You’ll Never Upload Your Mind Into A Computer

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I'm not saying we'll see this in our lifetime but listing reasons why it will never happen seems goofy. I'm sure cavemen probably thought TV, computers, airplanes, etc. would never happen either.

Many futurists predict that one day we'll upload our minds into computers, where we'll romp around in virtual reality environments. That's possible — but there are still a number of thorny issues to consider. Here are eight reasons why your brain may never be digitized.
 
I would argue that some variation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle would come into play ... although I think we will eventually figure out a way to replicate the functions of a human mind I would argue that there are likely to be many electrochemical processes occurring in the brain that it might be impossible to replicate them all without error

The true test will be cloning anyway since we will have the capability to do that before we can replicate the full function of a human brain (probably) ... we have yet to produce a human clone ... if a human clone actually has all the memories and personality of the person cloned then we can argue that the human mind is mechanical enough to replicate or copy ... if we get a copy that has biological life but isn't human in any capacity then we might have to consider the human mind isn't something we fully understand ;)
 
I just want to be able to make a backup, so if something happens to me they can grow a clone and just restore my backup. :)
 
I would argue that some variation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle would come into play ...

Count on it.

Season_4_-_Heisenberg.jpg
 
If we could make a perfect copy of a human mind, would that copy then be considered a living consciousness, the deleting of which would amount to murder?
 
Through the first half of the article I thought..."there's gotta be a blond joke in here somewhere"

Through the entire article I was thinking about The Lawnmower Man and Tron.

It's interesting to think about the idea and technology is certainly advancing in all kinds of ways that make "wetware" a real possibility. It could not happen with off-the-shelf components. But it does lead to certain questions:

1) How much harddrive space would be required?
2) How fast would the processor need to be?
3) What OS would be required before the upload could take place?

Then there is:
1) What happens to the body after the upload? does it die? or does it become a vegetable in a coma?
2) IF - big IF - you could successfully transmit your thoughts, feelings, identity, your very soul into a computer and out of the body...once we have become smart enough to do this, doesn't that automatically mean we wouldn't even need the "computer" anymore? does this then provide all the proof that anyone would ever need to believe that there is no God?

There are far too many insane dictators in this world for me to think about how the entire human race could be wiped out in a nanosecond via such things. Sci-fi is cool and it's fun to fantasize about all kinds of things but this is truly scary to think that it could so easily end up in the wrong hands; and just who is the right hands?
 
Pretty lame article. "X can't happen because we don't understand how it could happen". The whole article seems to gloss over future tech. Pray tell, what happens when we have quantum computers which simulate all physical interactions which occur in a human mind, at the atomic level, faster than the human mind functions in 'reality'?
 
If we could make a perfect copy of a human mind, would that copy then be considered a living consciousness, the deleting of which would amount to murder?

Technically, it would be an individuals...intellectual property. bwahahaha
 
I'm sure you're right. I won't upload my brain onto a computer.

But does that mean someone else down the road/time will never be able to? Definitely not. We've advanced so much in such a short amount of time that I'm sure it'll be possible. New advances in science and mathematics will bring about new ways to do things.

A lot of the future world relies on our ability to get along with each other - if one of the many other ways we can get knocked off, doesn't happen first!
 
Makes me think of The Ghost Brigades by John Scalzi. They succeeded in uploading a consciousness imprint, but without memories it didn't run as expected. Only when those memories were recreated could the mind mirror the previous thinker's.
 
Makes me think of The Ghost Brigades by John Scalzi. They succeeded in uploading a consciousness imprint, but without memories it didn't run as expected. Only when those memories were recreated could the mind mirror the previous thinker's.

