Why Apple Could Kill Nintendo’s DS

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Forbes seems to think that Apple’s iPhone and iPod Touch could eventually pose a serious threat to Nintendo’s DS. Before you scoff at the idea, think about it…everything is there to make these things great mobile gamers, all they need are the games and applications (Quake on the iPod Touch anyone?).

Monday, however, Nintendo will likely face a new and far more dangerous foe: Apple. Steve Jobs' computer and gizmo maker will likely launch a long-promised feature, dubbed the App Store, which will let outside developers pour software into the iPhone and iPod Touch.
 
This has occured to me before, but there's always one thing that I think could make it not work: buttons. Gamers need some sort of tactile feedback for high-response buttons. The DS mixes and matches buttons and a touchscreen. The iPhone/iTouch only have one button. Sure, Apple could make it work, but I think there needs to be a minimal amount of buttons there for it to work out nicely.
 
Something else I forgot that Apple does have going for it, is that the iPhone has far more processing power than any other mobile device out there. I seem to remember John Carmack being ecstatic because it had OpenGL capabilities and the power to back it up. Combine that with Apple's Core Audio/Video stuff, and you have a powerful platform that is easy to produce quality applications with very little effort.

All I really want is a Sudoku game. :D
 
I have a hard time beliving somthing like the "iphone" or even a WM6 phone is going to replace the DS or a PSP or any kinda of portable gaming device.

Mommy and daddy are not going to drop 600 bucks for a phone and then 30+ dollars more on games for that phone. And to add on to that. How are the games changed out?

I'm not a console gamer, or even a handle held one. I love my comp :D

But i do like to take my kids DS and play brain games on it. It's kinda like my HTC 6800.

Somtimes i wonder why people knee jerk themselfs.
 
The DS is priced safely in the impulse buy range and has a huge library of games. Plus it's made for gaming.

The iPod Touch may support games, but it's still a music player not made for gaming. It will have gaming success similar to the EyeToy (as in: you can, but why?).
 
by the time a new iphone is out that has enough quality games... and is under 200$... i doubt it. plus they need these in the hands of 10-18 year olds as well, college kids too. most iphone users i know are yippies, yuppies and hipsters.

by that time... nintendo could create their own all in one device, but i dont see them doing this at all since they hardly make use of the ds... (it would be a great office, business and accounting tool... such a nifty handheld device should be used more)
 
This has occured to me before, but there's always one thing that I think could make it not work: buttons. Gamers need some sort of tactile feedback for high-response buttons. The DS mixes and matches buttons and a touchscreen. The iPhone/iTouch only have one button. Sure, Apple could make it work, but I think there needs to be a minimal amount of buttons there for it to work out nicely.

I also agree with this. Gamers need high rate buttons. Be it keyboard, controller, or whatever. No buttons no gamers. Simple as that.
 
The reason why most of nieces and nephews have a nintendo handheld is because it is actually somewhat affordable and allows you to actually teach a child about how to work with money and the value of that money. With apple, all you would be teaching your child is paying to much for something provides to little so you can look like something you aren't in front of your friends.
 
Along with cost, control options, and game space, unless Nintendo starts making games for it, it ain't gonna happen. DS installed base is beyond everything for a single platform, and as previously stated, Nintendo can just come up with some new tweak and they will sell them all over again.
 
Both of my kids have a DS but they are too young for a cell phone. And speaking of cost, I have already had to replace one DS. I am very glad I was not replacing an iphone.
 
Could the iPhone be a good gaming platform? Damn straight it could!

Could the iPhone kill the Nintendo DS market? I wouldn't bet on it.

Why? The style of games. The games found on the DS take advantage of dual screens, one touch, as well as a microphone. Granted the iPhone does have a trouch screen, but it doesnt have two, or a mic.

So what? Well, quite a few notable games actually make use of these features. Zelda for example uses both aspects heavily in it's puzzles. Countless games use both screens very effectively.

So what? Well, a lot of the stylization of the DS games that make them attractive, is the fun way in which they combine the top and bottom screen, the touch aspect, and the mic. There is also the aspect that many of these games are Nintendo-esque, they're things we recognize as unique to Nintendo.

