Aluminum and copper in the same loop...

Are there any fluid dynamic experts (professionals) in here? I think I read over at OC forumns from an expert that once you got over 1 gpm flow rate (in your loop) you had massively diminishing returns.

Maybe someone in here can clarify that better (with the math).
 
Are there any fluid dynamic experts (professionals) in here? I think I read over at OC forumns from an expert that once you got over 1 gpm flow rate (in your loop) you had massively diminishing returns.

Uhh oh... :D
 
Forget to mention this dumbshit didn't use an additive and the thread ended up getting locked?

Everyone just needs to get over it, when used RIGHT, alu in a loop is fine. When done right you have a better chance of a leak that those FUD pictures posted by Runker.

It is funny to watch some defend Swiftech though ;) .... blah blah blah our technic is better blah blah blah

Blah blah yourself. I was just in that thread and when I hit post reply, guess what happened... yep, the reply box popped up. It's no more locked than your jaw. You should check your facts before shooting off your mouth.
 
Are there any fluid dynamic experts (professionals) in here? I think I read over at OC forumns from an expert that once you got over 1 gpm flow rate (in your loop) you had massively diminishing returns.

Maybe someone in here can clarify that better (with the math).

You don't need a fluid dynamics professional to tell you that :eek:

And anyways, about corrosion, just remove the electrical connection between the dissimilar metals, and you'll get corrosion acceleration. Make sure the aluminum block isn't electrically connected to the ground (so, most chips without ihs's these days are safe) and you're fine.
 
Blah blah yourself. I was just in that thread and when I hit post reply, guess what happened... yep, the reply box popped up. It's no more locked than your jaw. You should check your facts before shooting off your mouth.

No point arguing with Top Nurse or RickCain. Any other forum where hardcore enthusiasts, CEO's, resellers, and reviewers get in a mix and these guys won't go there. Let them try this propaganda on other forums and see if they get away with it. Every chance TN gets, she'll try to create a drama thread to prove a point she can't possibly defend.

Stay in your sandbox TN/Rick. You'll only be tolerated by uninformed folks.
 
Blah blah yourself. I was just in that thread and when I hit post reply, guess what happened... yep, the reply box popped up. It's no more locked than your jaw. You should check your facts before shooting off your mouth.

No point arguing with Top Nurse or RickCain. Any other forum where hardcore enthusiasts, CEO's, resellers, and reviewers get in a mix and these guys won't go there. Let them try this propaganda on other forums and see if they get away with it. Every chance TN gets, she'll try to create a drama thread to prove a point she can't possibly defend.

Stay in your sandbox TN/Rick. You'll only be tolerated by uninformed folks.

Here is the DIRECT quote from the dipshit at Xtreme....... Denial is a beautiful thing.

You know Wanker, for someone who has been watercooling for about two months, you are pretty smart :eek:

I used ONLY destilled water without any "admixture" to stop corrosion
 
Here is the DIRECT quote from the dipshit at Xtreme....... Denial is a beautiful thing.

You know Wanker, for someone who has been watercooling for about two months, you are pretty smart :eek:

2 months? Making up stuff again I see to make yourself feel better? I've been doing this for 3 years.

Your quote basically sums up the point. Idiots and the general masses can't be trusted to put anti-corrosive additives into their loops. Just like Cathar and Marci have stated, if a design isn't idiot proof, then it's up to the manufacturers to build around it.
 
No point arguing with Top Nurse or RickCain. Any other forum where hardcore enthusiasts, CEO's, resellers, and reviewers get in a mix and these guys won't go there. Let them try this propaganda on other forums and see if they get away with it. Every chance TN gets, she'll try to create a drama thread to prove a point she can't possibly defend.

Stay in your sandbox TN/Rick. You'll only be tolerated by uninformed folks.

Then your leaving? Please go back to your vaunted ;) forum where CEO's, resellers of the same, and their paid review lackleys hang about and tell each other how great they are. Whoops...they don't like your mouth either do they? :D

So getting back to the OP's (me) question why is it you wank on other manufacturers for doing something, like using aluminum, that you then defend when a high flow company does the same thing?

