Windows 8 is Ugly.

I like it enough that I am considering jumping from Android to Windows Phone for my mobile device. I have enjoyed the freedom of Android, but having the ability to have a somewhat seamless experience from mobile to desktop to tablet and game console is something that has my attention.

I did. While I do miss the 'open-ness' and freedom that Android gave me, the Windows Phone interface is far superior. It's fast, extremely stable (even better than my wifes iPhone) and very user friendly. Sure, it's not as modable or customizable as an Android, but it works perfectly. Live tiles are very nice, as well. I am looking to upgrade to a newer phone, and while the Android still looks nice (and is still an amazing platform, absolutely nothing but love from me on that one), I'm looking at another WP (probably going for WP8, though).
 
The same market researchers that said Microsoft Bob was going to be awesome? :p

Well considering that Bob was a flop, probably not. But the peanut gallery gets it wrong on occasion as well. Remember all of the people that said that Office 2007 would fail because of the Ribbon and how people in droves would switch to other office suites if Microsoft didn't have a switch to turn on the classic menus? That didn't exactly happen.

The success or failure of Windows 8 will be tied to hardware. Lots of good hardware at good prices and there's really no reason why it wouldn't do well in spite of the new UI. Light fast machines with crazy battery life, ultratook laptop/tablet hybrids, slick touch screen laptops, these will drive Windows 8 sales again if they are good and the prices are reasonable.
 
Lots of good hardware at good prices and there's really no reason why it wouldn't do well in spite of the new UI. Light fast machines with crazy battery life, ultratook laptop/tablet hybrids, slick touch screen laptops, these will drive Windows 8 sales again if they are good and the prices are reasonable.

That's what I'm worried about. The iPad is a damn nice piece of hardware, and it's what Windows 8 tablets will be compared to. It doesn't matter than W8 is a full featured OS that can run standard Windows desktop applications. Price needs to be competitive to the iPad, and I don't see that happening at all.

I'm really looking forward to Win8 tablets, but I'm not looking forward to the pricing. Hopefully, Microsoft will do what they did with Windows Phone and put a minimum spec on hardware, so manufacturers aren't pushing sub-standard, cheap POS's out the door (like some Android tablets... Ouch.).
 
That's what I'm worried about. The iPad is a damn nice piece of hardware, and it's what Windows 8 tablets will be compared to. It doesn't matter than W8 is a full featured OS that can run standard Windows desktop applications.

Uh, no, Win8 on a tablet (at least an ARM tablet) will not run standard desktop applications. Think of it as an unrelated OS, save for the ugly appearance.
 
I think you'll see three tiers of pricing for Windows 8/RT tablets. Windows RT will be at the bottom and will be priced similarly with Android devices of the hardware. Next will be Atom Cedar Trail devices that will probably start at $500 for basic models and run up to $1k for devices with large SSDs and hybrid keyboard docks. At the top and will be Ivy Bridge devices that start at $1k and going as high as features will take them, like ruggedization as so forth.

I don't think Microsoft and OEMs are stupid, on an apples to apples hardware basis Windows 8/RT will be competitively priced but the Windows 8 tablets will go much higher in price but those devices will be ultrabooks in reality and fall in line with those prices.
 
Uh, no, Win8 on a tablet (at least an ARM tablet) will not run standard desktop applications. Think of it as an unrelated OS, save for the ugly appearance.

True but those devices techinically aren't running Windows 8 but Windows RT and RT devices will include and run Office which is something that could be compelling to a lot of people.
 
I was up in the air about the preview, my thought process went like this:

1. Metro is dumb and useless for me but it's the new start button so UGH
2. FUCKING GOOGLE
3. Find classic shell, START BUTTON LIVES AGAIN, everything is customizable

PROBLEM SOLVED. Played around a little after that, and with help from the new task manager functionality I spent like 10 minutes screwing around and trimmed out some more shit I didn't need (I emphasize screwing around, because I was really trying to see how bare bones I could possibly get it for shits and giggles, it's no different than W7 in regard to how much stuff is running by default). Bam had it starting at 19 processes on boot, had my start menu, all was right in the world.


If you like Windows 7 then there's no reason to not like 8. If you don't like Metro, just fucking tweak your shit and bypass it. Reap the positives and bypass the negatives.
 
If things continue this way, I'll be selling my pc and getting an imac.

