Windows 8.1 Allow Users to Boot to Desktop?

I walked by a set of laptops at Sams the other day, they ofcourse all had Windows 8 on them. On one of them though, someone typed "Windows 8 is terrible" into the app search box. I laughed, and agreed.
 
It's as much as individuals as it is about anything really. Microsoft may have to address the declining desktop market by offering the old UI and a Metro off switch. I think that would be a pretty serious blow to Microsoft because I doubt that such options would do much to change the course of traditional desktop and laptop sales even if the PR came across well. And those options would slow the development of the new UI.

Why would development of the UI slow if so many people are going to ignore Metro anyway? I keep hearing this theory and have yet to hear a good explanation.

Here's a wild idea - how about they make it optional (as in, FIRST PARTY support for not defaulting to it) until they actually DO improve it, rather than making people work inside the construction zone, make it compelling so that people actually want to use it, including KB/M users. You know, just like how its easier to talk a wife/girlfriend into something if you make them feel like it was their idea.

They're never going to force this change. There is no shortcut or free ride to relevance in the mobile market. If they want Metro to be their longterm strategy they need to build something more people than the .00001% of touch enabled PC users actually want to use.
 
This looks like the same conversation we've had 8,437 times before.

What new ground is being covered here, exactly?
 
Why would development of the UI slow if so many people are going to ignore Metro anyway? I keep hearing this theory and have yet to hear a good explanation.

I don't think that the general population is ignoring Metro as much as one would be led to think around here. And the other part of it too is hardware. The conventional wisdom goes that Windows 8 works better with touch devices. If the option is there to simply turn all of that off then I think that also lessens OEMs motivation to invest in developing touch capable devices.

Here's a wild idea - how about they make it optional (as in, FIRST PARTY support for not defaulting to it) until they actually DO improve it, rather than making people work inside the construction zone, make it compelling so that people actually want to use it, including KB/M users. You know, just like how its easier to talk a wife/girlfriend into something if you make them feel like it was their idea.

At some point though you're still going to get blow back with this type of change. It might be wiser to do it now than to prolong the situation.

They're never going to force this change. There is no shortcut or free ride to relevance in the mobile market. If they want Metro to be their longterm strategy they need to build something more people than the .00001% of touch enabled PC users actually want to use.

We'll see how fast touch and tablets grow in the PC market. It's estimated to be around 2% of the market now and that number is going to grow, even if the PC market continues to shrink as a whole. As touch and tablet PC hardware gets better and cheaper, yes, it is quite possible to force this change. Indeed these kinds of changes have happened before, like the transitions to laptops. As laptops got cheaper and faster that's what everyone started buying in the PC world. Tablets and hybrids could follow a similar path.
 
I don't think that the general population is ignoring Metro as much as one would be led to think around here.

"Around here"? Really? You do realize the major start menu replacement makers EACH continue to report downloads in the millions. Start8 reported 3 mil as of Jan.16. Pokki reported 1.5mil as of the same date. Its been 3 months and millions more downloads each since then. Thats not even factoring ClassicShell, StartIsBack and other lesser known or free alternatives. If that isnt a wholesale rejection, I dont know what is. And if you think MS is wise to keep ignoring this reality and press ahead removing options trying to force their changes, I'm afraid its going to continue to be a terrible year for Windows 8 branded products.

And the other part of it too is hardware. The conventional wisdom goes that Windows 8 works better with touch devices. If the option is there to simply turn all of that off then I think that also lessens OEMs motivation to invest in developing touch capable devices.

OEM's aren't going to invest in touch simply because there ISNT the ability to disable Metro. Thats ridiculous. MS can't force OEM's to fall in line either. It all starts with customers, and customer demand. If customers don't want it, they aren't going to waste money making it. And for customers to want it, the product has to be compelling. Do you really believe keeping customers captive waiting for stockholm syndrome to set in is a viable business strategy? Dont bother, I already know the answer.
 
"Around here"? Really? You do realize the major start menu replacement makers EACH continue to report downloads in the millions. Start8 reported 3 mil as of Jan.16. Pokki reported 1.5mil as of the same date. Its been 3 months and millions more downloads each since then. Thats not even factoring ClassicShell, StartIsBack and other lesser known or free alternatives. If that isnt a wholesale rejection, I dont know what is. And if you think MS is wise to keep ignoring this reality and press ahead removing options trying to force their changes, I'm afraid its going to continue to be a terrible year for Windows 8 branded products.

