Windows Vista SP2 Beta Next Week

Those are the types of people that are this country's future leaders ... and seems like running it now.

And I'm not referring to the presidency. Anyone who thinks the presidency actually runs this country has been in la la land for decades.

/off topic part.

A local computer shop owner publicly said in an interview - and my stupid local news station actually broadcast it - that none of your old software would work in Vista. He threatened any new computer buyers and potential Vista upgraders that, and I quote, "You will have to spend $400 on new software including Microsoft Office just so it will work with Vista!" Office 2003 ran flawlessly on all three of my Vista machines, one of which was built on Vista right after it came out. I never had any Office '03 issues. Don't know about 2000 or older, though.

I have installed Office 2000 on vista. All the programs other than Outlook worked just fine. Outlook had trouble with 2 or 3 dlls that dealt with contacts and the address book not being registered and I had to manually register them. However that was with a clean install of Vista and trying to install Office on top of it, if going from an upgrade where it is already installed it might work just fine. But it is working for the person we have setup to use it. She is able to work in word and excel just fine and uses outlook after I registered the files and has no trouble.

I knowed that I tried 97 as a what the hell, might as well give it a try for testing. However its been so long I can't remember the results that I had. However a quick look states how it will work with SR1 or below. However you can't install SR2 due to it trying to replace a font that it can't replace. So yes it should work.
 
* Support for VIA 64-bit CPUs
* Support for Bluetooth 2.1.
* Support for ICCD/CCID smart cards.
* Support for native Blu-Ray media recording.
* Windows Connect Now (WCN), a new tool to assist in connecting to Wi-Fi networks.
* ex-FAT file system, supporting UTC timestamps to ensure correct file synchronization across time zones.
* Windows Search 4.0 integration.
* Improved support for resuming with active Wi-Fi connections.
279MB. All the info I could get.
 
279MB. All the info I could get.

Great info, but I'm still upset.

"* Support for native Blu-Ray media recording." - nice, but so what?

Support for native Blu-Ray PLAYBACK - now that would be beneficial. Even if I start backing stuff up on blu-rays, I am going to burn a blu ray a LOT LESS than I will watch blu ray movies. :(
 
I'm led to believe that Windows 7 is most likely to have native Blu-ray playback support, what with the H.264 updates for WMC and all.
 
I'm led to believe that Windows 7 is most likely to have native Blu-ray playback support, what with the H.264 updates for WMC and all.

That will be nice, but Vista has all the technology and power necessary to integrate that already. Why should we have to wait for windows 7 to get something that you should be able to add to Windows XP Media center edition?

There are lots of XP and Vista PC's with media center that are plenty powerful enough to process blu-ray data. People would likely be quicker to adopt blu-ray and buy more movies if it was more universal. A lot of people already love MS's excellent media center interface, which I agree is quite good. If they knew they could just slap in a blu ray drive and start playing blu ray movies, I bet they'd buy a lot more movies and it would help blu ray sales. I haven't bought a single one, and I won't until some of these issues are resolved. I don't want to have to run two different programs just to watch movies. It's stupid. Make stuff effing right the first time.
 
That will be nice, but Vista has all the technology and power necessary to integrate that already. Why should we have to wait for windows 7 to get something that you should be able to add to Windows XP Media center edition?

There are lots of XP and Vista PC's with media center that are plenty powerful enough to process blu-ray data. People would likely be quicker to adopt blu-ray and buy more movies if it was more universal. A lot of people already love MS's excellent media center interface, which I agree is quite good. If they knew they could just slap in a blu ray drive and start playing blu ray movies, I bet they'd buy a lot more movies and it would help blu ray sales. I haven't bought a single one, and I won't until some of these issues are resolved. I don't want to have to run two different programs just to watch movies. It's stupid. Make stuff effing right the first time.

Maybe they are trying to let others sell their own software first. If Microsoft could / did support every know video / media format out of the box then think of how many companies would not be able to sell you their software. Google complained about Microsoft adding a better search ablity to vista as it cut the need for Google desktop. Think of what it would be like if you never had to buy another dvd/blu-ray playback software ever again. While it would be nice if Microsoft included playback for Blu-Ray and tons of other things. The truth is that they would be hounded left and right due to them abusing their position and "preventing" others from selling you software to do so. Who knows maybe when Windows 7 comes out "if" it supports the feature maybe they will put it into Vista then also.
 
I think 99.5% of the blame for that one lies with the media industry. If the whole DRM path wasn't so damn convoluted for HD discs there would already be more software players and likely integated blu-ray play.

