the $1000 gaming PC, thoughts please

Ampsonic

Gawd
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
830
About two years ago I bought a laptop and have not had a desktop since, and I simply cannot take it anymore. Bioshock now and COD 4 soon are telling me I need a gaming PC again.

Of course, I'm a poor college student, so I am trying to keep it under $1000 dollars. Here's what I've got, let me know what you'd change.

$129.99 Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R
$125.99 Intel Core 2 Duo E4400
$72.99 2GB (2 x 1GB) Kingston DDR2 667
$139.99 XFX GeForce 8600GT 256MB (core @ 620mhz) ((Is this the XXX version reviewed on the homepage? I can't find that designation for sale anywhere.))
$79.99 Seagate 7200.10 320GB SATA 3.0 (perpendicular recording)
$74.99 Cooler Master Centurion w/ 430w PS
$239.99 Acer AL2223Wd 22" widescreen LCD
$35.99 Lite-On 20x DVDR w/ lightscribe (sata)

$111.99 MS Vista Home Premium for System Builders (OEM)


I know vista may not be the best choice right now, but this will be my system for a while and I want to be future proofed. Please feel free to rip on this choice as well, I can be swayed.

Also I have a tendancy to throw Ubuntu on my systems from time to time.

Go!
 
you're *really* going to want a better graphics card. There's just not really any reason these days not to get an 8800gts for the price/performance ratio. can find them for <275 these days.

also note: You're getting a cheap bundled psu which may or may not have enough power to run your system, and may or may not explode. insert cliche "get a corsair" comment here
 
The 8800 series really is that much better, eh? I originally had one in there, but I was trying to squeeze some dollars out. Whats a good power supply that wouldn't' cost too much, FSP any good?
 
Another fellow poor College student.. I know how you feel.

Now lets cut costs shall we?

First, ditch that case/PSU combo and go with this combo instead:
Antec Sonata III Case - $114

The Earthwatts 500W that comes with the Sonata III is a pretty good quality power supply. It should be more than enough for your needs. Or if the Sonata III isn't to your liking, go with this set instead:
Cooler Master Elite 330 RC-330-KKN1-GP ATX Case $40
XCLIO Goodpower 500W PSU - $50
-----
Total: $90 Plus tax and shipping

Second, cheaper place to get the E4400:
Antec Sonata III Case - $114

Third, ditch the 8600GT and go with the x1950GT. It's faster than the 8600GT and it costs much much less. Also, any DX10 game being released within the next year will have DX9 mode. So no need for a DX10 video card yet:
Sapphire 100199L Radeon X1950GT 256MB PCI-E Video Card - $115

Fourth, cheaper copy of Vista:
Windows Vista Home Premium OEM- $100

Fifth, get the DS3R here with free shipping which should save you some money:
GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3R Intel P35 Motherboard - $130

However if you don't need RAID or four extra SATA ports, then go with the Abit IP35-E. It's the same in terms of overclocking and performance as the DS3R but without RAID support and 4 less SATA ports:
Abit IP35-E Intel P35 Motherboard - $90

Sixth, if you're willing to deal with rebates, get this Ballistix RAM instead. It has Micro D9 chips so it overclocks well and it's only $70AR:
Crucial Ballistix BL2KIT12864AA804 2 x 1GB DDR2 800 RAM - $110 ($70)

Hope that helps.
 
I agree with Danny.

Can't you get Windows from your school for much less? Its usually free or around $30 or something like that, depending on how good of a deal your university got.
 
Here are some options from New egg:


COOLER MASTER Centurion 5 CAC-T05-UW Black Aluminum Bezel , SECC Chassis ATX Mid Tower Computer Case - Retail : $40 (Net of $10 Rebate)

COOLER MASTER eXtreme RP-500-PCAR ATX from factor 12V V2.01 500W Power Supply 90-132V/180-260V Nemko, TUV, cUL, CE, BSMI, FCC, CCC - Retail : $30 (Net of $20 Rebate)


ECS KN3 SLI2 (1.0) AM2 NVIDIA nForce 590 SLI MCP ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail : $100 (Net of $20 Rebate)

AMD Athlon 64 X2 6000+ Windsor 3.0GHz 2 x 1MB L2 Cache Socket AM2 Processor - Retail : $169 : More Expensive but for the additional $70 you get allot more performance.

XFX PVT84JUDF3 GeForce 8600GT 256MB 128-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 SLI Supported Video Card - Retail : $105 (Net of $15 Rebate)

GeIL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - Retail : $66.99 (Net of $30 Rebate)


I have been running these parts in a number of machines for a bit and for the price you can't go wrong. I also have the same Seagate drive you mentioned and again the dollarized value is their for that as well. :)
 
If you're looking to play bioshock and use a 22" monitor (and have it look half decent), you need a 8800 series card even if you have to skimp elsewhere.
 
ECS KN3 SLI2 (1.0) AM2 NVIDIA nForce 590 SLI MCP ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail : $100 (Net of $20 Rebate)

AMD Athlon 64 X2 6000+ Windsor 3.0GHz 2 x 1MB L2 Cache Socket AM2 Processor - Retail : $169 : More Expensive but for the additional $70 you get allot more performance.