I have to agree.
At first I thought the plummeting PC sales were due to other factors, but it pretty much is looking like people are just steering clear of Windows 8 and it's default GUI.

Just today, I had another user ask to put on Windows 7 in place of Windows 8 on his new system before ordering it.
I think it's universal at this point, either Microsoft needs FIX their terrible GUI or start giving users the option to change it natively, without the need for 3rd party tools.

3rd party tools are a nice quick 'fix', but the average users of the world aren't messing with this bullshit any further.
Come on Microsoft, start listening to your user-base and give them what they want, it certainly is not asking too much.
 
"Around here"? Really? You do realize the major start menu replacement makers EACH continue to report downloads in the millions. Start8 reported 3 mil as of Jan.16. Pokki reported 1.5mil as of the same date. Its been 3 months and millions more downloads each since then. Thats not even factoring ClassicShell, StartIsBack and other lesser known or free alternatives. If that isnt a wholesale rejection, I dont know what is. And if you think MS is wise to keep ignoring this reality and press ahead removing options trying to force their changes, I'm afraid its going to continue to be a terrible year for Windows 8 branded products.

All I'm saying is that the average person is just going to use Windows as is. At this point there's tens of millions of Windows 8 machines out there, it's probably a slate bet that most don't have a Start Menu/Button replacement. As for those that ado use these tools I'm sure most downloaded several to compare and pick one.

Not saying that these things aren't popular, but unlikely deployed in the general Windows 8 population the at percentages of Windows 8 users in places like this.

Dont bother, I already know the answer.

The thing is no one has the answers. Maybe Windows 8 won't work out and Microsoft will be forced to put in a switch for the new UI. Again all I'm saying is that that action is unlikely to sell many more copies of Windows or conventional Windows desktop and laptops because the market for computing devices is simply moving towards more mobile and touch oriented devices.
 
It's as much as individuals as it is about anything really. Microsoft may have to address the declining desktop market by offering the old UI and a Metro off switch. I think that would be a pretty serious blow to Microsoft because I doubt that such options would do much to change the course of traditional desktop and laptop sales even if the PR came across well. And those options would slow the development of the new UI.

After 18 months of Windows 8 daily across different form factors and input methods, 8 is capable of a lot, perhaps too much. The UI is on the complex side and it does make more sense if one uses it on a touch screen or with some type of touch input what supports gestures. This complexity added with a lot of unfinished parts do make it rough product. I do think that a good number of keyboard and mouse users can be made somewhat happier with refinements in the new UI without the need to bring back the old UI in the box. How successful Microsoft will be in that venture in 8.1, I have no idea.

I personally find Windows 8 extremely pleasant to use with a mouse and keyboard, moreso even than Windows 7 (albeit after a significant learning curve).

The turning point for me was when my mother and father asked me to put it on the notebook they currently use to run their business as well as purchased two more machines with Windows 8, one for personal use and a secondary machine for the business. I feel like if they can wrap their head around it and embrace the change, then Microsoft must be doing something right.
 
I personally find Windows 8 extremely pleasant to use with a mouse and keyboard, moreso even than Windows 7 (albeit after a significant learning curve).

The turning point for me was when my mother and father asked me to put it on the notebook they currently use to run their business as well as purchased two more machines with Windows 8, one for personal use and a secondary machine for the business. I feel like if they can wrap their head around it and embrace the change, then Microsoft must be doing something right.

There is absolutely no reason to "upgrade" to Win8. It sounds like your parents might be trying to jump on the "look, we are using the newest windows so we must be up to date and cool!" bandwagon, the same bandwagon heatlesssun cheer leads for in every Win8 thread.
 
I personally find Windows 8 extremely pleasant to use with a mouse and keyboard, moreso even than Windows 7 (albeit after a significant learning curve).

The turning point for me was when my mother and father asked me to put it on the notebook they currently use to run their business as well as purchased two more machines with Windows 8, one for personal use and a secondary machine for the business. I feel like if they can wrap their head around it and embrace the change, then Microsoft must be doing something right.