BTW, I didn't see that on the list of features for 7 that was out today so I wouldn't count on it.
 
Maybe they are trying to let others sell their own software first. If Microsoft could / did support every know video / media format out of the box then think of how many companies would not be able to sell you their software. Google complained about Microsoft adding a better search ablity to vista as it cut the need for Google desktop. Think of what it would be like if you never had to buy another dvd/blu-ray playback software ever again. While it would be nice if Microsoft included playback for Blu-Ray and tons of other things. The truth is that they would be hounded left and right due to them abusing their position and "preventing" others from selling you software to do so. Who knows maybe when Windows 7 comes out "if" it supports the feature maybe they will put it into Vista then also.

I don't mind Vista requiring me to buy someone else's software in order to play their content. I understand the monopoly/antitrust thing (which Apple violates with 95% of their hardware almost 100% of the time - though on a smaller scale). But remember the XP days where windows media player wouldn't play DVD's unless you installed a 3rd party decoder? Once you installed WinDVD you were good to go. Every DVD played just fine in Media Player.

As I've said before, AT THE VERY LEAST let Vista use the 3rd party decoders' ability to play back blu rays. Let us use our simple MCE interface. You can install decoders for DivX, XVid, vob, avi, mpg, and a bajillion other formats of video and GUESS WHAT .... Media Center Plays them JUST FINE all within the confines of a simple, uniform and stable interface.

I can play regular DVD's in a Blu Ray player. They work just fine, therefore I need only one optical drive playing unit in my home theater, not one for DVD's and another for blu rays. Some people might prefer as many different sources and redundant devices in their house as possible, but for those that want to buy one device and have it play all of their movies, the simple blu ray players out there can do that.

Media Center can play any file format you can find a codec for that will integrate into vista, and there are dozens. So why leave out blu ray?

Perhaps it's Microsoft's sneaky way of fighting blu ray. Remember that they are making a big push right now for digital distribution in an area where the internet infrastructure is still not even close to adequate to support it. Nevertheless, microsoft will push as usual. You can't play blu rays in MCE, but you sure have access to all kinds of internet TV and digital downloads .... Sneaky.

I think 99.5% of the blame for that one lies with the media industry. If the whole DRM path wasn't so damn convoluted for HD discs there would already be more software players and likely integated blu-ray play.

BTW, I didn't see that on the list of features for 7 that was out today so I wouldn't count on it.
 
I think 99.5% of the blame for that one lies with the media industry. If the whole DRM path wasn't so damn convoluted for HD discs there would already be more software players and likely integated blu-ray play.

BTW, I didn't see that on the list of features for 7 that was out today so I wouldn't count on it.

+1.

It would be nice, but I'm not holding my breath.
 
I personally can't wait for another bloatware OS that has no driver support for any of my components.
 
Perhaps it's Microsoft's sneaky way of fighting blu ray. Remember that they are making a big push right now for digital distribution in an area where the internet infrastructure is still not even close to adequate to support it. Nevertheless, microsoft will push as usual. You can't play blu rays in MCE, but you sure have access to all kinds of internet TV and digital downloads .... Sneaky.

Heh, could be... There's still people who are convinced they only backed HD DVD as a way to pester Sony, knowing it wouldn't be successful in the end. Though bringing out an HD DVD player for the Xbox seems a bit much if that was their original intent. :p
 
Btw, what you're talking about could/would probably just be built into a WMP update wouldn't it? Don't see why it would necessarily be tied to a SP, Windows 7, or any OS-wide specific update.
 
Btw, what you're talking about could/would probably just be built into a WMP update wouldn't it? Don't see why it would necessarily be tied to a SP, Windows 7, or any OS-wide specific update.

Well then why in the H E double HOCKEY STICKS haven't the done it yet???? :confused:

Heh, could be... There's still people who are convinced they only backed HD DVD as a way to pester Sony, knowing it wouldn't be successful in the end. Though bringing out an HD DVD player for the Xbox seems a bit much if that was their original intent. :p

That is my suspicion. And I doubt it cost them very much considering Toshiba made all the drives for them and then MS sold them at $200 a piece. Boy, that would've really been a genius calculation.

I mean, look back at the consumer attitude one year before now. I have worked in electronics retail for almost four years now. I literally had hundreds of customers come in and say "Oh, I don't want to buy that blu ray player yet ... I've gotta see who wins the war!"

Would the "war" have lasted quite as long had it not been for the amount of HD DVD players that sold for the X-Box? I know a ton of standalones sold too, but HD DVD still had enough clout, and in large part because of Microsoft's backing. In fact, I remember even asking myself, why would Microsoft be backing HD DVD if it was just going to lose?