And he was able to remember to return that library book. Thank goodness.
 
http://www.goingfaster.com/term2029/ascensionp1.html

Although its fiction, I think the approach of neural net code in this piece is how a 'true AI' will emerge. Its code, but even proprietary code will need the right hardware. I don't think silicon will support it; it will have to be some different type of construction. Also, I don't think the Heisenberg principle applies here exactly; its mostly applied to quantum physics, (e.g. teleportation) not digital code, unless - to be fair to your statement, it applies to the quantum physics within the hardware. I could be wrong tho.
 
http://www.goingfaster.com/term2029/ascensionp1.html

Although its fiction, I think the approach of neural net code in this piece is how a 'true AI' will emerge. Its code, but even proprietary code will need the right hardware. I don't think silicon will support it; it will have to be some different type of construction. Also, I don't think the Heisenberg principle applies here exactly; its mostly applied to quantum physics, (e.g. teleportation) not digital code, unless - to be fair to your statement, it applies to the quantum physics within the hardware. I could be wrong tho.

I was thinking of it in the ability to exactly copy a living mind in its entirety ... I suspect there might be sufficient complexity there that you would run into the Uncertainty Principle in trying to make an exact nerve for nerve/memory for memory/personality for personality copy

I don't think it would prevent us from eventually creating a mind of equivalent complexity or maybe even superior capability but copying the essence of my specific personality might not be possible due to the Uncertainty principle ... in my opinion :cool:
 
i'd see this happening if flash storage got much more durable and reliable....don't see it happening on a mechanical system

then again do we really need a real life glados lol :)
 
I just want to be able to make a backup, so if something happens to me they can grow a clone and just restore my backup. :)

Don't forget leaving a note for your backup that says "Btw, if you are reading this, X was a REALLY BAD IDEA!
 
Through the first half of the article I thought..."there's gotta be a blond joke in here somewhere"

Through the entire article I was thinking about The Lawnmower Man and Tron.

It's interesting to think about the idea and technology is certainly advancing in all kinds of ways that make "wetware" a real possibility. It could not happen with off-the-shelf components. But it does lead to certain questions:

1) How much harddrive space would be required?
2) How fast would the processor need to be?
3) What OS would be required before the upload could take place?

And...would I be smarter if I water cooled myself?
 

This always makes me wonder how people can claim 'the brain is an unimaginably powerful! computer with near infinite resolution from your eyes! and computers couldn't even process the data from our eyes.' Yet, it runs fairly-slowly in terms of clocks per cycle...

Even if theres 'billions' of cells...if they are only running at 40hz... and data from your eyes are being collected at "5,000 frames" per second, it seems like a lot of frames would be dropped :D. Maybe that's why when you move your hand moderately-fast infront of your eyes, it begins to blur. Seems to be modern-day cameras can pickup 'motion' hundreds of times better than our eyes. Like a Cannon camera can keep its shutter open for 1/40,000th of a second to capture pretty-accurate details of an object moving at 100s of km an hour while our eyes just see a blur pass in front. Even then, the fastest we can react if we are a trained professional boxer to an 'incoming object' like a fist is around 1/16th of a second.

Seems pretty even compared to how fast a computer could anaylze data and react given the right hardware like an reacting to a series of images being transfered from a SSD to Cache located near a processor. Give us 20 years of advancement and PCs reaction time will be much more advanced. Since it has a program military application, its probably already in the military's budget/works to make some kind of automated gun that responds to sensory input for laser-based counter-measures, etc. North Korean jet fires rocket? rocket explodes 0.2sec later right infront of jet throwing scrapnel through North Korean jet's window... assuming the Jet didn't crash on the runway. :D
 
IF - big IF - you could successfully transmit your thoughts, feelings, identity, your very soul into a computer and out of the body...once we have become smart enough to do this, doesn't that automatically mean we wouldn't even need the "computer" anymore? does this then provide all the proof that anyone would ever need to believe that there is no God?

Wouldn't prove anything, since how would you upload your soul?

Uploading a brain without a soul may finally give us skynet :)
 
This always makes me wonder how people can claim 'the brain is an unimaginably powerful! computer with near infinite resolution from your eyes! and computers couldn't even process the data from our eyes.' Yet, it runs fairly-slowly in terms of clocks per cycle...

