Windows 7 Touch: Dead On Arrival

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The folks at Network World are complaining about the state of touchscreen technology in both both Windows 7 and Mac OS X Snow Leopard.

Well, that was the theory. The truth has been a bitter disappointment. In both Windows 7 and Mac OS X Snow Leopard, the touch experience has been underwhelming. Limited deployment is partly to blame, as -- despite marketing hype -- neither Apple nor Microsoft is making a serious effort to touchify their OSes. For Microsoft, touch seems to be a technology crush it won't admit it's fallen out of love with; for Apple, touch seems to be a key part of its non-PC strategy.
 
Their opinions are ridiculous, but then again, they're a network-technology-centric publication, go figure. It's not like they're experts or anything...

Bleh.
 
Yeah most of the complaints are a little ridiculous. They're complaining for the most part that touch can't compete with keyboard and mouse. I'm gonna have to go with "no shit, Sherlock".

Desktop computer will always use keyboard and mouse primarily. Touch and tablet will always be secondary.

Although Star Trek: The Voyage Home comes to mind.. "how quaint".
 
I'd have a problem with my right arm looking like A. Schwarzenegger from usage and my left like a limp dick.:D
 
I haven't had a chance to try windows 7's touch capabilities, but from what I've seen on artickles and videos people seem to really enjoy it. I'm looking at getting an hp tx2 tablet/laptop and a lot of people really like the touchscreen. Both of these OSes just came out and these screens are still being perfected, they will both get better over time. These guys are ridiculous.
 
Well, once 30+ contact point multi touch screens are cheap as dirt and common place on laptops and some sort of Teflon anti fingerprint material is discovered to coat the screens with then the tech might take off.
 
So he is complaining that windows 7 and mac osx are not designed with "tough" at the center like the iPhone and Palm Pre are?

Thats pretty stupid if you ask me. PC's are a lot more complex, redesigning them to be used with pure touch would drive me crazy.

I put in some elo touch terminals at a client for filling out online EMR's and while the idea was cool. It just isn't the same, i ended up hooking a keyboard and mouse up to them.
 
I hate having fingerprints on my screen.

I watched a Windows 7 touch screen demo on youtube and a lot of the regular motions would have been far easier with a mouse than using your hand.
 
People are not getting this. Touch is not meant to replace keyboards and mice but to augment them. Try web surfing with only one hand, that's not at ALL easy with a keyboard and mouse for instance.
 
I hate having fingerprints on my screen.

This is a VERY common complaint. And whats so odd is that anything you touch has finger prints all over it, you just don't necessarily seem them. At any rate it used to bother me until I realized that my keyboard is has finger prints all over it. Once you just accept the screen as an input device its no big deal.
 
Then I saw this and realized this guy has NO CLUE how to even use this technology.

(Windows 7 does have a handwriting app that is OK to write with, but impossible to edit with. And writing more than a dozen words at a time is likely to make your fingers and arm hurt.)

I write in OneNote with a pen all the time. Fingers and arm hurting? What kind of sissy is this guy? Writting on my tx2z is EASIER than writing on paper. Editing? Its FAR easier than with paper.
 
Millions of lonely people in dark rooms do this every night.

Yeah, I knew that kind of comment was coming but really, I like to read in the bed at night and its just cool to be able to lay on my side and control the machine with a finger. Now the pen is usually easier and the article does have a point that for the most part apps aren't all that finger, by default. You can use zooming to make it easier to click on things with your finger, much like mobile phone browsers, only that its much faster.
 
It's as simple as it is in my sig:

Bleh. You either get it or you don't. Some of us do, some of us don't... can't we all just get along? :)
 
Trust me when I say that they are full of crap... I OWN an HP TX2-1270us with Windows 7 RTM and the Win 7 touchpack installed.

It... is... AMAZING

Apple, on the other hand, has a lot of catching up to do.
 
It's as simple as it is in my sig:

Bleh. You either get it or you don't. Some of us do, some of us don't... can't we all just get along? :)

True but what I don't get is why everyone talks about pen and touch technology they are ALWAYS looking at it terms of replacing the mouse and keyboard on a desk. These technologies were NEVER meant to replace the keyboard and mouse.

I have yet to see an article like this mention that simple common sense notion. And these guys are supposed to be the experts?:confused:
 
I remember all the hype when they first showed this... guess it sizzled out... lol
 
Thats pretty stupid if you ask me. PC's are a lot more complex, redesigning them to be used with pure touch would drive me crazy.
Agreed. In some situations, nothing is better than a keyboard and a mouse. They're both fast, accurate and tactile input devices (except for Apple's Mighty Mouse, which is an abomination of a mouse). A touch surface is comparatively sloppy and full of potential ergonomic pitfalls. Great for one-handed operation, but how many desktop/notebook PC users need that kind of capability?

I can see the appeal of gesturing, particularly since I'm an iPhone user, but gestures are generally a replacement for dedicated and discrete controls such as a button or slider and are typically not in any way inherently superior to these controls. If those controls are there, I'd rather use a mouse and/or keyboard shortcuts to access them, particularly since they afford greater precision (rotating in 45 degree or 90 degree increments by holding down a toggle key, for example, instead of free rotation only).
 
