Windows phone 7 vs Android

aFive

2[H]4U
Joined
Nov 4, 2007
Messages
3,637
Just looking for some opinions as to what people think of Windows Phone 7...

I have been an Android user ever since it was released, love the OS. I currently have the Vibrant, and it is indeed a good phone. I was never into IOS for many reasons, so not really interested in that. I have used Win Mo 6.5, but quickly ran back to Android as I hated the way that it was, how unpolished it was, lack of apps, etc. Then came Windows Phone 7...

From everything i see on it, looks as if something i would steer clear from, but it got me interested. I LOVED Zune HD interface, and remember saying that I wish they had a phone with Zune... and guess what? Windows Phone 7 might be that! I was watching an HD7 video, and I gotta admit, looks awesome!

While it is very simplistic and is obviously going to be missing some features which Android already has, I think it could be a really great platform. Ranging from amazing Zune software to a cool interface. Noah @ phonedog said that windows phone 7 UI makes an iphone look like a dinosaur, there might be something to it!

Not looking for a flame on OS's, but what do you think about Windows Phone 7? Excited? Disappointed? Only thing I am not liking so far is lack of multitasking and very very simplistic messaging.
 
Im currently using a HTC HD2. Never owned a HTC before as i owned all iPhone series (2G, 3G, 3GS and 4G).

So far ive learnt how much more you can do with a HTC mobile, let alone the OS on it. HD2 comes with WM 6.1/6.5.

I didn't mind Windows Mobile 6.5 until i installed Android OS on my phone instead. I love android compared to AppleOS and Windows Mobile OS.

But i am looking forward to seeing Windows Mobile 7, as ive heard alot of 'Hype' for it and will be interesting to see how well it runs. But ill always run Android on my mobile now especially if they figured out a way to run it on the NAND instead.

Btw i think WM7 will be pretty big for HTC because most simple/begginer users dont like complicated layouts or settings. Ive seen a video on what its like for customization. It sorta reminds me of the Apple Mobile OS simple-ness but gives a much more stylish look.
 
Im currently using a HTC HD2. Never owned a HTC before as i owned all iPhone series (2G, 3G, 3GS and 4G).

So far ive learnt how much more you can do with a HTC mobile, let alone the OS on it. HD2 comes with WM 6.1/6.5.

I didn't mind Windows Mobile 6.5 until i installed Android OS on my phone instead. I love android compared to AppleOS and Windows Mobile OS.

But i am looking forward to seeing Windows Mobile 7, as ive heard alot of 'Hype' for it and will be interesting to see how well it runs. But ill always run Android on my mobile now especially if they figured out a way to run it on the NAND instead.

Btw i think WM7 will be pretty big for HTC because most simple/begginer users dont like complicated layouts or settings. Ive seen a video on what its like for customization. It sorta reminds me of the Apple Mobile OS simple-ness but gives a much more stylish look.

Oh yea, like I said, WM6.5 is crap compared to Android. Sure, you can do some cool stuff with it, but it is not on the level of an Android OS. I'm sure it is all subjective, but to an average user....

What Windows Phone 7 has is what Apple brought to the table when Iphone first came out. When compared to the competition, it may be lacking some features, apps. But, the interface is simply sweet looking in my opinion, that is what has gotten me interested in it.

While I love Android, I am very curious to check out a new OS, and a new device.
 
I've owned 2 winmo phones, neither ever got an update to a newer winmo version. As such, I won't consider running Windows Phone 7 until MS has demonstrated that they actually intend to support and continue with the platform.

That said, I'm excited to see what they've done with the UI, even though I have no intention of actually buying one.
 
...I won't consider running Windows Phone 7 until MS has demonstrated that they actually intend to support and continue with the platform.

Exactly!

I'm enjoying Android on my HD2 because there's a ton of support, even if most of the apps are craptastic.
 
I've owned 2 winmo phones, neither ever got an update to a newer winmo version. As such, I won't consider running Windows Phone 7 until MS has demonstrated that they actually intend to support and continue with the platform.

That said, I'm excited to see what they've done with the UI, even though I have no intention of actually buying one.

