Windows phone 7 vs Android

Early reports are meaningless since nobody actually has done a real review of Windows Phone 7 on a production level device as of this date.

I am not basing my negative opinion of WP7 on early reviews but early reports. The stuff from MS itself, from MIX10 on forward. Harsaphes, Endgadget is a corporate shill. If you want to buy what the corporate cabal wants you to buy then by all means read Endgadget. I've had this argument too many times with Endgadget fans so I don't want to derail this thread, but the fact: Endgadget=AOL=Time Warner=Big Content.

Microsoft itself has listed the negatives of its OS vs the field. Someone listed some of them above but its not comprehensive and I am not going to dig through MS press reports and articles on MS events over the past year to list them out, bit its all there. And as I said, maybe later MS will get its house in order but for now if you are not a huge mobile geek and run with multiple phones, WP7 is not for you except MS fans and, possibly, people with low end mobile function needs.

If that's you then no problem, otherwise, WP7 is just missing too many features to be a competitive OS at the level of the game today for "power" users. My other problem of WP7 is the experience is purely aping Apple conceptually. Replace Zune desktop with iTunes and there you have it. That whole idea of "mommy" needing to hold your hand and create an iron curtain behind which you are allowed to play is an anathema to me, a free adult, not a child that needs a mommy.

Some of you in this thread seem to want "mommy". No problem, if that's you then fine, but I still say iOS is a better option for you in that case. Its mature, with a huge developer base where WP7 is in early adopter phase and has less developers on board than WebOS.

The digs at Android, I don't argue that. As I said, Android is having growing pains. However to the people that think Android is too "open", I argue there is no such thing. Sure, you have to actually spend some time playing with your phone to set it up and figure out the issues you have, and if you are not interested in that then may I introduce you to "mommy" Apple who will hold your hand and help you cross the street and lock you behind an iron curtain so that you don't have to spend any time tinkering with your phone.

As I said, the HD2 is my favorite phone out the the 3 I use daily. The reason WinMo got killed was because it was as "inconvenient" as Android but had the added problem of having a terrible UI. On the HD2 the UI problem is fixed, out of the box, by HTC Sense. That is not why its my favorite phone though, its that way because of the hardware (finally a huge screen), the great depth of developer support, and its lack of trying to control me (even more than Android who tries to force me into the cloud and shoves adware down my throat).

But WinMo is gone, killed by "mommy" Apple and its legion who seem to really want their mommy. So WP7 is trying to get them by offering the same iron curtain but with many hardware options. In the end, that may be a more attractive mainstream platform, but on October 11th, its still an early adapter platform missing developers and almost every competitive feature.
 
GSMArena has a review of WP7 up right now. Don't know about you guys,but no tethering,no mass memory mode,no multitasking - big no no for me. Waiting for the Nokia N9 on meego or the milestone 2 to launch here.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Oh course Engadget is a corporate shill, but you have to go somewhere for your information. Their early review seems very fair to me...they point out many negatives and positives. My gadget information is culled from Engadget, Gizmodo, Hardocp, The Tech Report, Ars, Boy Genius and XDA. I rotate through these during the day, so I feel Im pretty well rounded. I currently own the HD2, Nexus 1, MotoX, and Iphone 3GS. All of the features that will be missing from the W7 launch were missing from the Iphone and everyone got over it..so for me its not a big deal. .Apps?...I really could care less about them....what apps do you really USE all day long? For all the apps that my Apple friends install on their phones I bet five are USED and the rest are to show to someone. And..say what you will about the MOMMY factor, but the fact is you and I and all here on Hard are a tiny tiny minority of folks who love to tinker and hack our devices..the average person doesnt even know about XDA or cares to know about it. They want to turn their phones on and have them work. Im sure when I turn on my W7 phone, it will do just that.
 
I am excited about window 7 but with the lack of support in market, I would prefer Android.
 
For those of you worried about no tethering im sure a version of PDANet will be available for the phone soon enough.

http://www.junefabrics.com/palmnet/

Works with my BB flawlessly. Id assume the same level of quality on a WinMo version.

PDANet is crap! On Android, they want to charge you $50 to view any and all HTTPS sites after a short trial. On top of which, you have to install desktop client as well... Or, I could download Androidn WIFI or Wired Tether and use it with no issues, no need to install any software either.

Seems to be like WP7 is always going to be playing catch up. Each release of Android brings more and more features. Microsoft will be ironing out bugs in an OS which is lacking feathres, while the big boys such as Android and Apple are going to be adding to their already stable platform. Sad, but true. Zune had graet potential, but it failed at catching up pretty badly.
 