Erasmus354 said this thread was flame bait. Actually it was intended to be a discrimination bait thread where those who throw their propaganda around could be seen for what they really are...

You sir win First Prize!
 
Then your leaving? Please go back to your vaunted ;) forum where CEO's, resellers of the same, and their paid review lackleys hang about and tell each other how great they are. Whoops...they don't like your mouth either do they? :D

So getting back to the OP's (me) question why is it you wank on other manufacturers for doing something, like using aluminum, that you then defend when a high flow company does the same thing?

Erasmus354 said this thread was flame bait. Actually it was intended to be a discrimination bait thread where those who throw their propaganda around could be seen for what they really are...

You sir win First Prize!

It also gives our resident "ambulance chaser in training" something to argue about too.
 
I know how everyone hates my car analogies, cant figure out why though, so here is the one that's FTW.

Let's face it and I have said this time and time again about how high flow cooling is quite akin to high performance racing, right? Some just boo hoo this like I was talking about the second coming, right?

So now we have a high flow water cooling company (Swiftech) that brings out their hot shot new cooler and lord of all things it has an aluminum top! More interesting is that they make it so it looks like an Edelbrock aluminum racing manifold as stated right here from their own website:

"The Apogee™ GTX water-block is to the Apogee™ GT what Saleen is to the Ford Mustang: a good deal of added performance with some killer looks. The reference to automotive does not stop there: we designed the Apogee™ GTX to provide a racing feel, not dissimilar to that of Edelbrock's famous V8 valve covers."​

So it appears that I was right on the money all the time, but you "water cooling racers" just refused to have someone call your real name! If you want a racing water cooling system then go high flow because that is what it is all about. If you want a regular computer that is silent, achieves a decent OC, and keeps you computer around for a while (electromigration :p) then get a low to medium flow rig and let the high flowers do all the high performance racing nonsense. :cool:
 
TN, large bore wc setups can be silent as well. Low flow does not = silence. It = low flow. An increase in tubing size does not mean an increase in noise.
 
[Offtopic]

Short question: what is the meaning of "OP"?
I have seen it many times in the last days but I have no clue what it means :confused:

[/Offtopic]
 
[Offtopic]

Short question: what is the meaning of "OP"?
I have seen it many times in the last days but I have no clue what it means :confused:

[/Offtopic]

It means original post or original poster depending upon how the person using it words their post.

TN, Ranker has repeatedly said that the high flow enthusiasts aren't very happy about the whole mixed metals used in the GTX. I ran mixed metals in my loop for three years or close to it and I'm glad to be away from it. It's not that I was worried about it since I ran a rich enough mix of antifreeze to ensure that I wasn't going to get corrosion but with a straight copper loop I can lean that mixture down and get better cooling from my coolant because as everyone knows water is the superior heat transferring medium.

I'm personally not sold on the GTX due to the simple fact that it uses metal barbs. All it takes is a little galling and that fancy plating is history which means that if you're not using enough anti-corrosion additive you're screwed. Same goes for any other block that has the barbs (or whatever tubing mounts it uses) screwed into the aluminum. Now, you could fix that by using softer barbs, such as nylon to prevent any galling.

Personally I'm not going to recommend the GTX to anyone that's after a large bore system due to the aluminum top. The GT is nearly as good for less money or the Fuzion again for less money.

As to small bore, I'm not going to bag on them but I can't make recommendations because they're not my cuppa.
 
TN, large bore wc setups can be silent as well. Low flow does not = silence. It = low flow. An increase in tubing size does not mean an increase in noise.

Yep. My larger loop isn't loud at all. The ONLY noise comes from the fans all running at 6v :eek:
 
Nice chart! However, a lot of these guys won't believe it because it wasn't done in the USA and it isn't in English. For some strange reason people of a high flow philosophy seem to be quite ethnocentric in their water cooling practices. ;) Must have something to do with high performance racing as evidenced by the "Edelbrock" look that Swiftech is putting out now. :p

No we won't discount that chart because it is foreign. However, I took one glance at the 6 year old blocks they tested and kept on going. Not to mention the Swiftech 6000, while a great block, is best suited to medium / low flow situations due to its flow agnostic characteristics. But nice try.....
 
