 which is the same price as the 22" monitor I was looking at. Since, I am already spending more money than I originally wanted to, I am not looking to spend money on a monitor.

I appreciate the recommendations, but I really only want to know if I will notice much difference with a 4870 over a 4850 on 1680x1050. A couple of you gave indirect answers, but I hope someone can answer more directly.
 
I'm in the same boat as you. I have a nice Samsung 22" LCD which I love. I'm in the process of upgrading to a new pc built around either a quad 6600, quad 9450 or 8400 (I'm indecisive). My current best video card is an 8800GTS G90 and I want to get something more up to date. I'm torn between the 4850, 4870 and the GTX 260. The price point of the 4850 is more to my liking plus I can probably scrape up enough change to crossfire it in the near future. My gut instinct at this time is not the spend the extra $ for the 4870 since I'm not a hardcore gamer and don't need to inflate my "e-penis" anymore:eek:.
My over 40 eyes probably won't be able to see the diff in the cards anyway.
 
Well... Look at it this way... About six months back the hottest card on the block was 8800GT... And the most taxing game was Crysis and people with a 8800GT + a 22" Monitor were happy playing with it...

Now still the most taxing game is Crysis... But the newer Radeons 4850/4870 perform almost 1.4+ times then the 8800GT... Its just that one performs 1.4 and the latter performs 1.6 or so then the 8800GT...

Also it is now a known fact that Crysis was indeed coded badly... And the new one will perform better on the older cards... Also there is no other GPU heavy game coming this year which will tax a 4850 @ 1650... So i would suggest you to stick with a 22" + 4850.

Yes 4870 will help you in a little more FPS on the same res but the eyecandy will be same and majorly the gameply experience would "almost" be the same. You will find games running more smoother with a 4870 compared to a 4850.
 
What's there to get? If I had $600-$700 laying around I wouldn't be asking this question. But, unfortunately I don't, so I want to know if it is worth upgrading to a 4870 on a 1680x1050. And I am not about to drop 300 "bones" on a GPU if its not going to shine on the 22", which is what I am trying to figure out.

If it makes more sense, I am building a whole new computer around a Q9550. I currently, have a 19" monitor that I would be more than happy with keeping. But, my father mentioned that he would buy my 19" for $220 which is the same price as the 22" monitor I was looking at. Since, I am already spending more money than I originally wanted to, I am not looking to spend money on a monitor.

I appreciate the recommendations, but I really only want to know if I will notice much difference with a 4870 over a 4850 on 1680x1050. A couple of you gave indirect answers, but I hope someone can answer more directly.


Direct answer: the 4870 will perform noticeably better than the 4850 at 1680x1050.

Wankery: it's (to me) not a difference worth $120.

More wankery: you probably won't notice the difference between a q9450 and a q9550, so why not spring for a 9450, save $200, and get a 4870 and a nice 24 incher?
 
Well... Look at it this way... About six months back the hottest card on the block was 8800GT... And the most taxing game was Crysis and people with a 8800GT + a 22" Monitor were happy playing with it...

Now still the most taxing game is Crysis... But the newer Radeons 4850/4870 perform almost 1.4+ times then the 8800GT... Its just that one performs 1.4 and the latter performs 1.6 or so then the 8800GT...

Also it is now a known fact that Crysis was indeed coded badly... And the new one will perform better on the older cards... Also there is no other GPU heavy game coming this year which will tax a 4850 @ 1650... So i would suggest you to stick with a 22" + 4850.

Yes 4870 will help you in a little more FPS on the same res but the eyecandy will be same and majorly the gameply experience would "almost" be the same. You will find games running more smoother with a 4870 compared to a 4850.

Naw I got a feeling the New stalker coming out next month might stress these new cards. It is DX10 and the tech demo's just LOOK BADASS. Can't wait to play it
 
you probably won't notice the difference between a q9450 and a q9550, so why not spring for a 9450, save $200, and get a 4870 and a nice 24 incher?
I heard by the end of July the Q9450 will be discontinued and replaced by the Q9550 for the same price. Either way, I am waiting until the end of July to see what happens.
 
What's there to get? If I had $600-$700 laying around I wouldn't be asking this question. But, unfortunately I don't, so I want to know if it is worth upgrading to a 4870 on a 1680x1050. And I am not about to drop 300 "bones" on a GPU if its not going to shine on the 22", which is what I am trying to figure out.

If it makes more sense, I am building a whole new computer around a Q9550. I currently, have a 19" monitor that I would be more than happy with keeping. But, my father mentioned that he would buy my 19" for $220 which is the same price as the 22" monitor I was looking at. Since, I am already spending more money than I originally wanted to, I am not looking to spend money on a monitor.

I appreciate the recommendations, but I really only want to know if I will notice much difference with a 4870 over a 4850 on 1680x1050. A couple of you gave indirect answers, but I hope someone can answer more directly.

long story short. i like crysis and the 4870 can play crysis at 19x12 with shaders on high (pretty much the most important setting) with everything else on medium. the 4850 is as powerful as the premium cards of the last generation and they could only play crysis at 1600 res with shaders at high. the 4870 is a bad motherfucker at $300 and can run the most demanding (or most poorly coded; whatever is you're preference) game on the market as well as it can be run without spending $500.
 
long story short. i like crysis and the 4870 can play crysis at 19x12 with shaders on high (pretty much the most important setting) with everything else on medium. the 4850 is as powerful as the premium cards of the last generation and they could only play crysis at 1600 res with shaders at high. the 4870 is a bad motherfucker at $300 and can run the most demanding (or most poorly coded; whatever is you're preference) game on the market as well as it can be run without spending $500.