PDANet is crap! On Android, they want to charge you $50 to view any and all HTTPS sites after a short trial. On top of which, you have to install desktop client as well... Or, I could download Androidn WIFI or Wired Tether and use it with no issues, no need to install any software either.

And dont forget, if you have multiple PCs, you have to buy multiple coppies of the software! (really pissed me back in the day when I tried it, bought it, was told "oh install the desktop all you want, just only 1 phone app" and when I got my 2nd laptop, or when I needed it on my desktop because my DSL went out, I found out I had to purchase it AGAIN to use it in 2 places...) WiFi Tether on Android FTMFW!
 
And dont forget, if you have multiple PCs, you have to buy multiple coppies of the software! (really pissed me back in the day when I tried it, bought it, was told "oh install the desktop all you want, just only 1 phone app" and when I got my 2nd laptop, or when I needed it on my desktop because my DSL went out, I found out I had to purchase it AGAIN to use it in 2 places...) WiFi Tether on Android FTMFW!

That's even worse than I thought it was! Wifi tether is amazing, so is the wired one lol. I would always use it on my phones while at school. My college blocks some sites, and with full blown HSPA on Tmobile here, it was actually on par if not faster than my school's network. Oh, and a year back, my school's wifi would always get overloaded, brining my download/upload speeds to a crawl... WIfi thether was a life saver!
 
hd2 has built in tethering courtesy of wm pro 6.5 no need for additional apps here.
 
hd2 has built in tethering courtesy of wm pro 6.5 no need for additional apps here.

your lucky. Or you know the same trick I knew. Wm6.5's USB/BT tethering only works if you first initiate a data session with a program like Skyfire, THEN use tether, otherwise you will always get "The remote party has ended the data session" or "Cannot dial #777 please check the number and dial again"
 
phone comes already setup, if it was not, i would have to enter tbe required before using the phone as a tethering device.
 
phone comes already setup, if it was not, i would have to enter tbe required before using the phone as a tethering device.

your cell provider must allow tethering. Most of us that are using 3rd party solutions have providers that dont like us tethering. My method is a work-a-round so Sprint doesn't know I'm tethering, if they know, they shut me down immediately.
 
hd2 has built in tethering courtesy of wm pro 6.5 no need for additional apps here.

Android 2.2 has built in tethering as well... and it works better. point is, it's not hard to get your device to be a "modem". However, most carrier have an issue with the feature being there, thus, it gets disabled.
 
Android 2.2 has built in tethering as well... and it works better. point is, it's not hard to get your device to be a "modem". However, most carrier have an issue with the feature being there, thus, it gets disabled.

Doesnt work with sprint, 3rd party apps are required.

The only company I've found who has no issue with tethering is AT&T, but then they LOVE you to tether so they can charge you insane fees, so... (I think I paid like $2 just for viewing one website when I didnt realize I was roaming onto ATT... x_x )
 
lol ok if you say so.....do you even know how it works on the hd2?

Do you know how it works on Froyo? I happen to know how it works for both. With the HD2, you plug in the USB and select internet sharing. With Froyo, you plug in the USB and select tethering OR you can turn it into a wifi hotspot.

Froyo wins. Both have simple USB tether, but Froyo has wifi hotspot that the HD2 doesn't.
 
lol ok if you say so.....do you even know how it works on the hd2?

lol..... read what I quoted below. He is right on the spot. Froyo tethering is way better, I've had a chance to play around with both.


Do you know how it works on Froyo? I happen to know how it works for both. With the HD2, you plug in the USB and select internet sharing. With Froyo, you plug in the USB and select tethering OR you can turn it into a wifi hotspot.

Froyo wins. Both have simple USB tether, but Froyo has wifi hotspot that the HD2 doesn't.
 
Do you know how it works on Froyo? I happen to know how it works for both. With the HD2, you plug in the USB and select internet sharing. With Froyo, you plug in the USB and select tethering OR you can turn it into a wifi hotspot.

Froyo wins. Both have simple USB tether, but Froyo has wifi hotspot that the HD2 doesn't.

so based upon this you thin froyo is better? lawl okay plug and click is about as easy as it gets........and of course you can do Wifi hotspot with HD2 via third party app so again what's your point?
 
so based upon this you thin froyo is better? lawl okay plug and click is about as easy as it gets........and of course you can do Wifi hotspot with HD2 via third party app so again what's your point?

Yes, because with USB you need drivers. Also you seemed to have missed the part where Froyo does that same thing - plug in a check a box. Likewise, great, a 3rd party program can do wifi hotspot for the HD2, but Froyo has it built in.

It's close, sure, but Froyo takes the win thanks to built in wifi tethering. I'm really not sure why you are even trying to argue it, 'tis simply the facts.
 
