Grrr...Bioshock widescreen cropping

Now 4:3 users can turn around and say, hey I'm getting less screen space than widescreen users.
4:3 owners already know they're getting less screen space than widescreen users. If they had wanted more horizontal real estate, they would have bought 16:10/16:9 panels, would they have not? They bought a panel with a 4:3 aspect ratio, and they should expect to game in such an aspect ratio. They should not experience the game the same way that 16:10 owners experience the game.

16:10 owners bought a panel with a 16:10 aspect ratio, and they should expect to game in such an aspect ratio. Valve, id, Epic and many other AAA developers have gotten it right. Irrational has not.

It's a shockingly easy concept to comprehend. If you haven't "gotten" it by this point, it's clear you never will. It seems to me you're arguing purely for the sake of arguing, not because you actually believe your own "arguments".
 
They bought a panel with a 4:3 aspect ratio, and they should expect to game in such an aspect ratio. They should not experience the game the same way that 16:10 owners experience the game.
And they're not; they benefit from the extra height that their monitors have.


In response to questions about an "HDTV show more on the sides then SDTV (sic)": You'll note that when you watch a 16:9 dvd on a 4:3 display it letterboxes the image. You see exactly the same film. In the case of the 4:3 display however, its extra height is unused (ie. filled with black). What happens in Bioshock is that that extra height is actually displayed in.
 
And they're not; they benefit from the extra height that their monitors have.


In response to questions about an "HDTV show more on the sides then SDTV (sic)": You'll note that when you watch a 16:9 dvd on a 4:3 display it letterboxes the image. You see exactly the same film. In the case of the 4:3 display however, its extra height is unused (ie. filled with black). What happens in Bioshock is that that extra height is actually displayed in.

your still not getting it

the point of HD is to show MORE on it not less if you dont like letter box dvds buy the full screen ver oh wait you lose the sides funny isnt it

http://www.crutchfieldadvisor.com/ISEO-rgbtcspd/learningcenter/home/tv_glossary.html
see here
 
I understand what's going on quite well.

For native 4:3 footage being displayed on a 16:9 display you have to chop top and bottom off (or put black boxes at the side).

For native 16:9 footage on a 4:3 display you would have to chop off the sides (or put black boxes on the top and bottom).

In either situation, the non-native display is not seeing the entire picture. In the case of Bioshock, they have chosen to do the former. There is no "correct" choice; this is purely a design decision.
 
Even though I'm playing on 16:9, why should I care if someone with a 4:3 actually gets more viewable area? What I keep picking up in this thread is that 16:9 and 16:10 owners seem to feel as though this purchase decision *entitles* them to something better. I'm not sure why that is. There are 4:3 monitors that are more expensive and just as high quality (if not more) as the LCD's, Plasmas, and projections out there. Maybe they should complain that they spent the extra money for a gigantic 4:3 CRT and they want to take advantage of the extra vertical space that monitor offers.
It just seems like widescreen gamers feel entitled and I just don't feel that way even though I am one.
The Bioshock designers wanted or at least chose to give the 4:3 gamers more viewable area. So what? Who cares? Why does having a widescreen monitor (that *might* be cheaper or inferior to a 4:3 model) somehow mean you should automatically get more viewable area?
 
Maybe they should complain that they spent the extra money for a gigantic 4:3 CRT and they want to take advantage of the extra vertical space that monitor offers.
Vertical space is an irrelevant factor. We're not talking about resolution, but the aspect ratio. Not the number of pixels, but how those pixels are arranged. Regardless of whether I have a 17" 4:3 display or a 40" 4:3 display, the field of view should not change, because the aspect ratio of both displays is the same. A widescreen display, however, allows for a wider field of view because it has a wide aspect ratio, so it's only natural that it be taken advantage of. We aren't entitled to it, though we do expect it, and we obviously will complain when we don't get it. It's an entirely reasonable complaint.

Why does having a widescreen monitor somehow mean you should automatically get more viewable area?
Because that's the purpose of a wide aspect display. That's why we buy wide aspect displays. As I said before, if it were just about resolution, a 4:3 panel may have made more sense.