That's true, look at Kin even... They promised a Market with apps in the near future, but instead, abandoned the platform completely. Android already has more features than WinMo, by the time Windows Phone 7 releases and all of the bugs begin to get ironed out, we will have Android 3.0.. lol
 
I'm going to have to wait to use it before I pass judgement. I'm hoping that it will be able to compete with iOS and Android, but from the looks of it, it will be a pretty limited platform (at least in vanilla flavors). Honestly, my gut is telling me that they're WAY too late to the game to play catchup.

especially when they're releasing it OOTB with less features and incentive to buy than it's biggest competitors. It took Android quite some time to catch up to iOS sales (and they had better features out of the box, IMO, than iOS did) and now MS has to do the same with less? I just don't see it happening. Hopefully I'm wrong, because I really want a good solid windows phone, but Microsofts track record hasn't been great lately, especially with portable devices.
 
WP7 has great potential. The question is whether or not MS keeps up support like Apple does with iOS and Google does with Android.

Personally I don't think I'll ever abandon Android because I love the modding community too much, but WP7 would be viable for my wife. I loathe, hate, despise, and hope Facebook dies but my wife uses it every day. WP7 looks to be amazing for things like that.

Again the catch will be whether or not Microsoft lives up to their promise of support.
 
I've owned 2 winmo phones, neither ever got an update to a newer winmo version. As such, I won't consider running Windows Phone 7 until MS has demonstrated that they actually intend to support and continue with the platform.

That said, I'm excited to see what they've done with the UI, even though I have no intention of actually buying one.

WinMo has had incremental updates... Its up to your carrier to release them for your specific phone... Or, take the initiative and look for ROMs to upgrade and tweak your phone.
 
As much as I like my Zune HD, I don't think that it is can convince me to switch over to WP7 day one. It seems that while MS often makes great products, it takes quite a while for third party support to build. I know this is a problem that they are working to avoid, but I don't think that it will be completely solved by launch.

If you look at past devices and OS's, it's taken a bit of time for other companies to get in line with what MS is doing. The Kin was already mentioned as having a lack of support, but the same can be said of the Zune HD (in terms of apps). Even when Vista came out, I know I was frustrated by the absolutely horrible drivers Nvidia had until months after release.

Phone 7 itself looks pretty great. I love the UI, and I like that there will be integrated Zune and Xbox sections. Hell, I like the on-screen keyboard on my Zune HD more than the stock Android one. I just don't foresee it having enough support out of the gate to draw me away from the (now) fully developed and supported OS that is Android.

I probably would have felt the same way if I was going from the IPhone to Android 1.0, but fortunately I was going from a Blackberry Pearl to a G1, so at worst it was a move sideways, not down.

For me, personally, as interesting as it looks, I see no reason to jump from Android to a new platform when there are phones like the Vibrant, G2 and upcoming "MyTouch". It's not like these new Windows phones will have a large (if any) spec advantage over any Android phones. The way I see it, if you are on T-Mobile or ATT there is little incentive to switch as you have either the Vibrant/G2/MyTouch or Captivate/IPhone. I don't believe Phone 7 will be out for CMDA carriers until early 2011, so maybe things will change by then.

Long story short, I probably won't seriously consider WP7 until around the holidays in 2011.
 
WinMo has had incremental updates... Its up to your carrier to release them for your specific phone... Or, take the initiative and look for ROMs to upgrade and tweak your phone.

IMO custom ROMs are for getting early upgrades and/or new features, not for making up for the complete lack of official updates.

I know some phones have gotten updates, but I don't know of any that have gone from, say, WinMo 6 to 6.5 officially, and if there are any they are the exception. These days that just isn't good enough anymore, and my WinMo phone was replaced with a Moto Droid a year ago - no regrets whatsoever.
 
As much as I like my Zune HD, I don't think that it is can convince me to switch over to WP7 day one. It seems that while MS often makes great products, it takes quite a while for third party support to build. I know this is a problem that they are working to avoid, but I don't think that it will be completely solved by launch.

If you look at past devices and OS's, it's taken a bit of time for other companies to get in line with what MS is doing. The Kin was already mentioned as having a lack of support, but the same can be said of the Zune HD (in terms of apps). Even when Vista came out, I know I was frustrated by the absolutely horrible drivers Nvidia had until months after release.

Phone 7 itself looks pretty great. I love the UI, and I like that there will be integrated Zune and Xbox sections. Hell, I like the on-screen keyboard on my Zune HD more than the stock Android one. I just don't foresee it having enough support out of the gate to draw me away from the (now) fully developed and supported OS that is Android.

I probably would have felt the same way if I was going from the IPhone to Android 1.0, but fortunately I was going from a Blackberry Pearl to a G1, so at worst it was a move sideways, not down.

