XBOX360 Revealed: Implications for R520?

Lorien said:
Err the 2 companies have different policies with regards to letting their employees speak about released/unreleased products. Take a guess which one is more friendly/open to the community?

I've had first-hand experience with how 'open' those ATi employees can be yes.
I was the one who pointed out that 3Dc would not work in 3DMark05 because of the bumpmap antialiasing method they used (which happened to be described in an NVIDIA paper), despite ATi saying in public that 3DMark05 would benefit from 3Dc (and ATi knew the 3DMark05 algo, because they were involved in the development, and advised against using 3Dc).

At first I received a very rude and threatening private message from one of those 'open' ATi employees, and eventually I got banned from Beyond3D altogether. Yes, I'm glad the ATi people are so friendly/open to the community.
The irony of this all is that I actually owned a Radeon at the time, and still do... Last GeForce I had was a GF2GTS... So yes, they turn against their own customers.
 
There's 2 sides tro every story and i'll leave it at that.
Anyways what does this contribute/have to do with the discussion currently going on? Actually nvm i can see where this will escalate once the usual suspects(f_an_bois) start popping out. Have fun :)
 
Lorien said:
There's 2 sides tro every story and i'll leave it at that.
Anyways what does this contribute/have to do with the discussion currently going on? Actually nvm i can see where this will escalate once the usual suspects(f_an_bois) start popping out. Have fun :)

Hey, you brought the issue up, I'm just telling you the downside of ATi employees on a forum.
I think it's pretty nasty to have your own customers silenced on an internet forum, just because they prove that some of your public statements are ... lies.
At least NVIDIA doesn't try to limit their customers' freedom of speech, and limits itself to official statements only, through their own channels.

Why are you trying to poke in this forum anyway?
 
FanATIc said:
please, for god sake someone find any official post saying this. I cannot BELIEVE that this is so actively believed. Its been said right from the announce of he R520 series its a completely new core. So someone find where its yet another extension please.
Go find it yourself, they have a search function in their forum, it’s not hard...

First, why should we trust you more than the people over at B3D? As Lorien said there are a lot of forum members over there that are in the business, both hardware and software developers.

And secondly you say "Its been said right from the announce of he R520 series its a completely new core", who said that?! ATI sure didn't. ATI hasn’t said anything officially. It’s all just speculations...
 
The B3D crowd on average has the highest level of industry knowledge / technical understanding and lowest level of rampant fanb0yism of all popular forums. Period.

IMO there is a somewhat noticeable ATI slant there and I've been on the receiving end of some serious hypocrisy regarding which users are 'moderated' but it is not all that bad and it's a small price to pay for the wealth of knowledge that you gain. Most other forums are rife with bickering about some Inq article or rampant uninformed speculation. There is a bit of that at B3D too but there is also a lot of substance and it is the best place to be if you are actually interested in learning something about real-time 3D rendering.

Sorry for the OT. What was this thread about again?
 
mjannusch said:
Wrong.

1080i = 1920x540 per field, for a per-frame resolution of 1920x1080. Regardless, the video card needs to draw a full 1920x1080 frame for each complete frame.
I don't get it.

I mean, surely most home televisions that the Xbox360 will be played on cannot support such a rediculously high resolution. So the console must be able to scale its resolution depending on what kind of tv its being played on. But how would a console be able to know what the television is capable of? Also, if the XBox360 is being played on a smaller television that can't support 1080i (and suppose it drops down to a lower resolution), will it be able render out more fps?
 
GVX said:
I don't get it.

I mean, surely most home televisions that the Xbox360 will be played on cannot support such a rediculously high resolution. So the console must be able to scale its resolution depending on what kind of tv its being played on. But how would a console be able to know what the television is capable of? Also, if the XBox360 is being played on a smaller television that can't support 1080i (and suppose it drops down to a lower resolution), will it be able render out more fps?


I'd imagine it would be a setting in the "gamers guide" or whatever they call it. Not having an hdtv myself, I don't know what kind of connectivity requirements 1080i would need, as far as regular component or dvi or even hdmi.

Of course, if you're using the regular composite or svideo jack you'll get PDTV (plain definition). As far as fps, I would believe it *would* be capable of higher fps, but would be limited by refresh rate.
 
trinibwoy said:
The B3D crowd on average has the highest level of industry knowledge / technical understanding and lowest level of rampant fanb0yism of all popular forums. Period.

