Razer AC-1 vs CMI8788 reference cards

Shorehn

Gawd
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
715
I've been looking around for a good deal on a CMI8788-based sound card to replace my X-Fi since it won't work under Linux. I don't have a lot of money to spend, ~$100, and one of the cheaper CMI8788 cards like the BGears B-Enspirer or the Sondigo Inferno seemed to be my best options. Hell, I'd love to have a Xonar D2 or an HT Omega Claro, but they're just too expensive.

Anyhow, I've been doing a lot of comparisons between the 8788 cards out there and I've learned a lot about them - for example, that the B-Enspirer and Inferno appear to use the same reference design. A quick look under the hood of Razer's AC-1 revealed that it appears to be a modified version of the reference model. The opamps, DACs, etc are the same as the Inferno and B-Enspirer, but the layout is different. Most importantly, it appears to have a FRONT PANEL AUDIO connector! Huzzah!

With Razer being Razer, I never dreamed that I'd see the AC-1 anywhere near my price range, but I've found it being sold new for $92 shipped, which is less than what the B-Enspirer is currently going for on Newegg. It just might be the option I'm looking for: a hundred bones or under, CMI8788 with decent components like the Enspirer and Inferno, and a front panel audio connector. The keyword here is "might"...how would it stack up to the reference design cards? Would having that adapter on the front adversely affect the sound, since I won't be using the Razer headset? Is this too good to be true?
 
Is this too good to be true?

what is too good to be true is that Woot had the AC-1 for $75 last week, i got one and just installed it today, and it is truly awesome. I don't have the headphones, i have used 5.1 speakers and my analog sony headphones on it, and the sound is amazing. granted i haven't tried it with games, but all the music i've played on it sounds so much better than my old card (x-fi extrememusic).

and i have vista x64 and didn't have a problem with installing it, just make sure you grab the drivers from razer's website.

seriously highly recommend this card.
 
$75? :mad: Well, better late than never, you know? No wonder there are so many of them on eBay! eBay, that's right...my secret is out :eek:

Still, I'm glad to hear that it sounds better compared to the Xtrememusic, which is what I was using before. The 8788 ALSA support is almost totally done at this point (no bloated drivers for me!) so I think I'll try my luck and see if I can't get a good last-minute bid. It's got pretty good quality components like the rest of the reference cards, a nifty EMI shield like the Xonar, and a front panel connector like the HT Omega Claro. What's not to like?

EDIT: In your face, Wooters! I just won one for $71 and $9.99 shipping! Not too bad for a schmuck who missed the Woot... :p
I'll make sure to post a review once it arrives.
 
I bought this when it first came out, when I was doing my build) I'm debatng of switching over to an ESI Juli@. Overall alot of people hosed the card without trying it. I thought it was way better than onboard sound, and I'll be putting up on a amp later on. It's a good card. Now that the price has gone down, a good buy.
 
I had a blue gears but it sucked for gaming. For music certainly better than the x-fi though.
 
I got the woot deal too, but I am not happy.
In BF2 (on XP SP2), the voiceover is stuttering. The mike is frequently staticky and very quiet, even with mic boost turned on. Sometimes it is just fine.
Music sounds great but I don't think there is much difference to the Audigy-2 I had before. And that card had no mike problems. However driver support under Vista is so bad that I am happy to throw it out.
 
i had a razer my self for a year , i did like the music quailty but , not having 5.1 in vista with it in the rest of my games got tiring. I only 5.1 in a few and it was certain games, like 11 games out of 30 that i had installed at the time.

Plus razer took ages with there drivers, to get around it , I used a program called velbac for a while and used my a2zs with the razer to get 5.1 in vista .

In the end after using my A2z alone I decide to just sell the razer card on ebay because i wasnt happy with it or the razer headphones. And used the money to get me a prelude and ath-ad700 headphones. Now razer decide to put out new drivers 4 months after i sold it.

I would say just get the cheaper inferno, paying more for the razer is not worth it. not even for the front audio panel support.Since there all the same cards, it be something diffent if it was the auzen x-merdian.
 
New Vista drivers are available for it on razerzone.com. The drivers are actually solid now, Im still using mine as well, I just put it back in last night :)
 
wooted for $54.99 shipped. :D

Anyone know if i can plug my ps3 into the optical and get sound from my non-optical 5.1 logitechs hooked up to the dongle?
 
I got the woot deal too, but I am not happy.
In BF2 (on XP SP2), the voiceover is stuttering. The mike is frequently staticky and very quiet, even with mic boost turned on. Sometimes it is just fine.
Music sounds great but I don't think there is much difference to the Audigy-2 I had before. And that card had no mike problems. However driver support under Vista is so bad that I am happy to throw it out.

Update drivers, try new PCI slot, update BIOS. In that order.
 
If you are having static problems with the Razer sound card I have heard that its because of the dongle for connectors. To fix this use electrical tape to surround and cover the unused leads and also surround those connections that are in use. Basically, the dongle contact each other and cause static. I hope this solves your problems :)
 
Back
Top