I am looking forward to the 3rd beta.

Troll! :(

Nobody that's not trolling would seriously get rid of PCs and buy new spendy Apple stuff because they are displeased with Windows 8. You would do what everybody else does; bitch about Windows 8 and stick with Windows 7.

I like the Win8 look (and no I'm not on the take) but I'd like to play with the Start screen options more which I think is going to be in the RC coming this week.
 
Maybe it's just the type of person I am, I'm always willing to give something new an earnest try where as many people get comfortable and want everything to stay the same forever.

IMO, this is the biggest issue here. Everyone is so comfy in Windows, they don't want anything to change.

I used W8 as my main laptop for 3ish months. I used it to write and edit class documents, create basic web pages, and manage (small) amounts of media. I spent VERY little time in the Metro environment.

Seriously, how many of you actually use the Start menu to browse applications? I'll bet that the vast majority hit the start key, and start typing to search for the program they want to launch. That functionality is preserved in W8. Want to pin applications to the desktop or the bar at the bottom of the screen? Still there. Hot keys? Not only are they still fully functional, but they have been improved.

I've said it many times, if you treat Metro like a glorified start menu, the transition is far smoother. The only groups I think can get truly upset at W8 is the HTPC crowd and people that have to manage large numbers of people. And that second one is arguable.

First week or so, it took some getting used to. It was doable, but it wasn't 'easier' for me. After the initial learning curve and getting used to it, it did get a LOT better.

It does take getting used to, but IMO the learning curve is still very, very small.

I like it enough that I am considering jumping from Android to Windows Phone for my mobile device. I have enjoyed the freedom of Android, but having the ability to have a somewhat seamless experience from mobile to desktop to tablet and game console is something that has my attention.

I already did. Dell Venue Pro checking in.
 
+1 for sticking with Windows 7... I didn't like Metro on the 360, didn't dig WP7, and I'm definitely NOT liking it on the desktop.
 
Uh, no, Win8 on a tablet (at least an ARM tablet) will not run standard desktop applications. Think of it as an unrelated OS, save for the ugly appearance.

You do know there will be x86 based tablets, right? WOA (Windows RT) won't run x86 applications without emulation. It will be Metro apps only, pretty much. Not a lot of news on that front yet.

x86 tablets are what I was talking about (obviously).

Metro is a nice UI. Very informative just by looking at the live tiles. Quick, easy to use. I like the look.
 
Troll! :(

Nobody that's not trolling would seriously get rid of PCs and buy new spendy Apple stuff because they are displeased with Windows 8.

Speak for yourself. I'm considering doing the same thing he is. Esp. if the iMac gets the rumored retina display.
 
Speak for yourself. I'm considering doing the same thing he is. Esp. if the iMac gets the rumored retina display.

But really, how many people will buy Macs because they don't like Windows 8? Those people won't buy ANYTHING and just stick with what they have, Windows 7 isn't going away any time soon. In the grand scheme of things it will be a piss ant number. Overall moving from a PC to a Mac is at least as hard as going from Windows 7 to Windows 8 for most.
 
But really, how many people will buy Macs because they don't like Windows 8? Those people won't buy ANYTHING and just stick with what they have, Windows 7 isn't going away any time soon. In the grand scheme of things it will be a piss ant number. Overall moving from a PC to a Mac is at least as hard as going from Windows 7 to Windows 8 for most.

It doesn't matter to ME how many other people might. If I do it that's all that matters to me.
 
It doesn't matter to ME how many other people might. If I do it that's all that matters to me.

Fair enough. And that's exactly how I feel. Windows 8 works the way that I use computers anyway and have for years and improves the experience for me. If it worsens it for you and doesn't suit your needs then you obviously have alternatives.

It's simply that I think that ultimately that the idea of convergence will be popular simply because it ain't that big of deal. If you got to a Mac, all the keyboard and mice driven apps that you get for it, once launched they are going to work pretty much like they do in Windows 8, Metro be damned. Between Windows 7 and 8, that keyboard and mouse app is going work just like it always have and hell if it's pinned to the task bar will launch the same.

This whole Metro debate has really very little to do with the vast amount of time that people actually do things with their computers. It's only about a very small sliver of actual computing time and when you get the hang of it, the nothing is different.

That's why I think Windows 8 will do well. The controversy is really about something as trivial as what to have for dinner. It's just now that Windows 8 will offer a wider variety on the menu.
 