IMO there is a somewhat noticeable ATI slant there and I've been on the receiving end of some serious hypocrisy regarding which users are 'moderated' but it is not all that bad and it's a small price to pay for the wealth of knowledge that you gain. Most other forums are rife with bickering about some Inq article or rampant uninformed speculation. There is a bit of that at B3D too but there is also a lot of substance and it is the best place to be if you are actually interested in learning something about real-time 3D rendering.

Sorry for the OT. What was this thread about again?

QFT...there's a lot of experience over there...however, they are human...and behave like dicks on occasion...
 
I'll be buying the Nintendo Revolution.

Mario/Link/Samus Aran >>>>>>> Master Chief and the guy from GTA.
 
Mojo said:
I'll be buying the Nintendo Revolution.

Mario/Link/Samus Aran >>>>>>> Master Chief and the guy from GTA.

AGREED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I think they should just hardwire a pentium 4 chip or an AMD FX-55 directly to the gpu. This way we get a clock speed of 3.2ghz or 2.6ghz.
 
S_Z said:
Go find it yourself, they have a search function in their forum, it’s not hard...

First, why should we trust you more than the people over at B3D? As Lorien said there are a lot of forum members over there that are in the business, both hardware and software developers.

And secondly you say "Its been said right from the announce of he R520 series its a completely new core", who said that?! ATI sure didn't. ATI hasn’t said anything officially. It’s all just speculations...

Correct, ATI hasnt even acknowledged the core officially other then saying it will be at the show, and Fudo, yes, Fudo, that came out "officially" like 1 month ago. So what makes you so sure of what you are saying about the core? Everything i have posted has no official link that i can post, correct, but i'll trust it. And because i do trust it, it shows absolutly no sence what so ever on ATI's part to lead it to the R420 or R300. To me it most certainly looks like serious dedication to a long term core. What do you see? I'll tell you what i see, if ATI does what you say, they're screwed. The R420 resources tapped the limit to the R300.

New types of pipes, double the transistors, advanced TSMC fab process, new floating point support, new shader support, beginning support for longhorn, 32 supportable pixel pipelines, support for next generation graphic ram and up to levels of 1024MB of it.....yea that sounds like a refresh to me.

Something you dont understand is that graphic cards cannot simply increase in raw speed, mhz. They must do it elseware. The R480 tops out at what 540 stock? You think its a refresh, therefore same WPC, how high you think they can push it for improvment if the R420/R480->R520? 700mhz-1gig? Wont happen for a long time. We'll see pipes get lengthened and WPCs increased, as well as dual cores before we see either company submit to massive mhz raising. The R300->R480 line did its job great, but ATI simply cannot afford to fall back on it again as dedicated as they have. I'd put good money on it.

That being said the R500 truely is a custom core, and technically should have ties to NOTHING ATI does in terms of what they release. The below quote is enough reason for anyone to stop talking about the R600 and R500 together.

When design work started up on the 360, Microsoft decided it needed to own the actual chip designs instead of simply buying chips from suppliers. Microsoft worked with IBM and ATI to architect the CPU and graphics chip for the next Xbox. Since Microsoft owns the chip designs, it can place its own chip orders with the third-party semiconductor foundries that produce the silicon. Microsoft also decides when it's appropriate to move to a smaller manufacturing process, like going from 90nm to 65nm, to reduce costs.
 
to answer a question stated much earlier in this thread

"Why not release this to the consumer market?"

ATI only had to develop this core for a known hardware confiruration, and was able to perform a lot of testing for that platform. They will need to do a LOT of QA before they can start putting it on the store shelves.
 
Its the simple fact that the design is not their's anymore.......

Microsoft hired them to design one hell of a core for the Xbox 360, once it was design it all shifted to MS, for fab and production, fab shrinks and all of that. MS now owns the rights to the R500.
 
GVX said:
I don't get it.

I mean, surely most home televisions that the Xbox360 will be played on cannot support such a rediculously high resolution. So the console must be able to scale its resolution depending on what kind of tv its being played on. But how would a console be able to know what the television is capable of? Also, if the XBox360 is being played on a smaller television that can't support 1080i (and suppose it drops down to a lower resolution), will it be able render out more fps?

