Windows 8 Release Preview Review

Perhaps because you did not make that as a point, but instead just pointed fingers. Since you can see it from both sides, if I read it correctly, then I retract what I said.

Any side of this isn't the one true path towards Windows 8 glorification/defecation. I know that I've taken the side of "not happy one damn bit" with Metro but people are entitled to have any opinion they choose about it. Seeing how much people entirely defend Metro is a bit jarring at points despite the negatives surrounding it, which is what I honestly pointed out about those two [H]ers. They tend to have a large amount of frequent flyer miles with any Windows 8 thread. Nothing wrong with passion for something but appearing as uberfans isn't always a good thing. :)
 
Why isn't it bad change? Because all your devices can become synced (if you want it), and everywhere you go you will get a familiar UI. Here are some things that can make the start screen superior to the start menu on a desktop computer:

1. The start screen can hold more tiles/shortcuts than the start menu can (pinned).
2. Live tiles can provide you info on you calendar events, email, the weather, your common stocks, without having to visit 5 different websites, load outlook, etc.
3. The Windows Store provides a centralized place to get access to legitimate applications (as opposed to malware). The store obviously will have Metro apps, but will also allow you to search for desktop apps (won't provide downloads, but will provide links to the developer's download page)
4. The majority of users who use computers use them solely for consumption (when they aren't at work). These users can benefit from the rich security model of Metro apps, because they all live in a sandboxed environment.

And why doesn't Microsoft just let you turn Metro off? Why not bring back the classic start menu from Windows 95? Non sarcastically, if they kept in the start menu a large number of people would simply turn off Metro without even trying it.

Also, I have read through your complaints you have given, and the primary one seems to be cost of training. However, very few companies will be upgrading to W8, with or without Metro, because it simply doesn't fit their upgrade cycle.

I don't want a familiar UI if it makes the experience on one of my primary devices worse. Universal UI's to fit products that do completely different things suck.

1) Between the task bar and start menu I have everything I need while maintaining a clean desktop. I use far more programs than the average person, so the tiles of metro aren't a benefit if that is the argument. If anything they just take up more unnecessary space and once again, Do not justify lack of choice.

2) I don't need weatherbug built into windows..Again, doesn't justify lack of choice.

3) I don't need a UI change to access an app store.

4) Big assumption that the majority of users benefit from metro.

None of those reasons justify why I don't have a choice. If they know that a large number of people would just turn it off, that is the first hint that the design is bad. A well designed interface encourages people to use it even if they have a choice. A Shitty design requries all users to be forced because they know no one will otherwise.

Metro is Bulky, ugly and offers zero benefit to the desktop experience. There is absolutely no justification for MS cramming it down our throats and not giving any choice.
 
Whether or not MS has been force feeding BS down the pipelines for years isn't the point. I still find Metro way abhorrent than start menu ever has been. I actually use RocketDock & taskbar-pinned shortcuts more often than the start menu in 7 anyways. Metro is very tablet & phone centric, which is why I'm not at all happy with it on the desktop. I don't mind change at all but when it comes like a thief in the night & steals the more from the desktop than what I'd care for, it's a definite negative change.

I've spent a lot of time thinking about Metro's "appropriateness" on a desktop with a mouse and keyboard. It's ultimately a matter of opinion and one's biases and comfort level. I'm not saying that Metro is perfect on the desktop but I don't see the Start Menu as the ultimate in desktop appropriateness either. It's pretty small and even with a mouse takes some effort to target accurately.
 
Metro is Bulky, ugly and offers zero benefit to the desktop experience. There is absolutely no justification for MS cramming it down our throats and not giving any choice.

Amen. I hate the ugly XBox 360 interface, I hate my wife's ugly Windows Phone interface so I surely hate Metro UI. I tried it. I hated it. I will never use this on my desktop PC. Guess I will either stick to Win 7 or move to Linux and I have bought and used every single version of windows since 3.11. It's a shame Microsoft basically said F*** You!! to desktop users. I already have a start screen. It's called a desktop and if I wanted it cluttered with a bunch of apps and crap I can do that now. I choose not to. In my opinion this is absolutely the worst working and looking version of Windows ever and that includes ME and it was crap.
 
But it's even more than convergence. Touch is simply a first class input method with Windows now. The other side of the argument is that why should a PC be an exception in the land of computing devices? It's not a desktop, or a laptop, or a tablet, its a PC that should be able to take the shape and size and utilize common input methods.
Well that is convergence :p

Why should a PC be an exception? Because it's a different device, it's a productivity device and it's the most flexible device as well, it has greater precision with a mouse than a touch interface and has more screen real estate than a phone or portable tablet, so its interface should not be limited by that.

