X2 250 or x3 435

Joined
Feb 24, 2010
Messages
59
I'm going to be using this new build for SC2 and Diablo 3. It will also be used for watching 1080 movies and web browsing.

The x2 250 I can get for $64

The x3 435 for $71

Which is better and which motherboard would you recommend?
 
the x3

from what ive heard SC2 is multi threaded, more threads then will help

pretty much any 785G board will suit your needs....need more info like what RAM your using, what your budget is before we can give you a good recommendation.....i'm assuming a budget build, so any Asus 785G EVO board should fit your needs
 
For a couple bucks more you could get a quad core Athlon II 630 $99. or if you plan on unlocking anyway you could go with the Phenom II 550 $99 + 785G. AMD offers great bang for your buck these days.
 
I wasn't sure if I could ask for budget builds here.

I'm looking to build a computer to stream 1080p movies and play SC2 and Diablo III when it comes out. Not looking to spend more than $500, but lower would be better.
Keep in mind I'm in Canada so I don't have good pricing like some states.
I haven't done any gaming on the PC for 4-5 years now. Last game I played on the PC was Counter-strike. I do my gaming on the PS3 now. I'm just building this for SC2 and Diablo III.

So far what I've come up with at NCIX prices are PM with different companies

AMD Athlon II X3 435

$70.99 PM with bestdirect

The Athlon II 630 is $30 more which I don't think I need. I rather get a better video card with the money I save.

ASUS M4A78LT-M LE

$66.44 PM with onhop

I chose this motherboard because that is the cheapest I found with DDR3

EVGA E-GEFORCE 9800GT $93.99 - $30 rebate = 63.99 PM with newegg

Cooler Master Elite 310 Blue Mid Tower Case @ CC for $45

or Antec Three Hundred for $50.

My friend just built a computer with the Cooler Master Elite 310 and I thought it was a really case and he recommended it because it had a side fan right where the video card is.

I already have a 1TB WD so I won't need that and I'm deciding between the OCZ ModXStream Pro OCZ500MXSP 500W $39 or the Corsair 400CX 400W for $29 at NCIX.

I'm not sure what kind of ram to get. any 4GB DDR3 I guess. I'm not really familiar with any brands for memory
 
Here's my complete list now. Tell me what you guys think

AMD Athlon II X3 435 Retail = $70.79

MSI 760GM-E51 mATX AM3 760G DDR3 = $64.99

G.SKILL F3-12800CL8D Ripjaws4 GB 2X2GB DDR3-1600 CL8-8-8-24 = $112.46

OCZ StealthXStream OCZ500SXS 500W = $48.05 - $15 MIR = $33.05

EVGA E-GEFORCE 9800GT 550MHZ 512MB = $93.99 - $30 MIR = $63.99

Antec Three Hundred = $49.79

Samsung SH-S243D/BEBE 24X Black DVD Writer = $19.99

Shipping Insurnace = $6.90
Subtotal = $476.96
No PST - Outside BC residents: $0.00
GST(5%)= $23.35

Total = $500.31 - $30+15 MIR = $455.31
 
I'd ditch the OCZ PSU and get this Corsair model instead. It has a bigger MIR* and is of higher quality than the OCZ unit. 400w should be fine for that build.

*I wouldn't expect to have the MIRs honored. The 3rd party companies that run those things do everything they can to keep from paying out.
 
I'd ditch the OCZ PSU and get this Corsair model instead. It has a bigger MIR* and is of higher quality than the OCZ unit. 400w should be fine for that build.

*I wouldn't expect to have the MIRs honored. The 3rd party companies that run those things do everything they can to keep from paying out.

I've had great success with OCZ products. My brother just got his rebate recently and so did I awhile ago. There's also a warehouse near my place and they have provided me with excellent support so far.
 