For the Xbox, the user set the settings. If you did NOT have a High Definition audio/video cable pack, then you did NOT get any menu selection for 480p, 720p, or 1080i in the Xbox Dashboard. So for those who used the crap composite cables or had s-video, there wasn't even an option for setting those resolutions and the Xbox would default to the standard 4:3 interlaced. There was something in the cables that the Xbox recognized to enable the menu options that brought up the high definition resolutions so they could be enabled, but otherwise they would default to 4:3 480i. I imagine that the Xbox 360 will have to rely on either the current Xbox's system.
 
In regards to the 720p/1080i support vs 480i discussions.

The current rumor mill is stating that the xbox360 content will all be designed around the current widescreen/HD specifications. Meaning that all the games must support a minimum of at least 720p (1280x720) and at most 1080i (1920x1080)

This 'should' mean that when you hook it up via standard composite or s-video cables, cables that aren't capable of passing through an HD feed, that on a non-HD TV, with a standard 4x3 interface, you will be viewing a letterboxed image, just like when you watch a widescreen DVD on a regular TV. Or, for you gamecubers out there, just like when you played Resident Evil 4, with no option to display a standard 4x3 image.

There is potential for the games to support a 4x3 optimized image as well, but that will be up to the developers of each game, or Microsoft if thats something they end up demanding. It should NOT amount to higher framerates in lower resolutions though, as most games now have a frame rate cap on consoles so that no matter what resolution it is displayed in, the frame rate remains the same, regardless of whether you play in 480i, 480p or 720p. Each gamer would receive the same level of performance regardless of monitor capability.

The exception to the rule being multiplayer splitscreen as anyone who's played Halo 2 can account for. :)

and as always, I could be totally wrong.

T
 
Kahnvex said:
In regards to the 720p/1080i support vs 480i discussions.

The current rumor mill is stating that the xbox360 content will all be designed around the current widescreen/HD specifications. Meaning that all the games must support a minimum of at least 720p (1280x720) and at most 1080i (1920x1080)

This 'should' mean that when you hook it up via standard composite or s-video cables, cables that aren't capable of passing through an HD feed, that on a non-HD TV, with a standard 4x3 interface, you will be viewing a letterboxed image, just like when you watch a widescreen DVD on a regular TV. Or, for you gamecubers out there, just like when you played Resident Evil 4, with no option to display a standard 4x3 image.

There is potential for the games to support a 4x3 optimized image as well, but that will be up to the developers of each game, or Microsoft if thats something they end up demanding. It should NOT amount to higher framerates in lower resolutions though, as most games now have a frame rate cap on consoles so that no matter what resolution it is displayed in, the frame rate remains the same, regardless of whether you play in 480i, 480p or 720p. Each gamer would receive the same level of performance regardless of monitor capability.

The exception to the rule being multiplayer splitscreen as anyone who's played Halo 2 can account for. :)

and as always, I could be totally wrong.

T

I would imagine that the chip can support multiple resolutions and so will all the games...I seriously doubt microsoft would put normal tv users out to pasture when the install base is 90% of their customers and it's a very simple matter to support the old resolution...
 
In response to Lorien, I'm not a crapper in any of these H forums, and I do often provide posts that are worthier than many of the forum members. However, I poked my head into this thread to offer what I saw. I was a lurker on the B3D forums once... however, almost everyone there had a certain.... slant... or bias shall I say. They were less objective than they could be, and usually were very strongly opinionated on certain products. While knowledgable they may be, many of their members come off as fan-boys, and that's nothing that you can deny. That's like going to Anand and reading an Intel vs AMD type article. You know what you can expect.
 
FanATIc said:
Correct, ATI hasnt even acknowledged the core officially other then saying it will be at the show, and Fudo, yes, Fudo, that came out "officially" like 1 month ago. So what makes you so sure of what you are saying about the core? Everything i have posted has no official link that i can post, correct, but i'll trust it. And because i do trust it, it shows absolutly no sence what so ever on ATI's part to lead it to the R420 or R300. To me it most certainly looks like serious dedication to a long term core. What do you see? I'll tell you what i see, if ATI does what you say, they're screwed. The R420 resources tapped the limit to the R300.

New types of pipes, double the transistors, advanced TSMC fab process, new floating point support, new shader support, beginning support for longhorn, 32 supportable pixel pipelines, support for next generation graphic ram and up to levels of 1024MB of it.....yea that sounds like a refresh to me.