Take Office, I'd love to see a good phone and tablet version of office, but I sure as fuck don't want it to be the same interface as my desktop has. The ribbon alone takes up more space than a phone screen has. Nor do I want my desktop Office to be limited by what my phone can do.

Or CAD programs, I'd love some part viewers for my phone so when someone sends me CAD I can just open it and preview it on my phone, or save some of my CAD to my phone (or cloud storage) and show people without having to drag them to my office to see it on my desktop. That does NOT mean I want UGS NX on my phone, nor do I want NX on my desktop limited by my phone's interface, they should be unique programs with unique interfaces.

So then the question arises, if I want different programs on my tablet or my phone to what I have on my desktop (though still able to access and read the same files) why do I want the same operating system or OS UI as well? Answer: I don't.

I just don't see this ideal of common input methods for different devices that you see, so I want the option to stick to my good old optimised-for-mouse-and-keyboard interfaces.

And while I understand your point Windows has always been about one size fits all when it comes to the desktop and never been very customizable and indeed very few people do customize Windows beyond wallpapers and other minor tweaks. Definitely not to the point of having different UIs based on input methods.
Windows has never been very customisable, but they've also never been reaching out for different input methods either. What works for a mouse works for a track pad or track ball. If Windows is wanting to branch out to different input methods (I feel at least) they should use different overlays. Hell, why stop at touch, I'd also love to operate my HTPC with a remote or my 360 controller or voice control. Doesn't mean I want the same damned interface for all of them.
 
I don't want a familiar UI if it makes the experience on one of my primary devices worse. Universal UI's to fit products that do completely different things suck.

No one has really attempted what Microsoft is trying to do with Windows 8, not on this scale and not with a focus on new hardware and form factors. We have nothing to really compare this too.

1) Between the task bar and start menu I have everything I need while maintaining a clean desktop. I use far more programs than the average person, so the tiles of metro aren't a benefit if that is the argument. If anything they just take up more unnecessary space and once again, Do not justify lack of choice.

I use a lot of things too, and when you count games I have in access of 500+ things installed on my main rig. Now how many of them do I use on a routine basis? No more than fifty. Something that I rarely used I'm not going to hunt for it in the Start Menu, I just type. That works just as well in Windows 8 as Windows 7. In terms of launching apps, there's no practical difference for me with a keyboard and mouse. Now when I go to a touch screen, HUGE difference. There's now ONE app launcher approach that doesn't change for the vast majority of people on the desktop but works immensely better with touch. That's a win in a market that's moving more and more to touch devices.

2) I don't need weatherbug built into windows..Again, doesn't justify lack of choice.

3) I don't need a UI change to access an app store.

4) Big assumption that the majority of users benefit from metro.

And your assumptions all revolve around the notion that PCs are just keyboard and mouse driven devices and should always remain this. Again, that just doesn't seem to be what average people are interested in these days.

None of those reasons justify why I don't have a choice. If they know that a large number of people would just turn it off, that is the first hint that the design is bad.

No, that's just a hint that people don't care about change. And the idea that one just turns if off and on presents a number of challenges and it's never been anything that Windows has been about historically. Windows has always been about one size fitting all. Maybe that's wrong in this case but still there's just no history of Microsoft offering infinitely customizable UIs and overall, at as far as Windows is concerned, that approach seems to have worked for Microsoft.

A well designed interface encourages people to use it even if they have a choice. A Shitty design requries all users to be forced because they know no one will otherwise.

In which case it's pretty hard to say that the current Windows UI is well designed since there's never been a choice, not in the box.

Metro is Bulky, ugly and offers zero benefit to the desktop experience. There is absolutely no justification for MS cramming it down our throats and not giving any choice.
[/QUOTE]

And for you and the way you use a computer I'm sure you're right but the desktop is in relative decline. For me Metro is about freedom and using what device I want and what input method I want based on the circumstance. There's nothing bulking about have a 2 lbs full Windows x86 device that I can use places you can't take a desktop or mouse and keyboard.
 
This almost feels like Politics, it's fairly obvious that a few have their opinions and seem to enjoy Win8, while others such as myself, do not. Seeing as XP will be still technically be usable for a quite a while, I would doubt MS can't come up with an OS for those that aren't happy Metro within the next 14 years. Only time will tell whether or not MS made something that sells well.