I can link OpenSuse again for change but it is not working for MS, they sell things that are not wanted by the industry, it is being shunned. It is not a user problem I mean you can use any OS if you are okay with computers.

MS attitude towards this is we have windows now every device will run windows like it was on the X86 and it does not work.

Windows RT their wet dream of sales on ARM devices is just been a waterfall of tears for them , it is not working.

For whatever reasons the operating system has pissed of people at Valve and so on and so forth it running back to desktop does not matter either.

The major changes could not stop windows 8 from failing badly. At the top people just are not bright enough to see the signs that are right in front of them.

Windows 8 would not sell even if it came with free candy every time you boot it.
 
I personally find Windows 8 extremely pleasant to use with a mouse and keyboard, moreso even than Windows 7 (albeit after a significant learning curve).

The turning point for me was when my mother and father asked me to put it on the notebook they currently use to run their business as well as purchased two more machines with Windows 8, one for personal use and a secondary machine for the business. I feel like if they can wrap their head around it and embrace the change, then Microsoft must be doing something right.

There seems to be a need by some to declare Windows 8/RT as total failures and while it's true that things are rough, particularly for RT, I don't think you just up and abandon things after less than six months, particularly when the stakes are this important.

I agree that using Windows 8 with a keyboard and mouse isn't difficult at all and works very much like Windows 7 in many ways. Yes, using the default UI is different and it does take for time to get used to it, but like you I've seen some pretty non-technical folks pick up 8 just fine but I also know some people that haven't gotten and don't like it.

The key for Microsoft is to get enough of the issues in the new UI straight enough to get at least some of these people on board. If they can't they may be forced to put in a Metro off switch. But again, with the years long decline in conventional desktops and laptops and the rise of mobile, it won't matter that much in the long term, even if Windows 8 were declared the greatest desktop OS in history, so what if the world is moving to other devices. Microsoft would be better served by getting the UI cleaned up first.
 
It won't be abandoned yet. Microsoft has had a history of taking a product through two iterations and determining whether or not to continue if the second iteration remains unprofitable before giving it the axe. Then again, this is their flagship product line that's seeing poor performance in their primary market so there's no doubt going to be other tactics considered because of the nature of the threat this poses to one of their core products.
 
It won't be abandoned yet. Microsoft has had a history of taking a product through two iterations and determining whether or not to continue if the second iteration remains unprofitable before giving it the axe. Then again, this is their flagship product line that's seeing poor performance in their primary market so there's no doubt going to be other tactics considered because of the nature of the threat this poses to one of their core products.

they killed Silverlight (pretty much) already so you know, maybe they are getting faster? :D
 
they killed Silverlight (pretty much) already so you know, maybe they are getting faster? :D

Didn't Silverlight come out in like 2007? They should have walked away from it like twenty years ago. It would have been better for all of us.

Off the top of my head, Netflix was the only major player that I recall seeing adopt Silverlight and they're Flash-based now.
 
Re-iterating my lengthy post from a day or two ago regarding pricing of Windows 8 devices, here's an article from ComputerWorld:
http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9238404/Don_t_blame_Windows_8_for_PC_slowdown_Apple_hit_too

In summary, it's not that consumers don't like Windows, it's just that the mentality of consumers look to the price of said product first. And, many consumers want touchscreen-enabled devices but the prices of Windows 8 combined with touchscreens are still too high. The article stated that for computer companies to succeed, they'd have to drop prices of these touchscreen-enabled computers another $100 to $150 to be competitive against lower-priced, higher end tablets with Android and iOS so that entry-level Windows 8 tablets and notebooks are at the $400 to $500 range. Currently the lowest priced Win 8 tablet is with a slower-than-Intel Core i3/i5 or AMD APU Intel Atom processor at $499 from ASUS or depending on manufacturer, and next cheapest is at $549. The next price up is at $649 to $699, then $749 to $799, and then highest at $1249 to $1499.

That means Windows 8 tablets should start at $349 to $399 at the lowest Again, non-RT Windows 8 tablets because it's stupid you can't install programs outside Windows Store apps on an RT device.

Even still, it's going to be a hard sell when most of the tablets sold are in the $250 to $400 range. Microsoft and OEMs are not helping with the issue of declining PC sales nor offering features on PCs at affordable prices that people could afford. I'm talking about average people who go for the fancy feature sets and touchscreens, and pricing.

