X-bit labs Quad vs Dual core comparison

Yeah, right now in some cases the quad shows its extra juice but in others it just doesn't and higher clocks rule the roost. This is exactly why I dropped a mere $119 on my E7200 last month. At 3.6Ghz is holds its own against quads costing double or more
 
Almost all of their benchmarks were run at stock speeds. Who buys any of these CPU's and runs them at stock? The one single page they devoted to overclocking results they didn't bother to include results from the Duo.

Yeah, right now in some cases the quad shows its extra juice but in others it just doesn't and higher clocks rule the roost. This is exactly why I dropped a mere $119 on my E7200 last month. At 3.6Ghz is holds its own against quads costing double or more

So assuming you're not just comparing against stock clocked quads while you rock a Ghz overclock, is it the fact that you have less cache or half the cores that you think makes your E7200 "hold it's own"?
 
Anything using UT3 engine (I.E. Rainbow Six Vegas 1/2, UT3, Mass Effect, Stranglehold) are gonna really beat up dual cores with it using up to 4 cores.
 
Lol, one look at the resolutions used, and I closed the tab.
 
Lol, one look at the resolutions used, and I closed the tab.

Well, it is a CPU review, not a Videocard review, low resolutions are an attempt to focus on the CPU only in the review by eliminating the GPU as a possible bottleneck.
 
I understand that, but low resolutions are not real-world situations. That's kind of a big deal on [H] .

That's all I'm saying, *shrug*
 
they are when comparing CPU's!!!! this isnt a GPu review, it is CPU review, the only way to CPU bound a game is to run at low resolutions, once you go higher your GPU is the bottleneck thus you cant really see what CPU is faster....

[H] would do the same thing in a CPU review to test games
 
I've seen a few great deals on the Q9400 which makes it have alot of potential for a great Quad Core CPU.
 
I think this is just another review that misses that point. Instead of testing actual multitasking performance, they just throw in a bunch of apps that support multiple threads and then run them one. at. a. time. I would love to see some real world tests like *gasp* playing a game WHILE encoding video.
 
they are when comparing CPU's!!!! this isnt a GPu review, it is CPU review, the only way to CPU bound a game is to run at low resolutions, once you go higher your GPU is the bottleneck thus you cant really see what CPU is faster....

If you run a game at a real-world resolution and two CPUs end up with the same framerates, than obviously neither one is faster for gaming. Whether or not one of them pushes more FPS at a lower resolution is a moot point since it means fuck all when you're actually using the PC.
 
If you run a game at a real-world resolution and two CPUs end up with the same framerates, than obviously neither one is faster for gaming. Whether or not one of them pushes more FPS at a lower resolution is a moot point since it means fuck all when you're actually using the PC.

No it isn't. Because the CPU that pushes more frames at a lower resolution is the faster cpu and will last you longer. Not everyone wants to upgrade their cpu/mobo yearly.

If you test at GPU limited resolutions than you're doing a GPU review, not a cpu review.
 
No one's forcing you to read it, but if you've been reading the site for years there's obviously something there you value... ;) Personally I appreciate the fact that the [H] attitude and general approach hasn't changed much over the years, there's usually an explicit reason why certain things are done they way they are and it's usually explained if you bother to read it.
 
No offense Kyle, I am new the forums but i've been reading your website for a number of years now and I simply have gotten the impression of "Well, everyone does it this way, but i'm gonna be different and do it MY way cause I can, la la la!" from how you run and manage your website. Not that there's anything wrong with that, it just comes across as somewhat "cocky" to me but that seems to be the [H] style, especially when peeps in the forums that act like they are in a continual E-Penis size competition.

I now await the ban hammer:D
Not to jump in front of The Man, but did you read any of the articles that [H] did explaining the methodology and thought process behind their ideas? For me, though I agreed with the methods, I found the article to be very interesting:
http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQ2MSwsLGhlbnRodXNpYXN0
 
Not to jump in front of The Man, but did you read any of the articles that [H] did explaining the methodology and thought process behind their ideas? For me, though I agreed with the methods, I found the article to be very interesting:
http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQ2MSwsLGhlbnRodXNpYXN0

I have and I can see his "points" and view in regards to it, but it still doesn't chime with me. For advice and info, I go to [H]ard forums. For benchmarks, I look elsewhere. That's just me *shrug*
 
For advice and info, I go to [H]ard forums. For benchmarks, I look elsewhere. That's just me *shrug*
Well, I guess that's the point, now isn't it.
If you want non-applicable numbers and (albeit pretty) graphs, go elsewhere.
If you want to know how a card/cpu/mobo etc will perform, stay here.

However, I'm still not sure how that means:

"Well, everyone does it this way, but i'm gonna be different and do it MY way cause I can, la la la!"
 
You've made your choice, great. So why bitch about it?


I fail to see how my statement of
I question Kyles method of testing hardware myself, but whatever.
comes across "bitching" as its just my personal opinion, if flawed.

Well, I guess that's the point, now isn't it.
If you want non-applicable numbers and (albeit pretty) graphs, go elsewhere.
If you want to know how a card/cpu/mobo etc will perform, stay here.

I'm not going their as you've already diverted my thread past its intended discussion. If you or Kyle want to make this personal, PM is to the upper right of the screen. We agree to disagree, fair enough?
 
i agree with those that say that when reviewing CPUs, test games at resolutions that will not stress the gfx card, because otherwise, you end up just doing a graphics review....

remember when the Core 2 Duo came out, and [H]'s conclusion that Core 2 was only slightly or not at all better than AMD when it came to gaming? What a load of crap that turned out to be....