To each his own. :)
 
This almost feels like Politics, it's fairly obvious that a few have their opinions and seem to enjoy Win8, while others such as myself, do not. Seeing as XP will be still technically be usable for a quite a while, I would doubt MS can't come up with an OS for those that aren't happy Metro within the next 14 years. Only time will tell whether or not MS made something that sells well.

To each his own. :)

I would agree. But one thing that you have to consider no matter what your opinion of Metro is how people will use PCs in the future. There's a possibility that conventional PCs as we know them are an endangered species.

Metro isn't change for the sake of change. It's change for the sake of survival. Every analysts, pundit and the market is telling Microsoft that people don't care about PCs anymore and are even looking towards tablets to do productive work.
 
Every analysts, pundit and the market is telling Microsoft that people don't care about PCs anymore and are even looking towards tablets to do productive work.

I thought the general logical consensus was these people were talking out their asses, have no clue how extablish market growth vs new market growth are hardly the same thing, and that tablets vs desktop/laptop OS sales aren't even 1 for every 10?

Hopefully this OS bombs, just so all these moron "experts" get fired, and MS can go back to making stuff better, rather than making stuff "different".
 
8 takes things that were comparatively easy for the less knowledgeable user, like my mother, and makes them harder. Adding clicks to accomplish the same tasks, separating the desktop into two environments, having a meaninglessly 'cloaked' start button, these things are just absurd.

Why would I want to make my mother's computing experience harder when it took ages to get her comfortable with the basics?
 
8 takes things that were comparatively easy for the less knowledgeable user, like my mother, and makes them harder. Adding clicks to accomplish the same tasks, separating the desktop into two environments, having a meaninglessly 'cloaked' start button, these things are just absurd.

Why would I want to make my mother's computing experience harder when it took ages to get her comfortable with the basics?

What, besides shutdown/reboot requires more clicks?
 
I thought the general logical consensus was these people were talking out their asses, have no clue how extablish market growth vs new market growth are hardly the same thing, and that tablets vs desktop/laptop OS sales aren't even 1 for every 10?

Tablets will outsell desktops (the form factor) in retail this year. And whether or not anyone is talking crazy, more and more discussion around the need for PCs for average people keeps popping up and there's more and more focus on tablets for productive purposes. I'm not saying things like AutoCAD but for office automation and with remote access to desktop software when needed the trends do not look great for traditional PCs. And I think PC OEMs are saying much the same. At least their stocks are.

Hopefully this OS bombs, just so all these moron "experts" get fired, and MS can go back to making stuff better, rather than making stuff "different".

And for someone who likes Tablet PCs and finds Metro very productive and useful on desktops, laptops, convertibles and tablets, I hope it does well. To me the idea of needing multiple OSes and multiple devices to do what a single OS and device can do is a retarded as you think Metro is on the desktop.

With a new generation of hardware that's lighter, faster, more battery efficient and now touch enabled, Windows 8 has a good chance of doing well with good devices at good prices especially considering that upgrades have never been a big part of Windows sales. As dismiss Metro as much as one wants, it's going to be the hardware as much as anything that pushes Windows 8.
 
No one has really attempted what Microsoft is trying to do with Windows 8, not on this scale and not with a focus on new hardware and form factors. We have nothing to really compare this too.
You can compare traditional websites to their mobile counterparts. In the web design, we refer to a design which adapts to different viewport resolutions, devices and so forth as being "responsive". The UI "responds" to changes in input types and viewport sizes and aspect ratios by modifying itself to better suit those aspects and deliver a better user experience.

An acceptable word to use to describe Metro, therefore, is "unresponsive". The negative connotation we associate with that word is something I consider to be rather fitting as a description for what Metro is as a cross-device UI paradigm.
 
You can compare traditional websites to their mobile counterparts. In the web design, we refer to a design which adapts to different viewport resolutions, devices and so forth as being "responsive". The UI "responds" to changes in input types and viewport sizes and aspect ratios by modifying itself to better suit those aspects and deliver a better user experience.

An acceptable word to use to describe Metro, therefore, is "unresponsive". The negative connotation we associate with that word is something I consider to be rather fitting as a description for what Metro is as a cross-device UI paradigm.

This really isn't the issue. The issue is grafting a UI convention on another that simply doesn't consider closing a program at the same level of importance. And the close button convention on the desktop isn't as consistent as many of you make it out to be. Lots of applications don't have close buttons or they are non standard ones and often the close button doesn't even close the application.

The issue in Metro is that closing an application with a mouse (trackpads will have gestures that will be even faster than close buttons) is a bit cumbersome within the app. However it's it easy to do with a right click on the side bar.

