Dual vs Quad , Gaming, is there a difference?

Well, currently dual cores would be just a bit better in gaming - especially when it comes to older games. Also due to fact that they have more headroom to overclock in terms of heat and voltages. But the trend now is quadcores, and alot of developers are optimizing the code for it. So, to future proof yourself for just a tad longer - quad is the way to go.

Have a read.
 
I'm not sure about that Oblivion one, especially if they left the .ini file at the default.

I bumped the number of threads up to 32 (that's 8 per core on a quad), with 8 physics (Havok) threads, which would mostly likely cripple the game if it was only using a single, or even probably a dual core, but my FPS jumped up by an average of 5. I think it makes a bigger difference that most people think, you just have to tweak some games.

Most other games though I havn't noticed much of a difference with. Aside from the obvious speed boost of going from a 2.7 GHz Opteron to a 3.6 GHz Core 2 :p
 
Tomshardware did a comparision between the two. Their test results showed that quads are in general faster than the dual cores - apparently due to the 8mb L2 cache. In their testing, the quads were on par with the duals at 200 mhz slower clocks.

I'm not saying it's conclusive, or absolute fact.

Crysis is being optimized for quads. That's reason enough for me to have one!
 
Get a Quadcore,if you run other things while gaming it'll help even more.I can fold,and game at the same time,or encode,and fold and game at the same time,try that on a dual core ? :D and see what kind of performance you get
 
most games don't even utilize dual cores efficiently yet,

but if u need a big epenis, sure , go with quadcore
 
if only quad cores could increase a persons ability to research the facts before making judgements
 
Just go for a quad and be done, ive currently have four cores going strong at 3.6 ;).
 
if only quad cores could increase a persons ability to research the facts before making judgements

yeah i wish, obviously that quad core didn't help you one bit ,
boohoo, so u found one game which performs noticably better on 4cores,

http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/000942.html
quad over dual improvement
Supreme Commander - none


http://xtreview.com/review212.htm
Purely nominal advantage of QX6850 above X6800 or E6850 : first, four core processor in games did not give any special advantages ,Dual core processor with faster frequency show better result.

http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2879&p=10
QUAKE4
Even though the latest version of the engine is multi-threaded, there's no real benefit above two cores.

Oblivion performance is notably worse on Quad FX than with only a single socket AMD system due to the added memory latency

And once again, Quad FX doesn't do so well if all you're doing is running a single game; an Athlon 64 X2 setup is faster.

http://www.overclockers.com/tips01057/
You have to read these articles closely to discover that:

# only a handful of games plan on using four-cores
# they won't show up for about a year
# the games won't take full advantage of all those cores

http://www.theinquirer.net/en/inquirer/news/2006/10/07/quad-core-is-useless-for-games
WE spoke with many developers including some big names and we learned that they can't make much sense out of quad or more core CPUs. They confirm that they can put two cores to good use but not much more.

http://www.tomshardware.com/2006/09/10/four_cores_on_the_rampage/index.html
Gaming fans, however, can confidently stick with the Core 2 Duo/Extreme or the legendary Pentium D 805. That's due to a lack of adaptations for four CPUs - in practice, only a maximum of two processors are used in games.

..yeah, need more research?

...continue to more quad core goodness http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1031470838&posted=1#post1031470838
 
Actually SupCom does benefit from it, but you missed that part in my post. I have experienced repeatable direct benefits.

And games is not the only reason people go quad, another point you missed.

So neener-neener on you? Excuse me while I go home and polish my e-penis.
 
Unreal Engine 3 games really support quad-core, as well as Crysis, among other games.

Besides, also it speeds up video/audio editing, 3d rendering, etc. The prices are nice and cheap now, cheaper than my $350 3800x2 back in '05. :)

Here's some info showing the benefits of quad-core processing in games,
quadLPjpg.jpg

http://www.thattechsite.com/vbulletin/forums/showthread.php?p=404#post404
 
yeah , im sure there will be some games which will take the advantage of 4 cores in next 2 or 3 years,

but lets bring that lost planet test up to 1900x1200 resolution, put it up against a dual core and see if the spilled milk is worth crying over
 
I have a quick question. Does one have to have a 64 bit operating system in order to utilize all four cores in a game that supports 4 cores, or can I use Vista 32 and still have the game run on all 4 cores. It is probably an obvious question, but I have never used a 64 bit OS, or a dual or quad core CPU.
 
Thread title=yes.

64bit OS will primarily help with memory addressing, and is not required for Multithreaded games.
 
yeah , im sure there will be some games which will take the advantage of 4 cores in next 2 or 3 years,

but lets bring that lost planet test up to 1900x1200 resolution, put it up against a dual core and see if the spilled milk is worth crying over

Lets bring into play the low percentage of PC gamers that play at 1900x1200 and see if we give a shit. I already have a few. Lost Planet, World in Conflict, Crysis beta, Supreme Commander. World in Conflict is completely different with a Quad now. Until you've personally experienced the difference, how about you go pound some sand?
 