There are many games that will only do well on the DS. This is not to say that there aren't games that won't do well on the iPhone, but they will be drastically different. So much so, that the iPhone will not steal DS market share, merely generate it's own interest.

That is, if they put Crysis on it :p
 
I think that even if iPhones and other handheld mobile devices have enough hardware to encourage the growth of it as a gaming platform Nintendo will continue to dominate because of the types of titles they offer and the focus many Nintendo developers have on gameplay.

I can see the iPhone as a great platform for 'Leisure Suit Larry 14: Don't Touch Me There!' though. :D
 
I think InorganicMatter and Jroe52 hit the nail in the head.

Lack of buttons on the ipod/iphone makes it a challenge to play games on it (but not imposible).

A newer/smaller form-factor for the DS and development of "Applications" (not just games) could breathe new life to the DS and increase it customer base.

At the moment, neither platform poses a threat to each other; maybe in a fiew years.
 
also nintendo's own games help drive ds sales... so does years of programmers using their languages for game designs...

also... apple has driven their company nearly out of business tons of times... nintendo not so much
 
What, Apple Pippin? As others have noted, tactile function is a deal breaker. Leave it to Forbes Magazine to come up with this stuff. I do understand that the iPhone has taken off, especially in the modder community, but I think this is bunk for now.
 
also nintendo's own games help drive ds sales... so does years of programmers using their languages for game designs...


Very true. DS 1st Party games like Mario Kart and Animal Crossing are major selling points. Apple simply lacks the experience necessary to create legacy titles. Plus using your bulky fingers on the touch screen is far less precise than the stylus, let alone the lack of buttons.
 
It wont work, although I would be the first to buy an RTS! You can get by without buttons in an RTS I would think, same with some puzzle games. echochrome would be great on the iphone!
 
The DS can a lot of this already except make phone calls and internet (it can to some extent)
look at other phone/game platforms (engage???) they fail because they pack too much into one thing. The DS will still thrive because it does exactly what it was made to do and thats play great games without a monthly cost.

Get yourself a flash cart for the DS and you've got a mini media player, homebrew games, game ports (it plays quake)

And yes, how in the world are you going to play any game with just the touch screen??
 
I think the title needs a change

Somthing like. How apples iphone can't even touch the nintendo DS market.
 
The Gameboy and DS have been in the market longer than apple when it comes to portable gaming devices.

iWHAT? yeah Apple doesn't have shit to Nintendo.

I want the feel of a button, then tapping on a touchscreen hoping it took my input. Nintendo has competitive pricing, as Apple price fixes their crap.
 
also apple is limited to the att customers.

ds buyers come from EVERYWHERE man lol.
 
Seriously? Who the hell is going to develop games for the iPhone? It doesn't matter how capable the iPhone is of playing games if no games exist.
 
I think the bigger issue here isn't Apple, but the MID market in general. Tegra and the Atom will bring devices into the market to really challenge the PSP and the DS. Can you imagine if I made a device that was the size of an iPhone or a little bit bigger, added a D-pad, 4 or 6 buttons, and told people it could play WoW? Talk about instant sucess.
 
A Nintendo handheld in trouble of losing out to another? Since when? That will be a first.

When it comes to handhelds Nintendo knows what they are doing. They released the orginal gameboy and it beat out the gamegear and lynx as it as a longer battery life even though the others had color. They kept the system having a greenish color display till they could keep the batter life the same. Then they switched to color. Battery life has always been a major factor for them. So is making change for the good and not for the sake of making change. The DS was not meant to be a replacment for the GBA. It was meant to be a device for older people and they had a new GameBoy system that was going to replace the GBA. However the DS did well in all markets not just the adult market like the expected, so instead of releasing the new GameBoy system a year or so after the DS like they had planned they just scrapped it.

They also have the game and the first party support. That is one of the things that hurt Sony. They didn't make orginal games for the psp, they only make ports and wanted 3rd party developers to make all the new games. The PSP has been able to hold its own against the DS, but Nintendo has never been in any grave danger of the DS being killed by the PSP. Same with the iPhone. Yes it has a touch screen. But that along isn't what gives the DS its power to stay where it is in the market. Just like Sony adding motion control to the PS3 didn't kill off the Wii. It is the 1st part support that Nintendo has for their systems in addition to its features.
 