Ive always wondered, what exactly do you guys mean by "poorly coded"? I always wondered why Crysis was so demanding and lately alot of people have been saying it was because it was poorly coded (i think the best cited example is that crysis warhead, which should be of similar graphics, but is able to run on lower system specs then the original) and what exactly does that mean? Also do you have to have a good quality monitor to enjoy your graphics? I mean if I have a cheap 22" monitor and a 4870 but my friend has a high quality 22" monitor and a 4850, who will see the better visuals/performance if they are playing a game like Crysis or any game for that matter?
 
Personally I am using a 22" 1680x1050 with my 4850 and I love it. Most people will highly disagree with this comment... but IMO a 24" 1920x1200 is to big for me, I like to run dual monitors when I'm not gaming and my 2nd monitor is a 1280x1024. So I think its more productive to use dual medium sized monitors then just one big monitor. Then again, if your setup is 100% for gaming then maybe you want a bigger monitor.

Direct answer: If I were in your position I would take the 4850 and the 1680x1050. Can always Xfire a 2nd 4850 later if you need more graphics power. (Espcially considering you can get 2 4850's for cheaper then the 4870 at newegg after rebates and coupons.)
 
a- the cheapest 19x12 monitor is the soyo, an MVA, but since ALL the 22" are TN, it is no use say that cheap 24" are crap, all 24"are at least as bad as the 22" around.

I agree that all TN panels are crap. I hate them. Especially since I'm forced to use one.
 
You have to decide what upgrade path you will be using in the future. If you get a 24" monitor now there will be no need to upgrade it anytime soon. Then if you get a 4850 now it will do a good job for quite awhile on almost all games out there (with a couple exceptions). Later down the road you should be able to pick up the next 'bang for the buck' card that will blow away the 4850 you buy now.

HOWEVER... if you buy a 4870 now with a 22" monitor, 6 months or a year from now you will be wanting to upgrade your video card anyway to be able to play the latest games, and you wont have a 24" monitor to play them on.

YMMV, but I rarely upgrade monitors and cases (because I buy good ones). Video cards are my most often upgrade, in fact I have bought 3 video cards that have run with the same CPU. And only one monitor during that time.
 
I don't think I would reccommend a dual card setup @ 1680x1050 any longer.
IMHO and in my experience, this is the cutoff resolution where the single gpu plays the best so I would say 4870.

So, I am saying that @ 1680x1050 and below, in most cases, a single 4870 will be close or maybe even outperform 2 x 4850's and you don't have to worry about profiles or whether the game benefits from multi gpu or not or having an 800-1000 watt psu. There are a few games that really really scale with multi gpu but by and large that is not the case and the games that do, don't need freakin multi gpu anyway cause they already run great.

I recently added an 8800GTS to my existing one and absolutely minimal difference. I was so disgusted, I sold all my nvidia stuff off and went with X48 and a single 4870. Now, I did get a dual X16 board but I will never be fooled again. I am under no illusions that I can wait till 4870's get cheap and add another one to get longevity (skip a generation) out of this system as long as I stay @ 1680. That was an early promise of multi-gpu setups and it has just not worked out that way for me.

Just my 2 cents. Long story short. My answer to your question is @ 1680x1050 a single 4870 is my choice.

Now, I do know, that if I want to invest in a really nice 24"er @ 1920 I can add the other card and voila.
 
24" the least to take full advantage of hd 4870, it has enough memory for 1920x1200 if you look at the reviews and it does seem to run out of memory at 2560 resolution so for someone to suggest 512mb of ram is only good for 1680x1050 is just not right, I play every game with my hd 4870 with 8xAA at 1920x1200 and ofcourse with the exception of crysis.

I dont think that the hd 4870 will not be able to play games that come out in 6 months, sometimes I hear things that are totally irrelevant, because the games aren't even out yet and someone seems to suggest that the new cards won't be able to play games that come out in 6 months, hd 4870 and gtx 280 carry twice the performanc of previous generation and for someone to suggest that it would not be able to play newer games within 6 months period is not really a good suggestion because we just don't know that.
 
I'm ponying up for the 26" doublesight. I agree, though. I wish there were better monitor options in the 22-24" ranges.

As far as which to buy...honestly, you could probably save a buck or two and go with the 4850.

~S
 
Ive always wondered, what exactly do you guys mean by "poorly coded"? I always wondered why Crysis was so demanding and lately alot of people have been saying it was because it was poorly coded (i think the best cited example is that crysis warhead, which should be of similar graphics, but is able to run on lower system specs then the original) and what exactly does that mean? Also do you have to have a good quality monitor to enjoy your graphics? I mean if I have a cheap 22" monitor and a 4870 but my friend has a high quality 22" monitor and a 4850, who will see the better visuals/performance if they are playing a game like Crysis or any game for that matter?

i personally don't think crysis is a poorly coded game, considering how much of the game environment the engine is constantly having to render; nearly fully destructive environments, day/night transitions that effect the real time rendered shadows. the engine builds an entire island this way, not just the immediate location where you're moving around. my best guess is that the improved performance may mean that the engine does less of what i described. maybe also the reason crytek is able to get cryengine 2 to run on the consoles.
 
Back
Top