This is one Metro concern from the opposition that I do have some agreement one but then I look at the inconsistency in the close button in desktop apps and kind of wonder if it isn't a wash. A drag an drop from the top will ALWAYS close a Metro.
 
Much as you confuse issues under discussion, you've confused this thread with another.
 
Much as you confuse issues under discussion, you've confused this thread with another.

If you say so. I was talking specifically about the concept of a close button. Since I actually use Windows 8 everyday I simply pointed out what I see and my experience and try to talk about things specifically. You were the one talking about the close button.
 
No one has really attempted what Microsoft is trying to do with Windows 8, not on this scale and not with a focus on new hardware and form factors. We have nothing to really compare this too.



I use a lot of things too, and when you count games I have in access of 500+ things installed on my main rig. Now how many of them do I use on a routine basis? No more than fifty. Something that I rarely used I'm not going to hunt for it in the Start Menu, I just type. That works just as well in Windows 8 as Windows 7. In terms of launching apps, there's no practical difference for me with a keyboard and mouse. Now when I go to a touch screen, HUGE difference. There's now ONE app launcher approach that doesn't change for the vast majority of people on the desktop but works immensely better with touch. That's a win in a market that's moving more and more to touch devices.



And your assumptions all revolve around the notion that PCs are just keyboard and mouse driven devices and should always remain this. Again, that just doesn't seem to be what average people are interested in these days.



No, that's just a hint that people don't care about change. And the idea that one just turns if off and on presents a number of challenges and it's never been anything that Windows has been about historically. Windows has always been about one size fitting all. Maybe that's wrong in this case but still there's just no history of Microsoft offering infinitely customizable UIs and overall, at as far as Windows is concerned, that approach seems to have worked for Microsoft.



In which case it's pretty hard to say that the current Windows UI is well designed since there's never been a choice, not in the box.

And for you and the way you use a computer I'm sure you're right but the desktop is in relative decline. For me Metro is about freedom and using what device I want and what input method I want based on the circumstance. There's nothing bulking about have a 2 lbs full Windows x86 device that I can use places you can't take a desktop or mouse and keyboard.[/QUOTE]

I know where you are coming from heartless, but you still don't give a single reason that justifies desktop users having a touch interface forced on them. You have heard me state numerous times that I love metro on a mobile touch device. A desktop and standard laptop don't operate like a tablet and never will. They are distinctly different products and frankly it doesn't matter if their sales numbers appear in relative decline. The fact is there are still many times more traditional desktops and laptops out there than touch devices and will be for some years to come. The other thing to consider is desktops have had time to reach a level of saturation while touch is new. OFC desktop sales seem to be slowing, that is the captain obvious statement of the year.

Again there isn't a single argument as to why the UI change should be mandatory. The only purpose it serves is to alienate customer base. This is one of the stupidest decisions to come out of Redmond in a decade.
 
I know where you are coming from heartless, but you still don't give a single reason that justifies desktop users having a touch interface forced on them. You have heard me state numerous times that I love metro on a mobile touch device. A desktop and standard laptop don't operate like a tablet and never will. They are distinctly different products and frankly it doesn't matter if their sales numbers appear in relative decline. The fact is there are still many times more traditional desktops and laptops out there than touch devices and will be for some years to come. The other thing to consider is desktops have had time to reach a level of saturation while touch is new. OFC desktop sales seem to be slowing, that is the captain obvious statement of the year.

Again there isn't a single argument as to why the UI change should be mandatory. The only purpose it serves is to alienate customer base. This is one of the stupidest decisions to come out of Redmond in a decade.

I'll be the first to admit and have said on many occasions that Microsoft is leveraging the power on Windows on desktops to gain entry into tablets. Little could be more obvious than that.

So the motives behind Metro are profit driven plain and simple. But being a long time Windows tablet user I simply agree with this because I think Metro is as straight forward a solution to a complex problem if one believes that a computer, regardless of form factor, can and should work in a consistent manner.

Love or hate Metro, having the option to "switch it off" does make Windows 8 more complex. Two different UIs in Windows is something that Microsoft simply has NEVER done. So even if Microsoft is forcing Metro now it's not like they have never have done the same thing like forever.

I accept that you and plenty of people will never like Metro. I'm pretty sure than more than one or two Microsoft employees feel the same. Indeed the Courier device concept that leaked a couple of years ago was one vision of Microsoft's possible strategies in tablets and those guys went on to make Paper for the iPad.