Something you dont understand is that graphic cards cannot simply increase in raw speed, mhz. They must do it elseware. The R480 tops out at what 540 stock? You think its a refresh, therefore same WPC, how high you think they can push it for improvment if the R420/R480->R520? 700mhz-1gig? Wont happen for a long time. We'll see pipes get lengthened and WPCs increased, as well as dual cores before we see either company submit to massive mhz raising. The R300->R480 line did its job great, but ATI simply cannot afford to fall back on it again as dedicated as they have. I'd put good money on it.

That being said the R500 truely is a custom core, and technically should have ties to NOTHING ATI does in terms of what they release. The below quote is enough reason for anyone to stop talking about the R600 and R500 together.
Listen, I’m not sure of anything concerning the upcoming ATI graphic cores since as I said before it’s just rumors and speculations. But if I was to believe anyone I would rather choose to listen to people like Dave Baumann and company on B3D which I know are very knowledgeable in this area (have been reading that forum for a long time) then some guy that calls himself FanATIc on HardOCPs forum ;)

We just have to wait and see...
 
mastercheeze said:
Nope.

http://electronics.howstuffworks.com/hdtv1.htm

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=900035

They're both 1920x1080, the difference is in how they are shown. Progressive (1080p) displays the whole image at once, 60 times a second. Interlaced (1080i) displays alternating halves of the image 60 times a second, i.e, you still need the whole resolution image.

edit- DANG mjannusch beat me to it! :p

My bad, wasn't thinking. 1080i = 1920x540 on any given frame. I'm not a fan of interlaced resolutions, fine text and lines have artifacts, same with fast movement. maybe I'm just more sensitive to it than others :p
 
S_Z said:
Listen, I’m not sure of anything concerning the upcoming ATI graphic cores since as I said before it’s just rumors and speculations. But if I was to believe anyone I would rather choose to listen to people like Dave Baumann and company on B3D which I know are very knowledgeable in this area (have been reading that forum for a long time) then some guy that calls himself FanATIc on HardOCPs forum ;)

We just have to wait and see...

Well, DaveBaumann and co do have good connections in the industry... But I know from first-hand experience that they do not always have the knowledge and expertise to interpret their information properly... And I also know from first-hand experience that at least DaveBaumann is quite biased against NVIDIA (or would that be towards ATi?).
Namely, when 3DMark05 was released, and they found out that it used the DST/PCF functionality on NVIDIA cards to improve shadowmap quality and performance, they attacked 3DMark05 brutally, saying it was favouring a certain vendor.
But, DaveBaumann did admit to me in a private message that he was aware of other manufacturers supporting DST aswell, in upcoming hardware. So he was aware (as was FutureMark) that the DST option was not vendor-specific, it was just currently only supported by one vendor's released products.
But still he attacked FutureMark for favouring NVIDIA and breaking their own rules (any feature must be supported by at least 2 vendors in order to be supported in 3DMark), and made a big noise out of it.
 
All I can say is, if they are hoping that the 360 becomes the central part of someones AV system then they had better equip it with a darn sight better DVD system than the current Xbox has or there will be screams all round. Its all very well saying it 'supports' certain HD resolutions and standards but it needs to do them well too. But great picture and sound quality costs money and I cant see that in something that will end up being sold for $149.99 in two years time. Thats what I'm more worried about.

Still doesnt have a VGA port either!
 
daglesj said:
All I can say is, if they are hoping that the 360 becomes the central part of someones ...

Still doesnt have a VGA port either!


I don't think they're tryin to replace it ... they're only tryin to make it fit better with the silver electronics. The industry is moving towards silver today so they made the perfect move. Other than that, I would not replace it for a quality DVD player or stereo system. It's just a cheaper way of acquiring an HTPC.

I'm only getting it to play games.
 
KrakenGuy said:
I think they should just hardwire a pentium 4 chip or an AMD FX-55 directly to the gpu. This way we get a clock speed of 3.2ghz or 2.6ghz.

CPUs!=GPUs in terms of architecture, GPUs are highly specialized to their duties.
 
the xbox 360 gpu isn't going to be based on r420 or r600 or r520.

it's a custom design made for microsoft by ati according to microsoft's supplied design requirements. also microsoft owns r500 not ati. what do you think would happen if ati used r500 elements in r600 that were designed by microsoft?