If we wanted to experience games in the same manner that 4:3 owners experience games, why in the world would we specifically purchase 16:10 displays? For shits and giggles?

Some here are acting as if some governmental agency is responsible for issuing displays to consumers. Some get 16:10 displays while other get 4:3 displays, and that there's no say in the matter. That's obviously not the case -- we specifically choose a display for a specific purpose.
 
If we wanted to experience games in the same manner that 4:3 owners experience games, why in the world would we specifically purchase 16:10 displays? For shits and giggles?

The thing is, you know full well when you're running a widescreen monitor that not all games support it and many that do aren't doing it the exact way you want it to. That's life. It's a new standard for gaming and it's still getting the kinks worked out. It's why there are sites like WSGF out there. You should expect this by now. When you buy a 16:9 or 16:10 monitor, you're essentially taking a risk. 4:3 people know what they're getting and the one time they get something slightly better, people start whining. "I bought a widescreen monitor because I expect this and that!" Guess what? *ALL* games support 4:3. Maybe people that are on 4:3 are the ones that have the right expectations?
 
Gee, what a bunch of whiner who argue for nothing... This remind me of the special olympics pics if you know what I'm talking about. If we want to make the dev team change his mind (they already stated there will be a patch to fix this so it's pointless now), learn to bark at the right tree, not here...

Viewing ratio is up to each own perferences and it's normal views is different on the issue. The only thing 2kgames should have done from the start is to have a option to let us pick what we want with the default being the design team preferences.
 
A widescreen display, however, allows for a wider field of view because it has a wide aspect ratio, so it's only natural that it be taken advantage of.
No. The FOV should be dictated by the physical dimensions of the monitor rather than the aspect ratio. In an ideal world, if one monitor is wider than another it should have a wider FOV, regardless of the aspect ratio.
 
It's a new standard for gaming and it's still getting the kinks worked out.
Valve introduced excellent native widescreen support in 2004 with Half-Life 2. The WSGF article says this of HL2:
In terms of widescreen, this game does everything right, and is the game that all other widescreen-aware games should be compared to.
There are no kinks that need to be worked out. That's already been done.

If we want to make the dev team change his mind (they already stated there will be a patch to fix this so it's pointless now), learn to bark at the right tree, not here...
We already did that, which is why 2K intends to issue a fix. This is a discussion.

No. The FOV should be dictated by the physical dimensions of the monitor rather than the aspect ratio. In an ideal world, if one monitor is wider than another it should have a wider FOV, regardless of the aspect ratio.
An interesting albeit unrealistic expectation. Still, it's possible given that the developers would allow such a thing to work, which is not the case with BioShock. Multi-monitor support is an example of how you'd execute something like that, but you'd never frame a cutscene or any other important event in such a way as to not make it viewable on any panel of any aspect ratio or any size.
 
An interesting albeit unrealistic expectation. Still, it's possible given that the developers would allow such a thing to work, which is not the case with BioShock. Multi-monitor support is an example of how you'd execute something like that, but you'd never frame a cutscene or any other important event in such a way as to not make it viewable on any panel of any aspect ratio or any size.
I agree it's unrealistic given some of the practical requirements in making a product that works well on variety of display sizes.

Nonetheless, it does illustrate my point. Ideally horizontal FOV is a function of absolute monitor width, therefore we can't say widescreen displays should have a wider FOV, since they're not necessarily physically wider than a 4:3 display.

It really is just a design decision. Maybe supporting 4:3 displays was an afterthought and they just did it by extending the vertical FOV.
 
Its perfectly simple, the whole idea widescreen is to give you a WIDER field of view. Bioshock does NOT give you wider field of view, it zooms your view in and keeps the same hFOV and alters your vFOV to fit.

A person who buys a widescreen simply wants to see more on the side, Bioshock fails to deliver.

Anyone trying to argue the point past this idea might as well be trying to argue that we all dont need to bother breathing air. No one is going to pay you serious attention because you're talking bollocks.
 