I've had great success with OCZ products. My brother just got his rebate recently and so did I awhile ago. There's also a warehouse near my place and they have provided me with excellent support so far.

i have that corsair 400w...

its a tossup

for the 500w, you can pretty much upgrade to any single video card and peripheries you want... but it only has 3 SATA power cables, so if you have more than 2xHDD and 1xDVD, you're outta luck(unless you get those periphery adapters)... and cables are somewhat short

for the 400w, you are a little limited to your video card upgrades, but its pretty much covers everything you need for a budget/medium build(6xSATA, enough power for a 5770/4870.. cables are really long too
 
Last edited:
AMD Athlon II X3 435 Retail = $70.79 yes

MSI 760GM-E51 mATX AM3 760G DDR3 = $64.99 yes

G.SKILL F3-12800CL8D Ripjaws4 GB 2X2GB DDR3-1600 CL8-8-8-24 = $112.46 yes

OCZ StealthXStream OCZ500SXS 500W = $48.05 - $15 MIR = $33.05 no, go corsair

EVGA E-GEFORCE 9800GT 550MHZ 512MB = $93.99 - $30 MIR = $63.99 very outdated, try to get ati 5xxx

Antec Three Hundred = $49.79 yes

Samsung SH-S243D/BEBE 24X Black DVD Writer = $19.99 yes
 
I highly recommend the Corsair over the OCZ. It's of far superior quality than the OCZ. We're talking a large difference like between a Ferrari and Pinto here.
 
Go with the Athlon II x3, but dump the 9800GT and get either a 5750 (I've seen 512mb ones between $110-$120) or a 5670. Everything else looks solid in your build.
 
At newegg they have the X3 720 (which has the 6M L3) for $84 after promo gift card...
 
Go with the Athlon II x3, but dump the 9800GT and get either a 5750 (I've seen 512mb ones between $110-$120) or a 5670. Everything else looks solid in your build.
I've looked into the 5750 and I think the 9800 GT is enough for me. I'm not going to be doing any end high gaming and it's almost double the price of what I'm paying

At newegg they have the X3 720 (which has the 6M L3) for $84 after promo gift card...
not for Canadians:(
 
I would ditch the G.Skill ram and get Corsair, Kingston or Patriot. I have had a lot of bad luck with G.Skill in DDR3.

While 400 Watts might be enough I would agree with others that I would get a 500 Watt PSU to give a little head room for the future. Personally I perfer the Earthwatt Series from Antec, very effecient and have not had a failure yet.
 
I've looked into the 5750 and I think the 9800 GT is enough for me. I'm not going to be doing any end high gaming and it's almost double the price of what I'm paying


the 5750 is a low end card.....better than the 9800 GT, and ~20 bucks more, a far cry from the double....it has the added bonus that it is DX11
 
Most OZC power suplly's are terrible.Corsair or Antec are excellent brands
To bad about the X3 720BE processor's,teriffic value
 
Is OCZ that bad? What actually makes that terrible? The one I'm looking at his 80% efficiency. I thought that was good enough. The 5750 is actually $55 more than the 9800 GT I'm getting. The cheapest I found was a Powercolor 5750 for $99 after a $20 rebate. I didn't jump on it because I'm not sure about the brand Powercolor. I think I rather wait for a better brand to go on sale.

I know the 5750 will future-proof my build, but I really don't want to spend more than $60-70 on a video card. Do I really need a 5750 to play SC2 or Diablo 3? I though the 9800 GT is more than enough for those two games.
 
The OCZ isnt the best brand, they are sub-par quality, and will not out put the rated power....if i remember, to get 80+ certified isnt very difficult.....if you look up a review on most OCZ(atleast the sub $200 ones) PSUs, you will see they fail....look at either Johnny Guru or HardOCPs reviews.....
 
Nothing wrong with Powercolor. My 4850 is a very well built, overclocks very well and stays relatively cool. Id have no problem recommending or buying their stuff.
 
Is OCZ that bad? What actually makes that terrible? The one I'm looking at his 80% efficiency. I thought that was good enough..

Nope. There are plenty of shitty PSUs out there that have 80% efficiency. The 80 Plus group does not check for ripple/voltage fluctuations and they only test at room temperature. As such, it's actually pretty easy to get 80 Plus certified.

Any way, most of OCZ's PSU lineup is made of FSP Episilon PSU designs or a mediocre Sirfa design. The only good OCZ PSU these days is their Z-Series line.