For me, personally, as interesting as it looks, I see no reason to jump from Android to a new platform when there are phones like the Vibrant, G2 and upcoming "MyTouch". It's not like these new Windows phones will have a large (if any) spec advantage over any Android phones. The way I see it, if you are on T-Mobile or ATT there is little incentive to switch as you have either the Vibrant/G2/MyTouch or Captivate/IPhone. I don't believe Phone 7 will be out for CMDA carriers until early 2011, so maybe things will change by then.

Long story short, I probably won't seriously consider WP7 until around the holidays in 2011.

Well. they have already confirmed that T-Mobile is going to have some sort of Windows Phone 7 announcement on October 11th when ATT is supposed to announce something big. It look as if Tmobile is going to be at least getting the HD7 this year, with something coming around the same time to ATT. It also seems as if Windows Phone 7 is not going to Verizon, nor Sprint this year.

Zune HD was great, but like you said, lack of apps. It didn't have anything months after release, broken promises.... They seem to want to do things right with Windows Phone 7, but you're right, may not happen. Even with Google being behind it, the first year, nobody even really cared about it. Lacking apps, low user base.

What I am wondering is if WP7 may actually do good if Microsoft supports it properly. Why? Because they may be launching on many carriers, versus just one that Android was launched on in US.
 
I've owned 2 winmo phones, neither ever got an update to a newer winmo version. As such, I won't consider running Windows Phone 7 until MS has demonstrated that they actually intend to support and continue with the platform.

Just to be clear on this issue, this was not MS's fault, so much as it was the phone manufacturers that didn't update their devices for the updated versions of winmo.
I remember my HTC Touch Pro had windows updates on it, only because HTC actually kept up with Microsoft's updates to the OS

If Asus releases a mobo that came out when XP was available but doesn't update the board's drivers when Vista comes out, is that MS's fault too?



I know some phones have gotten updates, but I don't know of any that have gone from, say, WinMo 6 to 6.5 officially

The Samsung Blackjack is one that comes to mind as I've dealt with it personally.

Again, the update was possible only because Samsung made it possible. Had nothing to do with Microsoft
 
Last edited:
Oh yea, like I said, WM6.5 is crap compared to Android. Sure, you can do some cool stuff with it, but it is not on the level of an Android OS. I'm sure it is all subjective, but to an average user....

What Windows Phone 7 has is what Apple brought to the table when Iphone first came out. When compared to the competition, it may be lacking some features, apps. But, the interface is simply sweet looking in my opinion, that is what has gotten me interested in it.

While I love Android, I am very curious to check out a new OS, and a new device.

what do you mean on the same level? I could care less what OS my phone runs as long as it does what it is intended to do........
 
Am I the only one who things the square boxes on the Windows phones look ugly?
 
I'm currently a windows mobile 6.1 user, I've tried 6.5 but had issues with it on my phone so went back. I've been contemplating either going with Android or Windows Phone 7 and if it helps, I think I'm going to choose Android.

Windows Phone 7 looks phenomenal, but right now there are no apps and an indication it will take a while to match iphone and androids selection. Unlocking seems to be iffy since we don't know what sets are coming precisely and how long it will take. Then who knows if the set will be rooted or whatever you want to call it -

Soooo personally I think I'm going to go with Android, probably an HTC Desire and right now I'm just waiting to see if I can get a discount of some kind with my provider - therefore I'll be able to unlock, root and load the phone how I want from day 1.
 
what do you mean on the same level? I could care less what OS my phone runs as long as it does what it is intended to do........

I could care less about what OS my phone has either, so long that it does what I need it to do.... well.... Yes, Windows Mobile 6.5 can do many things, but at the end of the day it is ugly, not very user intuitive, and laggy in some areas. It's like me running Windows XP as it does everything I need it to do. I don't want to run it as I have options such as Windows 7 Out there....
Am I the only one who things the square boxes on the Windows phones look ugly?

That was my first impression too. But then I remembered how much I liked Zune, and the newer videos of it I've seen look very modern IMO.
 
Just to be clear on this issue, this was not MS's fault, so much as it was the phone manufacturers that didn't update their devices for the updated versions of winmo.
I remember my HTC Touch Pro had windows updates on it, only because HTC actually kept up with Microsoft's updates to the OS

If Asus releases a mobo that came out when XP was available but doesn't update the board's drivers when Vista comes out, is that MS's fault too?





The Samsung Blackjack is one that comes to mind as I've dealt with it personally.

Again, the update was possible only because Samsung made it possible. Had nothing to do with Microsoft

Yes and no. MS didn't push for vendors to keep their phones updated, and I think they actually charged them to update. I don't think it was free for vendors to update. THAT is definitely MS's fault.