Well, if you're gonna go multicore, you might as well go Quad right now.

Anything that is designed for more than one core will be more than likely mean its multithreaded. Multithreading usually consists of hundreds of threads. So a Quad will almost invariably always be more advantageous than a Dual as long as the app is programmed for more than one core.

The big leap was single to duo though, as everyone had to rewrite their code to get the speed advantage. From duo to quad though, there should be little to no rewriting necessary.

But the limiting factor in most games in most peoples systems (including single core CPU's) is the videocard.. Sad but true.

Although its nice to have an active virusscanner and software firewall running simultaneously to a game. (In addition to having to not shut down a game just to check my email every so often) I find that with a quad, I just don't bother pressing the "X" close button on things, as nothing ever seems to slow down. With two screens, I just push it over to the second one, and start up (or simply alt-tab) the games.. Its really strange how a Quad (and lots of memory) changes the way you do things.
 
The big leap was single to duo though, as everyone had to rewrite their code to get the speed advantage. From duo to quad though, there should be little to no rewriting necessary.

You'd be surprised.
 
Tomshardware did a comparision between the two. Their test results showed that quads are in general faster than the dual cores - apparently due to the 8mb L2 cache. In their testing, the quads were on par with the duals at 200 mhz slower clocks.

I'm not saying it's conclusive, or absolute fact.

Crysis is being optimized for quads. That's reason enough for me to have one!

Yup.

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031408230&postcount=3

actually when it comes to gaming and pretty much everything else an overclocked quad will always win. Hell if it now comes to a game that is optimized for quads then the lead becomes bigger. A overclocked q6600 @3.5-3.6 will whallop a e6850 overclocked to 3.8 in single threaded and multithreaded apps. Mind you this is with a G0 stepping quad....

Exibit A :- http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/core2quad-q6600.html





 
um, didn't HardOCP demonstrate Sup Com taking advantage of 4 cores?

/too lazy to look up article myself of course

I'm really torn on this myself since I plan to build at the end of year. Quad-core is the "wave of the future" but I'm very tempted to take a E6850 (or whatever) for the current punch of the higher clock speed. Thankfully I've got a couple more months to see how newer games handle quad-cores. ;)
 
What is really helping the Quad even before counting the extra cores - is the double size cache.

Games that naturally eat up a gig or so of main memory get a lot more breathing room with the 2x4MB cache. Games that naturally fit into smaller main ram tend to not need anywhere near as much cache and have a slight advantage there because of clockspeed - seems pretty straighforward.

There is no question though that games are starting to punch past the 1GB to 2GB main ram range, which means that just by having the larger cache, the Quad is much better prepared for the future - Even before counting the two extra cores compared to a duo, which for the most part right now playing games, the Quad has two or even three cores that are idle.

If Intel made a 2.4Ghz dual core with 8MB, and it was the same price as the current 3.0Ghz dual core with 4MB... I'd think I'd still be buying the chip with the larger cache. If that doesn't succinctly say "buy the Quad" I don't know what does.
 
I'm waiting for a cheap refresh of the Quad D processors.

If by "Quad D" you mean "Quad Cored Pentium D", it's not happening; I believe they're going to in the very near future, if they haven't already, completely stop the production of Netburst processors. I honestly don't see a quad-cored Pentium D on the horizon.

Assuming that's what you're talking about ;)
 
Here's my logic:

Get a quad when it becomes mainstream in applications. If you get one now; you will be sort of future-proofed but once it becomes mainstream, there will be newer quads that are optimized or have new features or new chipsets that utilize those features in such a fashion that your old future proofed quad ends up sort of lacking.

My theory when buying technology is to buy today's tech today, and tomorrow's tech tomorrow. It's cheaper and better value.
 
um, didn't HardOCP demonstrate Sup Com taking advantage of 4 cores?

/too lazy to look up article myself of course

I'm really torn on this myself since I plan to build at the end of year. Quad-core is the "wave of the future" but I'm very tempted to take a E6850 (or whatever) for the current punch of the higher clock speed. Thankfully I've got a couple more months to see how newer games handle quad-cores. ;)


Yes,but that doesnt matter,as Bob Brownik so expertly pointed out thier results are obviouslly suspect,and all about teh e-peen :D


Seriously though,I go by my own expriences and real world tests,and those show quad is better.
 
If you're buying a new processor, you might as well get the quad because even if there isn't a large difference now, by the time the processor is obsolete, there will be a difference.
 
Get a Quadcore,if you run other things while gaming it'll help even more.I can fold,and game at the same time,or encode,and fold and game at the same time,try that on a dual core ? :D and see what kind of performance you get

Wow, if you want to encode as you play games, you can't be considered a true gaming enthusiast.

The "proper" way to game has always been and always will be to shutdown every running process leaving only the game app. Extreme gaming is about squeezing every last fps from one's rig.

Multiple cores don't do anything significant in games. They are 80% hype and will stay this way.

Games will ALWAYS run great on single cores.