Ok, Talk to me about AMD vs. Intel right now. I'm so out of the loop on this stuff. I will have to do some research when I get to work.

I will check with my university and see if I can get a discount on windows.

And I'm convinced on the video card, I will go with the 8800, anyone recommend a model? I was thinking the eVGA Geforce 8800GTS.
 
COOLER MASTER eXtreme RP-500-PCAR ATX from factor 12V V2.01 500W Power Supply 90-132V/180-260V Nemko, TUV, cUL, CE, BSMI, FCC, CCC - Retail : $30 (Net of $20 Rebate)
ECS KN3 SLI2 (1.0) AM2 NVIDIA nForce 590 SLI MCP ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail : $100 (Net of $20 Rebate)

The CoolerMaster RP-500-PCAR 500W is really a SevenTeam ST-450ZPF 450W. I wouldn't trust it, for the simple fact that they rebadged a lower rated PSU and gave it a higher rating on its label. This leads me to beleive CoolerMaster has lower standards for their PSUs. The only PSU line I'd trust from them is their greenpower. Stick with the XClio Goodpower... its a solid CWT built unit with proper cooling and 28A on the +12V rails.

I can't tell you how many ECS boards have failed, but it is a large number of them... though, usually from Fry's, which is known to have poor QA. For Intel chipsets, the ECS boards seem to be ok if paired with a good quality PSU. For other chipsets, such as via, nvidia, ati, they're not so great, especially with a low quality PSU. If you want AMD, go for the Biostar TForce 560 instead, since its an AM2+ socket board. Its also cheaper than that ECS SLI board, and you don't need SLI anyhow, so no point in paying for it.

INTEL vs AMD...

The Core2 CPU has been out for over a year, and it kicks the Athlon's ass. The only way the Athlon can compete is by lowering its price... no, even when overclocking, it loses to the Core2. So, if you have a low budget, then AMD is your best shot. Since you have a nice $1k budget, go with a Core2.

Yes, most of these links are old, but it gives you an idea of how revolutionary the Conroe was:
http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2795
http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2802
http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2903 << the E4300 has been replaced with the E4400, and the E4500 has been released
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/core2duo-e6420.html
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/core2duo-e6850.html

Since you can afford a Core2Duo, you might as well go for it, since these Core2 chips OC with such ease and stability, you'd be crazy to not OC (even a modest OC).

E4400: 10 * 200 = 2.0Ghz, DDR2-400 << STOCK speeds
E4400: 10 * 266 = 2.6Ghz, DDR2-533 << Easy OC
E4400: 10 * 333 = 3.3Ghz, DDR2-667 << Great OC

Both companies have new chips on the way... AMD has Barcelona/Phenom, while Intel has Penryn/Wolfdale/Yorkfield. Those new mainstream chips are expected to hit in Q1'08, with high end chips premiering a month or two prior. The new CPUs from AMD, socket AM2+ and socket AM3, will be compatible with existing AM2 motherboards. Intel has a new eaglelake chipset out next year, to replace the P35 Express family (G33, X38, etc).

Yes, go with the eVGA... it has the best warranty (lifetime, you can oc, you can change the cooler).
 
How well would the E4400 overclock on the stock cooler? Do I need to look into a different cooler?

However if you don't need RAID or four extra SATA ports, then go with the Abit IP35-E. It's the same in terms of overclocking and performance as the DS3R but without RAID support and 4 less SATA ports:
Abit IP35-E Intel P35 Motherboard - $90

The newegg reviews say this board has some linux problems, anyone comment on the quality of this board?
 
How well would the E4400 overclock on the stock cooler? Do I need to look into a different cooler?

Before I upgraded to Q660 I had E4400 - with stock cooler you can get to 2.8Ghz and with Freezer 7pro(which cost around 25 USD) I managed 3.25Ghz (my max. with that chip was 3.5Ghz with my present cooler Thermalright Ultra 120 eXtreme + Scythe S-Flex fam 1600RPM) .
 
Also, is the $50 bucks worth it to go from the E4400 to the E6550 with the faster FSB and larger L2 cache? What kinds of real performance gain does that provide?
 
Also, is the $50 bucks worth it to go from the E4400 to the E6550 with the faster FSB and larger L2 cache? What kinds of real performance gain does that provide?

You should be able to OC the E6550 a good bit higher with a nice aftermarket cooler like the Scythe Ninja Plus Rev B or similar (~$40). I'd go that route were it me. Over all the newer chips (E6550/6750/6850) are considerably more OC-friendly than their older brethren.
 
Also, is the $50 bucks worth it to go from the E4400 to the E6550 with the faster FSB and larger L2 cache? What kinds of real performance gain does that provide?