Yes, because with USB you need drivers.

This was HELL for me with my Intrepid. No XP drivers, no Mac drivers, and no 64-bit drivers! I literally had no choice but to use bluetooth or wifi (and guess what, 3/4 devices didnt have blue-tooth built in!)

I second, in this arena Froyo clearly wins with built-in WiFi tethering.
 
Yes, because with USB you need drivers. Also you seemed to have missed the part where Froyo does that same thing - plug in a check a box. Likewise, great, a 3rd party program can do wifi hotspot for the HD2, but Froyo has it built in.

It's close, sure, but Froyo takes the win thanks to built in wifi tethering. I'm really not sure why you are even trying to argue it, 'tis simply the facts.

aFive stated

Android 2.2 has built in tethering as well... and it works better.

I just wanted to know why he can state it works better when there is no substance to back it up in his post

I think they work the same because they are both 1 click apps that have absolutely nothing to do with the hardware's ability to effectively get good data rates.....and IMHO wifi sharing is pointless unless you are definately in an area with good 3G signal and can maintain a 4Mbit+ data rate (that is hard to come by in a lot of places as the biggest network complaint is weaksauce coverage no matter who the carrier is)
 
Yes, because with USB you need drivers.

wait wut? plug the phone in and Windows 2K + machines automatically set up the connection.....lawl......Windows already has the required drivers built in to make use tethering..... all the device does is pass along it's abilities to your windows machine and it does the rest...
 
Because it doesn't even need drivers is all. With hd2, you sometimes had to look for drivers prior to tethering actually working. That is why it works better.


aFive stated

Android 2.2 has built in tethering as well... and it works better.

I just wanted to know why he can state it works better when there is no substance to back it up in his post

I think they work the same because they are both 1 click apps that have absolutely nothing to do with the hardware's ability to effectively get good data rates.....and IMHO wifi sharing is pointless unless you are definately in an area with good 3G signal and can maintain a 4Mbit+ data rate (that is hard to come by in a lot of places as the biggest network complaint is weaksauce coverage no matter who the carrier is)
 
I saw a few brief TV sessions about Windows Phone 7. It appears to be quite ok. The 1st impression about the navigation and browsing looks smooth and attractive enough. I though the web experience very sensible probably due to fine-tuning. As a matter of fact I still have occasional pauses in my desktop experience so to see the touch-based mobilephone operations flew smoothly in the demo is rather refreshing.

I understand Iphone/Android/WebOS/Nokia/Sony probably have a lot more features/user-experience. For entry level market, this should be receptive enough for start.

The only thing that I still have question, besides price, is whether MS will offer Apple/Google style update? It seems Iphone/Android phones will at least try to offer free 2 or 3 OS upgrades.

Cheers
 
wait wut? plug the phone in and Windows 2K + machines automatically set up the connection.....lawl......Windows already has the required drivers built in to make use tethering..... all the device does is pass along it's abilities to your windows machine and it does the rest...

And if you plug in to a Mac or Linux computer? Android has you covered there, no problems. What about an iPod Touch? Android has you covered there with wifi tethering.

Not everything runs Windows, has a USB port, and supports WinMo's USB tethering drivers.

IMHO wifi sharing is pointless unless you are definately in an area with good 3G signal and can maintain a 4Mbit+ data rate (that is hard to come by in a lot of places as the biggest network complaint is weaksauce coverage no matter who the carrier is)

So then USB tethering must be worthless unless you are in a good 3G signal and can maintain 4Mbit+, right? :rolleyes:
 
No thanks:

Microsoft has also launched an advertising platform exclusively for the Windows Phone 7 platform. Microsoft's General Manager for Strategy and Business Development, Kostas Mallios, said that Windows Phone 7 will be an "ad-serving machine", pushing advertising and brand-related content to the user. The platform will feature advertising tiles near applications and toast notifications, which will bring updating advertising notifications. Mallios said that Windows Phone 7 will be able to "preserve the brand experience by going directly from the web site right to the application", and that Windows Phone 7 "enables advertisers to connect with consumers over time". Mallios continued: "you're now able to push information as an advertiser, and stay in touch with your customer. It's a dynamic relationship that is created and provides for an ongoing dialog with the consumer."
 
No thanks:

Microsoft has also launched an advertising platform exclusively for the Windows Phone 7 platform. Microsoft's General Manager for Strategy and Business Development, Kostas Mallios, said that Windows Phone 7 will be an "ad-serving machine", pushing advertising and brand-related content to the user.

This is the unfortunate reality of today's smartphone experience. You won't be able to avoid ads no matter what platform you're on--iOS, Android, or WP7.
 
