ZDNet Editorial: Blu-ray is Dead

Blu-Ray is just to damn expensive. Old re released movies for $25.99 are they NUTS!!! I miss HD-DVD & competition.

That is too expensive, but I have no idea where you are paying that much. I generally pay $15-$18 for catalog Blu Ray rereleases. You can find them pretty easily on Amazon or discount websites. If you're buying at a brick and mortar store then I guess it would be harder, plus you'd be paying sales tax on top.
 
The only thing more asinine would be for BR to FAIL because they can't compete with standard DVD because BR has priced themselves out of the market

How are they doing that if BD content and players are dropping in price far faster than DVD did when it was introduced... Are you saying if it isn't adopted fast enough it's simply gonna cease to exist? That won't happen if they're making some profit off early adopters and enthusiasts.

However, Steve's argument of achieving mass adoption by selling at a loss could have the opposite effect if the market's ignorance or indifference doesn't move the product even if it were priced equal to DVD... It's a double edged sword.
 
http://www.soundandvisionmag.com/bluray/3000/blu-ray-2008-the-studio-report-card.html

This is why I won't buy into Blu-Ray.

And until there is a set standard as to what is acceptable as high-def for BD, that no studio can get out of doing for ALL their movies they want to put on BD, screw it. Why should I pay the extra money for a high def format disc when the actual movie is not in high def? Not surprisingly Sony is the only one who shines out of the bunch. But that doesn't mean they're setting a standard.
 
How are they doing that if BD content and players are dropping in price far faster than DVD did when it was introduced... Are you saying if it isn't adopted fast enough it's simply gonna cease to exist? That won't happen if they're making some profit off early adopters and enthusiasts.

However, Steve's argument of achieving mass adoption by selling at a loss could have the opposite effect if the market's ignorance or indifference doesn't move the product even if it were priced equal to DVD... It's a double edged sword.

Pretty much. Lower prices won't drive people from DVD to Blu Ray, simply because they don't care, and if you're going to price it low enough for people to care, well, you have absolutely no business running things because racing for the bottom is how businesses are murdered.
 
It took years for all the 'cattle' to migrate to DVD, and there's no change from that plan with Blu-Ray other than the adoption rate is rather quick compared to DVDs' adoption rate at the same age of the format.

Bottom line: Buy if you want to. Don't buy it if you don't want to. Those of us that do, will enjoy it. Those that don't will miss out. Period.
 
Movies for me are usually an impulse buy. That means pulling it off the shelf at a brick and mortar. Most new releases I've seen on Bluray are about $25 with average prices between $20 and $30 depending on the title's age and extra content. Sure Amazon may be cheaper but I am rarely patient enough for mail order. Until Bluray's library of titles and pricing falls more inline with DVD at the brick and mortars they will have a tough time of it. That doesn't even account for the massive market saturation DVD already enjoys.

Digital downloads? My connection speeds are crap. Sure a download starts fairly quick but within a minute or two the connection speed has crept down to "I guess I'll go clean the house/garage/yard while this downloads." The only "download service" I've used that's worth a damn is my On Demand and the free HD movies on that service. I don't have a DVR so paying for the movies that aren't free doesn't make sense either. +1 for physical media - I don't like paying for things I won't own outright.
 
I will also say that I have a 42" tv and a PS3 that I do buy Blurays for. I notice a difference and my viewing distance is 8 feet.

With the price of Blurays vs. dvd I just buy less movies - my overall movie budget is the same amount.
 
Strangely, theres a lot of people out there who have 50" screens with 1080p and still refuse to go Bluray and insist on a good dvd player with upconverting.

And really, the quality on an upconverted DVD is quite good. Bluray doesn't exactly blow you away like its another century or even "next gen" video hardware; in some cases DVD and BRD are practically indestinguishable. It was a bit of a letdown. There are definitely some great titles out there, but the support for bluray in the market is still weak because of all the sdtv's and even hdtv's under 50" floating around.

BluRay was an intense let-down, seems like 1080P is just a title and nothing else.
 
Sony will wait until mid next year to make any major decreases in price. They will ride the wave of the broadcast change over to HD signals and when the big serge for HD TV’s goes ballistic (big drop in HD TV’s prices) they will and the Studios will drop their products in price.
 
Sony will wait until mid next year to make any major decreases in price. They will ride the wave of the broadcast change over to HD signals and when the big serge for HD TV’s goes ballistic (big drop in HD TV’s prices) they will and the Studios will drop their products in price.

$200 players have been available for over a month. 2 for 1 deals on movies have been common ever since the format came out. Expect this to kick into overdrive during the holidays.

I don't think you have to wait till next year. ;)
 
$200 players have been available for over a month. 2 for 1 deals on movies have been common ever since the format came out. Expect this to kick into overdrive during the holidays.

I don't think you have to wait till next year. ;)

$200 players are still a joke when you can buy a decent $50 DVD player online.

In comparison- yes- much cheaper than original. But still not where it needs to be.