If blu ray had come out as the solo HD format, there would've been no war and almost no consumer doubt. Only price would've been Blu Ray's hurdle.

But there was a delay, and that delay mysteriously gave MS a little more time to prep their digital download platform.

Interesting, to say the least.

I personally can't wait for another bloatware OS that has no driver support for any of my components.

nVidia had access to Vista code two years before it released, and still their cards were crashing when Vista finally came out. But who got sued? nVidia, and rightfully so. XP was six years old. Hardware developers can complain if there's a new OS they've got to rewrite drivers for every year or so, but six years? That's not enough time?

Give me a break. If a big corporation can sit on their fat asses and just sell product, that's what they do, as long as stuff sells. That's what nVidia did. And even though it bet them a little at first, it wasn't as big of a deal to them because at that time ATI wasn't even playing ball. Want to see another example? Linksys/Cisco. 80% of the computers Best Buy sells have Vista 64 bit installed. 64 bit is more stable, more efficient, potentially faster, and just plain better. But how many Linksys PCI and USB WiFi adapters fully support Vista 64 bit?

Big fat large lazy corporations. Capitalism's finest. That's why you didn't have video card drivers when Vista came out. And Vista works with so much product right now. Just a year after release Vista was dialed in to pretty much all mainstream and definitely all new/cutting edge hardware.

MS has to write an OS that will be new enough, better enough, and attractive enough to sell, while at the same time working with lazy crapbag companies' old hardware so people won't have trouble getting their stuff to run properly. As powerful and wealthy as MS is, there are so many more variables out there hardware wise. And open your eyes. The same exact thing happened with XP, and we were even worse off with the XP transition back then than we are with Vista now.

There is real bloatware in Vista, however, and it's the ridiculously hefty DRM built in.
 
Well then why in the H E double HOCKEY STICKS haven't the done it yet???? :confused:

Simple: antitrust. If they include Blu-ray playback in Windows, then Cyberlink and Corel will both go to the US and EU governments screaming bloody murder. Will probably cost Microsoft at least $1 billion between settlements and absurd EU fines. Let's see....$1b in fines versus a few unhappy HTPC customers (who will still buy Windows anyway because the media center frontends in Linux and Mac OS X both suck). Guess who wins. ;)
 
Simple: antitrust. If they include Blu-ray playback in Windows, then Cyberlink and Corel will both go to the US and EU governments screaming bloody murder. Will probably cost Microsoft at least $1 billion between settlements and absurd EU fines. Let's see....$1b in fines versus a few unhappy HTPC customers (who will still buy Windows anyway because the media center frontends in Linux and Mac OS X both suck). Guess who wins. ;)

Yep this is really what it is. Remember everytime MS brings us something we want somebody else screams anti-trust because their 3rd party software does it too and gets the government involved.
 
I don't mind Vista requiring me to buy someone else's software in order to play their content. I understand the monopoly/antitrust thing (which Apple violates with 95% of their hardware almost 100% of the time - though on a smaller scale). But remember the XP days where windows media player wouldn't play DVD's unless you installed a 3rd party decoder? Once you installed WinDVD you were good to go. Every DVD played just fine in Media Player.

As I've said before, AT THE VERY LEAST let Vista use the 3rd party decoders' ability to play back blu rays. Let us use our simple MCE interface. You can install decoders for DivX, XVid, vob, avi, mpg, and a bajillion other formats of video and GUESS WHAT .... Media Center Plays them JUST FINE all within the confines of a simple, uniform and stable interface.

I can play regular DVD's in a Blu Ray player. They work just fine, therefore I need only one optical drive playing unit in my home theater, not one for DVD's and another for blu rays. Some people might prefer as many different sources and redundant devices in their house as possible, but for those that want to buy one device and have it play all of their movies, the simple blu ray players out there can do that.

Media Center can play any file format you can find a codec for that will integrate into vista, and there are dozens. So why leave out blu ray?

Perhaps it's Microsoft's sneaky way of fighting blu ray. Remember that they are making a big push right now for digital distribution in an area where the internet infrastructure is still not even close to adequate to support it. Nevertheless, microsoft will push as usual. You can't play blu rays in MCE, but you sure have access to all kinds of internet TV and digital downloads .... Sneaky.


I fully agree with you there. I wasn't aware that it wouldn't / couldn't use a blu-ray codec if you had it installed. Yes they should change that so that it would use the codec once installed. Although if correct XP didnt' do that at first either did it? Wasn't is 10 I think that added that ablity? Or did it use them from the start?