Likewise, much of it is MS's fault since MS just didn't make many updates in the first place. There was what, a 2 year gap between WinMo 5 and 6? Then another year to get to 6.1 and yet another year to get to 6.5.

Also, a quick google search shows the HTC Touch Pro launching with Win Mo 6.1 Pro, which is also supposedly it's current OS. That would be no updates. It looks like HTC released updates for it's stuff (like HTC's custom touch layer), but WinMo itself wasn't updated. Since HTC seemed willing to keep updating the ROM with newer versions of it's custom extras, I'm going to guess that updating the Win Mo version isn't as straightforward as one would hope, and definitely not as easy for vendors to update as, say, Android.
 
Tl;dr

I will agree with the OP that the number of applications (especially free ones) is much more limited on the WM/PPC platform. As for the interface, I could take it or leave it (you think 6.5 was bad? you should have tried PPC OS 2.0!) I've been a M$ fanboy since my old M$-DOS PC and my Axim X5.

But not anymore...

When I heard all the "un-needed features" that were stripped from WP7 (like tethering! I eat, sleep, and breethe the internet (not to mention use it to keep tabs on servers) so I cannot live without this feature --- whole reason my netbook is running XP instead of a much more modern Linux OS - linux did not support Bluetooth tethering w/o manually-written shell scripts) I started looking for alternatives...

I took advantage of Sprint's offer Oct 1st to upgrade to a new smartphone for $10/$20 more I went with an Android Phone (HTC's EVO 4G) and I had few expectations, honestly I expected to call them up by friday and say "switch me back to my Intrepid (WM 6.5)" but wow! I'm blown away! I love the android OS, it's features, and it's HUGE app store of free apps! Unless Google decides to pull a M$ and remove a load of features, I dont see myself going back to WP7/8/9/etc ever... (hell with WiFi tethering I may even convert my PCs over to linux and tell M$ where to get off!)

The interface is just eye-candy, I can install a custom launcher and do whatever I want with it, What I care about is the Core OS, and M$ decided to rape all their business customers with WP7, which I feel is a financial suicide (what're they thinking? "We'll steal _all_ of Apple's Customers!"? not with WM7, which is even more crippled than iOS!)

Honestly, I'm just waiting for Billy's little empire to start crumbling now, this is the first blow and I hope more people will demand a better OS.
 
Being an early adopter of WP7 will be as painful as being an early adopter of any mobile OS--a few missing features and very few apps at launch. But if you can live without the missing features (most of which the average user doesn't care about), don't worry about apps because I believe developer support for WP7 will be massive within a few months of launch. Microsoft have made it very easy for competent .NET developers to transition from web and/or desktop development to mobile app development with a set of free tools, and WP7 leverages existing .NET knowledge to make the learning curve fairly easy for programmers who already have .NET skills. There will be plenty of quality apps soon enough.

WP7 is also designed with a completely different experience in mind compared to iOS and Android. iOS and Android are very much app-based--click here to launch this app, then launch that app, etc. WP7 is designed around tasks/categories of tasks. The idea is to present logical groupings of tasks and make it as easy as possible to navigate intuitively instead of trying to figure out what app does what. I don't see this as better or worse necessarily--just different.

I think WP7 will be successful, but my definition of success is different from the typical frothing-at-the-mouth fanboy. WP7 doesn't have to beat down iOS and Android to be a success. It just has to gain a solid market share and continue to improve and stay relevant as existing OSes continue to improve down the road. I think it'll manage this easily. I expect it to get a lot of enterprise support with its strong Outlook integration, and that's a pretty big market right there. Then there are end users who are intimidated by Android and want a more streamlined and polished experience. For those customers WP7 will be fighting iOS, and I'm not sure how well it'll fare there. The iOS brainwashing is strong indeed.

To those who think WP7 arrives too late, I can only point to the fact that we're on the very front end of a smartphone explosion. The market isn't even close to being saturated, and WP7 arrives just in time to grab some of those new smartphone users along with users of other OSes who are looking for something different, not to mention any WM6.x users who were holding out for WP7. I'd be shocked if WP7 doesn't establish a solid foothold in the market and gain good market share. This is not the Kin, folks. Microsoft tasted success in the mobile market before, and they will be putting a lot of marketing and development support muscle behind this platform.

For me, I still haven't decided between WP7 and Android. I might end up with both as I'm a .NET developer but really like the openness of Android.
 