It's like the gas prices right now. Hit over $4/gal here. Now all of a sudden it's $1.97 in places, and we think this is a freaking STEAL OF A DEAL... But I remember when this first started folks were saying if it hit $2, nobody would drive anywhere.

Point being: We're used to these high prices that a $200 player (Or $2 gas) seems like a steal, when it's not.
 
$200 players are still a joke when you can buy a decent $50 DVD player online.

In comparison- yes- much cheaper than original. But still not where it needs to be.

As I've said before, I think BR will be stuck as a niche format for enthusiasts. DVD will stick around because it is "good enough" for the majority of people who don't care about image quality. On top of that, convenience trumps quality, which is why I believe HD downloads will eventually prevail as the dominant format over BR.

All that said, if you are a video enthusiast that is strapped for cash but want to jump into the best quality possible (like I was 10+ years ago), now is not a bad time. I bought Laserdiscs when I was in high school and college as a poor film student, those were rough times as those things cost $40-$120 depending on the release (special edition, CAV or CLV laserdisc, etc). And the players, phew, forget it...

Also keep in mind that Blu Ray is already cheaper across the board (media, set-top players, PC drives and burners) than DVD was in the same amount of time. DVD came out in late 1996, and by 1998 it was still much more expensive than Blu Ray (which coincidentally came out in 2006) is at this point. Again, I don't think Blu Ray will dominate over DVD, but if we are comparing prices from a historical standpoint it really isn't such a bad thing. Combine all that with the huge leap in quality you get over anything else out there, I'm not complaining.
 
As I've said before, I think BR will be stuck as a niche format for enthusiasts. DVD will stick around because it is "good enough" for the majority of people who don't care about image quality. On top of that, convenience trumps quality, which is why I believe HD downloads will eventually prevail as the dominant format over BR.

All that said, if you are a video enthusiast that is strapped for cash but want to jump into the best quality possible (like I was 10+ years ago), now is not a bad time. I bought Laserdiscs when I was in high school and college as a poor film student, those were rough times as those things cost $40-$120 depending on the release (special edition, CAV or CLV laserdisc, etc). And the players, phew, forget it...

Also keep in mind that Blu Ray is already cheaper across the board (media, set-top players, PC drives and burners) than DVD was in the same amount of time. DVD came out in late 1996, and by 1998 it was still much more expensive than Blu Ray (which coincidentally came out in 2006) is at this point. Again, I don't think Blu Ray will dominate over DVD, but if we are comparing prices from a historical standpoint it really isn't such a bad thing. Combine all that with the huge leap in quality you get over anything else out there, I'm not complaining.

You could have said the same thing about VHS and DVD. And it's not that convenient to wait 3+ hours for a movie to download when you can run up to Blockbuster and have it in 15 minutes. HD downloads won't become popular until we start getting a lot more people beyond 1.5Mbps DSL at $40 a month.
 
Good thing BD movies arent 30$ a title then eh? The misinformation that still exists still blows my mind.

Uhm no, most BD movies in retail stores, especially new releases are over 30.00. Matrix trilogy is 100.00, Transformers is 35.00 as well as many newer releases, most are 24-30 dollars, with some older movies being in the 15-20 dollar range.

Sure I can go shop for them online and find them cheaper in some places, but the fact remains that most brick and mortar stores are carrying BD movies in the 25-35 dollar range.
 
ryan - That's a good point, perhaps I'm too bearish on physical media. My own experience with HD downloads is limited to free offers on both XBox Live and iTunes. In both cases, downloading was fast and I was able to start viewing very quickly without buffering interrupting anything, within minutes (I'm currently on a 1.5Mbps DSL line). My experience in both cases from a convenience standpoint was very positive. My experience from a quality standpoint was less positive, but then again I'm the guy that can't stand DVDs. At least I recognize that I'm in a minority there. :)

I have no solid figures on this but I'd love to know what the correlation is between people who have HD sets and broadband internet is. Its only an assumption but I'd guess that most people that have HD also have broadband internet. If that is the case, then I see no reason why HD download won't be able to leapfrog Blu Ray in acceptance (again assuming that convenience trumps image quality), but we'll see.
 
Strangely, theres a lot of people out there who have 50" screens with 1080p and still refuse to go Bluray and insist on a good dvd player with upconverting.

And really, the quality on an upconverted DVD is quite good. Bluray doesn't exactly blow you away like its another century or even "next gen" video hardware; in some cases DVD and BRD are practically indestinguishable. It was a bit of a letdown. There are definitely some great titles out there, but the support for bluray in the market is still weak because of all the sdtv's and even hdtv's under 50" floating around.

Actually could not disagree with you more here. We have two tv's capable of true HD output and on either (Pioneer Elite Pro 739 62" RP or the PRO-151FD) tv blu-ray is by FAR better looking. I obviously can't speak for anyone else or their setup but the HDMI from blu to our tv's in true HD is ridiculous. Artifacting is almost non-existent in all but the fastest filmed shows and the sound is obviously nuts.

In my mind upconverting is just doing what DIVX does now at a slightly higher level, and remember we all had this same conversation concerning data and picture when DVD came out as well, plenty of people said it was not "that" much better than VHS and look where we are now.
 