I personally can't wait for another bloatware OS that has no driver support for any of my components.

Windows 7 will support/use Vista drivers.

Simple: antitrust. If they include Blu-ray playback in Windows, then Cyberlink and Corel will both go to the US and EU governments screaming bloody murder. Will probably cost Microsoft at least $1 billion between settlements and absurd EU fines. Let's see....$1b in fines versus a few unhappy HTPC customers (who will still buy Windows anyway because the media center frontends in Linux and Mac OS X both suck). Guess who wins. ;)

Yep this is really what it is. Remember everytime MS brings us something we want somebody else screams anti-trust because their 3rd party software does it too and gets the government involved.

But like SirKronan said, not including their own and not using one that you buy from somebody else are two different things.
 
I fully agree with you there. I wasn't aware that it wouldn't / couldn't use a blu-ray codec if you had it installed. Yes they should change that so that it would use the codec once installed. Although if correct XP didnt' do that at first either did it? Wasn't is 10 I think that added that ablity? Or did it use them from the start?.

Nah XP has never supported DVD out of the box, even with SP3.

I happened to have a laptop prepared for an employee right next to me and I tried it to see if I remembered right. It has WMP11 and SP3 and all the updates (It's XP Professional). I got prompted "WMP cannot play the DVD because a compatible DVD decoder is not installed on your computer"

Nothing a free copy of WinDVD can't fix.

But I agree, Microsoft should have stuck a deal with third party developers to include decoders, similar to how they had Symantec license their defragger ages ago.
 
Nah XP has never supported DVD out of the box, even with SP3.

I happened to have a laptop prepared for an employee right next to me and I tried it to see if I remembered right. It has WMP11 and SP3 and all the updates (It's XP Professional). I got prompted "WMP cannot play the DVD because a compatible DVD decoder is not installed on your computer"

Nothing a free copy of WinDVD can't fix.

But I agree, Microsoft should have stuck a deal with third party developers to include decoders, similar to how they had Symantec license their defragger ages ago.

I didn't mean out of the box. What I was asking / unsure of was if the early versions of XP with media player 9 could use a dvd codec to play the dvd in windows media player or if you HAD to use the actual software to play the dvd. IE if you install xp sp 0 or sp 1 on a box and dont' apply any updates. Then install windvd or powerdvd or something like that, will media player 9 allow you to play the dvd from inside of it, or do you have to play it through powerdvd or windvd instead.

I was thinking that you had to play it through powerdvd or windvd (or whatever program you install) with media player 9 but that 10 added the ability for you to use the codec from the program you installed. However its been such a long time I can't remember now. I know that I use to use powerdvd as my player, but I don't remeber if I really had to, or if I just did it.
 
But like SirKronan said, not including their own and not using one that you buy from somebody else are two different things.

I can't disagree with that but it's a sad state of affairs we're in right now because what I said is what happens.

I wish at times that MS would offer up a separate piece of software that would add that piece of functionality we want for $1 at the store just so that they can say it doesn't come with Windows in order to slap some businesses around a little bit.
 
I didn't mean out of the box. What I was asking / unsure of was if the early versions of XP with media player 9 could use a dvd codec to play the dvd in windows media player or if you HAD to use the actual software to play the dvd. IE if you install xp sp 0 or sp 1 on a box and dont' apply any updates. Then install windvd or powerdvd or something like that, will media player 9 allow you to play the dvd from inside of it, or do you have to play it through powerdvd or windvd instead.

I was thinking that you had to play it through powerdvd or windvd (or whatever program you install) with media player 9 but that 10 added the ability for you to use the codec from the program you installed. However its been such a long time I can't remember now. I know that I use to use powerdvd as my player, but I don't remeber if I really had to, or if I just did it.

Yes, even back in WMP 9 if you installed a 3rd party codec, which you could certainly buy depending on your needs, WMP would use that codec to play a DVD movie.

And for those that still think it's an antitrust issue, that may be, but why not at least give Media Center the ability to use the third party codec of your choice to be able to play all of your movies in the same program??? That's the point I'm trying to make. You'd still have to go out and buy PowerDVD or the Corel DVD player, so they'd get their business just the same!!!
 
Maybe it's more of a technical/DRM issue with the Blu-Ray codec itself, rather than something more sinester, I dunno.
 
i like the updates included in this sp2. sounds like a worthwhile FREE upgrade guys, even though these were slated for RTM originally....
 
I don't think they would add Blu-Ray playback support, they don't even have DVD play back support yet, you still need a 3rd party app like power dvd.
 
Back
Top