I don't think they heard very well... => http://www.swiftnets.com/products/stealth.asp

I guess they don't think too much of your arguments either :p

Stop flamebaiting. You know as well as I do that the Stealth was in development when the GTX was introduced. By that time they've got too much time invested, money invested in tooling and production runs to just say "Let's just chuck it all in the trash and start again". I know that you can't seriously believe that the Stealth is brought to market this soon after the GTX and not have been in development from the time that the 8800's first hit the scene, which would coincide with the GTX's development cycle.

If there's enough uproar over these blocks it'll be apparent if Gabe listened to his customers when the new cards launch requiring new blocks.
 
There is no reason to mix aluminum and copper so I prefer to avoid it... Can it be done successfully? Yes. Why do it then? To save money for the manufacturer and for bling. EOM.
 
So old data isn't good anymore?

Old data is perfectly valid, but the data shown does not fit with the point that was trying to be made by the person who posted the data.

That test could have taken a completely open block (nothing to impede flow) and gone "Hey look, this 'High Flow' block gets insane flow rates!! but the cooling is worse than this low flow block!! ZOMG WTFBBQSAUCE!!!!11!11!!one" (which is essentially what that post/data amounted too, it took a flow agnostic block and used it to compare the entire high flow cooling perspective :rolleyes:)
 
Stop flamebaiting. You know as well as I do that the Stealth was in development when the GTX was introduced. By that time they've got too much time invested, money invested in tooling and production runs to just say "Let's just chuck it all in the trash and start again". I know that you can't seriously believe that the Stealth is brought to market this soon after the GTX and not have been in development from the time that the 8800's first hit the scene, which would coincide with the GTX's development cycle.

If there's enough uproar over these blocks it'll be apparent if Gabe listened to his customers when the new cards launch requiring new blocks.

Absolutely correct. Gabe had stated that he began the Stealth in conjunction with the GTX.

Anyhow, TN loves to flame bait. It's something I've come to accept. However, it doesn't mean I'm going to back down and let her try brainwash the few uninformed folks with her relentless mantra of 'low flow is better or just as good as high flow', 'alu is awesome', 'Aqua Computer's is the second coming of Christ'.

I totally disagree with dissimilar metals in the SAME block, regardless of coating or plating procedures.

There's NOTHING you can do about corrosion while the metals are touching eachother... Except of course, for additives.

There is no reason to mix aluminum and copper so I prefer to avoid it... Can it be done successfully? Yes. Why do it then? To save money for the manufacturer and for bling. EOM.

Agreed. You summed it up perfectly: it's just a way to cut costs and to add bling. This is exactly what I'm hoping they'll learn from the next time around when they enter their R&D cycle. I'm planning to take Gabe up on his offer for lunch and voice what my and fellow WC'ing enthusiasts concerns are. Most of us can't care any less about the bling as long as we the performance we're looking for. I'd pay $30 more for a block that nets me a 1C drop in temps. However, I'm not paying $30 more because a block looks "Custom, like a car"

I'm going to quote Cathar and Marci again because it quite simply puts everything into perspective and says all that needs to be said about Aluminum:
Marci said:
My stance on the use of aluminium is well-documented both here and on all other sites I frequent... that being, just avoid using it and thus avoid the complications that come alongside it. (ie: Is the anodizing good enough...? Has the enduser done sufficient research to know he HAS to use an additive...? Already there are now two factors out of anyone's control to account for - remove the use of aluminium, remove two uncontrollable factors, and thus remove the need for this entire topic which crops up with monotonous regularity every 6 weeks and has doneso for eons)

If we could have the faith that folks would use additive, then this wouldn't be a problem, but this whole thread highlights a lack of research, plain and simple. For nearing 10 years it's been common knowledge that you need to run anticorrosive additives alongside aluminium blocks in watercooling systems... to miss this fact simply demonstrates that adequate research prior to the purchase of the parts is lacking. This is what happens when watercooling becomes more mainstream. Parts availability becomes easy, and folks don't bother doing their research first.