Well said! I feel exactly the same.

I have a 30" 16:9 hdtv that is a tube. It works great. I actually got rid of my 37" westinghouse due to no CC available on it. Not all dvd's come with English subtitles. PROGRESSIVE scan never works for subtitles. I've never seen it discussed, but the fact is:

$200+ for a movie player = LOSE (if it was $200 & played ps3 games, maybe...)
$30 for a movie = LOSE
Having to blow another $1500+ on a new tv to see the difference = BIG LOSE

Anyone know if all Blu-Ray discs have english subtitles or CC? If they don't they are useless to me as I need to read subitles/cc in order to understand movies.
I have a laptop for that purpose via HDMI which if there isn't subtitles with a show, I'm able to download the subtitles at any of the subtitle sites if they have them, open the movie in TheKMPlayer, load subtitles, sync properly using [ or ] and watch away.
 
As I've said before, I think BR will be stuck as a niche format for enthusiasts. DVD will stick around because it is "good enough" for the majority of people who don't care about image quality.
Exactly. Don't say that too loud around the BR fanboys because it's better than sliced bread though :rolleyes:
Fact of the matter is your average person either A) can't tell the difference unless the TV is bigger than 50" or B) doesn't have a TV that would give an advantage anyway.

Upscaling DVD player on a 42" screen side by side with a BR player on a 42" screen you really cannot tell the difference. If you stand there a long time and LOOK for differences, sure.

On top of that, convenience trumps quality, which is why I believe HD downloads will eventually prevail as the dominant format over BR.
No, they won't.
Over 50% of America is still on dial up.

Physical media is here to stay. No downloading time.

I think we might start seeing something like flash drive format, but not downloads for quite some time yet. America's broadband situation STINKS.
 
Upscaling DVD player on a 42" screen side by side with a BR player on a 42" screen you really cannot tell the difference. If you stand there a long time and LOOK for differences, sure.

Come to my house and I guarantee you'll be able to tell the difference on my 42" screen in less than a second...

So many ill-informed people, even on this "enthusiast" board...crazy. :rolleyes:
 
I use a Playstation 3, and a 46" Samsung 650 series LCD. I pretty much can't stand to watch a non Bluray movie anymore. When Netflix send a non Bluray movie, I cringe. If you think you can't tell the difference then you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about, or you've never really seen a decent setup. You simply can't take a lousy picture and make it look better. It's a basic rule of video production. Upscaling looks slightly better than 480i on certain DVD players, but it doesn't compare to Bluray.

As to the article - I'm pretty sure the author needs to put HIS crack pipe down. I bet he was saying the same thing when DVD's came out.
 
just a note on the whole "upconverted DVDs look almost as good..." issue.. I watch a lot of both HD DVDs and SD DVDs on my Tosh HD-A30 (going to an Olevia 747i) and some SD DVDs do look really nice when upconverted, but it varies from DVD to DVD... just like some HD DVDs look better than others... but the worst looking HD DVD I have still looks better than the best looking SD DVD I have when upconverted.. I think it's pretty obvious when you compare the two back to back that HD DVD and BluRay's IQ is superior to that of SD DVDs when viewed on a large 1080i/p panel.. but is it worth making the switch to the avg consumer? I am thinking not... but to the enthusiast, yes...
 
I think that misinformation on upconverting along with people still being confused what HD is keeps holding back Blu Ray. The general consensus my older family members (50s) reached at the Labor Day BBQ was that a new DVD player + new flatscreen = HD movies! As long as their new TV says its getting a 720p or 1080p signal, they think that is as good as it gets. Very hard to change the minds of people like that,, I tried...
 
I think that misinformation on upconverting along with people still being confused what HD is keeps holding back Blu Ray. The general consensus my older family members (50s) reached at the Labor Day BBQ was that a new DVD player + new flatscreen = HD movies! As long as their new TV says its getting a 720p or 1080p signal, they think that is as good as it gets. Very hard to change the minds of people like that,, I tried...

QFT. however, when you do buy a flatscreen and still use dvd's, youre upconverting that into a better picture then it once was- so to many people that is a significant improvement. the way i see it, any tv smaller then a 42" really doesnt need bluray. we just installed 32" flatscreens in a stadium and it wasn't that easy to tell if they were on hd channels or not. its not like computer monitors where you sit right up on them....
 
Actually, yes i would. I dont want to see insane panoramic scenes just film the fucking movie in the common format for televisions already.

The whole reason we dealt with letterbox on 4:3 TVs for the last 30+ years was because we dont want to miss anything like you said. So we go and make 16:9 the common format for TVs to get the whole aspect and some artsy fuck decides to undermine the process by making the film even wider so were back to square 1.

I dont like it and i know im not alone. I didnt buy a widescreen HDTV to go back to watching movies that only use 2/3 of my screen.

On the one hand, I couldn't agree with you more. On the other...Movies were made in the wider format before we all had 16:9 TVs so it's not like some vast conspiracy against consumers.

Either way i would rather have a 16:9 disc. 16:9 is wide enough.
 
Back
Top