This is why PCs are in decline is because of pricing and lack of comparable features to tablets especially when most tablets have higher screen resolutions at the $300 to $500 range. And, it doesn't matter if notebooks have touchscreen or not. People are looking for the latest and biggest thing in a gadget, but they want it at a good price.

That and Windows 8 without a way to make the UI more convoluted as it is, isn't helping matters with the sales decline either. And, computers are lasting longer and longer since the software we have today runs perfectly fine on something as old as a Core 2 Duo, so there's no point in upgrading to a newer, better computer.

Hexus.net as well as other web sites are reporting that line of code that may allow suppression of the Start Screen and boot straight to desktop. However, Hexus.net believes this option will not be enabled by default given that you will be booting straight to a blank Desktop and no pinned programs to the Taskbar. That and there's no mention of the Start menu. So there you have it folks, Start Screen will be the default menu but, hey, at least you get a boot to desktop option probably buried in Control Panel or Personalization settings.
 
There is absolutely no reason to "upgrade" to Win8. It sounds like your parents might be trying to jump on the "look, we are using the newest windows so we must be up to date and cool!" bandwagon, the same bandwagon heatlesssun cheer leads for in every Win8 thread.

I will respectfully disagree with your assertion. My parents are in their late fifties and have absolutely no desire to be up to date and cool, it's simply a matter of usability. My mother particularly liked it when she used it on my desktop and it's a really good fit. They generally have little to no interest to dig into the file-level and their uses include launching about four programs.

I mentioned that the new start menu is best to think of like an app or program "drawer". I don't see a lot of difference between shortcuts on the desktop and the new start menu.
 
I don't think that the general population is ignoring Metro as much as one would be led to think around here. And the other part of it too is hardware. The conventional wisdom goes that Windows 8 works better with touch devices. If the option is there to simply turn all of that off then I think that also lessens OEMs motivation to invest in developing touch capable devices.



At some point though you're still going to get blow back with this type of change. It might be wiser to do it now than to prolong the situation.



We'll see how fast touch and tablets grow in the PC market. It's estimated to be around 2% of the market now and that number is going to grow, even if the PC market continues to shrink as a whole. As touch and tablet PC hardware gets better and cheaper, yes, it is quite possible to force this change. Indeed these kinds of changes have happened before, like the transitions to laptops. As laptops got cheaper and faster that's what everyone started buying in the PC world. Tablets and hybrids could follow a similar path.

You are so wrong. I have had very many of my clients up and give up on 8 even some returned their purchases. People are avoiding 8 on purpose because now 8 has a horrid stigma due to its own design.

As for laptops there was a demand to have a mobile workstation, and its still took years to achieve this transition. There is no demand for a Hybrid solution, MS is trying to invent a new market which no one has any interest in or demands solutions in.

Piss poor design, piss poor execution, piss poor experience. Rant and rave all you want but the Hybrid device demand is not there and may never be.


Its like the Hybrid car situation.. If you used your reasoning how come everyone doesn't drive a hybrid car?
 
You are so wrong. I have had very many of my clients up and give up on 8 even some returned their purchases. People are avoiding 8 on purpose because now 8 has a horrid stigma due to its own design.

We can debate the new UI back and forth, that's not really the issue here. All I am saying is that it is unlikely that most out of the tens of millions of Windows 8 machines in the field to date are running a Start Button/Menu replacement. There's no way for either of us to prove the point one way or the other but historically the case seems to have been well made that most people who buy new computers tend to use what's there without lots of tweaking or major modifications to the UI.

As for laptops there was a demand to have a mobile workstation, and its still took years to achieve this transition. There is no demand for a Hybrid solution, MS is trying to invent a new market which no one has any interest in or demands solutions in.

Piss poor design, piss poor execution, piss poor experience. Rant and rave all you want but the Hybrid device demand is not there and may never be.

I think there is plenty of indication that is interest in hybrid designs. Look at how many people use keyboards with their iPads for instance. And there's always demand for lighter, thinner and better battery life. And how many people even really know what a hybrid is at this point? I get asked a good number of questions about my Samsung 500T. When I give them a quick run down of all that it can do they are generally very impressed. The main sticking point is the price. If devices like the 500T can come in around $500 with the performance that Bay Trail seems to be offering with 1080P + screens in around 10" to 12" I think hybrids will do very well.