I didn't read the entire thread but this is what 2K says about widescreen,
THE TRUTH ABOUT WIDESCREEN
August 22, 2007

We understand there has been some concern about the implementation of widescreen mode in BioShock. Hopefully, we can clarify how we’ve chosen to do this.

The first thing we want to make clear is the mode we developed the game on and the optimal mode for playing the game is the widescreen mode. 90% of our development stations were widescreen displays: artists, programmers and designers.

- BioShock was primarily developed and tuned for widescreen mode. Artists and designers worked with widescreen displays and chose a field of view (FOV) that best reflected their intentions with respect to the way the world is perceived, the perceived speed of movement of the player relative to the world and the amount of the world they wanted to be viewed for the best game-play experience. We went through dozens of iterations and finally settled upon a widescreen aspect ratio that best suited the gameplay experience.

- When playing in widescreen modes the game makes use of the full screen resolution, and does not crop or stretch a lower resolution image into a wide screen one. For example, at 720p the game renders natively to the full 1280x720 resolution.

- Once this FOV was established, we chose to keep exactly the same horizontal FOV for standard def displays, so as not to in any way alter the gameplay experience.

- Instead of cropping the FOV for 4:3 displays and making all 4:3 owners mad in doing so, we slightly extended the vertical FOV for standard def mode: we never wanted to have black bars on people’s displays. (This way, everybody is happy…) This does mean that people playing on a standard def display see slightly more vertical space, but, this does not significantly affect the game-play experience and, we felt that it best served our goal of keeping the game experience as close as possible to the original design and art vision on both types of displays. Reports of the widescreen FOV being a crop of the 4:3 FOV are completely false.

One thing we can assure you that all these decisions were made with the best interests of the game in mind. We didn’t save any money or development time by choosing this set of parameters. We did what we thought was the best thing for the game: developing and optimizing it for widescreen displays, and making the decision not to do the usual crop for 4:3 displays. As a consumer, you certainly have the right to disagree.

We understand that not all users might not be happy with these choices and we will be looking into options for allowing users to adjust FOV settings manually. But as we mentioned earlier, changes to video game code do not happen in minutes or hours. We appreciate your understanding.
 
I didn't read the entire thread but this is what 2K says about widescreen,
AFAIK everybody discussing this is already well aware of what 2K said. Its really a non issue now that they have announced a widescreen patch to fix the issue.;)
 
Nonetheless, it does illustrate my point. Ideally horizontal FOV is a function of absolute monitor width, therefore we can't say widescreen displays should have a wider FOV, since they're not necessarily physically wider than a 4:3 display.

It really is just a design decision. Maybe supporting 4:3 displays was an afterthought and they just did it by extending the vertical FOV.

Don't waste your time, some people have simply decided it's "wrong" and are content to rely on blind ignorance and "omg i read on teh interwebz they're ripping off widescreen owners! wtf!" hyperbole. Not to mention 2K have clearly stated the game was designed primarily for widescreen aspect ratios and is working as intended. Fact is, no one was complaining about the fov until the comparison screenshots appeared, even if some people have now convinced themselves they had noticed beforehand.

AFAIK everybody discussing this is already well aware of what 2K said. Its really a non issue now that they have announced a widescreen patch to fix the issue.;)

What's funny about the announcement of the patch (and they quite rightly call it a patch and not a fix, because it wasn't broken in the first place) is how they imply that people who want a wider fov can't handle the "harrowing experience".
 
Its perfectly simple, the whole idea widescreen is to give you a WIDER field of view. Bioshock does NOT give you wider field of view, it zooms your view in and keeps the same hFOV and alters your vFOV to fit.

A person who buys a widescreen simply wants to see more on the side, Bioshock fails to deliver.

Anyone trying to argue the point past this idea might as well be trying to argue that we all dont need to bother breathing air. No one is going to pay you serious attention because you're talking bollocks.
Well it's in fact not perfectly simple. That may be why you bought a widescreen, but that doesn't mean its incorrect for a game to show a taller vertical FOV on a 4:3 display, and that's exactly what is happening here.
If you consider that a 4:3 display is just widescreen with additional area at the top and bottom, it makes perfect sense for it to have the same horizontal FOV, and an increased vertical FOV. You're insisting on looking at it from the perspective that a widescreen is a wider 4:3.
 
