How's LOTRO?

So is anyone going to purchase this game and the lifetime membership?

I purchased it, but only plan to go with the $9.99 plan. $200 is too much, who knows what will happen with the game. They could pull a SWG and it will be ruined in a year.
 

Sorry, Star Wars Galaxies. I realize that Sony Online Entertainment isn't running LOTRO, but I'm still cautious with any game in this genre. No way I'm paying $200 with the chance that they could completely change key aspects of the game, or nerf my character after I have spent hundreds of hours on it.
 
Sorry, Star Wars Galaxies. I realize that Sony Online Entertainment isn't running LOTRO, but I'm still cautious with any game in this genre. No way I'm paying $200 with the chance that they could completely change key aspects of the game, or nerf my character after I have spent hundreds of hours on it.

What MMO or RPG doesn't do this? Diablo 2 changed a whole lot from version 1.0 to now.

I don't play WoW, but I hear they changed a lot of stuff in that...

They have changed a lot of stuff in Lineage II as well...

bascially every MMO that comes to mind, they've nerfed something because of people exploiding "bugs"
 
Sorry, Star Wars Galaxies. I realize that Sony Online Entertainment isn't running LOTRO, but I'm still cautious with any game in this genre. No way I'm paying $200 with the chance that they could completely change key aspects of the game, or nerf my character after I have spent hundreds of hours on it.

Ever played an MMO that didn't have constant patches that changed game balance and lead to massive whining about things being nerfed or buffed too much?
 
What MMO or RPG doesn't do this? Diablo 2 changed a whole lot from version 1.0 to now.

I don't play WoW, but I hear they changed a lot of stuff in that...

They have changed a lot of stuff in Lineage II as well...

bascially every MMO that comes to mind, they've nerfed something because of people exploiding "bugs"

Exactly, which is why I'm not willing to put down $200 in a one time fee to play any of them. I'll put down my $10-$15 a month and then if something changes in the first year I'm not stuck with $100 towards something I don't plan to play. Diablo 2 doesn't really count because it doesn't have monthly fees however. Although many other MMO's have had nerfs and tweaks, none have gone through what SWG did with having a number of classes completely removed and the whole style of game completely changed not once but twice. That's why I used it as the prime example.

You guys missed my point, I'm not saying MMO's are bad for having changes. I'm saying that due to this aspect of the genre I'm not putting down a huge lump sum prior to launch just to avoid monthly fees. It's quite simple.
 
I've looked through this thread, and I can't seem to find info for all my questions.

Anyway, is there a WoW raiding type system, go into instance, rape a few dragons, collect "phat lewtz" with 39 other people?

Are they ever planning on implementing a "horde" with orcs and whatnot that we can play as

What are the classes in LOTRO most closely like compared to WoW, I can see that champion is warrior, hunter is hunter, thief is rogue... but the others are kind of fuzzy.

How do they expect to expand the game, if it is based off of books that a man wrote years and years ago, are they going to make up some lore for the sake of the game? Include areas never mentioned by Tolkien to give us fresh areas? Blizzard had it easy, they created the Warcraft lore, and can continue to make it deeper, but how can you expand lore that is based off of some novels?

How many people are currently playing the beta? I see there is only about 8 "realms"


I guess I should probably google this some more, but i'm thinking some of you guys who are in the "world tour" can more appropriately answer some of my questions. This game has sparked my interest though.
 
I've looked through this thread, and I can't seem to find info for all my questions.

-WoW raiding

-"horde"

-classes

-lore

I bulleted some of your questions so i can attempt to answer them easily.

- As to raiding/dungeons, there are some things like that, and right now they are part of quests, where the entire party is ported into a dungeon... The max lvl for the open beta is 15 so we have not really seen a lot of the endgame stuff, in terms of loot crafting, mobs, areas and whatnot. I expect it to work similar to WoW and from reading up on it it should act pretty much the same way.

- As to Horde, there is a netherregions mode where everyone can become "horde" and improve the character, level up and do pretty much everything all over as in the regular game. however, it is a little more targeted and more along the lines of castle invasions to give the feel of the large scale battles in LOTRO movies. You can pick a variety of bad guys including wolves and spiders.