This info is WIDELY spread across ALL forums that I frequent... it is covered in every watercooling guide I've ever read, and in more or less every watercooling sections' sticky by default... it's almost the first rule of watercooling it's that old.

Ignore the terminology I use in this next sentence, it isn't meant to be insulting... it's just a suitable way of phrasing it and I can't be assed to think of a more P/C way of saying it...

Manufacturers cannot account for the idiot factor (aka net-clue-factor to coin Cathar's way of saying it). If you can't account for the idiot factor, don't build items that an idiot cannot use correctly.

To release alu blocks is milking the market. Manufacturers know there is a HIGH risk of that aluminium block getting destroyed by what I'd say would be a good 50% of the watercooling market (the chunk that don't do their research and just dive in head first). This destruction isn't covered by warranty, so another sale is milked from the equation when that customer requires a replacement. A responsible manufacturer would include a note in with every block clearly stating that an anticorrosive additive MUST be used.
 
There is no reason to mix aluminum and copper so I prefer to avoid it... Can it be done successfully? Yes. Why do it then? To save money for the manufacturer and for bling. EOM.

If the product cools the part it is is intended for in the manner it is needed for then why use an expensive metal when it is not needed? By this same logic you present we should make all blocks out of silver, because it cools better...
 
If the product cools the part it is is intended for in the manner it is needed for then why use an expensive metal when it is not needed? By this same logic you present we should make all blocks out of silver, because it cools better...

Silver is marginally better than copper for great additional cost.

Copper is greatly better than aluminum for medium additional cost.

Most loops already have copper in it, therefore to avoid any chance of mixed metals and corrosion, most of us dont see a compelling enough reason to ever use aluminum given the advantages that copper holds over it.

Succinct enough for you?
 
Anyhow, TN loves to flame bait. It's something I've come to accept. However, it doesn't mean I'm going to back down and let her try brainwash the few uninformed folks with her relentless mantra of 'low flow is better or just as good as high flow', 'alu is awesome', 'Aqua Computer's is the second coming of Christ'.

I just like pointing out what I perceive as people who always think they are right and don't notice that in everything there are always two sides to the same coin.

The only reason to go high flow is if you are into the racing thing: The coolest possible, at the highest flow possible, at the highest OC possible, etc.

So you don't believe you are trying to "brainwash" anyone here? LOL

If you don't like AC then there are lots of good manufacturers out there with similar philosophies: Innovatek, Koolance, etc. I see a lot more Koolance stuff out there in the computer stores than any other manufacturer. They sell a lot of product...

Agreed. You summed it up perfectly: it's just a way to cut costs and to add bling. This is exactly what I'm hoping they'll learn from the next time around when they enter their R&D cycle. I'm planning to take Gabe up on his offer for lunch and voice what my and fellow WC'ing enthusiasts concerns are. Most of us can't care any less about the bling as long as we the performance we're looking for. I'd pay $30 more for a block that nets me a 1C drop in temps. However, I'm not paying $30 more because a block looks "Custom, like a car"

I suspect that you and your fellow extremists account for such a small percentage of Swiftech sales that they might give you lip service, but I doubt it is going to change their marketing or product lineup.

I'm going to quote Cathar and Marci again because it quite simply puts everything into perspective and says all that needs to be said about Aluminum:

That was a good thing to say years ago, but the world has changed from your extremism in WC to a much wider mass market appeal. In case you hadn't notices most companies that have some kind of aluminum in their product lineup usually include the proper coolant in their kits. The ones that don't specifically recommend their own flavor of anti-corrosion additives. So get off the horse and buggy and join the rest of the world. :p
 
I totally disagree with dissimilar metals in the SAME block, regardless of coating or plating procedures.

There's NOTHING you can do about corrosion while the metals are touching each other... Except of course, for additives.

I don't think having additives is going to help much with direct contact of copper and aluminum. AC already tried it and it was problematic (in the AquagraFX 6800 FCB's with the copper inserts), but I guess other companies gotta see for themselves. ;)
 
The only reason to go high flow is if you are into the racing thing: The coolest possible, at the highest flow possible, at the highest OC possible, etc.