Scream "real world!!11!!" all you want, but when I read a CPU review, all I care about is learning about which one has more grunt behind it... especially because I'm not the type that upgrades yearly (more like every 3 years or so ...).

Today, I dont think anyone would say that the Core 2s from that fateful review in summer 2006 are only slightly better than the AX2's they were tested against... not with games like Crysis and Supreme Commander out, showing clear Intel superiority.... yet, this superiority was not shown in the [H] review (though other sites' reviews *did* show the Core 2s to be better gaming processors... using the gaming titles of the time no less....)



edit: that poor phenom gets its ass kicked...... what a horrible showing.....
 
remember when the Core 2 Duo came out, and [H]'s conclusion that Core 2 was only slightly or not at all better than AMD when it came to gaming? What a load of crap that turned out to be....

Scream "real world!!11!!" all you want, but when I read a CPU review, all I care about is learning about which one has more grunt behind it... especially because I'm not the type that upgrades yearly (more like every 3 years or so ...).

I still fully stand behind our Core 2 results. Please quote me on the "load of crap" we fed you.

And just to refresh your very limited memory, here is EXACTLY what I said that you are referring to as a "load of crap." (Honestly, you sound like one of those guys that listen to idiot forum posters instead of actually taking the time to read it themselves.) Yes, sadly what we published and what you have made up in your mind are two very different things.

Intel Core 2 Gaming Performance - We test Intel's Core 2 Duo and Extreme using real-world gaming. Don't let a bunch of canned benchmarks lie to you about gaming performance, real gameplay experience tells a different story. Unless of course you game at 800x600.

"As for the AMD Athlon 64 FX-62, all of our testing shows that it does trail the two new Intel CPUs in gameplay performance. So, if you wanted to point one out as being a “winner” then for sure it is the new Intel Core 2 X6800 and E6700."

"When it comes to playing games, the only persons that need to be even a little concerned with upgrading their CPU to a Core 2 processor might be those with high-end SLI, CrossFire, or GeForce GX2 video cards and we have yet to prove that due to the testing limitations we ran into. Then, and only then, you might see an Intel Core 2 processor deliver a performance advantage."

Onto Core 2 Applications

Intel Core 2 Music, Images, & Movie Performance - Looking for a new system to edit your home movies and pictures on? If you are heavy into encoding video, you will want to know about Intel's new Core 2 processors and the talents that lie within.

"There is no doubt that when it comes to editing video, manipulating images, or encoding music, the Intel Core 2 Duo and Extreme processors at 2.66GHz and above currently enjoy a healthy performance advantage over AMD’s Athlon FX and Athlon 64 line of processors. Moreover, I would be remiss if I did not mention the Core 2 Duo and Extreme also do a great job of making the Pentium 4 look like a dinosaur."

And we did an article on power as well

Intel Core 2 Duo & Extreme Power Consumption - Are you wondering if Intel’s new Core 2 Duo and Extreme are raging infernos like their predecessors? We show you what kind of wattage you can expect to draw so you know what PSU is in your future. And we throw in AMD's Energy Efficient 3800+ as well.

"There is no doubt that Intel deserves huge kudos as they have brought the power consumption of their flagship processors well under AMD's as we saw in our 50% and 100% load tests. Not only will this bode well for those of you contemplating the possible need for a new PSU with your next upgrade, but you will not see the terrible heat concerns associated with the last generation of Pentium 4s either. In fact, as suggested by the wattage consumption graphs seen previously, we saw very cool CPU temperatures being read by our systems."

And finally some real world gaming comparisons with 8800 GTX SLI which are still very relevant today.

Real-World Gaming CPU Comparison with 8800 GTX SLI - AMD and Intel head-to-head. With NVIDIA's 8800 series GPU supplying a big jump in performance over the last generation of video cards, we revisit just what these CPUs do for you when you are gaming. Is one truly better? The results have changed.

"With today’s fastest video cards, we certainly saw more differences between our AMD and Intel processors than we did at the launch of the Core 2 Duo, and certainly more differences than we saw in March of last year. Undoubtedly, the Core 2 Duo allowed us a better gaming experience overall. Also we saw some examples where we were again GPU bottlenecked in games even with these massively fast BFGTech 8800 GTX cards.

There is undoubtedly a world where the Intel Core 2 Duo reigns supreme, but in the world of gaming that power is not near as apparent. We again see games remain very GPU dependent, but the GeForce 8800 series of GPU is allowing us to begin to see the Core 2 Duo flex its muscle. One thing is for sure. If you are building a gaming system, your big money is better spent on your video cards than your processor as you are never likely to see any true differences in your gaming experiences without a hugely powerful GPU. If you do however have the alpha-male of video card(s), Intel’s Core 2 Duo can provide you with a better gaming experience."

Bottom line - I stand fully behind what we have published and your unproven claims fall flat here and simply come across as another uninformed if not ignorant opinion.
 
I think this is just another review that misses that point. Instead of testing actual multitasking performance, they just throw in a bunch of apps that support multiple threads and then run them one. at. a. time. I would love to see some real world tests like *gasp* playing a game WHILE encoding video.

Did you ever try?
In my experience the game gets so slow and erratic that it's no longer enjoyable to play.
And that's not just the CPU, but rather the other resources that get drowned out, mostly memory (although with Nehalem that might be different).
Ofcourse, toy games like HL2 are no problem, but I stopped playing those years ago, so I don't really care anymore.
 
If they were comparing two at the same speed this might be interesting but their not so it's useless to me as I overclock.
 
Back
Top