That's exactly the thing, it just has to work. Android has some issues with T-Mobile at least, ran into them with every Android phone i've had. Could be just carrier, but I do kind of want something new and different. Also am curious to see what new WP7 has to bring, I kind of dig the interface, which is huge to me. I really liked my Vibrant, but it was a little buggy still :(. I do miss it though, am gonna wait till WP7 announcement/new Tmobile phones prior to getting a new one.
 
from what i have sen, in many ways wp7 appears to be a giant step backwords compared to winmo 6.5
 
Avoid WP7, for a while at least IMO. All the early reports come with huge negatives. I'm a huge mobile geek. Started back in the 90's with Palm Pilot Personal and I've been through it all. From Symbian, to WM, to iOS, to Android. Currently using a HD2, Samsung Galaxy S and iPhone 3GS on 3 different networks.

I'm not going to do a review or anything, there's tons of that out there, but for comparison's sake, the HD2 is my favorite phone (Dolphin is a nice browser but Opera mobile, not mini, is so superior IMO) however with WM dead and buried that is a moot point. iPhone is a nice toy for kids that need mommy to tell them what they can do with their toys. It has a lot of games and is just that, a child's toy. Android is experiencing some growing pains but is the best platform today. WP7 is missing everything from sideloading to multitasking and they are playing Apple's "mommy told me not to do that with my phone" game. So if you like having "mommy" around, you'd be better off with an iPhone than WP7; but between Android and WP7 there is no competition, yet anyway. Maybe later MS will get its house in order but for now if you are not a huge mobile geek and run with multiple phones, WP7 is not for you except MS fans and, possibly, people with low end mobile function needs.

If you are a person who likes to wait, I'd keep an eye on HP's upcoming WebOS phone. Finally WebOS is going to get a phone with some decent specs. Of all the modern OSes, I like WebOS the best, but its low end hardware (eg Pre) and lack of developer base make it impossible to defend.Its possible with an upcoming tablet and a competitive phone, WebOS might put their leg in the race, maybe.
 
Last edited:
Avoid WP7, for a while at least IMO. All the early reports come with huge negatives.....

Care to elaborate on that statement?..I have followed the W7 scene since it was first spoken about and would love to know what reports have huge negatives in them. Most pre reviews including Engadget, which is pretty exhaustive and dated way back to July are mostly positive. I have gone from Iphone to Nexus One and currently on a Moto X, which I happen to think is a piece of junk. The problem for me with Android is its all over the place. The N1 is pure Android, but most others are flavored by the Manufacturer or Mobile provider...so for me at least the experience is different on each set of phones. While customization is certainly fun and so are a million apps, first and foremost I just want my phone to do the basics, without following guides at XDA on how to remove features that I feel impedes that. I am definitely replacing my X with a new W7 phone and Im looking forward to trying it out. If it fails me, well whatever..I will sell it and go back to the N1...or G2?
 
Early reports are meaningless since nobody actually has done a real review of Windows Phone 7 on a production level device as of this date. In a few more days, after the introduction on Monday, we'll start to see real reviews but honestly, I never ever buy anything based on a review. I never have, I never will, because the only person that can ever truly offer opinions that matter on a device is me - and that goes for every other person as well.

I picked up an HTC HD2 lately for a decent price, and while I have zero qualms with Windows Mobile 6.5 (it does what I require, and that's all I need), I have been playing around with the multitude of Android ROMs that can easily be fired up on the HD2 as well. I don't find Android particularly appealing, actually. It's neat and everything, and being able to run it on the HD2 at performance levels that exceed some actual Android-from-the-factory devices (with the HyperDroid ROM on it, this thing is nearly 50% more responsive and 'faster' than a Nexus One running the same OS based on benchmarks), but I don't run it nearly as often as Windows Mobile 6.5.

Who knows... been using "PDAs" for 15+ years now, Windows Mobile has always done what I need it to do, but I'm not sure if I'm game for Windows Phone 7 since WM6.5 is so useful to me. I've owned a Zune HD in the recent past, didn't find it particularly appealing because I require more from such a device, hence getting rid of it and sticking with my Axim X51v that I've used for the 6+ years that I've owned it.

The HD2 was and still is the first device I've found that has actually had me using it more than my Axim, so that's a big plus for the HD2 in my situation. iPhones, iPod touchs, those things bore me these days because they're not much fun unless they're Jailbroken and I can do what I want. The HD2 will probably see a ported Windows Phone 7 ROM at some point once the HD3/HD7 gets released so we'll see what happens.