Really? Because personally I thought cheaper price, and better overall price/performance was a very compelling reason myself. But then again what do I know, I guess everyone is of the mindset that spending more for bling is what really matter....unless they want MAX XTREME OC ZOMG!!!>!
 
Silver is marginally better than copper for great additional cost.

Copper is greatly better than aluminum for medium additional cost.

Most loops already have copper in it, therefore to avoid any chance of mixed metals and corrosion, most of us dont see a compelling enough reason to ever use aluminum given the advantages that copper holds over it.

Succinct enough for you?

Copper isn't needed for all water blocks. Aluminum works just as well and it is considerably less in price in some applications. That is why you see mosfet and ram blocks made out of aluminum Copper prices are going out the roof in price. Companies that don't make use of aluminum where it makes sense will price themselves right out of the market...

Why do you think Swiftech started using aluminum in their blocks?
 
That was a good thing to say years ago, but the world has changed from your extremism in WC to a much wider mass market appeal. In case you hadn't notices most companies that have some kind of aluminum in their product lineup usually include the proper coolant in their kits. The ones that don't specifically recommend their own flavor of anti-corrosion additives. So get off the horse and buggy and join the rest of the world. :p

You hit the nail on your head. Watercooling is becoming more mass market. The same mass market that spills coffee in their lap and sues. The same mass market that thinks American Idol is the best show since sliced bread. These are the people that are idiotic enough not to follow simple instructions, and to fill up their watercooling loop with tap water. I mean...its water cooling, tap water is water, what could go wrong?!?

Idiot proofing is much more important to a mass market audience then it is to a small enthusiast market.
 
Copper isn't needed for all water blocks. Aluminum works just as well and it is considerably less in price in some applications. That is why you see mosfet and ram blocks made out of aluminum Copper prices are going out the roof in price. Companies that don't make use of aluminum where it makes sense will price themselves right out of the market...

Why do you think Swiftech started using aluminum in their blocks?

GPU's dump more heat now then a CPU does...why then does a GPU not need copper? (Oh thats right it would ruin the looks GASP)

Mosfets and RAM don't need blocks period. So arguing that using aluminum is better....well using nothing there is better still! (I bet you nothing is cheaper than aluminum ;) )
 
Really? Because personally I thought cheaper price, and better overall price/performance was a very compelling reason myself. But then again what do I know, I guess everyone is of the mindset that spending more for bling is what really matter....unless they want MAX XTREME OC ZOMG!!!>!

Some low flow equipment is expensive like AC and their are other companies like Koolance, Alphacool, and Innovatek that are cheaper. If it's the same price and your computer runs well then you would think low flow is okay? Haven't you been listening to all these people who are quite happy with what they are using?

Maybe it's just me, but whenever someone comes along with their cheapo WC kit and says that it is working peachy fine I seem to hear a big clamour about how fucked their cooling hardware really is. I know for a fact that many of our online WC distributors sell 10-1 in favor of things like the Big Water to a nice setup from Swiftech, Danger Den, AC, and other higher end cooling kits. Guess what, they get good results too...
 
GPU's dump more heat now then a CPU does...why then does a GPU not need copper? (Oh thats right it would ruin the looks GASP)

???? My GPU blocks are made of copper, my NB block is solid silver, my CPU cooler has a silver baseplate with nickel plated brass for a center piece, and my mosfet cooler is made out of aluminum. I don't expect corrosion problems with FOUR different metals in my water loop because many others have done the same thing with NO CORROSION. Can you imagine that? :D

Mosfets and RAM don't need blocks period. So arguing that using aluminum is better....well using nothing there is better still! (I bet you nothing is cheaper than aluminum ;) )

According to you they aren't needed so don't use them. Plenty of other people think otherwise or their wouldn't be all these manufacturers all over the world who are making them as fast as they can make them....because people are buying them... Wake up and smell the coffee. :rolleyes:
 
You hit the nail on your head. Watercooling is becoming more mass market. The same mass market that spills coffee in their lap and sues. The same mass market that thinks American Idol is the best show since sliced bread. These are the people that are idiotic enough not to follow simple instructions, and to fill up their watercooling loop with tap water. I mean...its water cooling, tap water is water, what could go wrong?!?