Even if theres 'billions' of cells...if they are only running at 40hz... and data from your eyes are being collected at "5,000 frames" per second, it seems like a lot of frames would be dropped :D. Maybe that's why when you move your hand moderately-fast infront of your eyes, it begins to blur. Seems to be modern-day cameras can pickup 'motion' hundreds of times better than our eyes. Like a Cannon camera can keep its shutter open for 1/40,000th of a second to capture pretty-accurate details of an object moving at 100s of km an hour while our eyes just see a blur pass in front. Even then, the fastest we can react if we are a trained professional boxer to an 'incoming object' like a fist is around 1/16th of a second.

Seems pretty even compared to how fast a computer could anaylze data and react given the right hardware like an reacting to a series of images being transfered from a SSD to Cache located near a processor. Give us 20 years of advancement and PCs reaction time will be much more advanced. Since it has a program military application, its probably already in the military's budget/works to make some kind of automated gun that responds to sensory input for laser-based counter-measures, etc. North Korean jet fires rocket? rocket explodes 0.2sec later right infront of jet throwing scrapnel through North Korean jet's window... assuming the Jet didn't crash on the runway. :D

You're confusing speed with throughput, a 32-core system running at 2GHz an process a ton more raw data than a 4-core system running at 4GHz. Our brains may not be able to react to the faster events that a single purpose device can, but those single purpose devices don't have to handle 600,000 different operations (hearing, seeing, hormonal control, digestion, ... ... ..)



As for uploading our minds to a computer, not something I will EVER do. There's absolutely no way to prove that what ends up in the computer is in fact "me" or just a copy. Afterall transferring a file across the internet doesn't actually move the physical electrons that made up that file, it only copies the information represented by those electrons. The same goes for teleportation, at least for the "break you down and rebuild you" implementations..
 
Point 7 is the big roadblock for me.

As Steve said pretty much all of the technological constraints could possibly be overcome with engineering we simply haven't conceived of yet, but is it actually you on the other side of the upload would be the thing for me.

My current position would be "no", you are duplicating not transferring.

Certainly what lived on the machine would believe it was you and fell like it was you (assuming equivalence of the experience of consciousness) and probably be indistinguishable to other people who know/knew you. But it's not actually you, it's a copy, you die with the meat.

This is a jump, but I suspect many of the people who think "you" can be uploaded to a computer, rather than what amounts to a complex simulation of you, also on some level believe in a "soul" and differentiate their identity from the collection of fats and proteins and chemical reactions that embodies everything we are, do and think.

Further though, whenever I think on this I inevitably come around to feel like even that doesn't matter, because really, we don't actually have true continuous consciousness anyway, it's pretty much an illusion.
Because of the constant cycle of cell death and replication we are literally a different person from one moment to the next anyway, we are in a constant state of having our matter uploaded to new mechanics, including our brain/neurons.
There are no cells in your body that existed 10 years ago, you are simply a copy of that guy/gal, forged through cell replication.
 
Point 7 is the big roadblock for me.

As Steve said pretty much all of the technological constraints could possibly be overcome with engineering we simply haven't conceived of yet, but is it actually you on the other side of the upload would be the thing for me.

My current position would be "no", you are duplicating not transferring.

Certainly what lived on the machine would believe it was you and fell like it was you (assuming equivalence of the experience of consciousness) and probably be indistinguishable to other people who know/knew you. But it's not actually you, it's a copy, you die with the meat.

This is a jump, but I suspect many of the people who think "you" can be uploaded to a computer, rather than what amounts to a complex simulation of you, also on some level believe in a "soul" and differentiate their identity from the collection of fats and proteins and chemical reactions that embodies everything we are, do and think.

Further though, whenever I think on this I inevitably come around to feel like even that doesn't matter, because really, we don't actually have true continuous consciousness anyway, it's pretty much an illusion.
Because of the constant cycle of cell death and replication we are literally a different person from one moment to the next anyway, we are in a constant state of having our matter uploaded to new mechanics, including our brain/neurons.
There are no cells in your body that existed 10 years ago, you are simply a copy of that guy/gal, forged through cell replication.