Would be killer to be able to run WM6.5, WP7, or any Android version I want all on the same device just because I can... ;)

Just noted that someone created a list of all the current Android ROMs one can run on the HD2, check this out:

http://android.hd2roms.com/

That's even more stuff going on than I've been able to do over the years with my Axim and the multitude of WM ROMs that are floating around. This HD2 truly is an exceptional piece of hardware...

Edit:
Just to clarify, they're "builds" meaning they run off the microSD card - ROMs would be actual code applied to the device's NAND internal memory so, might as well be technically accurate. :D
 
Just looking for some opinions as to what people think of Windows Phone 7...

I have been an Android user ever since it was released, love the OS. I currently have the Vibrant, and it is indeed a good phone. I was never into IOS for many reasons, so not really interested in that. I have used Win Mo 6.5, but quickly ran back to Android as I hated the way that it was, how unpolished it was, lack of apps, etc. Then came Windows Phone 7...

From everything i see on it, looks as if something i would steer clear from, but it got me interested. I LOVED Zune HD interface, and remember saying that I wish they had a phone with Zune... and guess what? Windows Phone 7 might be that! I was watching an HD7 video, and I gotta admit, looks awesome!

While it is very simplistic and is obviously going to be missing some features which Android already has, I think it could be a really great platform. Ranging from amazing Zune software to a cool interface. Noah @ phonedog said that windows phone 7 UI makes an iphone look like a dinosaur, there might be something to it!

Not looking for a flame on OS's, but what do you think about Windows Phone 7? Excited? Disappointed? Only thing I am not liking so far is lack of multitasking and very very simplistic messaging.

WP7 will be decent...but it doesn't offer anything over Android. I don't like the Zune interface, but that's personal preference really. If you like the icon/label based launcher, I've already seen easy to do customizations of Android launchers that make Android look much like WP7.

At best, WP7 will have some gimmicks for Xbox Live users(like myself) but nothing that I will care enough about to give up the customization and power Android has.

I used WinMo and I liked it generally, until about 9 months after having my Qtek 8310 and Windows would crash all the time and slow down for no apparent reason. Hopefully Microsoft will get it right this time...but I don't see it offering anything over Android.

Either way competition is good! Next year is going to be insane for mobile phones...Android vs iOS vs WP7 vs BB6 vs WebOS vs MeeGo





Early reports are meaningless since nobody actually has done a real review of Windows Phone 7 on a production level device as of this date. In a few more days, after the introduction on Monday, we'll start to see real reviews but honestly, I never ever buy anything based on a review. I never have, I never will, because the only person that can ever truly offer opinions that matter on a device is me - and that goes for every other person as well.

I picked up an HTC HD2 lately for a decent price, and while I have zero qualms with Windows Mobile 6.5 (it does what I require, and that's all I need), I have been playing around with the multitude of Android ROMs that can easily be fired up on the HD2 as well. I don't find Android particularly appealing, actually. It's neat and everything, and being able to run it on the HD2 at performance levels that exceed some actual Android-from-the-factory devices (with the HyperDroid ROM on it, this thing is nearly 50% more responsive and 'faster' than a Nexus One running the same OS based on benchmarks), but I don't run it nearly as often as Windows Mobile 6.5.

Who knows... been using "PDAs" for 15+ years now, Windows Mobile has always done what I need it to do, but I'm not sure if I'm game for Windows Phone 7 since WM6.5 is so useful to me. I've owned a Zune HD in the recent past, didn't find it particularly appealing because I require more from such a device, hence getting rid of it and sticking with my Axim X51v that I've used for the 6+ years that I've owned it.

The HD2 was and still is the first device I've found that has actually had me using it more than my Axim, so that's a big plus for the HD2 in my situation. iPhones, iPod touchs, those things bore me these days because they're not much fun unless they're Jailbroken and I can do what I want. The HD2 will probably see a ported Windows Phone 7 ROM at some point once the HD3/HD7 gets released so we'll see what happens.

Would be killer to be able to run WM6.5, WP7, or any Android version I want all on the same device just because I can... ;)

Just noted that someone created a list of all the current Android ROMs one can run on the HD2, check this out:

http://android.hd2roms.com/

That's even more stuff going on than I've been able to do over the years with my Axim and the multitude of WM ROMs that are floating around. This HD2 truly is an exceptional piece of hardware...