Idiot proofing is much more important to a mass market audience then it is to a small enthusiast market.

Great! Then leave it up to the ambulance chasers and get off everybody's case. Ranker is a special case as he is an ambulance chaser in training. :D

I don't watch any TV other than maybe PBS, so what is American Idol? :cool:
 
Stop flamebaiting. You know as well as I do that the Stealth was in development when the GTX was introduced. By that time they've got too much time invested, money invested in tooling and production runs to just say "Let's just chuck it all in the trash and start again". I know that you can't seriously believe that the Stealth is brought to market this soon after the GTX and not have been in development from the time that the 8800's first hit the scene, which would coincide with the GTX's development cycle.

If there's enough uproar over these blocks it'll be apparent if Gabe listened to his customers when the new cards launch requiring new blocks.

Actually I would assume that they were in product development way before the release of the 8800 series blocks just like AC was. No matter what the uproar is won't make a bit of difference. What matters is sales...
 
Hey, TN, there's this great feature called multi quote now. Look at the bottom right corner of each post box and next to the quote there's a + sign. Click that in each post you wish to address and when you hit "post reply" all the quotes will be in there. This will save the thread from blooming by 5 to 10 posts as you address multiple posts and it should save you some time ;) Just a thought.

Edit:

Copper isn't needed for all water blocks. Aluminum works just as well and it is considerably less in price in some applications. That is why you see mosfet and ram blocks made out of aluminum Copper prices are going out the roof in price. Companies that don't make use of aluminum where it makes sense will price themselves right out of the market...

Why do you think Swiftech started using aluminum in their blocks?

ZOMG! ROFL!! Swiftech isn't using aluminum on the base of the blocks, they're machining the tops out of it and the molded plastic they were using is way cheaper than milled aluminum. I've gotta say, thanks, that was the funniest thing I've seen in days.
 
If the product cools the part it is is intended for in the manner it is needed for then why use an expensive metal when it is not needed? By this same logic you present we should make all blocks out of silver, because it cools better...

Last time I checked, Silver was classified as a valuable metal with much higher prices than Copper. The cost of going from Copper to Silver is much more than going from Alu to Copper.

I just like pointing out what I perceive as people who always think they are right and don't notice that in everything there are always two sides to the same coin.

The only reason to go high flow is if you are into the racing thing: The coolest possible, at the highest flow possible, at the highest OC possible, etc.

Absolutely false, "high flow" companies are not only cheaper in cost, give you the lowest temps, greatest room for OC, and can be run silent. This takes away everything a "low flow" setup can offer other than looks. You're paying the extra price for bling. Just accept it.


If you don't like AC then there are lots of good manufacturers out there with similar philosophies: Innovatek, Koolance, etc. I see a lot more Koolance stuff out there in the computer stores than any other manufacturer. They sell a lot of product...

Sorry. Koolance doesn't classify as good. That's universally accepted constant right up there with Gravity. Most people who buy Koolance never go back. It costs an arm and a leg and gives you a fraction of the performance of a custom build that costs less. All the companies you named are basically considered crap. McDonald's sells a lot of food, but that doesn't make it healthy nor good. It's just got more marketing muscle than most companies.

I suspect that you and your fellow extremists account for such a small percentage of Swiftech sales that they might give you lip service, but I doubt it is going to change their marketing or product lineup.

They're one of the few companies actually have CEO's and their employees participate on boards. Swiftech had no interest in creating a FC block until those of us on XS started demanding one. He does listen and is one of the few CEO's along with Eddie, Marci and others that regularly post on XS.

As for extremists, I believe that's your specialty. I'm not the one running around preaching "low flow is better than high flow" something akin to saying "there is no god but Allah" in my books.