:rolleyes: Do you really have to be the constant pseudo microsoft spokesperson in all these threads?
 
This whole Metro debate has really very little to do with the vast amount of time that people actually do things with their computers. It's only about a very small sliver of actual computing time and when you get the hang of it, the nothing is different.

So searching for stuff, closing apps, switching between them, sleep/shutdown are all very minor things? These are all tasks everyone does all the time, and are radically different, and harder to do in Win 8.

For you maybe its not a big deal. I will use Win 8 as well, but for most non-tech people, its a bunch of changes that will make it very hard for them to use. I want to see how you explain this to someone stuck in a Metro app with no idea how to exit it. Or hunting for their familiar shutdown/sleep command in total vain.

Keep repeating the 'convergence' mantra just like MS does, the fact is most people won't have touch devices for a very long time.
 
:rolleyes: Do you really have to be the constant pseudo microsoft spokesperson in all these threads?

I have a different point of view than most around. If one can't communicate those that have different points then it's impossible to see the whole picture.

As I have stated more than once, Windows 8 makes sense to me because I have used Windows daily for a decade with more than mice and keyboards but I understand that that is far from the experience of most.

I do understand that you and PLENTY of others have expressed that you feel that Windows 8 and Metro forces you into something and you think it doesn't work well with a mouse and keyboard. Indeed you may be absolutely correct from your point of view. From my point of view the ease and efficiencies gained with touch and tablets and pens in Windows are a quantum leap and because I spend so much time with Windows tablets I may simply be compensating which is why I also setup a dual screen keyboard and mouse only setup, and to write Metro apps.

After nine months, sure I see plenty of differences and rough edges (those have improved from DP to CP to RP however). It's just in nine months that for the things I do 99% of the time Windows 8 makes little difference. As many have said, when I'm actually using my computer I'm not in a Start Screen or Start Menu. Yes, Windows 8 is at it's core two OSes in one. But then life is full of duality. Hell I'm a Gemini, the idea of two in one is what I am.;)
 
So searching for stuff, closing apps, switching between them, sleep/shutdown are all very minor things? These are all tasks everyone does all the time, and are radically different, and harder to do in Win 8.

Well, let's be clear. On the desktop switching between apps and closing them is NO DIFFERENT. Sleep and shut down aren't more difficult in the vast majority of circumstances. On a laptop you close the lid, on a tablet you'll press a button. And even on a desktop the system will turn itself off. And really, how often does one shut down a system anyway? The power thing is just a non-issue in the real world.

As for switching between Metro apps and the desktop, it's not more difficult but different. Closing Metro apps with a mouse (no gestures that will be available on a trackpad) is more cumbersome in a way but it's also more consistent. Close buttons on MANY desktop apps do nothing of the sort. I have no idea why people want to discount this very common thing.
[/QUTOE]

For you maybe its not a big deal. I will use Win 8 as well, but for most non-tech people, its a bunch of changes that will make it very hard for them to use. I want to see how you explain this to someone stuck in a Metro app with no idea how to exit it. Or hunting for their familiar shutdown/sleep command in total vain.

Stuck in a Metro app? I tell them to hit Alt-F4. Done. Power? Windows+C Settings Power. I deal with end users all the time and tell them to do things over IM of phone far more complex than this trivial stuff. I find it interesting that people love to say that Microsoft thinks people are stupid. Microsoft is actually taking a big risk in thinking that people will be able to adapt to something that you and others think they'll never figure out.


Keep repeating the 'convergence' mantra just like MS does, the fact is most people won't have touch devices for a very long time.

And keep thinking that the same old same old hardware will be sold. If you haven't noticed PC OEMs are hurting big time selling regurgitated crap. They, along with Intel are highly motivated to sell next gen hardware.
 
Well, let's be clear. On the desktop switching between apps and closing them is NO DIFFERENT. Sleep and shut down aren't more difficult in the vast majority of circumstances. On a laptop you close the lid, on a tablet you'll press a button. And even on a desktop the system will turn itself off. And really, how often does one shut down a system anyway? The power thing is just a non-issue in the real world.