- As to classes i think you have got them spot on. The descriptions when picking a class even puts it bluntly (AOE, range DPS, Tank, healer...).

-lore - it seems that they will use relatively accurate lore and the events in the game sort of surround and predate the movie events. For example even right now in some quest descriptions/ story the movie events are alluded to. Plus it seems some of the areas of the game (famous from the movie) will come as expansions later down the road (when the story is evolved to the time of the movie).
 
Exactly, which is why I'm not willing to put down $200 in a one time fee to play any of them. I'll put down my $10-$15 a month and then if something changes in the first year I'm not stuck with $100 towards something I don't plan to play. Diablo 2 doesn't really count because it doesn't have monthly fees however. Although many other MMO's have had nerfs and tweaks, none have gone through what SWG did with having a number of classes completely removed and the whole style of game completely changed not once but twice. That's why I used it as the prime example.

You guys missed my point, I'm not saying MMO's are bad for having changes. I'm saying that due to this aspect of the genre I'm not putting down a huge lump sum prior to launch just to avoid monthly fees. It's quite simple.

I understand your point. Why spend money + time = 4 something that doesnt = anything because it got lots of -'s from nerfs. I'm not saying that I don't agree with you, I don't play MMO's because I don't like paying monthly for a games...
 
i thought it would be something like oblivion... we'll have to play it online then :(
 
How do they expect to expand the game, if it is based off of books that a man wrote years and years ago, are they going to make up some lore for the sake of the game? Include areas never mentioned by Tolkien to give us fresh areas? Blizzard had it easy, they created the Warcraft lore, and can continue to make it deeper, but how can you expand lore that is based off of some novels?

I'm only answering this question because the others were answered already.

Anyway, I highly doubt that Turbine is going to up and create lore out of nowhere (and areas). Every area in the game is found in the novels, at least mentioned or ventured to/through.

For example, Shores of Evendim is a content update set to release in June. Lots of new quests, items, armor, etc., set in brand new area set north of The Shire, around Lake Evendim (which, as far as I know, doesn't have a role in any of the LOTR novels).
The LOTR lore is a lot deeper than you might think... there's plenty to stuff the game with, and I'm hoping they continue to do so as time progresses (content update not two months after launch = hope!!).
 
I tried it back in the beta stage and I cant say that I really liked it all that much. I played it for about a weeks time and just decided that there were too many aspects of the game that I didnt like. But its worth a try, dont take anyone elses word for it,if you can try it.

QFT.

I didn't like it at all in the Closed Beta at all. It just wasn't fun for me. So I went back to WOW
 
Question - I had jumped in during the very first open beta, and the combat system kinda sucked.

I'm used to RPGs more like 'Oblivion', where combat actions are actual actions. I swing my axe, you raise your shield, they hit, you recoil, damage is done based on your blocking skill, shield strength, armor, etc vs my attack (very RPG-like, that part). Only...if you DON'T raise your shield, or you do but don't block the blow, it hits you proper and you do not get the 'block' bonuses...and you recoil directly from that. Physics (IE., your balance) reacts differently based on where you are hit and how hard).

With LOTRO, an attack just involved two characters saddling up roughly to the same general area as each other and wildly swinging in the air with damage points somehow magically effecting their target. To emphasize the point - no physical contact at ALL between the characters/creatures/whatever. Just whiff (+2), whiff (+12), whiff (+9), etc

Has that - or will that - change? Or is this going to rather be like every other MMO?
 