<sarcasm> yeah i can see microsoft allowing them to use those for free, after all microsoft's history is all about giving away tech for free and writing lots of checks. </sarcasm>

face it r500 is going to be a completely generic beast in all respects yet have some specific features that will be in directx next and in future revisions for longhorn but not be a directx 9 part. they could not get ati to give away specific hardware features that ati uses currently for directx 9 acceleration that are outside the spec.

in other words
ati wouldn't give away their property that they developed that allows them any speed advantages in directx 9 over what the vanilla specifications call for as then they'd be giving away their property.
also microsoft isn't going to allow ati much in regards to what ati would be able to use in future products based on microsoft's property either.

so any fill rate deficiencies are due to a straight ahead memory controller with no advanced cross bar architechture or specialized components to optimize read write effiency that ati has in place now. anything in there for memory speed advancement is in there from microsoft's design, not from ati's previous architechture or future plans.

also microsoft has stated 1080i capable on all games. not all games are default to 1080i. just that all games must also be in 1080i as well as normal 4:3 t.v. resolution. expect a lot of titles to support 4:3 and 1080i only to cut down developement costs.
 
wetware interface said:
the xbox 360 gpu isn't going to be based on r420 or r600 or r520.

it's a custom design made for microsoft by ati according to microsoft's supplied design requirements. also microsoft owns r500 not ati. what do you think would happen if ati used r500 elements in r600 that were designed by microsoft?
Do you honestly believe that ATI will not use any elements of the R500 in their coming graphic cores for PC? Things like the unified shader technology for example, do you really think they will come up with a completely new unified shader technology for their PC cores? Not very likely IMO. I’m positive that we will see elements of the R500 in upcoming graphic cores, I have no doubts about it.
 
The 'ownership' of the chips is mainly about the designs, meaning that MS doesn't have to buy any chips from a vendor, but can have the designs manufactured by the factory of their choice...
I don't believe that MS actually owns the technology in those designs... MS doesn't have a need to own the technology, and ATi would be silly to sell its technology to MS for a console.
In which case I don't see why ATi wouldn't have a similar design available for PCs soon.
 
Scali said:
The 'ownership' of the chips is mainly about the designs, meaning that MS doesn't have to buy any chips from a vendor, but can have the designs manufactured by the factory of their choice...
I don't believe that MS actually owns the technology in those designs... MS doesn't have a need to own the technology, and ATi would be silly to sell its technology to MS for a console.
In which case I don't see why ATi wouldn't have a similar design available for PCs soon.

Agreed.
 
Damn I hate when I hear quaility "DVD palyers". There is no such thing IMO. My top of the line Sony died and I replaced it with a $50 Plasonic or some name like that my sister got at Walmart and hell if I could notice a difference and I paid near $180 for the Sony. Sound and the DVD quality wont matter at all to the average consumer or even most audiophiles. What matters is the TV, it that is crap than everything you see and hear on it will be.
 
I read all the B3D posts regarding R600 that I could find. They basically all seem to be based on comments from Xbox insiders saying that ATI won't release a card supporting ALL the same features as the 360's videocard does until 2006 or 2007.

However, such statments have absolutely no bearing on whether the R520 will be a "next-gen" (not based on R300) core or not. ATI could easily be planning to release their first iteration of their next core without FULL WGF 2.0 support (when was the last time any videocard maker released a product with full support for an unreleased DirectX spec anyway?) and without embedded Dram and thus be totally in agreement with the Xbox peoples comments, and yet still realease a new core.

So what it comes down to is this..

Based on Inquirer speculation the R520 will be a true "next-gen" core.
Based on Xbox 360 related statements the R520 will not support/have every feature the Xbox360 does.
Based on Xbox 360 related statements the R600 will eventually be released and support/have all the features the Xbox360 has.

That is ALL the semi-official speculation we have to go on that I am aware of. If anyone has more please link to it.... I would really like to see a post from someone with a decent reputation in the industry, who is known to have inside sources, and who says the R520 will be based on R300 still. Without such a post the inquirer article is still the best thing we have to go on.


 
arentol said:
(when was the last time any videocard maker released a product with full support for an unreleased DirectX spec anyway?)

I think the 9700Pro was released before DX9.0 was official.
 
arentol said:
I read all the B3D posts regarding R600 that I could find. They basically all seem to be based on comments from Xbox insiders saying that ATI won't release a card supporting ALL the same features as the 360's videocard does until 2006 or 2007.