So could have Microsoft made Metro switchable , sure. Two UIs depending on the device and then possibly if the device was docked or not and then you installed a Metro app but the you don't see the live tile because you took the tablet out of the dock and now you see the Start Menu. But then you could have a desktop and that defaults to the Start Menu and then where the Windows Store if there's a cool Metro app that came out. No matter what, two UIs adds to the complexity of what many already say is complicated.

So out of all the things, this might be the best reason for "forcing" Metro on people.
 
I'll be the first to admit and have said on many occasions that Microsoft is leveraging the power on Windows on desktops to gain entry into tablets. Little could be more obvious than that.

So the motives behind Metro are profit driven plain and simple. But being a long time Windows tablet user I simply agree with this because I think Metro is as straight forward a solution to a complex problem if one believes that a computer, regardless of form factor, can and should work in a consistent manner.

Love or hate Metro, having the option to "switch it off" does make Windows 8 more complex. Two different UIs in Windows is something that Microsoft simply has NEVER done. So even if Microsoft is forcing Metro now it's not like they have never have done the same thing like forever.

I accept that you and plenty of people will never like Metro. I'm pretty sure than more than one or two Microsoft employees feel the same. Indeed the Courier device concept that leaked a couple of years ago was one vision of Microsoft's possible strategies in tablets and those guys went on to make Paper for the iPad.

So could have Microsoft made Metro switchable , sure. Two UIs depending on the device and then possibly if the device was docked or not and then you installed a Metro app but the you don't see the live tile because you took the tablet out of the dock and now you see the Start Menu. But then you could have a desktop and that defaults to the Start Menu and then where the Windows Store if there's a cool Metro app that came out. No matter what, two UIs adds to the complexity of what many already say is complicated.

So out of all the things, this might be the best reason for "forcing" Metro on people.

While this is fairly sound reasoning, it unfortunately is what we call in software development "Perfect world scenario" which isn't a realistic scenario. As such few if any software companies design their gui around that scenario because the only result is it ends up frustrating the majority of users when it doesn't work as expected.

Does it add a level of complexity? Not actually. It might add a dozen lines of code at the most and that is assuming some extremely sloppy code. Really a UI change is nothing more than a few and if statements. Also you wouldn't be switching the UI on a tablet. You and I both know that the Win 7 interface for example would be absolute crap on a tablet. The windows store and cool metro apps (lol) are pure options that have no bearing on the ui design. If someone absolutely "must" see the live tiles or the latest metro app they would obviously have metro on or go to the windows store respectively. This is like modifying the interface on my phone to auto show me the latest app in the android market without me going to the market. Chances are I really don't give a damn unless I specifically open it up.

This concept is really nothing more than a new take on advertisements. No one likes ads, no matter what they are. This is why most of us use ad block as soon as we learn about it. Now of course we use the choice to unblock ads on sites like this one that we support, but it doesn't mean we actually give a crap about the actual ad. I have 3 websites that I don't block ads on, this being one of them and it is only because I know it helps make them money. If it didn't I would block them because frankly I don't care about the ads and never will. Flashing the latest app up on my computer without my having gone to the "store" is effectively the same thing without the option to block it.

Now on the upside some companies are already coming up with a means to completely gut metro and have a standard interface. Unfortunately these options are pay services. The last thing I want to do is pony up more money to make my brand new OS I just bought actually functional.
 
W's 8 SAFE MODE access hooha perfectly exemplifies MS's contempt for the end user.
 
While this is fairly sound reasoning, it unfortunately is what we call in software development "Perfect world scenario" which isn't a realistic scenario. As such few if any software companies design their gui around that scenario because the only result is it ends up frustrating the majority of users when it doesn't work as expected.

But you're assuming based on Internet feedback that Windows 8 IS frustrating the majority of users. I'm a software developer as well. And one thing I've learned is that change is almost never welcome. Maybe Windows 8 will not be perceived well by most users, particularly current Windows users. But I remember quite well the online furor over the ribbon UI in Office 2007, it's practically the same debate that we are no having over Metro with virtually the same level of anonymous online negative feedback. And that feedback was simply wrong.

Another thing that I've learned being a software developer, you'll get a lot feedback, but not all feedback it created equal. Do you really think that if Microsoft created an OS based on anonymous feedback of people who don't even understand the market or design needs of the software that the OS would be better?