The test can be carried even one step further: aliens stop time (bare with me, this is a philosophical thought experiment) come to your room while you are sleeping, make a complete copy of you, take your original body, kill you, and put the copy in the exact same place and let it continue sleeping and live out its life.

Is that you? When that copy opens its eyes is it as if you are opening your eyes?

Is there something special about your consciousness that somehow they have failed to copy it by simply copying all of particles and energies of our universe? What does consciousness mean?

I agree with you, your body can be thought of as a copy of itself from the past. But I believe a true copy of you is no different then yourself. I do not believe in any soul or spirit.
 
The test can be carried even one step further: aliens stop time (bare with me, this is a philosophical thought experiment) come to your room while you are sleeping, make a complete copy of you, take your original body, kill you, and put the copy in the exact same place and let it continue sleeping and live out its life.

Is that you? When that copy opens its eyes is it as if you are opening your eyes?

Is there something special about your consciousness that somehow they have failed to copy it by simply copying all of particles and energies of our universe? What does consciousness mean?

I agree with you, your body can be thought of as a copy of itself from the past. But I believe a true copy of you is no different then yourself. I do not believe in any soul or spirit.

Separating out the entire soul argument which is impossible to prove or disprove ... even the mechanical elements of copying a specific person are problematic ... assuming that we (as unique individuals) are just the sum of a billion billion billion atoms all arranged in a very precise pattern ... the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle implies we could never arrange an exact copy of all those atoms in precisely the same locations since it is impossible to make the exact measurements to do that ... also, there is no guarantee that the paths of those atoms would continue in the same trajectory as their originals (creating at best a temporary twin but not a continuing copy) ;)
 
My current position would be "no", you are duplicating not transferring.

When I heard people mention this, I can't help but think... if I upload a photo to 'generic image sharing site.com', whether the original photo still exists or is destroyed(deleted) after uploading completes, I've still uploaded the data.

The article and headline states "You'll never upload your mind into a computer". I disagree and think from a technological standpoint you'll be able to duplicate your 'data' in digital-form and whether the original is destroyed in the process is a bit inconsequential to the issue of whether it can be done. It will definitely as you say be a duplication and not a 'transferrence. However,' by definition of what it means to upload something -- an upload occurs when the data 'appears' in the new location regardless of what happens to the data at the old location. Only if the data at the new location is corrupt, out of order, or did not appear or is 'lost' would one generally say the upload 'failed'.

One interesting idea though with uploading your data into digital form is ... from a consumer entertainment standpoint. Our 'biological' essence of us only has 80 years or so. 60 or so if you don't count time spent eating, sleeping, urinating, showering, etc. Who wants to waste time listening to music or watching moives/tv you won't like or even 'love' :D. Feed it through Techno-You and Techo-You can finish enjoying the content in 30seconds to tell you if the movie was enjoyable or not :p or give you a x/10 rating you'd agree with :D

I think that kind of idea is intellectually neat.
 
This always makes me wonder how people can claim 'the brain is an unimaginably powerful! computer with near infinite resolution from your eyes! and computers couldn't even process the data from our eyes.' Yet, it runs fairly-slowly in terms of clocks per cycle...

Even if theres 'billions' of cells...if they are only running at 40hz... and data from your eyes are being collected at "5,000 frames" per second, it seems like a lot of frames would be dropped :D. Maybe that's why when you move your hand moderately-fast infront of your eyes, it begins to blur. Seems to be modern-day cameras can pickup 'motion' hundreds of times better than our eyes. Like a Cannon camera can keep its shutter open for 1/40,000th of a second to capture pretty-accurate details of an object moving at 100s of km an hour while our eyes just see a blur pass in front. Even then, the fastest we can react if we are a trained professional boxer to an 'incoming object' like a fist is around 1/16th of a second.

Seems pretty even compared to how fast a computer could anaylze data and react given the right hardware like an reacting to a series of images being transfered from a SSD to Cache located near a processor. Give us 20 years of advancement and PCs reaction time will be much more advanced. Since it has a program military application, its probably already in the military's budget/works to make some kind of automated gun that responds to sensory input for laser-based counter-measures, etc. North Korean jet fires rocket? rocket explodes 0.2sec later right infront of jet throwing scrapnel through North Korean jet's window... assuming the Jet didn't crash on the runway. :D

Speed is only part of the equation.

