Woz Supports Mike Daisey's Message

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Not only does Woz support Mike Daisey's message, he says you should too.

"I'm a presenter," Wozniak told CNET. "I give 50 or 60 talks a year. I'm involved in community plays, musicals and ballets, a lot of performing arts...what actors do is to try to dramatize issues and events that are real. When you're watching Stephen Colbert and 'The Daily Show' not everything they say is factual but what they're presenting is real. It's a method of presentation that brings issues and ideas more to your awareness."
 
I'm not an Apple fan (in fact I am somewhat of the opposite), but I have a tremendous amount of respect for the Woz.

He is a genius in his own right, and although Apple is partially his creation, he is not afraid to speak the truth, even when it conflicts with the Apple line.
 
I like Woz, but he's kind of missing the point here. The guy said his claims about what he experienced at Foxconn were true, now it turns out they aren't. Someone raised a good point on another site. This is like those emails about fudging climate change numbers. Suddenly, more people thought climate change was just a myth because of the actions of a couple scumbags.

When you tell a lie to support the truth, that truth becomes much harder for people to accept.
 
Sorry Woz, but I gotta disagree. It is ok to use entertainment to tell a story, as the Daily Show does, but you have to be up front about it. The problem with Daisy is that he wanted to present this stuff as a documentary, and then when it turned out it wasn't true say "Oh well then it was just entertainment." He was misrepresenting his work. That's the problem.
 
Exactly. His message is something I can support, but the means he used to express that message were wrong.

Suffice it to say that entertainment and fact don't need to conflict. To eschew fact for the sake of entertainment is fine — Hollywood does it all the time — but there's a time and a place for embellishment.
 
Exactly. His message is something I can support, but the means he used to express that message were wrong.

Suffice it to say that entertainment and fact don't need to conflict. To eschew fact for the sake of entertainment is fine — Hollywood does it all the time — but there's a time and a place for embellishment.

Now correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding of all this is that he didn't necessarily embellish anything, he just claimed that he had seen it with his own eyes, and used stories from other people? Correct?

Nothing wrong with that from the perspective of putting on a play, but he should have been very clear about this when he agreed to let his work be featured in a documentary on the issue.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038510854 said:
Now correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding of all this is that he didn't necessarily embellish anything, he just claimed that he had seen it with his own eyes, and used stories from other people? Correct?

Nothing wrong with that from the perspective of putting on a play, but he should have been very clear about this when he agreed to let his work be featured in a documentary on the issue.
Claiming to have seen it first-hand is embellishment. It goes to the credibility of the person.
To quote the article, he "vouched for the authenticity of his monologue during interviews with news outlets".
 
Daisey's credibility has been ruined already. Woz really loves attention.
 
so this guy did some plays based on an issue he thought needed attention and his material was later used in documentaries and the only criticism is that he didn't observe the things he portrayed in the first person?
 
Screw Daisey. He lied for personal gain, and should never be trusted again. He can get a job at McDonalds for all I care. Just let me know where so I never go there. I wouldn't trust him to assemble my Big Mac.
 
Back
Top