I''ve been playing about 4-5 days now and i pre-ordered it. It's not perfect, but it's a welcome change from WoW and other mmo's i've been playing.
Graphically, it reminds me a lot of EQ2 except done somewhat better. (This is at 1024x1078 or such resolution) Gameplay world is pretty nice looking to me at least and the water looks good as was mentioned. Should even look nicer once i get my 8800gtx and my 2405 monitor i hope.
The quest display as someone said could be done better, but if you read the history of the quest your on you can usually can find the spot or mobs your looking for. Hopefully it will be improved upon as the game matures as it does need more work.
Gameplaywise, it's not bad and as was mentioned there ARE a lot of quests to do with some of them being pretty original. Imho, i think that turbine will hopefully add PvP in a later expansion to go along with or to improve the monster PvP in the game now. No reason they couldn't add an evil expansion where you can play an orc, goblin, evil man or such. Would be a good thing to do later down the road. I'D love it...lol
The community at this point isn't huge but the groups i've been in have been pretty mature. You'll get the occasional idiot player though in group or in chat.
With the whole tolkien world to build upon, i think they'll be able to add a lot of content to this game eventually.
To be honest i haven't been able to get on WoW for a week now and i haven't really missed it. I'll still play it regular but LOTRO is slower paced which suits me fine atm. I reccomend it if your a tolkien fan (I am..hehe)
 
Quick question - can I get in on the World Tour still ... also, are there any magic style classes? I know the whole lore of Tolkien & wizards, but knowing if there's a magic class or not would be nice.
 
Loremasters seem to be the only magic using types atm, but i've not too much experience with those atm. Some pet using types tho. The tolkien universe doesn't have a huge amount of magic using people so understandable in that context.
 
I have only played 1 hour in the past week, partly because my rig is being retarded, however except nice gfx I found the game to be a copy of wow.... It is interesting, I guess I should give it some time, but I do not think I am going to preorder it, not until I read some reviews...
 
I''ve been playing about 4-5 days now and i pre-ordered it. It's not perfect, but it's a welcome change from WoW and other mmo's i've been playing.
Graphically, it reminds me a lot of EQ2 except done somewhat better. (This is at 1024x1078 or such resolution) Gameplay world is pretty nice looking to me at least and the water looks good as was mentioned. Should even look nicer once i get my 8800gtx and my 2405 monitor i hope.
The quest display as someone said could be done better, but if you read the history of the quest your on you can usually can find the spot or mobs your looking for. Hopefully it will be improved upon as the game matures as it does need more work.
Gameplaywise, it's not bad and as was mentioned there ARE a lot of quests to do with some of them being pretty original. Imho, i think that turbine will hopefully add PvP in a later expansion to go along with or to improve the monster PvP in the game now. No reason they couldn't add an evil expansion where you can play an orc, goblin, evil man or such. Would be a good thing to do later down the road. I'D love it...lol
The community at this point isn't huge but the groups i've been in have been pretty mature. You'll get the occasional idiot player though in group or in chat.
With the whole tolkien world to build upon, i think they'll be able to add a lot of content to this game eventually.
To be honest i haven't been able to get on WoW for a week now and i haven't really missed it. I'll still play it regular but LOTRO is slower paced which suits me fine atm. I reccomend it if your a tolkien fan (I am..hehe)



this is exactly how i feel... except i didnt preorder it , i would if i had the time.
 
I''ve been playing about 4-5 days now and i pre-ordered it. It's not perfect, but it's a welcome change from WoW and other mmo's i've been playing.
Graphically, it reminds me a lot of EQ2 except done somewhat better. (This is at 1024x1078 or such resolution) Gameplay world is pretty nice looking to me at least and the water looks good as was mentioned. Should even look nicer once i get my 8800gtx and my 2405 monitor i hope.
The quest display as someone said could be done better, but if you read the history of the quest your on you can usually can find the spot or mobs your looking for. Hopefully it will be improved upon as the game matures as it does need more work.
Gameplaywise, it's not bad and as was mentioned there ARE a lot of quests to do with some of them being pretty original. Imho, i think that turbine will hopefully add PvP in a later expansion to go along with or to improve the monster PvP in the game now. No reason they couldn't add an evil expansion where you can play an orc, goblin, evil man or such. Would be a good thing to do later down the road. I'D love it...lol
The community at this point isn't huge but the groups i've been in have been pretty mature. You'll get the occasional idiot player though in group or in chat.
With the whole tolkien world to build upon, i think they'll be able to add a lot of content to this game eventually.
To be honest i haven't been able to get on WoW for a week now and i haven't really missed it. I'll still play it regular but LOTRO is slower paced which suits me fine atm. I reccomend it if your a tolkien fan (I am..hehe)

There *is* PVP and you *can* play as a monster right now. Try going to a Fell Scrying pool.
 