Never going to happen, not a chance.

What the OS X Touch platform will provide is a unique user interface that combines touchscreen, tilt, motion control, location awareness, as well as powerful 3D graphics (on paper the specs are even greater than the PSP). For developers, they get easy distribution to every single user out there with a very good 70/30 profit sharing plan with Apple.

What it doesn't have is the first party library of Nintendo, plus the devices all come at a much higher price tag. The iPhone/iPod Touch will thrive but it will come nowhere close to Nintendo as far as gaming goes. Nintendo is king of handheld and that market is theirs to own.
 
Seriously? Who the hell is going to develop games for the iPhone? It doesn't matter how capable the iPhone is of playing games if no games exist.

EA and Sega are already on board, and Carmack has also said that he'll be working on stuff for it. The only smartphone that has more users in the US right now is the Blackberry. Apple will easily beat their own goal of 10 million iPhones sold before the end of the year, and that isn't even counting the iPod Touch. You have easy access to that many users through the online store and you can count on lots of games (among other applications) being developed for it.

Now, them beating Nintendo, that's totally ridiculous, but it is irrelevant since on their own I think they'll do pretty well.
 
So... Forbes thinks Apple is going to take over the DS market with an N-Gage Touch eh?

If they were to launch a gaming platform for the iPod I could see it gaining some decent momentum, but for that overpriced and underfeatured iPhone with barely any installation base or even consumer interest, I don't think so. But even then, none of Apple's gadgets have ever matched Nintendo's handhelds in sheer numbers sold, not even their iPods (from 2001 to March 2008, all 10 revisions of iPods together are at 150M, from 2001 to March 2008, the combined Gameboy Advance + DS has sold 150.8M with their combined four revisions).
 
They are forgetting a couple of key factors.

1) Price. Do they really think the Wii only costing $250 had nothing to do with it blowing past the 360 and PS3? This is the same reason the PSP had problems. I know several people who bought their kids (who break stuff as most kids do) a DS instead of a PSP because of price and there is >$40 difference between the 2.

2) The top 14 selling DS games are all made by Nintendo. 28 of the top 50 selling DS games are Nintendo titles. Unless Nintendo starts making games for the IPhone, they have nothing to worry about.

3) As others have mentioned, buttons are a requirement. Buttons would ruin the look of the IPhone.

4) The DS is 4 years old now. Do they really think that Nintendo's next system will not include motion sensing. Looking at Nintendo's history, it will probably also be backwards compatible with the DS and it will still end up costing a lot less than an IPhone.


When it really comes down to it. This will be the same as the Wii vs 360/PS3 battle. Their core audience and the people they market to are completely different.

This does make me think though. Wouldn't it be awesome if Nintendo sold a version of their next hand held that was an unlocked GSM phone. Throw your SIM card in and go.
 
Apple fanbois vs. Nintendo fanbois? ARE THEY MAD? The hard radiation from such an encounter between just two such individuals will kill everything within 500 meters. The IQs of victims beyond the 500m kill-radius will drop by 100 points out to a distance of 1500m. If these two factions meet a PAX the Greater Puget Sound region will be uninhabitable for at least a thousand years.

We must enforce the Fanbois Non-Proliferation Treaty.
 
I don't want my portable gaming device ringing in the middle of a game. iPhone as a serious gaming device? No thanks.
 
Any Apple O/S = epic phail for gaming. And the screen resolution is rubbish, at only 320x240 it's not worth bothering with. The WM-powered XDA line has several variants with 640x480 touchscreens plus full keyboards which would make for a far better gaming platform.
 
Any Apple O/S = epic phail for gaming. And the screen resolution is rubbish, at only 320x240 it's not worth bothering with. The WM-powered XDA line has several variants with 640x480 touchscreens plus full keyboards which would make for a far better gaming platform.

The iPhone/iPod Touch screen is actually 480x320...
 
Back
Top