In this particular case, the OCZ StealthXStream 500W is based off the FSP Epsilon design. The 500W model is ok but the longevity of the PSU is questionable and the performance is only adequate at best. Compared that to the Corsair 400CX that is built by Seasonic, rated and tested at 50C, and has superior performance
 
the problem with OCZ is once you pass a certain wattage on the PS it fall's out of spec.Ripple can have disasterous effects on components
 
Here's my modified list. Went with the Corsair and a different case for a little extra. I'm still kind of set on the video card or I might just use the onboard video until I see a good sale on a good video card. I don't need it now since Starcraft II hasn't come out yet.

AMD Athlon II X3 435 Retail = $70.79

MSI 760GM-E51 mATX AM3 760G DDR3 = $64.99

G.SKILL F3-12800CL8D Ripjaws4 GB 2X2GB DDR3-1600 CL8-8-8-24 = $112.46

Corsair CMPSU-400CX = $51.99 - $22MIR = $29.99

EVGA E-GEFORCE 9800GT 550MHZ 512MB = $93.99 - $30 MIR = $63.99

Coolermaster CM 690 II Basic = $71.50 after PM

Samsung SH-S243D/BEBE 24X Black DVD Writer = $19.99
 
If he doesn't mind getting some things used, I'd look here or on ebay for some good deals. I got my X3 425 slightly used for only $42.62 after shipping and it came with all the original packaging. Plus I got it OCed to 3.4Ghz.
 
the X3 435 is not available at NCIX anymore so I decided to go with a quad core. what would you guys recommend for something around $100-120

I was also wondering if the G.SKILL F3-12800CL9D-4GBRL compatible with MSI 760GM-E51 motherboard I'm getting. It's not listed on the qualified motherboard list so I want to make sure it would work.
 
Last edited:
the x3

from what ive heard SC2 is multi threaded, more threads then will help

pretty much any 785G board will suit your needs....need more info like what RAM your using, what your budget is before we can give you a good recommendation.....i'm assuming a budget build, so any Asus 785G EVO board should fit your needs

Why go for the ASUS 785G Evo? It is a solid board and I do like it alot but at that price range might as well go with 880G for SATA 6GB/s and USB 3.0.

880G boards
 
Because they should be dropping pretty quick due to the 880's coming out :)
 
Because they should be dropping pretty quick due to the 880's coming out :)

lol I understand. Though at the moment they hardly have bulge. If OP was to buy a board right now the 880G would be be a better buy since they are pretty much in the same price range.
 
Those 770 and 785G boards only have 2x SATA 6Gb/s and the rest are SATA2 in case you are not aware.

The ASUS 880G board have only SATA 6GB/s and the new SB850 southbridge.
 
Those 770 and 785G boards only have 2x SATA 6Gb/s and the rest are SATA2 in case you are not aware.

The ASUS 880G board have only SATA 6GB/s and the new SB850 southbridge.

I have a Western Digital WD1001FALS which is SATA 3Gb/s that I'll be transferring to this new build. I'm not sure what you mean though. Is SATA 6Gb/s not backwards compatible with SATA 3Gb/s harddrives?

Timonthy thanks for the suggestion, but I'm a bit worried about the AsRock board having only 1 year warranty. That's why I didn't get the MSI 760G I listed before for $65.

Also are there any advantages to a ATX board compare to a mATX board besides the extra PCI slots?
 
SATA 6Gb/s is backwards compatible and really though you won't see any difference unless you start using raid but I thought it be worth point that out.

There are hardly any real quality difference between mATX and ATX these days.
 
ATX is just larger, other than that, there is nearly no quality difference
 
the x3

from what ive heard SC2 is multi threaded, more threads then will help

pretty much any 785G board will suit your needs....need more info like what RAM your using, what your budget is before we can give you a good recommendation.....i'm assuming a budget build, so any Asus 785G EVO board should fit your needs

/thread
 
SATA 6Gb/s is backwards compatible and really though you won't see any difference unless you start using raid but I thought it be worth point that out.

There are hardly any real quality difference between mATX and ATX these days.

Why people belive Sata 3 helps in raid?

in raid every drive has it's own sata channel. So if one hdd wasn't bottlenecked by Sata2 putting 3 of them in raid won't be bottlenecked too.

Sata 3 benefits only people with ultra high end ssd
 
Back
Top