As for switching between Metro apps and the desktop, it's not more difficult but different. Closing Metro apps with a mouse (no gestures that will be available on a trackpad) is more cumbersome in a way but it's also more consistent. Close buttons on MANY desktop apps do nothing of the sort. I have no idea why people want to discount this very common thing.
[/QUTOE]



Stuck in a Metro app? I tell them to hit Alt-F4. Done. Power? Windows+C Settings Power. I deal with end users all the time and tell them to do things over IM of phone far more complex than this trivial stuff. I find it interesting that people love to say that Microsoft thinks people are stupid. Microsoft is actually taking a big risk in thinking that people will be able to adapt to something that you and others think they'll never figure out.




And keep thinking that the same old same old hardware will be sold. If you haven't noticed PC OEMs are hurting big time selling regurgitated crap. They, along with Intel are highly motivated to sell next gen hardware.

I think you have no idea how few people know any keyboard shortcuts at all. 99.9% are used to the Windows chrome, taskbar and the familiar start menu->shutdown, search etc.

Using Windows 8 for these people is a huge challenge. It goes against decades of training and muscle memory. Power users will adapt. Do you think its a coincidence that in the thousands of pages of blog posts, countless public demos and presentations, never once has MS demonstrated Win 8 on a normal pc or done any user studies on how desktop users will react.
 
I think you have no idea how few people know any keyboard shortcuts at all. 99.9% are used to the Windows chrome, taskbar and the familiar start menu->shutdown, search etc.

I agree, all I was saying that if someone asked me how to do something telling them how to press keys either via IM or over the phone works well, it's not like they'd have to know if I'm telling them what to do.

Using Windows 8 for these people is a huge challenge. It goes against decades of training and muscle memory. Power users will adapt.

Life is full of change. From jobs, to relationships, to where we live and everything in between. And by some miracle of God, people adapt everyday.

Do you think its a coincidence that in the thousands of pages of blog posts, countless public demos and presentations, never once has MS demonstrated Win 8 on a normal pc or done any user studies on how desktop users will react.

Not true. http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/05/21/enhancing-windows-8-for-multiple-monitors.aspx

And really, no studies on desktop users? Read the Building Windows 8 Blog. Microsoft has more studies and statics on this stuff than anyone on the planet.
 
Microsoft is really committed to this, I wonder why? :)

Anyone downloaded the newer version? (I did)
 
Microsoft is really committed to this, I wonder why? :)

The reason is obvious. The desktop market is in relative decline and Microsoft is late to the game and they are leveraging their desktop dominance to gain market share where they have none today.
 
Desktop is not on decline in strict sense, there are still laptop and desktop computers sales higher than these companies were expected them to be. Sometimes I think it's just the 2010s hype about everything being ultra thin and mobile, but we all know that only specific amounts of users are going to get tablet or mobile phone to do tasks they were doing on a PC. The things that no one uses PCs anymore and similar crap we hear from MS is just idiotic to prove us they are somehow right with what they want to do especially because the only ones who don't own computer today are those who don't want it. That's all W8 sux big time.
 
Last edited:
The desktop (meaning both keyboard and mouse driven desktops and laptops) is in relative decline as smart phones and tablets grow at a much faster rate.
 
Stuck in a Metro app? I tell them to hit Alt-F4. Done. Power? Windows+C Settings Power. I deal with end users all the time and tell them to do things over IM of phone far more complex than this trivial stuff. I find it interesting that people love to say that Microsoft thinks people are stupid. Microsoft is actually taking a big risk in thinking that people will be able to adapt to something that you and others think they'll never figure out.

You know it's MUCH easier to manipulate an interface with clear visual cues than relying on long-term memory.

"Alt - what now? Alt-F4 you say?. Alt, alt, where is Alt? Oh, there it is.".

Two days later.

"Uhm, I know you told me this before but I forgot, what keys do I press again? 4 and what again? Oh, and how do I turn this off again? It's P for power, right? Do I hit Alt-P for power, or Windows-P? Oh, Windows-C? OK, so Alt, Windows key, Start button what? yeah.. that makes a lot of sense." :rolleyes:
 
One thing I dislike about Windows 8, and I'm probably spoiled. I want more customization options on the Start Screen. Not just color, but background image (my own), a clock on the Start Screen, etc...

It's definitely built with a touchscreen in mind, but it works very well on a desktop... once you learn it.
 
You know it's MUCH easier to manipulate an interface with clear visual cues than relying on long-term memory.