Does it add a level of complexity? Not actually. It might add a dozen lines of code at the most and that is assuming some extremely sloppy code. Really a UI change is nothing more than a few and if statements. Also you wouldn't be switching the UI on a tablet. You and I both know that the Win 7 interface for example would be absolute crap on a tablet. The windows store and cool metro apps (lol) are pure options that have no bearing on the ui design. If someone absolutely "must" see the live tiles or the latest metro app they would obviously have metro on or go to the windows store respectively. This is like modifying the interface on my phone to auto show me the latest app in the android market without me going to the market. Chances are I really don't give a damn unless I specifically open it up.

As a software developer I've learned to be cautious when I hear "a few lines of code". Having used Windows tablets and desktops for decades, no it's just not that simple. The main problem with Windows on touch devices isn't the OS, its the applications. Microsoft has for a decade provided a tablet platform and in Windows 7 has tons of touch capability. But the hardware wasn't there and no one wrote touch apps. If desktop and keyboard and mouse computing were a healthy market then sure, just switch it off, who cares, everyone loves desktops and keyboards and mice just as much as tablets. Well the market is saying otherwise. HP just laid off 27,000 folks (I hope they all do well) and Dell is struggling as well. The market reality is that people see tablets, particularly the iPad as encroaching the PC market. Maybe that's not the truth, but it is the perception and perception is reality. Windows 8 could be the greatest mouse and keyboard infinitely customizable OS in history, no one would really care. And Apple would sell more iPads than ever. At least that would be the view of analysts.

Now on the upside some companies are already coming up with a means to completely gut metro and have a standard interface. Unfortunately these options are pay services. The last thing I want to do is pony up more money to make my brand new OS I just bought actually functional.

And while the world has gone iPad crazy someone thinks there's money to be made in gutting Metro when people who hate Metro are saying they are going to get a Mac or go to Linux. No one who values their time will mess with this to make worthwhile probably. But I imagine that there will be some "solution" that will fuck up Windows 8 completely.
 
@heatlesssun,

Ipad is about the only pad really doing well. How many companies have tried and got burned with the Tablet? So Tablet is the future...ok... I honestly do not think so, but I have been wrong in times past.

Now as for the CLOUD.... I have enough problems with my privacy being invaded! That being said, Google Chrome is syncing up bookmarks and settings these days. I went from Fedora 16 to Fedora 17 and when I installed Google Chrome all my bookmarks were there. Just Like Magic...tm. On the one hand, yes I admit it was slick. On the other hand I had to sit here a minute and consider how much I enjoy other entities being Fully UP in my Business. I am distinctly uncomfortable with the Cloud. I would not hand my important physical documents over to a 3rd party "for safe keeping", would you?

Am I afraid of change? Partner... I have ran FVWM, IceWM, Gnome 1, Gnome 2, KDE2, KDE3, KDE4 (running KDE4 now), Fluxbox (Cool Window Manager if you put in some work), E16, E17, Afterstep, XFCE, and even CDE. To put it mildly, no I do not fear change! I love to tinker with things. Sometimes you really need to ask "what is the point exactly?" Of metro..? ? ? I am looking and scratching my head. Tablets for the most part have been bad "juju" for most of the companies that have tried them. Admitedly recently they seem to be selling somewhat ok.. but hey the global economy is in the Shitter! Have any of the analysts ever stopped to consider Computer Device Sales might be in the crapper because far too many people have less money to spend? I know I do not.

So do not try this "oh you are just afraid of change" crap my friend. Holy Shit you sound like my friend Mark... "Just tow the damn line man!! C'mon just be a good...err...Just DO IT"... no. Just no. That being said I am still watching Win8.

Ok, I have a legit question. I have not tried Win8 Server. What does it look like? Does it use Metro? I guess I could go down to the college and talk to Mark or Adrian... They are a MS Beta site... just lazy I guess.
 
Ipad is about the only pad really doing well. How many companies have tried and got burned with the Tablet? So Tablet is the future...ok... I honestly do not think so, but I have been wrong in times past.

This is the problem with the tablet hype. It's not that the world is moving to tablets, it's that the world is moving to iPads. Like it or not, and whatever it may be attributed to, that's how it's going. And the more initial market share Apple gobbles up, the harder it's going to be to convince corporate and business customers to rewrite all their intranet apps again in .NET/Silverlight.

We keep hearing "wait for Android ICS" and "wait for Windows 8" from the pundits. And right around this time a few years ago, they were saying "wait for Android Honeycomb" and "wait for Windows 7."

Every single thing that's been said in this thread about Windows 8's touch support was said about Windows 7's a few years ago. And yet here we are again, once again being told "wait for the next version!" Quite frankly, I'm not holding my breath.
 