Its like the Hybrid car situation.. If you used your reasoning how come everyone doesn't drive a hybrid car?

It's not like a hybrid fuel vehicle in that the hybrid vehicle is still a vehicle that's used like a conventional vehicle . A hybrid tablet can be used just like a laptop and just like a touch based tablet in lots of situations.
 
We can debate the new UI back and forth, that's not really the issue here. All I am saying is that it is unlikely that most out of the tens of millions of Windows 8 machines in the field to date are running a Start Button/Menu replacement. There's no way for either of us to prove the point one way or the other but historically the case seems to have been well made that most people who buy new computers tend to use what's there without lots of tweaking or major modifications to the UI.



I think there is plenty of indication that is interest in hybrid designs. Look at how many people use keyboards with their iPads for instance. And there's always demand for lighter, thinner and better battery life. And how many people even really know what a hybrid is at this point? I get asked a good number of questions about my Samsung 500T. When I give them a quick run down of all that it can do they are generally very impressed. The main sticking point is the price. If devices like the 500T can come in around $500 with the performance that Bay Trail seems to be offering with 1080P + screens in around 10" to 12" I think hybrids will do very well.



It's not like a hybrid fuel vehicle in that the hybrid vehicle is still a vehicle that's used like a conventional vehicle . A hybrid tablet can be used just like a laptop and just like a touch based tablet in lots of situations.

The golden question is how many of the people you've impressed actually ran out and bought that same or similar setup ? Being impressed and actually purchasing something is a whole different ball game.

As for how many people use a ipad with a keyboard? I see VERY few people actually utilize this. Out of the 20 Ipads I see maybe 1 has a keyboard. Again the hybrid environment is non existent.

If there was a truly a hybrid demand everyone would want one. Same thing goes for Hybrid cars, they have been around for some time and yet the BULK of cars out there are still good ole' fashion NON Hybrid.
 
If there was a truly a hybrid demand everyone would want one. Same thing goes for Hybrid cars, they have been around for some time and yet the BULK of cars out there are still good ole' fashion NON Hybrid.

Your logic doesn't logic. Like, seriously, that makes almost no sense.

Let's rephrase it:
"If there was truly a Bieber demand, everyone would want Bieber. He's been around for a while and yet the BULK of music is good ol' non-Bieber."

"If there was truly a high-end GPU demand, then everyone would want a high-end GPU. They've been around for years, but the BULK of cards out there are good ol' Intel IGPs."

"If there was truly a Corvette demand, everyone would want one. They're been around for decades, yet the BULK of cars out there are good ol' non-Corvettes."

Yea, there's such a LACK of Hybrid demand out there that Toyota has decided to make three different Prius models instead of just one. And nearly every other major manufacturer jumped in on the game.

Or are you saying that Toyota, GM, Ford, Nissan, Hyundai, Honda, Chrysler, Mitsubishi, and others are all interested in building products for which there is no demand?
 
Your logic doesn't logic. Like, seriously, that makes almost no sense.

Let's rephrase it:
"If there was truly a Bieber demand, everyone would want Bieber. He's been around for a while and yet the BULK of music is good ol' non-Bieber."

"If there was truly a high-end GPU demand, then everyone would want a high-end GPU. They've been around for years, but the BULK of cards out there are good ol' Intel IGPs."

"If there was truly a Corvette demand, everyone would want one. They're been around for decades, yet the BULK of cars out there are good ol' non-Corvettes."

Yea, there's such a LACK of Hybrid demand out there that Toyota has decided to make three different Prius models instead of just one. And nearly every other major manufacturer jumped in on the game.

Or are you saying that Toyota, GM, Ford, Nissan, Hyundai, Honda, Chrysler, Mitsubishi, and others are all interested in building products for which there is no demand?

HOLY COW! Now you've done it, then internet is going to explode! :D Logic, what is Wrench going to do with that? :)
 
Your logic doesn't logic. Like, seriously, that makes almost no sense.

Let's rephrase it:
"If there was truly a Bieber demand, everyone would want Bieber. He's been around for a while and yet the BULK of music is good ol' non-Bieber."