Edit:
Just to clarify, they're "builds" meaning they run off the microSD card - ROMs would be actual code applied to the device's NAND internal memory so, might as well be technically accurate. :D

The HD2 is the best WinMo phone and it took a very very long time to get it to run as good as it does on it. However, the EVO 4G which is basically an HD2 looks quite similar as it also has SenseUI but runs sooo much better as it's Android and not WinMo. I hope the HD2 gets WP7 ROMs, it will be a shame if it doesn't.

That said, I'ld love to run WP7 on an Android phone, sounds like fun.


What about Android don't you find particularly appealing? And where did you read about it being 50% more response than the Nexus? I don't even see how that's possible haha.
 
I used WinMo and I liked it generally, until about 9 months after having my Qtek 8310 and Windows would crash all the time and slow down for no apparent reason. Hopefully Microsoft will get it right this time...but I don't see it offering anything over Android.

This is something that I hated about WM6.5, and I kept assuming it was _my_ fault. Phone would take upto 2 minutes to launch an application that normally launched in 2 seconds (worst culpret was the messaging program, especially if I had >50 messages) Since moving to android I've not run into this... yet... *knock on wood*
 
Early reports are meaningless since nobody actually has done a real review of Windows Phone 7 on a production level device as of this date.

while this is true, information cam be gathered from MS directly and developers indicate that the platform has several shortcomings

1. no copy paste
2. no tethering
3. no 3rd party preemtive multitasking
4. phone and sd card storage apper as one medium
5. inability to really customize the os to a particular brand (like HTC)
 
Care to elaborate on that statement?..I have followed the W7 scene since it was first spoken about and would love to know what reports have huge negatives in them. Most pre reviews including Engadget, which is pretty exhaustive and dated way back to July are mostly positive. I have gone from Iphone to Nexus One and currently on a Moto X, which I happen to think is a piece of junk. The problem for me with Android is its all over the place. The N1 is pure Android, but most others are flavored by the Manufacturer or Mobile provider...so for me at least the experience is different on each set of phones. While customization is certainly fun and so are a million apps, first and foremost I just want my phone to do the basics, without following guides at XDA on how to remove features that I feel impedes that. I am definitely replacing my X with a new W7 phone and Im looking forward to trying it out. If it fails me, well whatever..I will sell it and go back to the N1...or G2?


Ditto! While I do see shortcomings which I have quoted below, many "geeks" actually give it positive reviews. PhoneDog is a pretty big one and I trust their point of view, Noah really likes it. Engadget had a lot of positive on it, minus the whole no multitasking thing. PhoneArena was also very positive on it.

Problem with Android right now is that it is too open. Google allowed manufacturers to do whatever with their OS, which resulted in lots of issues. From HTC releasing phones such as MyTouch 3g Vanilla which were very very very laggy even with custom roms due to insufficient hardware. To companies such as Samsung throwing a buggy TouchWiz on the Behold 2 to make it super slow and not releasing promised upgrades.

When a new OS such as Android releases, it REQUIRES updates. With lots and lots of phones on the market, Google will find bigs, they will find things they want to change, some changes to improve user experience. All of those changes are important in order to help the platform move forward. With manufacturers reluctant to release updates due to them not being able to update their android overlay on time, you end up with inferior device.

Nexus one basically set a standard of what Android phones should have, hardware wise at least. Since then, we've seen devices which are capable of running Android without many issues. Aside from the buggy android skins manufacturer decides to throw.

While I don't agree with one device for all mentality. it does have huge benefits. IOS is that, one device for all. Apple can then make user experience identical across the board, eliminating many of the issues your average smartphone user has.

Take a look at Galaxy S phones. Amazing devices with amazing screen... Problems everywhere though, from lag in all apps, to broken GPS. Is it all fixable? YES! Can you fix it? YES! How? Search forums, install lag fixes, install GPS fixes or now the update for the GPS. Your average user will just consider the device broken and won't even dig for the solution. Iphone doesn't have that, primarily because platform is not segregated the way Android is.

that's the story with most Android phones for you. Can make them amazing, but for most of the devices, some digging around is required in order to make them that. Stock, not really. Even the Nexus One had to be rooted to allow it to use all of its ram... prior to 2.2 that is.