Agreed. In some situations, nothing is better than a keyboard and a mouse. They're both fast, accurate and tactile input devices (except for Apple's Mighty Mouse, which is an abomination of a mouse). A touch surface is comparatively sloppy and full of potential ergonomic pitfalls. Great for one-handed operation, but how many desktop/notebook PC users need that kind of capability?

And if you need to input text then most should use a keyboard. But why limit yourself to these modes of input when there are other options? What about non-textual information? Typing mathematical symbols sucks.

It’s nice to be able to just jot stuff down rather than having to go to a keyboard and type it like I’m doing with this post.

When every problem is a nail every solution is a hammer. Only thing is that not all problems are nails.
 
And if you need to input text then most should use a keyboard. But why limit yourself to these modes of input when there are other options?

Because they work fine for 90% or greater of the population.

Until the day i can strap a band to my head and have my computer interpret my brain waves, i will used a keyboard and mouse
 
maybe its just me, but is this guy kinda a apple fan boy? He states how both OS's are shortcoming but leads the title to think that on Windows is to blame. Having used both, I think MS wins this fight, Win7 touch aint really that bad, I dont know what this guys problem is.

But, about touch and being used on normal desktops, why? People are lazy, and most (not all, touch has its perks) situations you can think of its just better to have a mouse. Youve got to think also, how much screen are you covering with your big as clumsy hand when you try to touch something? A mouse takes up a few pixels and is far more acurate than my big ass fingers. Now if you ask me, a cross between a mouse and a glove would be the best idea, but thats just me...
 
Touch screens are a nice gimic on desktop PC's but have no real function. They do have possible applications on netbooks or other area's were keyboard and mouse is not always handy.
 
i put win7 on my carpc. it is leaps better then any other os for touchscreen capability.
 
Trust me when I say that they are full of crap... I OWN an HP TX2-1270us with Windows 7 RTM and the Win 7 touchpack installed.

It... is... AMAZING

Apple, on the other hand, has a lot of catching up to do.

I have the tx2z as well and the touch is cool and useful in the right environment and the Tocuh Pack stuff is pretty cool. I admit that I've having issues with the N-Trig RC drivers in 7 RTM. They work but there are some nasty quirks for me . Looking forward to the release drivers!
 
Because they work fine for 90% or greater of the population.

Until the day i can strap a band to my head and have my computer interpret my brain waves, i will used a keyboard and mouse

And I'll use a keyboard and mouse and pen and touch based on the need and environment. You limit your freedom with only a mouse and keyboard. And hey, when that mind interface comes along I go with that if it doesn't cause brain damage!:D
 
And I'll use a keyboard and mouse and pen and touch based on the need and environment. You limit your freedom with only a mouse and keyboard. And hey, when that mind interface comes along I go with that if it doesn't cause brain damage!:D

Have you ever tried to hit Ctrl + Alt + del on a tablet when it is closed?
 
Have you ever tried to hit Ctrl + Alt + del on a tablet when it is closed?

Most of them let you assign a gesture or even have a button to do that. I've got an old Fujitsu slate tablet (my favorite kind) and it's got a button by default for CAD, not an issue.

NEXT!!!
 
Most of them let you assign a gesture or even have a button to do that. I've got an old Fujitsu slate tablet (my favorite kind) and it's got a button by default for CAD, not an issue.

NEXT!!!

Hmm, IBM needs to do this, lol. Either that or i couldn't find the darned button

That said, i actually like the tablet computers, they are really handy and have great functionality.
 
I have the tx2z as well and the touch is cool and useful in the right environment and the Tocuh Pack stuff is pretty cool. I admit that I've having issues with the N-Trig RC drivers in 7 RTM. They work but there are some nasty quirks for me . Looking forward to the release drivers!

Ditto

Had my TZ2 about a week. I put win7 on it along with the N-trig multitouch beta drivers. I liked the touch navigation a lot (much faster than the touchpad for surfing) but I was getting random clicks / mouse movements, so I had to uninstall the beta drivers.

Looking forward to the final also.
 
Personally?

I'm avoiding a touchscreen till that's all that's on the shelf.

I like my keyboard and mouse.
 
that article is DOA not windows touch........however I do think it will take some time to iron out all the kinks......
 
Yeah most of the complaints are a little ridiculous. They're complaining for the most part that touch can't compete with keyboard and mouse. I'm gonna have to go with "no shit, Sherlock".

Desktop computer will always use keyboard and mouse primarily. Touch and tablet will always be secondary.

Although Star Trek: The Voyage Home comes to mind.. "how quaint".

Think outside the box. While that mentality trend maintains, computers will continue to suck while generating all kind of problems they shouldn't.
 
I'm not particularly sure what he thinks is lacking....Win7 has wonderful integration with touch. It plays well with the new taskbar (for instance, if you touch a taskbar icon the preview thumbnails stay up, the preview thumbnails have the "close" X constantly showing and the X is bigger than normal. Also, you can press and hold to get the show desktop preview effect and the show desktop button is bigger on touch-enabled machines to make it easier to hit), there's the multi-touch gestures, multi-touch in Paint..... it's fully integrated and a great experience. (Written from my tablet)
 
Back
Top