That was a good thing to say years ago, but the world has changed from your extremism in WC to a much wider mass market appeal. In case you hadn't notices most companies that have some kind of aluminum in their product lineup usually include the proper coolant in their kits. The ones that don't specifically recommend their own flavor of anti-corrosion additives. So get off the horse and buggy and join the rest of the world. :p

The world has definitely changed. More people are joining the WC'ing community. I have 15 associates that WC their computers. Only two of which read forums regarding to WC'ing. The others were clueless on mixing metals or even using distilled water. Like Cathar/Marci pointed out, it is the general masses without this sort of knowledge that needs to be protected...not exploited like those who use alu as their main component in their products.


Copper isn't needed for all water blocks. Aluminum works just as well and it is considerably less in price in some applications. That is why you see mosfet and ram blocks made out of aluminum Copper prices are going out the roof in price. Companies that don't make use of aluminum where it makes sense will price themselves right out of the market...

Why do you think Swiftech started using aluminum in their blocks?

Aluminum doesn't work just as well. Copper is the better performer. The rise in cost of copper is negligible as it sells for roughly $0.25 an ounce. The majority of the cost of WC'ing equipment isn't the materials used but the complex manufacturing process that requires multiple stages. One part is made/crafted at one location before shipping it to another part of the world to carry out the next step.

Price wasn't the issue for Swiftech's Stealth. It was done for "racing" looks.

Some low flow equipment is expensive like AC and their are other companies like Koolance, Alphacool, and Innovatek that are cheaper. If it's the same price and your computer runs well then you would think low flow is okay? Haven't you been listening to all these people who are quite happy with what they are using?

Don't be misleading. The stuff Koolance sells is by no means cheap in price. It costs just as much and often more than a comparable high flow setup. Alphacool is NOT a low flow company. They play in both camps and their high flow products were actually heralded at one point (until like DD they stopped pushing the envelope). However, Alphacool is still expensive.


???? My GPU blocks are made of copper, my NB block is solid silver, my CPU cooler has a silver baseplate with nickel plated brass for a center piece, and my mosfet cooler is made out of aluminum. I don't expect corrosion problems with FOUR different metals in my water loop because many others have done the same thing with NO CORROSION. Can you imagine that? :D

It really doesn't matter how many metals you have in your loop as long as they don't react to one another. Aluminum will cause corrosion unless necessary precautions are taken. Even then its not that corrosion doesn't occur, only the process is slowed down.


Great! Then leave it up to the ambulance chasers and get off everybody's case. Ranker is a special case as he is an ambulance chaser in training. :D

I don't watch any TV other than maybe PBS, so what is American Idol? :cool:

I appreciate the personal flame. It shows that you care.
 
Hey, TN, there's this great feature called multi quote now. Look at the bottom right corner of each post box and next to the quote there's a + sign. Click that in each post you wish to address and when you hit "post reply" all the quotes will be in there. This will save the thread from blooming by 5 to 10 posts as you address multiple posts and it should save you some time ;) Just a thought.

Swiftech isn't using aluminum on the base of the blocks, they're machining the tops out of it and the molded plastic they were using is way cheaper than milled aluminum. I've gotta say, thanks, that was the funniest thing I've seen in days.

Thanks for the tip as this is kinda handy! Aren't you glad I'm back to add in a little liveliness around here? BTW, just want to make sure you got your Multi-Tool I had Sharka send you?

For the same reason they use injection molded products, to save cost and make a higher margin.

EXACTLY :D

Last time I checked, Silver was classified as a valuable metal with much higher prices than Copper. The cost of going from Copper to Silver is much more than going from Alu to Copper.

Since when was eeking out the last dribble of performance an issue of price? Last time I looked those Iwaki pumps were two to three times the price of anything else on the market for dubious gains in cooling. BTW, why buy a 24 volt pump and run it at 12 volts? If your after the big flow then why not spend a few bucks and boost your voltage to the stock supply voltage?

Absolutely false, "high flow" companies are not only cheaper in cost, give you the lowest temps, greatest room for OC, and can be run silent. This takes away everything a "low flow" setup can offer other than looks. You're paying the extra price for bling. Just accept it.