What does WP7 have on Android? The way Msoft is requiring their manufacturers to handle their OS. Bingo! Baseline requirements which are actually good! No overlay over OS is a good thing for me, because most of the overlays over Android that I have seen are a total fail and a lot of the people I see, prefer stock! Baseline hardware, baseline resolution, baseline button layout... All of those things basically allow WP7 to offer pretty good user experience across the board, no matter the device. That is why I think it will be good. Sure, some features, such as the ones quoted below, are missing.... But, with time, they may add them. And to me, platform looks pretty good right now, aside from no multitasking.... That's a true shame, I always listen to Pandora/Slacker while playing with my phone, not being able to do that is a deal breaker to me.

while this is true, information cam be gathered from MS directly and developers indicate that the platform has several shortcomings

1. no copy paste
2. no tethering
3. no 3rd party preemtive multitasking
4. phone and sd card storage apper as one medium
5. inability to really customize the os to a particular brand (like HTC)
 
while this is true, information cam be gathered from MS directly and developers indicate that the platform has several shortcomings

1. no copy paste
2. no tethering
3. no 3rd party preemtive multitasking
4. phone and sd card storage apper as one medium
5. inability to really customize the os to a particular brand (like HTC)

All of those are correct. But how many people really care about any of those? Us nerds do of course, but the general populace? They bought the original iPhone with all of those shortcomings, even without the huge warehouse of apps available now on the App Store. These factors will not stop the general public from buying WP7. Marketing is everything, and early indications point to MS putting a ton of marketing muscle behind WP7.
 
One of the reasons I got my HD2 was because you COULD tether it and the fact that I like the phone's Sense UI interface..

People will care about the SD card issue when they try to upgrade the storage card and find out that you can't use the phone outside of emergency calls until you repair the problem (not even sure if you will be able to put the card back in and have it work again).
 
What SD/microSD card issue? I know that HTC is doing a "recall" of sorts on the factory microSD cards by issuing replacements, just requires a phone call. There's more info in the XDA-Developers thread at:

http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=796159

including the number in the first post. So far I haven't had issues with this card in this HD2 I got recently, and the assumption is that it's the factory card as the previous owner didn't really have anything on it aside from the Transformers movies and a few pictures he'd taken (obviously not a hard core user) whereas I've been putting all sorts of stuff on it, deleting it, replacing it, etc in the 3+ weeks that I've owned it.

I figure I'll call later today and see if they'll ship me a new microSD card as well. No I'm not the original owner or buyer of the phone but it shouldn't matter I suppose. I haven't noticed any issues so far with this one but, if they're sending a new one at no charge, it can't hurt.

</off_topic>
 
What SD/microSD card issue? I know that HTC is doing a "recall" of sorts on the factory microSD cards by issuing replacements, just requires a phone call. There's more info in the XDA-Developers thread at:

http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=796159

including the number in the first post. So far I haven't had issues with this card in this HD2 I got recently, and the assumption is that it's the factory card as the previous owner didn't really have anything on it aside from the Transformers movies and a few pictures he'd taken (obviously not a hard core user) whereas I've been putting all sorts of stuff on it, deleting it, replacing it, etc in the 3+ weeks that I've owned it.

I figure I'll call later today and see if they'll ship me a new microSD card as well. No I'm not the original owner or buyer of the phone but it shouldn't matter I suppose. I haven't noticed any issues so far with this one but, if they're sending a new one at no charge, it can't hurt.

</off_topic>

you misread what I said

In WP7 the phones's internal memory and the SD card are presented as one storage medium so if you remove the SD card to upgrade it, you will break the phone until you restore the device or reset it with the new sd card in place and restore it
 
you misread what I said

In WP7 the phones's internal memory and the SD card are presented as one storage medium so if you remove the SD card to upgrade it, you will break the phone until you restore the device or reset it with the new sd card in place and restore it

I actually see this as less of an issue than the lack of features. With the new "standard" of placing the SD card under the battery, it's unlikely that the average user (or even many "power users" will be changing it, especially if it's adequately large (discounting movies/music, I used a 512mb card in my old Axim for all apps and most of my data - an 8 or 16gb card today should be more than adequate for the average user)

Now if the manufacturer makes the SD card easy to access... then yes... all hell will break loose...
 
you misread what I said

In WP7 the phones's internal memory and the SD card are presented as one storage medium so if you remove the SD card to upgrade it, you will break the phone until you restore the device or reset it with the new sd card in place and restore it

Oh, well, yeah, but that's not broken as you seemed to be implying, it's by design. ;) Sounds weird but it's true, unfortunately.

I think I'll be sticking with this HD2 for many years to come. :D
 
Oh, well, yeah, but that's not broken as you seemed to be implying, it's by design. ;) Sounds weird but it's true, unfortunately.

I think I'll be sticking with this HD2 for many years to come. :D

I know it's by design but it definately is going to appear to be broken from a customer point of view....

and like you I will be sticking with the HD2 for a very long time (until it quits working)
 
Back
Top