Think of it like this: Say you transport people overseas commercially, would you: A.) Make 400 trips in a two seat airplane to carry one passenger at a time at high speed. -or- B.) Make one trip with 400 passengers in a big slow jumbo jet? The answer is B, as the one trip will take less time moving all the people at once than making 400 trips in the two seater, even though it goes much faster.



The brain does massive parallel processing, as in everything process at the same time. There are no limits to the amounts of threads it processes, so there is no need to run super fast.
 
When I heard people mention this, I can't help but think... if I upload a photo to 'generic image sharing site.com', whether the original photo still exists or is destroyed(deleted) after uploading completes, I've still uploaded the data.

The article and headline states "You'll never upload your mind into a computer". I disagree and think from a technological standpoint you'll be able to duplicate your 'data' in digital-form and whether the original is destroyed in the process is a bit inconsequential to the issue of whether it can be done. It will definitely as you say be a duplication and not a 'transferrence. However,' by definition of what it means to upload something -- an upload occurs when the data 'appears' in the new location regardless of what happens to the data at the old location. Only if the data at the new location is corrupt, out of order, or did not appear or is 'lost' would one generally say the upload 'failed'.

One interesting idea though with uploading your data into digital form is ... from a consumer entertainment standpoint. Our 'biological' essence of us only has 80 years or so. 60 or so if you don't count time spent eating, sleeping, urinating, showering, etc. Who wants to waste time listening to music or watching moives/tv you won't like or even 'love' :D. Feed it through Techno-You and Techo-You can finish enjoying the content in 30seconds to tell you if the movie was enjoyable or not :p or give you a x/10 rating you'd agree with :D

I think that kind of idea is intellectually neat.

What you liked ten years ago, you may not like today, and vice versa. That's because the way you think is shaped by your experiences. Since you and your copy would be experiencing two different sets of events, your copy's tastes will quickly start to deviate from yours.
 
What you liked ten years ago, you may not like today, and vice versa. That's because the way you think is shaped by your experiences. Since you and your copy would be experiencing two different sets of events, your copy's tastes will quickly start to deviate from yours.

Also, it might be hard for us to make some of the more exotic connections that the human brain is capable of ... we have 5 senses to translate our experiences into the memories stored in our main server (brain) ... listening to a favorite song might not just involve the auditory elements but an interaction with something you were touching or smelling or tasting at that moment (a song playing during a tender love making session, for instance) ... the human brain is one of the most complex and powerful machines ever produced ... although we might be able to mimic many of its functions, I think we might find the essence of that machine more difficult to replicate than some might think :cool:
 
Also, it might be hard for us to make some of the more exotic connections that the human brain is capable of ... we have 5 senses to translate our experiences into the memories stored in our main server (brain) ... listening to a favorite song might not just involve the auditory elements but an interaction with something you were touching or smelling or tasting at that moment (a song playing during a tender love making session, for instance) ... the human brain is one of the most complex and powerful machines ever produced ... although we might be able to mimic many of its functions, I think we might find the essence of that machine more difficult to replicate than some might think :cool:

Our senses are just an extension of the electrochemical processes at work inside the brain, which if they can be imitated, then the entire human experience would be attainable for a virtual human (a la The Matrix).
 
Our senses are just an extension of the electrochemical processes at work inside the brain, which if they can be imitated, then the entire human experience would be attainable for a virtual human (a la The Matrix).

I'm just saying there might be a fractal quality to it ... the brain uses very fuzzy logic sometimes (kind of like the joke t-shirt, "Just because I have ADHD doesn't mean ... oh look, a squirrel") and although we might be able to simulate it, it might be tough to replicate it exactly since trying to program in all the possible triggers and paths might strain the largely linear and logical world of the computer ... maybe the brain is the ultimate transcendental number :D
 
Back
Top