Ipad is about the only pad really doing well. How many companies have tried and got burned with the Tablet? So Tablet is the future...ok... I honestly do not think so, but I have been wrong in times past.
Android tablets are quite popular as well, but I agree with your thoughts in general. I don't see the sudden surge of tablets as being due to the fact people need or want them so much as the marketing juggernaut that is Apple. I think tablet sales are far more hype driven than actual practicality driven, and despite the predictions of tablets overtaking traditional laptop and desktop sales in the future, I think the truth is they are on shaky ground.

Not to say tablets and touch doesn't have a place, but I think that place is far smaller than people make out and I don't think MS is shooting for the future with W8 so much as trying to jump on the hype-train to make some money before it runs out of steam.
 
As I said once before, A couple of Dr.s offices I have been to over the last year or so have started using iPads for Customer Data Entry / Interaction. It seemed to work ok for them. Other than that, friends who have bought iPads seem to get burnt out on them within a month. After that they just lay around and collect dust mostly. How about you..? What have you observed?
 
I think tablet sales are far more hype driven than actual practicality driven, and despite the predictions of tablets overtaking traditional laptop and desktop sales in the future, I think the truth is they are on shaky ground.

LOL, you just used "tablet" and "practicality" in the same sentence. :p

Don't get me wrong, I love my iPad, but all it gets used for is watching movies and browsing meme pics. ;)
 
Haha, see thats what I am saying... iPad is cool for a few weeks... then they mostly collect dust. I know I would rather watch a movie on my 50" Plamsa TV...or my 24" HP ZR2440w... Hey im not trying to be an ass my friend I am just saying the iPads I played with just did not really wow me. I mean, they were Okay... but no way in hell I would drop that kind of cash for one! :) Phone / Kindle Fire / Desktop... :) I actually kind of enjoy a good eReader, but then it focuses on a certain aspect for a low low price and does what it does quite well. If I am the odd man out here, hell tell me I am :)
 
But you're assuming based on Internet feedback that Windows 8 IS frustrating the majority of users. I'm a software developer as well. And one thing I've learned is that change is almost never welcome. Maybe Windows 8 will not be perceived well by most users, particularly current Windows users. But I remember quite well the online furor over the ribbon UI in Office 2007, it's practically the same debate that we are no having over Metro with virtually the same level of anonymous online negative feedback. And that feedback was simply wrong.

Another thing that I've learned being a software developer, you'll get a lot feedback, but not all feedback it created equal. Do you really think that if Microsoft created an OS based on anonymous feedback of people who don't even understand the market or design needs of the software that the OS would be better?

Actually I don't give internet feedback much weight. I have had the chance to put win 8 in front of a ton of different users. The types of users one would define as "average" users. All of them found the interface extremely alienating and more than a few said outright they would rather switch to mac. Microsoft is fighting a battle of perception here. People perceive windows as difficult to use even though Win 7 is anything but, yet they perceive OSX as easy to use even if they never have. This of course we all know is garbage as OSX for someone who is familiar with windows is anything but easy to relearn. However due to years of very effective marketing by Apple, this is what people believe. So coming out with an interface that is unfamiliar in basically every respect strikes me as a massive blunder that will only exacerbate the perception problem they have.


As a software developer I've learned to be cautious when I hear "a few lines of code". Having used Windows tablets and desktops for decades, no it's just not that simple. The main problem with Windows on touch devices isn't the OS, its the applications. Microsoft has for a decade provided a tablet platform and in Windows 7 has tons of touch capability. But the hardware wasn't there and no one wrote touch apps. If desktop and keyboard and mouse computing were a healthy market then sure, just switch it off, who cares, everyone loves desktops and keyboards and mice just as much as tablets. Well the market is saying otherwise. HP just laid off 27,000 folks (I hope they all do well) and Dell is struggling as well. The market reality is that people see tablets, particularly the iPad as encroaching the PC market. Maybe that's not the truth, but it is the perception and perception is reality. Windows 8 could be the greatest mouse and keyboard infinitely customizable OS in history, no one would really care. And Apple would sell more iPads than ever. At least that would be the view of analysts.



And while the world has gone iPad crazy someone thinks there's money to be made in gutting Metro when people who hate Metro are saying they are going to get a Mac or go to Linux. No one who values their time will mess with this to make worthwhile probably. But I imagine that there will be some "solution" that will fuck up Windows 8 completely.

As for the rest, I think it stands to reason that neither of us are going to agree or convince the other.
 