Don't confuse HDTV with widescreen PC gaming. HDTV was designed to give you more space(along with increased resolution) because movies are shot in widescreen. PC games on the other hand are designed with whatever aspect ratio the developers decide is ideal.

So there's no law that was decreed by the display gods that says that widescreen users will have the advantage. That is why this thread exists, because not every company believes that a widescreen monitor should have more screen space than a 4:3 monitor.

One fact remains. That is that the majority of widescreen users don't get the simple concept that a widescreen monitor is a 4:3 monitor with the top and bottom chopped off and that a 4:3 monitor is a widescreen monitor with its sides chopped off and so on and so forth, and so on and so forth.
 
Fact is, no one was complaining about the fov until the comparison screenshots appeared, even if some people have now convinced themselves they had noticed beforehand.
That's a fact, is it? Very amusing. Why exactly do you believe those comparison shots were made the day the game was released? They didn't simply descend from the heavens; "appeared", as you call it. They were, in fact, made by individuals not in any way affiliated with 2K (or so I'm assuming).

You chose your words carefully as to not chance the appearance of invalidating your own fabricated, nonsensical argument. "Appeared".

If you consider that a 4:3 display is just widescreen with additional area at the top and bottom, it makes perfect sense for it to have the same horizontal FOV, and an increased vertical FOV.
Well, if we're going to imagine that a 4:3 display is just a widescreen with more vertical area, then isn't a widescreen just a widescreen with more vertical area, but wider?

This is an entirely self-defeating, circular argument without a grain of logic or sense.
 
Here is the widescreen agenda and the reasons behind it (neither reason below was implemented in BioShock originally):

Games use Horz+ as default
Why? While rare, super-wide setups are commercially supported (Matrox's Triplehead2Go; a 36:9 ratio widescreen setup) and used and if the game is vert- (like Bioshock), the game becomes unplayable for those users due to excessive vertical cropping. Massive tallscreen setups don't exist (nobody is vertically stacking 3 crts on top of each other to game with) This makes Horz+ the sane default for games. Note "massive" as used above does not mean physical dimensions, it means large ratios of width to height.
Bioshock used vert- with the result that if a widescreener rotated their monitor 90 degrees, they would get an expanded vertical FOV, dramatically expanded vs 4:3. See this thread for reference: http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11712

The game allows user configurable FOV
Why? If the game doesn't automatically support the format preferred, the user can set it himself. So if someone really wants tallscreen vert+, they can do it, if someone wants widescreen horz+, they can do it.


Neither of the above two reasons would cause 4:3 gamers to "not get as much as 16:9'rs" or such. If the 4:3 gamer wants to run in 16:9, he can do it and see exactly what the widescreener sees. If the widescreener wants to run in 4:3 he'll see exactly what the standard screener sees. Everyone is kept on a level playing field. If a game maker wants to leave out widescreen for competitive reasons, they MUST NOT use vert- (looking at EA here) because that allows the widescreener to rotate the monitor 90 degrees and get a super expanded tall FOV. 4:3 user loses out in big way with that method. The proper way is for the FOV to be permanently locked in both planes and for the game to support the widescreen resolutions/aspects but simply send black bars (ie: pillarbox) so that the panel runs at native resolution so scaling artifacts are not introduced. That's why we called out EA on their "equalizing the gaming field" nonesense and why we called out Bioshock about the maintaining the atmosphere. If either were truly the case, then the proper locking of both planes of FOV and pillar or letterboxing would have been used instead of leaving any plane of the FOV unlocked.


That's it. Icing on the cake is lack of HUD stretching between aspects as well as other minor details.
 
I have a 24" 16:10 LCD monitor I think that I will notice. I haven't tried the demo yet so we'll see.


So do I and I didn't notice at all. Keep in mind the game was developed for widescreen and the 4:3 was added later, so they took the easy way out by just increasing what that format sees on the top and bottom. Widescreen format still looks fantastic and there is no distortion/stretching of the scene or UI at all.
 
Back
Top