"Alt - what now? Alt-F4 you say?. Alt, alt, where is Alt? Oh, there it is.".

Two days later.

"Uhm, I know you told me this before but I forgot, what keys do I press again? 4 and what again? Oh, and how do I turn this off again? It's P for power, right? Do I hit Alt-P for power, or Windows-P? Oh, Windows-C? OK, so Alt, Windows key, Start button what? yeah.. that makes a lot of sense." :rolleyes:

How often are you shutting off your computer? It seems to me this gets a lot of comments and complaints, even if it's such a minuscule task compared to everything else you ever do. Modern desktop computers have soft power buttons, laptops have lids... I mean, how big of a deal is it?

I think it's this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson's_Law_of_Triviality
 
You know it's MUCH easier to manipulate an interface with clear visual cues than relying on long-term memory.

"Alt - what now? Alt-F4 you say?. Alt, alt, where is Alt? Oh, there it is.".

Two days later.

"Uhm, I know you told me this before but I forgot, what keys do I press again? 4 and what again? Oh, and how do I turn this off again? It's P for power, right? Do I hit Alt-P for power, or Windows-P? Oh, Windows-C? OK, so Alt, Windows key, Start button what? yeah.. that makes a lot of sense." :rolleyes:

I was just pointing out what I would do if someone asked me, not how to train them.

That said, as many people have pointed out, Metro is very much like if not indeed a tablet/phone UI and there are tons of hidden gestures in these UIs and somehow people figure it out.
 
I was just pointing out what I would do if someone asked me, not how to train them.

That said, as many people have pointed out, Metro is very much like if not indeed a tablet/phone UI and there are tons of hidden gestures in these UIs and somehow people figure it out.

But that is the gist of the problem, as stated countless times, a desktop is not a tablet. People have already "figured out" how to use a desktop for the most part, there is simply no need to change that paradigm for desktop users.

But I'm really just wasting my breath here. Let's revisit this next year, then you can tell me how awesome the Windows 8 roll out turned out to be.
 
People dont' like change, they will cry about how windows 8 sucks just because of the UI, just as many people said Vista sucked "it is nothing but a new GUI" with out bothering to get a clue and look at it under the hood, or even try to give the real OS a try and learn shortcuts and new ways to do things, that for some, may be more efficient, for others may not.
 
You know it's MUCH easier to manipulate an interface with clear visual cues than relying on long-term memory.

"Alt - what now? Alt-F4 you say?. Alt, alt, where is Alt? Oh, there it is.".

Two days later.

"Uhm, I know you told me this before but I forgot, what keys do I press again? 4 and what again? Oh, and how do I turn this off again? It's P for power, right? Do I hit Alt-P for power, or Windows-P? Oh, Windows-C? OK, so Alt, Windows key, Start button what? yeah.. that makes a lot of sense." :rolleyes:

Just press the damn power button, quitcherbitchin'
 
But that is the gist of the problem, as stated countless times, a desktop is not a tablet. People have already "figured out" how to use a desktop for the most part, there is simply no need to change that paradigm for desktop users.

But I'm really just wasting my breath here. Let's revisit this next year, then you can tell me how awesome the Windows 8 roll out turned out to be.

One of the obvious drawbacks of Metro on the desktop is that it is different. I honestly don't think that it will be a huge curve for most. It's obviously something that Microsoft is aware of and they must believe that most users will be able to make the transition. It kind of doesn't make sense that they believe that most people wouldn't be able to make the transition and still proceed with Metro as is anyway. Of course there will be frustrations and growing pains but there is some reward to even desktop users.

There's going to be a lot of Metro apps, of all of the issues surrounding Windows 8, I don't see lack of Metro apps as being one of them, there's just going to simply be too many Windows 8 devices to ignore. Even if Windows 8 is a failure, it's still going to sell in the hundreds of millions of copies. Developers can't afford to ignore Windows 8 even if Windows 8 is a failure.

So without question there's going to be a whole lot of new apps, some are going to be good or even great and even free and run just fine with keyboards and mice. So yes, there's benefit to Metro on the desktop for average users. Now you could say that Metro doesn't have any benefit for productivity purposes and there's is a legitimate point here.

But ultimately I think that two different UIs, while possible and maybe even desirable is more complex than I think people realize and it's certainly something Microsoft has ever done, Windows is a pretty much one size fits all UI.
 
Back
Top