Well, so far I don't even know what functionality the XBox360 has exactly... Do you know if there's any detailed info on that anywhere?
Apart from that, those features may not be all that useful to PCs anyway.
The original XBox can also do some tricks that no PC can, like rendering to a vertexbuffer, or using the same texture as both rendertarget and input texture... so you have read-modify-write functionality. Nice features, but not crucial for PCs.
 
Scali said:
Well, so far I don't even know what functionality the XBox360 has exactly... Do you know if there's any detailed info on that anywhere?
Apart from that, those features may not be all that useful to PCs anyway.
The original XBox can also do some tricks that no PC can, like rendering to a vertexbuffer, or using the same texture as both rendertarget and input texture... so you have read-modify-write functionality. Nice features, but not crucial for PCs.


Graphics Processor Custom ATI Processor
Graphics Core Clock Speed 500MHz
System Memory 512MB, 700MHz DDR (shared by CPU and GPU if needed)
Vector Units 1 VMX-128 unit per core (3 total)
CPU Math Performance 9 Billion Dot Product Operations per Second
System Memory Bandwith 22.4GB/s, 256GB/s to EDRAM
Memory Architecture Unified Memory Architecture
Shaders 48-way Parallel Floating Point Dynamically-Schedualed, 48 billion Operations/s
Video Memory 10MB Embedded DRAM
Fill Rate (pixels) 16 Gigasamples/s using 4X MSAA
Fill Rate (triangles) 500 Million/s
 
^^ that doesn't tell us what the architecture is like though, we don't know the 3D graphics features it has
 
no..microsoft really does own the chip design of the R500....heh

Brent_Justice said:
^^ that doesn't tell us what the architecture is like though, we don't know the 3D graphics features it has

thats something that will come out in time, unfortunetly what i posted i believe is as official as the information gets for now. Gamespot has a few ingame footage for some of the up and coming titles, watch them, be impressed. All that really matters right? :)
 
arentol said:
I read all the B3D posts regarding R600 that I could find.

I would really like to see a post from someone with a decent reputation in the industry, who is known to have inside sources, and who says the R520 will be based on R300 still. Without such a post the inquirer article is still the best thing we have to go on.
You didnt do a very good search of the B3D forums ;)

Here is one post were DaveBaumann mention that he believes the R520 still being based on the R300.

link: http://www.beyond3d.com/forum/viewt...storder=asc&highlight=r500+r600+r520&start=20
 
FanATIc said:
Gamespot has a few ingame footage for some of the up and coming titles, watch them, be impressed. All that really matters right? :)

Only impressive title so far seems to be GoW. Everything else looks like current gen tech. Unless the NBA2K6 video isn't a pre-render in which case it looks fantastic.
 
trinibwoy said:
Only impressive title so far seems to be GoW. Everything else looks like current gen tech. Unless the NBA2K6 video isn't a pre-render in which case it looks fantastic.

Dark Sector vid looked good to me. Also the Full Auto trailer that just got released as well. The detail level in it looks great.


S_Z said:
You didnt do a very good search of the B3D forums ;)

Here is one post were DaveBaumann mention that he believes the R520 still being based on the R300.

link: http://www.beyond3d.com/forum/viewt...storder=asc&highlight=r500+r600+r520&start=20

Key word being "believe" and his own word "fathom". Not to mention that thread is from august of 2004, the posts speak for themselves. Nv50 still alive and apparently under TSMC 90nm? :)

While i'll agree he had a much better wealth of knowledge for that time, i certainly would not say hes right or i agree with him. Absolutly nothing was known about the R520 then, not even rumors. The core wasnt even taped out until 8 months later. I'll fight tooth and nail with anyone that the "leaked" specs speak loudly of a new core. I know it really doesnt matter until its launched officially, but hey, i'll do it cause i believe im right and i have yet to see a good argument saying otherwise.

Calling the coin before it lands so to speak.
 
FanATIc said:
Dark Sector vid looked good to me. Also the Full Auto trailer that just got released as well. The detail level in it looks great.

They look good but only GoW looks "next gen" good. ;)

FanATIc said:
Not to mention that thread is from august of 2004..The core wasnt even taped out until 8 months later.

Do you mean 8 months after Aug 2004?
 
Back
Top