x800xl vs 8600gt?

munkle

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Jan 16, 2005
Messages
11,799
I found a deal on a 8600gt for cheap, and I wondering if its worth it to upgrade over my x800xl?
 
while it is a slight upgrade it would hardly be worth the trouble and expense.
 
Not even sure if its an upgrade.

Are you having performance issues with your 800xl, or do you just want better then pixel shader 2.0b?
 
while it is a slight upgrade it would hardly be worth the trouble and expense.

The expense is minimal (sub $60) and the trouble is hardly any for me. If its better I'll probably pick it up then because it has better video playback which is something I want.
 
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/2005-17gpu_12.html

I would think the 8600gt is around the 6800 ultra in performance, cant really say. I know the 7600gt was around 6800gt in performance and the 8600gt is maybe 10-15% better.

If a game requires pixel shader 3.0 then I can see an upgrade as worth while.

edit: video playback is definitely a +, so yeah if thats what you need it for, then go for it.
 
The expense is minimal (sub $60) and the trouble is hardly any for me. If its better I'll probably pick it up then because it has better video playback which is something I want.
well for $60 and if you need better video playback then sure why not. if you were buying this just for a gaming upgrade then I would say no.
 
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/2005-17gpu_12.html

I would think the 8600gt is around the 6800 ultra in performance, cant really say. I know the 7600gt was around 6800gt in performance and the 8600gt is maybe 10-15% better.

If a game requires pixel shader 3.0 then I can see an upgrade as worth while.
it would easily be much better than the 6800ultra at low resolutions and still better overall. it really depends on the game. in Bioshock the 8600gt would blow the 6800ultra away.
 
From what i can remember in some other thread like this, the 7600gt was about equal in performance to the x850xt pe. I suppose the 8600gt is a bit more powerful, but not by a huge leap. My x850xt is still a good performer for most games.

I wouldn't make the jump, personally, but it's up to you. I would probably go for this.
 
I would get the 8600GT for the following reasons:

HDCP ready (on certain models)
Shader Model 4.0
DX10 ready (though I wouldn't play DX10 games on this card)
H.264, VC-1, etc hardware encoding/decoding (good for video editing/playback)
Quantum Physics (much higher amount of shaders)
Higher Texture Fill Rate


Not to mention the X800XL is two generations old. If you are just doing DX9 gaming, get a X1900GT/Pro/XT or a 7900GS. These cards will outperform the 8600GT (in DX9).

EDIT: The X800XL is only using Shader Model 2.0, which won't even run cetain games that are out now. Good luck playing Bioshock with it. I think there is a fix for this, but it's just not worth the trouble.

If the 8600GT is cheap enough, get it.
 
hrmmm debating if i should drop by my local bestbuy..currently use a x850
 
the performance gain in game is minimal.

SM 4.0 and Direct X 10 are effectivly the same thing.

I would say your card is officially right now obsolete, but considering the pace of the graphics card market (usually, but certainly not over the past few months), i would hold off getting a new card till its absolutly Necessary.
 
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/2005-17gpu_12.html

I would think the 8600gt is around the 6800 ultra in performance, cant really say. I know the 7600gt was around 6800gt in performance and the 8600gt is maybe 10-15% better.

If a game requires pixel shader 3.0 then I can see an upgrade as worth while.

edit: video playback is definitely a +, so yeah if thats what you need it for, then go for it.

The X800XL is direct competition for the 6800GT. A 7600GT is actually closer to the 6800 Ultra. In fact it's faster than a 6800 Ultra. I'm not sure the 7600GT can be used as the most accurate point of reference, although it will have to suffice in lieu of a more suitable card.

Just to give you an idea though, here are some 3dmark05/06 results which compare the 7600, 7900, and 8600s. From this you can clearly see the difference between a 7600GT and 8600GT. What this means for actual gaming is perhaps a small performance gain. You can see those comparisons if you flip through Guru3d's review starting with this link.

Again, the 7600GT is obviously faster than a X800XL, so you'll have to compound that performance difference when you make an analysis on the above benchmarks. There should be a performance gain which would border the rim of "noticable." I know that I would have a tough time justifying such an upgrade.
 
Back
Top