Actually I don't give internet feedback much weight. I have had the chance to put win 8 in front of a ton of different users. The types of users one would define as "average" users. All of them found the interface extremely alienating and more than a few said outright they would rather switch to mac. Microsoft is fighting a battle of perception here. People perceive windows as difficult to use even though Win 7 is anything but, yet they perceive OSX as easy to use even if they never have. This of course we all know is garbage as OSX for someone who is familiar with windows is anything but easy to relearn. However due to years of very effective marketing by Apple, this is what people believe. So coming out with an interface that is unfamiliar in basically every respect strikes me as a massive blunder that will only exacerbate the perception problem they have.



As for the rest, I think it stands to reason that neither of us are going to agree or convince the other.

I'm really not trying to convince anyone, just conveying my experience with Windows 8. I'm sure that no matter what millions of people won't like Windows 8. I do think that with new hardware that Microsoft has the potential to gain millions more users. Whatever choices you think that Microsoft is taking away they are adding some with Windows 8 and its success will be based on if people appreciate the new stuff more than whatever is being perceived as being taken away.
 
Haha, see thats what I am saying... iPad is cool for a few weeks... then they mostly collect dust. I know I would rather watch a movie on my 50" Plamsa TV...or my 24" HP ZR2440w... Hey im not trying to be an ass my friend I am just saying the iPads I played with just did not really wow me. I mean, they were Okay... but no way in hell I would drop that kind of cash for one! :) Phone / Kindle Fire / Desktop... :) I actually kind of enjoy a good eReader, but then it focuses on a certain aspect for a low low price and does what it does quite well. If I am the odd man out here, hell tell me I am :)

I adore my eink kindles. Seriously some of the best purchases I've ever made in tech. If you like reading books folks, there is no comparison to eink other than real paper.

The joy of book after book coming off these little things is just a wonder. Maybe I love books too much. I don't care. ;)
 
Being broke and homeless is a change too. Why don't people just live with it?



Saying all change is good is idiotic and asinine.
Haha. Funny. I never said all change was good. I was saying people need to learn to live with change. Metro isn't THAT big of a deal. And if you're homeless, you learn to live with it, so I don't quite understand what you're trying to say. I'm sorry, but I just don't understand all the hate surrounding Windows 8, especially if it's stable and performs well.
 
Thing people forget is windows success comes from OEMs and the typical person thats buying an OEM machine will eat this up and beg for more. I can see setting up windows 8 machines for elderly or computer illiterate people for sure.

For me as a gamer and power user im not excited at all about it but from the standpoint of the "family IT guy" i cant wait. So long as it has the stability of 7 this will be my new go to for those types.
 
Thing people forget is windows success comes from OEMs and the typical person thats buying an OEM machine will eat this up and beg for more. I can see setting up windows 8 machines for elderly or computer illiterate people for sure.

For me as a gamer and power user im not excited at all about it but from the standpoint of the "family IT guy" i cant wait. So long as it has the stability of 7 this will be my new go to for those types.
This theory really didn't work too well for Vista. What makes you think Windows 8 would be any different? Yes, Microsoft sold a lot of Windows Vista licenses, but many of the systems were either pre-downgraded by the factory or downgraded by the end user/business back to XP.
 
I finally got a chance to play with Win8 last night...Its definitely geared towards tablets. I don't think you will see many desktops systems with it. For the casual user, wanting to IM and check out news and play with a few apps, it does what it needs to do. However, it's just too limiting and complex for the desktop to be readily adopted for business users or power/home users.
 
As I said once before, A couple of Dr.s offices I have been to over the last year or so have started using iPads for Customer Data Entry / Interaction. It seemed to work ok for them. Other than that, friends who have bought iPads seem to get burnt out on them within a month. After that they just lay around and collect dust mostly. How about you..? What have you observed?

We use it play movies for my son when we go out driving. He has educational games on it. My wifes uses it to VNC into her desktop so she can do things on it while watching TV or sitting in bed (but still have access to things that may not be available in "app" form).
 
I just installed it last night (since I just got a new SSD, I figured why not). I actually like it quite a bit. I very much like the new ribbon for windows explorer. I can definitely see this being an awesome OS for a hybrid tablet/laptop like Intel's Cove Point (this type of device would be the ONLY reason I would be buying a new laptop in the future... I'm done with classroom work for the most part so I really don't exactly need one).

I also believe that they should allow users to easily revert to the original start menu since a lot of you seem to hate it. I really don't have a problem with it because anytime I ever actually used the start menu I would just use the auto-search while typing to find whatever I was looking for.

I'm going to be really sad if they get rid of my transparent windows and taskbar, though. Even back in XP I would download transparent themes.
 
Back
Top