"If there was truly a high-end GPU demand, then everyone would want a high-end GPU. They've been around for years, but the BULK of cards out there are good ol' Intel IGPs."

"If there was truly a Corvette demand, everyone would want one. They're been around for decades, yet the BULK of cars out there are good ol' non-Corvettes."

Yea, there's such a LACK of Hybrid demand out there that Toyota has decided to make three different Prius models instead of just one. And nearly every other major manufacturer jumped in on the game.

Or are you saying that Toyota, GM, Ford, Nissan, Hyundai, Honda, Chrysler, Mitsubishi, and others are all interested in building products for which there is no demand?

Thank you, Pyroja.
 
Love the logic. :D

But seriously, a business creates Product A based on an emerging need, with possible high volume demand in the future. If the product becomes popular and mass production allows for cheaper manufacturing, then it will take off and be a success. If neither of those two things happen, the product can either fail or just be mediocre.

In the case of Hybrids specifically its simply too soon to tell what's going to happen. At this point its still an emerging technology, albeit a much smaller step than the leap which is complete touch-based tablet computing. Its a bridge product, pulling together the old (laptop/notebook/traditional computer) and the very new (tablet, smartphone, touch-based computing devices).

New technology always takes time to be accepted. In the case of touch-based computing businesses and consumers are still figuring out new ways to utilize the devices, so the process is continually evolving with new software and hardware. Let us not forget that there are still businesses, big businesses, which have not completed the move into the digital realm. No wonder they are slow on the touch-based computing uptake. It would be like telling consumers (who are now getting accustomed to their touch devices) that next month there will be Thought-based computing devices and if after a few months we don't see Massive sales and huge demand, that those have utterly failed.

In time, even coal turns into diamonds. Or it gets burned :eek: :p
 
New technology always takes time to be accepted. In the case of touch-based computing businesses and consumers are still figuring out new ways to utilize the devices, so the process is continually evolving with new software and hardware. Let us not forget that there are still businesses, big businesses, which have not completed the move into the digital realm. No wonder they are slow on the touch-based computing uptake. It would be like telling consumers (who are now getting accustomed to their touch devices) that next month there will be Thought-based computing devices and if after a few months we don't see Massive sales and huge demand, that those have utterly failed.

That analogy might have some merit if thought-computing had been around for 10-15+ years already, the industry has tried to introduce and reintroduce it as the next big thing several times much like the 3DTV fad. Then if the "new" thought-based computing devices were failing again after 7 months of multi-million dollar ad campaigns with people breakdancing in their cubicles with headgear on, and there still wasn't any demand, then I'm afraid there would be some bad news.
 
Your logic doesn't logic. Like, seriously, that makes almost no sense.

Let's rephrase it:
"If there was truly a Bieber demand, everyone would want Bieber. He's been around for a while and yet the BULK of music is good ol' non-Bieber."

"If there was truly a high-end GPU demand, then everyone would want a high-end GPU. They've been around for years, but the BULK of cards out there are good ol' Intel IGPs."

"If there was truly a Corvette demand, everyone would want one. They're been around for decades, yet the BULK of cars out there are good ol' non-Corvettes."

Yea, there's such a LACK of Hybrid demand out there that Toyota has decided to make three different Prius models instead of just one. And nearly every other major manufacturer jumped in on the game.

Or are you saying that Toyota, GM, Ford, Nissan, Hyundai, Honda, Chrysler, Mitsubishi, and others are all interested in building products for which there is no demand?


I'm not saying all the car manufacturers are not interested in building those cars. What I am saying is that there isn't an overwhelming DEMAND for hybrid cars.There is a demand and its growing but people still have a CHOICE. What MS did with 8 is the equivalent of every car manufacturer saying fuck it. ALL vehicles produced are Hybrids you no longer have a choice here is one sticker price if you don't like it fuck off.
Yes there is a demand for

What you missed is the point that 1. Market always gives you choices except for MS.
2. Just because the market has a potential doesn't mean every one will jump on board or the demand will be there.
 
The Start Button speculated for Windows 8.1 will be little more than a shortcut to the Metro start screen, according to Microsoft insiders speaking to MaryJoFoley and PaulThurott on condition of anonymity.

Microsoft just dont get it, do they.

image.jpg
 
Back
Top