And if you plug in to a Mac or Linux computer? Android has you covered there, no problems. What about an iPod Touch? Android has you covered there with wifi tethering.

Not everything runs Windows, has a USB port, and supports remote NDIS based sharing, right? .


So then USB tethering must be worthless unless you are in a good 3G signal and can maintain 4Mbit+, right? :rolleyes:

had to fix that for you

lol you use a mac you can suffer because you know going in first hand that your choices are going to be limited....and if the Mac does not know how to use remote NDIS not a windows mobile problem is it?

4mbit connection is fine for a single device or 2 but try it with 3 or more and you will run into issues due to lack of bandwidth when you try to do stuff like streaming on multiple devices......

nice try though
 
While WP7 phones look amazing, they are very lacking. I am actually rather disappointed, aside from the way they look ofcourse.

a) Snapdragon CPU which is identical to what Nexus One has... Really? While it may perform well, you won't see HSPA+ on T-mobile... Why would I spend $500 on a device that can't take advantage of their latest network upgrades when I could get an Android alternate with a better CPU and HSPA+ capabilities?

b) Screen is crap compared to current Android offerings. Most screens on launch devices are TFT/LCD and are not nearly as good as AMOLED. There's Dell Venue which does indeed have AMOLED, but that is only one device, which is rather thick too..

c) We knew this stuff, but still sad to hear that WP7 isn't gonna have a navigation, or basic multitasking till early 2011....

d) Keyboard in landscape looks cramped and like crap compared to Android IMO.

While WP7 may end up being great, I don't see that happening in the near future. I think it will need at least 6 months from the launch date in order to be a viable competitor. The mentioned problems are a deal breaker to me.
 
had to fix that for you

lol you use a mac you can suffer because you know going in first hand that your choices are going to be limited....and if the Mac does not know how to use remote NDIS not a windows mobile problem is it?

4mbit connection is fine for a single device or 2 but try it with 3 or more and you will run into issues due to lack of bandwidth when you try to do stuff like streaming on multiple devices......

nice try though

*sigh*

If you're just trolling, good job. If you're willfully ignorant, also a good job.

Seriously, it's simple:

Android supports: USB and Wifi tethering
WinMo supports: USB tethering

When it comes to tethering, Android > WinMo.

You really can't contest that, 'tis simply the facts.

Also, wifi tethering is handy when, say, you don't have a spare USB cable. Wifi tethering has been a godsend even with just a single device because people typically don't carry around random cables. You don't *have* to use more than 1 device for wifi tethering to be superior to USB tethering. You really haven't contested that either, you just sort of weakly claim that it doesn't matter. Well, it *does* matter and it gives Android a definite edge in the tethering category.

Too bad providers suck donkey balls and restrict the hell out of it (this goes for both platforms)
 
Microsoft has also launched an advertising platform exclusively for the Windows Phone 7 platform. Microsoft's General Manager for Strategy and Business Development, Kostas Mallios, said that Windows Phone 7 will be an "ad-serving machine", (...) "enables advertisers to connect with consumers over time". Mallios continued: "you're now able to push information as an advertiser, and stay in touch with your customer. It's a dynamic relationship that is created and provides for an ongoing dialog with the consumer."

Translation:
We're not satisfied with charging you $500 for a phone that lacks features and includes bloatware apps you'll never use, plus charging you another $60+/month for your contract, we're also going to advertise on your device so our sponsors will pay us even more!

(Not that Android is any better, it pushes adds too...)
 
The apps on Android push ads, not the whole OS. Plus the ads are easily blocked.
 
Translation:
We're not satisfied with charging you $500 for a phone that lacks features and includes bloatware apps you'll never use, plus charging you another $60+/month for your contract, we're also going to advertise on your device so our sponsors will pay us even more!

(Not that Android is any better, it pushes adds too...)

Ads make for more developers. You make a lot of money with ads on mobile platforms. More developers = more apps = better platform.
 
Android supports: USB and Wifi tethering
WinMo supports: USB tethering

When it comes to tethering, Android > WinMo.

You really can't contest that, 'tis simply the facts.
Maybe you should do your homework first. Windows Mobile supports USB and bluetooth tethering as well as the ability to act as a wifi access point.
 
Not built in it doesn't.
Even the original 6.1 ROM on my Touch Pro 2 had bluetooth tethering and most newer ones should have the wireless access point functionality as well (integrates nicely into HTC sense as well).
 
As a die hard winmo user, any chance of my buying WP7 died the day MS revealed the UI and feature list. Fuck that.
Now, Android > *
<3 EVO 4G
 
Back
Top