There *is* PVP and you *can* play as a monster right now. Try going to a Fell Scrying pool.

Reading is fundamental - he didn't say there was no PVP. He said "hopefully add PvP in a later expansion to go along with or to improve the monster PvP in the game now. No reason they couldn't add an evil expansion where you can play an orc, goblin, evil man or such."

Playing as a monster is not what folks want when doing PVP. They want a sworn enemy. Additionally, why spend that time gathering gear so I can play as a monster and look like every other monster out there? I want to play as an Orc...Nazgul...something...anything evil and has the desire to see the end of men, elves, dwarves, and those furry-footed hobbits.
 
i would be fun to play as an actual evil side, compared to wow where they are supposed to both be kinda good kinda bad. the evil side in lotr doesnt fuck around.
 
Most of the problem with allowing to play an evil character is that people will whine about being killed, or being "griefed". They did that all the time on Everquest PVP. You have dark elves, trolls, ogres, etc, but if you went nuts and actually played like those characters are supposed to play (role playing game?) you'd get banned from the game. So you always had to be "nice" even if you played an evil character.
 
Playing as a monster is not what folks want when doing PVP. They want a sworn enemy. Additionally, why spend that time gathering gear so I can play as a monster and look like every other monster out there? I want to play as an Orc...Nazgul...something...anything evil and has the desire to see the end of men, elves, dwarves, and those furry-footed hobbits.

That is what PvMP is, you can play as an Orc (uruk-hai and regular orc), a warg, or as a giant spider. And yes you can raid hobbits and eat their legs. You can't play as a Nazgul tho since there's only 9 of them and it wouldn't be right to see 100s of Nazguls running around. The PvMP area is pretty big and you have to hold outposts and towns within the area.
 
...
With LOTRO, an attack just involved two characters saddling up roughly to the same general area as each other and wildly swinging in the air with damage points somehow magically effecting their target. To emphasize the point - no physical contact at ALL between the characters/creatures/whatever. Just whiff (+2), whiff (+12), whiff (+9), etc

Has that - or will that - change? Or is this going to rather be like every other MMO?

Well, what you seem to be describing would involve active collision detection between characters, which wouldn't really work in an mmo. Aside from lag issues and such, with that many bodies you'd very often end up with blocked paths or not enough space to get next to a monster to swing (if you had several melee attacking one monster). You would also definitely see griefers deliberately blocking off certain monster camps, npcs, etc, so that other people couldn't access them.
 
Well, what you seem to be describing would involve active collision detection between characters, which wouldn't really work in an mmo. Aside from lag issues and such, with that many bodies you'd very often end up with blocked paths or not enough space to get next to a monster to swing (if you had several melee attacking one monster). You would also definitely see griefers deliberately blocking off certain monster camps, npcs, etc, so that other people couldn't access them.

Exactly what he said. Having the collision like you would in FPS would not work in MMO, simply because there are more people in a small, confined area. And if dead bodies would actually blo9ck path, that would lead to noobs blocking off areas and such. I could see it being nice in the FPS, but that is about it, for now at least. Right now you may think it is stupid, but once you play an MMO few months, you will appricaite that feature.
 
active collision detection between characters, which wouldn't really work in an mmo

EQ1 had it. not sure about EQ2.

In EQ1, it was a PITA in some areas like SOLB when you'd come in the door and an ogre and troll were camping the entrance and you couldn't get passed them. the developers had a /push command planned, but quickly learned people could use it to push people into lava etc. and nixed it.

it could be neat, but the game would have to be designed around it.
 
active collision detection between characters, which wouldn't really work in an mmo.

I think at least one or two under-development MMOs have mentioned having real collision detection between players to be used as a tactic (a front line of characters blocking a path). I may be thinking of Warhammer Online and Darkfall. Age of Conan may be one too, I know their combat system involves real dodging and depending on your swing you can slice through multiple enemies.
 