The key words there are "can be run silent" at a major performance loss? Whereas low to medium flow works just as well with considerable less space constraints and dead silent. Silence means no noise...

Sorry. Koolance doesn't classify as good. That's universally accepted constant right up there with Gravity. Most people who buy Koolance never go back. It costs an arm and a leg and gives you a fraction of the performance of a custom build that costs less. All the companies you named are basically considered crap. McDonald's sells a lot of food, but that doesn't make it healthy nor good. It's just got more marketing muscle than most companies.

If there all crap why do they keep setting new sales records? Your beating a dead horse here...

They're one of the few companies actually have CEO's and their employees participate on boards. Swiftech had no interest in creating a FC block until those of us on XS started demanding one. He does listen and is one of the few CEO's along with Eddie, Marci and others that regularly post on XS.

Obviously they got a lot of time on their hands. Maybe if they spent more time engineering and marketing they could have the breadth of products to sell like Koolance, Innnovatek, Alphacool, and Aqua Computer ad infinitum.

The world has definitely changed. More people are joining the WC'ing community. I have 15 associates that WC their computers. Only two of which read forums regarding to WC'ing. The others were clueless on mixing metals or even using distilled water.

Yes it has changed so quit trying to live in the past. Also I bet you surely indoctrinated them into the racing cult, right?

Aluminum doesn't work just as well. Copper is the better performer. The rise in cost of copper is negligible as it sells for roughly $0.25 an ounce. The majority of the cost of WC'ing equipment isn't the materials used but the complex manufacturing process that requires multiple stages. One part is made/crafted at one location before shipping it to another part of the world to carry out the next step.

On April 24, 2007, the International Copper Study Group (ICSG) said that its preliminary data showed that world copper production exceeded consumption by 40,000 tons in January. World mine production was up 9% from a year ago while total usage was up 6%. On May 16, 2007, the ICSG predicted that world refined copper production will exceed usage by 282,000 tons in 2007 and by 527,000 tons in 2008. Remember Econ 101? Demand over supply = higher prices...

Price wasn't the issue for Swiftech's Stealth. It was done for "racing" looks.

Now how the hell would you know that unless you are privy to Swiftech's books?

Don't be misleading. The stuff Koolance sells is by no means cheap in price. It costs just as much and often more than a comparable high flow setup. Alphacool is NOT a low flow company. They play in both camps and their high flow products were actually heralded at one point (until like DD they stopped pushing the envelope). However, Alphacool is still expensive.

Ahh... when a lawyer gets all jammed up they take the offensive with innuendos and misleading statements all the while claiming they aren't being misleading as well. As far as price goes it depends where you buying it from. Obviously shipping and currency exchange rates play an important part here. Alphacool makes stuff that works in both camps so what are you saying? Their lower flowing stuff is poorly designed, but their high flow stuff is good design?

It really doesn't matter how many metals you have in your loop as long as they don't react to one another. Aluminum will cause corrosion unless necessary precautions are taken. Even then its not that corrosion doesn't occur, only the process is slowed down.

Since my metals (aluminum, silver, copper, and nickel) haven't created corrosion why do you keep beating a dead horse here? So if it slows down to the point that it is a problem 10 years from now that's bad? Let me see now...where did I put that Athlon slot 1 700 Mhz cpu and board. Do you really think there would be a use for it....

horse.gif


I appreciate the personal flame. It shows that you care.

Yeah you have kinda been growing on me even though your a PITA. ;) Maybe I should go back to school and be a legal nurse consultant when I retire.
 

Hahahahaha this is priceless....care to read what you just posted TN?

"...copper production EXCEEDED [emphasis added] consumption..."
"...world mine production up 9%..."
"...copper production will exceed usage by 282,000 tons in 2007 and by 527,000 tons in 2008..."

I think you need to go back to English 101 TN, because your reading comprehension is down the tubes. All I see there is that Supply > Demand, which according to your Econ 101 class, would equal lowering prices....
 
That was funny! Well I guess I do make a few flubs occasionally as I'm not perfect. :D

However, the trend for the last few years shows copper escalating and it is way more expensive now than what it was say in 2004.
 
Back
Top