The CPU makers toss gamers a carrot and the gullible ones take a bite. Intel wants to make multi-core cpu's for business reasons that have nothing to do with improved performance in gaming. Do you think they are going to admit this in their marketing campaign? No, obviously not. They are going to spin multiple cores as the best thing since sliced bread. This is what they have been doing so far. It's hype. Why bite?

The Pentium 4 was the high mark of CPU achievement. There haven't been any improvements since then, at least from a gamer's perspective.

The CPU is becoming increasingly irrelevant. The future belongs to graphics and memory.
 
I think I'm more of an enthusiast if I can do multiple things at the same time, and do them faster than I could if I only had a dual core :cool:. I think you're not an enthusiast if you can ONLY game without doing anything else :p.
 
The old fart with a Dell pre-loaded with bloatware is also "doing multiple things at the same time" whenever he boots up his PC. Guess he must be a hardcore enthusiast. :D

Every serious gamer tries to turn his PC into a console while the game is running
 
The old fart with a Dell pre-loaded with bloatware is also "doing multiple things at the same time" whenever he boots up his PC. Guess he must be a hardcore enthusiast. :D

Every serious gamer tries to turn his PC into a console while the game is running

Lol...you are right about the graphics card being more relevant though. An old P4 Netburst with a 8800GTX will still beat the pants off of a QX6850 with a 7600GS.
 
I think the biggest benefit comes into play with the os more than anything for a quad. I've been able to game online with prime in the background... (though the painful loadup times were noticable).

While most will take the primary cores for gaming, the os happily churns away on the other 2 cores doing it's thing. anyone making the jump to vista will appreciate the other 2 cores as that os loves to do crap on it's own despite you wanting to use it for other purposes. Clock for clock I've noticed vista working better under a quad system...
 
Wow, if you want to encode as you play games, you can't be considered a true gaming enthusiast.

The "proper" way to game has always been and always will be to shutdown every running process leaving only the game app. Extreme gaming is about squeezing every last fps from one's rig.

Multiple cores don't do anything significant in games. They are 80% hype and will stay this way.

Games will ALWAYS run great on single cores.

The CPU makers toss gamers a carrot and the gullible ones take a bite. Intel wants to make multi-core cpu's for business reasons that have nothing to do with improved performance in gaming. Do you think they are going to admit this in their marketing campaign? No, obviously not. They are going to spin multiple cores as the best thing since sliced bread. This is what they have been doing so far. It's hype. Why bite?

The Pentium 4 was the high mark of CPU achievement. There haven't been any improvements since then, at least from a gamer's perspective.

The CPU is becoming increasingly irrelevant. The future belongs to graphics and memory.


There are soooo many things with your post I dont know where to begin... :D
 
The "proper" way to game has always been and always will be to shutdown every running process leaving only the game app. Extreme gaming is about squeezing every last fps from one's rig.

This is true when I was using Athlon X2 3800 @ 2.5 GHz. I shut every thing off, antivirus, IM, Windows Sidebar etc when I'm playing BF2. There was a definite performance penalty if I didn't shut every other program off.

I've upgraded to Q6600 a fortnight ago and it made a hell of a difference. I can game now without turning anything off. BF2 can run super smooth without any lag with Firefox, WMP, IM, antivirus, antispyware and whole lot of other things in the system tray. Granted some of the difference might come from me using 4 gigs of ram now and I used 2 gigs with my X2.

So why would I turned off every running process when I'm already running BF2 super smooth?
 
Well, there are many occasions where gamers don't turn off their other programs.

Civilization 4 on a huge/epic map, means that even a quad computer will be taking about half a minute to calculate each turn by the year 2000AD. Don't ask me why its so slow when technically it should be doing 56 billion calcs per second - it just is. It does not use multi-cores. While I'm waiting, you can be sure I've already alt-tabbed over to another app while its calculating.

FPS shooters, yes you will probably want to have only the one app running. WoW users however, may be running some sort of VOIP chat, in which case some do bother do get an actual VOIP router or simply another old computer to do the minor taskwork (and to check their email so they never have to close their WoW Client). UT2004 runs quite a bit smoother on a Quad if you use the ingame VOIP, as it runs on Microsofts software which is almost independant from the game, only needing to attach to the appropriate #voip channel.

Now for those people who run twinking setups (and I won't get into the morality of that) having two seperate computers is probably a good idea.
 
no offense but it's been awhile since we've had to do the whole "shut off every program" deal while gaming...

feel free to benchmark your favorite games and see if you even manage to gain a 5% performance boost...

with vista.. well that's another matter for the rigs with the crappy experience ratings...
 
Just for the sake of argument, I tried playing BF2 with everything except NOD32. I haven't done since I upgraded my rig.

I didn't notice any FPS improvement. Well that's probably because it was already running a max 60 fps with the vsnyc on as the limiter even when I didn't turn everything off.

The load time seems to be a smidgen faster though but even without turning everything off I was among the first to enter the map.
 
Back
Top