If you guys want pvp, play Lineage 2. Great mmo just requires too much grinding to get to the end-game levels.
 
I believe AoC is going to use collision detection. I'm sure they're working hard to figure out how to minimize it as a griefer tool, and I'm interested to see how they can succeed. It would be nice to see a classic "tank blocks the doorway" while ranged folks shoot arrows over his head strategy.

Lack of collision always seems silly. Run toward monster. Monster aggros. Runs through you. D'oh, you're getting stabbed in the butt now!
 
And yes you can raid hobbits and eat their legs.

You almost sold me on it on that statement alone. :D (What can I say - I'm an evil bastard...lol) So what's to keep a balance between folks wanting to play the monsters and folks wanting to play the good guys?
 
I'm getting it mainly because it IS slower paced than WoW is. I liked EQ2 which it reminds me of, but at the time i was playing it was very unfinished and i didn't feel like returning once it did get better later on. I like WoW, and it is fun still, but it's getting stale once you've done everything and leveled up the 3rd or 5th alt pretty much the same way as the rest.
I may drop WoW when AoC or a better MMo comes out tho.
As i said in my previous post, LoTRO is not a WoW killer but it is not that bad if you like the Tolkien sagas and history. I have no doubt it will be around for a while but it will be a niche MMO which is fine by me.
Plus the reduced pricing is nice if you can get it... :)
 
Update, just got it yesterday, got to play it a little this morning.

So far it seems great! Just have to remap some keys, and get used to the whole different quest thing.
 
You guys are saying that it is "not bad" but definitely not a "WoW killer". Well, think about it, in my opinion, If I pay monthly fee for something...it better be fuckin terrific, if LOTRO is not going to deliver, what is the point? Plus don't you think that WoW wants to stay ahead and that they will add a ton of new features into the game? Including maybe some DX10 gfx later down the road?
 
Exactly what he said. Having the collision like you would in FPS would not work in MMO, simply because there are more people in a small, confined area. And if dead bodies would actually blo9ck path, that would lead to noobs blocking off areas and such. I could see it being nice in the FPS, but that is about it, for now at least. Right now you may think it is stupid, but once you play an MMO few months, you will appricaite that feature.

Those sound like problems that can be overcome by a sufficiently clever developer.

I think I'll just wait on such a game. Plenty of great single-player (or multiplayer, but not MMO) RPGs have it, so...I am fine sticking with them for now.

Thanks for the info, anyway!
 
The game is great... imo.. the environment is stunning, for an MMO, nearing Oblivion levels of IQ when you have everything turned on.. especially in the Shire and in Bree! Some of the areas are sort of more sparcely decorated.. anyways, they've done a tremendous job of creating sort of living replica of middle earth, well a section of it, for now.. I have run all over the current explorable area (while in beta) and it's very well done..

The combat system seems a little bit repetitive, but I have always felt that way with mmo games.. the economy might need a little tuning, I think.. but it's better than it was in beta.. I run a little more lean in the pocket book than I would want to, but I have yet to run out of money.. repairing items used to cost way too much.. that has been changed.. thank goodness.. but seems like to me more loot $ should be dropped when farming.. anyways..

crafting is very cool.. just starting to get into that.. there are many professions to choose from.. it's funny to crest a hilltop on Staddle and see all of these farmer apprentices tossing seed on the ground in the moonlight.. hehe.. Staddle is one of my favorite parts of the game for some reason.. I guess I am just a small town type d00d.. ;) anyways.. I have screenshots at home, but there are some in the LOTRO forums in the Postcards from Middle Earth section... but I think the forum is down for maintenance.. should be back soon. I reckon.. but as I said.. the game is gorgeous and fun.. the sarter areas for elves sort of sucks tho.. well, just sort of lack-luster.. I enjoy the starter area for hobbits and humans the most.. I have not tried a dwarf yet..
 
doh.. srry dble post.. but I do have some pics.. not the best, but this is all I have on photobucket

lotro1.jpg

lotro2.jpg

lotro3.jpg
 
I'm still scratching my head - you went from Level 16 to Level 50 in no time flat? :confused:
 
Back
Top