Well at stock speeds the E6550 will beat the E4400 in most games and apps. However, the E6550 is much more difficult to OC than the E4400 since it has a 7x multiplier whereas the E4400 has a 10x multiplier. Also, where has the E4400 only needs cheap DDR2 667 to hit 3.3Ghz, the E6550 requires more expensive RAM with Micron chips in them for any decent for 3.0Ghz+ overclocking. So if you don't plan on OC'ing AT ALL, then the E6550 is a good choice. But if you want to dabble in OCing, the E4400 is easier to overclock.
 
Well at stock speeds the E6550 will beat the E4400 in most games and apps. However, the E6550 is much more difficult to OC than the E4400 since it has a 7x multiplier whereas the E4400 has a 10x multiplier. Also, where has the E4400 only needs cheap DDR2 667 to hit 3.3Ghz, the E6550 requires more expensive RAM with Micron chips in them for any decent for 3.0Ghz+ overclocking. So if you don't plan on OC'ing AT ALL, then the E6550 is a good choice. But if you want to dabble in OCing, the E4400 is easier to overclock.

Good to know. I assumed the whole 6x50 series had similar OCing ability. It very well might if you can hit really high FSB, but as you said, 7x multiplier would be a problem.
 
And we all learned something today. Thanks for all the info, I'm poor and will be trying to OC on the stock cooler, so the E4400 it is! I think I'm about a day away from ordering this baby.

Checked with my school, they don't offer an education version of Vista (just the upgrade). The techzone guy referred me to a website...what was it called, oh yes, he said 'newegg'. Anyone heard of it?
 
With the exception of the video card he suggested, I totally agree with Danny's parts list. I have the Sonata III case and I like it a lot.
 

Way over budget. Almost no one would recommend a Striker Extreme. He doesn't have $400+ to spent on a GPU, much less $600 to spend on GPUs that're going to be memory limited in SLI -- very poor plan. I'd ask if you read the thread, but you obviously didn't even read the thread /title/. Also, regardless of how poor the advice was, in the future do not link to posts when you could just as easily copy and paste. People shouldn't have to click to read a single recommendation post.
 
Ordered! Now who wants to point me towards some good resources for learning how to OC this bad boy?

Thanks again for all your help everyone.
 
Thank you for the advice! I believe that you have seen that I’ve given at least two possibilities! Anyway that was my opinion! He can spend a little more but will have a better performance for a longer time! You can always give yours!
Best regards my little friend!
P.s: I believe that is better using links to show the threads or posts inside the forums than copy/paste the posts! I don't like copy paste @ all :rolleyes:

Way over budget. Almost no one would recommend a Striker Extreme. He doesn't have $400+ to spent on a GPU, much less $600 to spend on GPUs that're going to be memory limited in SLI -- very poor plan. I'd ask if you read the thread, but you obviously didn't even read the thread /title/. Also, regardless of how poor the advice was, in the future do not link to posts when you could just as easily copy and paste. People shouldn't have to click to read a single recommendation post.
 
Gigabyte DS3R
Intel Core 2 Duo E4400
EVGA 8800GTS 320MB
Crucial Ballisitx 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2 800 (PC2 6400)
Lite On 20x DVD Burner w/ lightscribe (SATA)
Seagate 7200.10 320GB SATA (Perpendicular recording)
Cooler Master Elite 330 Mid Tower
XCLIO GoodPower 500W

Acer 22" Widescreen w/ HDCP

Vista Home Premium (OEM)

Order Total: 1,241.59 w/ shipping.

I ordered it all from newegg. I know I could have saved a few bucks by ordering some parts from other places, but I'd rather spend an extra $50 bucks to know it will get here fast and if I have problems they will be taken care of. (I once killed a processor in a new system build, newegg replaced it no questions asked.) ((I didn't pull the tabs off of both sides of the thermal tape)) (((That was really dumb)))

I've been looking over that large over clocking article, and I'm excited to see how well this system will do. I'm not going to go for anything crazy, Just whatever the system handles well.

So thanks again for all the great advice!
 
looks nice...

Gigabyte DS3R
Intel Core 2 Duo E4400
EVGA 8800GTS 320MB
Crucial Ballisitx 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2 800 (PC2 6400)
Lite On 20x DVD Burner w/ lightscribe (SATA)
Seagate 7200.10 320GB SATA (Perpendicular recording)
Cooler Master Elite 330 Mid Tower
XCLIO GoodPower 500W

Acer 22" Widescreen w/ HDCP

Vista Home Premium (OEM)

Order Total: 1,241.59 w/ shipping.

I ordered it all from newegg. I know I could have saved a few bucks by ordering some parts from other places, but I'd rather spend an extra $50 bucks to know it will get here fast and if I have problems they will be taken care of. (I once killed a processor in a new system build, newegg replaced it no questions asked.) ((I didn't pull the tabs off of both sides of the thermal tape)) (((That was really dumb)))

I've been looking over that large over clocking article, and I'm excited to see how well this system will do. I'm not going to go for anything crazy, Just whatever the system handles well.

So thanks again for all the great advice!
 
First post from the new system! It's up an running, and looks very nice. Still trying to get everything set up the way I like it. So far, vista hasn't been too bad. Lets hope that continues.

Will start overclocking soon, results to come.
 
Back
Top