Windows 7 Beta Taking Unusual Development Route

I seriously can't help but LOL at this.

That's what the media said about Vista too. Guess what? Sold at darn near double the rate that XP ever did.

Couple that with the fact Windows 7 is getting good praise AND isn't changing a ton of interfacing like Vista... It'll be a smash it. [\QUOTE]

First I am a big Windows fan. It's how I make a living so I want Windows to succeed. Vista numbers are bandied about, but I do know that it wasn't well received where I work, one of the largest corporate Windows bases in the world, 200,000+ desktops and thousands of servers. Now that had a lot to do with bad custom applications but still, no matter what the fault, when something related about Windows goes wrong, Microsoft fairly or not gets the blame.

I'd consider your little niche touchscreen market to be probably less than 5%. That's hardly something that will delay a billion-dollar profit cash cow for Microsoft.
[\QUOTE]

This maybe a niche market but I'll say it again, tableteers are among the most loyal mostly because NO ONE has this freeking awesome technology, not even Apple, the innovator of all things that someone else did ten years ago. I simply laugh when I see a guy put Linux on a tablet as the only OS because that's like turning down Jessica Alba for Jessica Simpson. When tableteers are born they worse than Trekies. I'm on my fourth tablet and will never ever again buy another regular laptop. Conventional laptops are like three legged cats to me. And from what I hear in the media, these devices make a lot of money for Microsoft and the hardware vendor. My guess is that a well outfitted tablet makes close to times the profit of a netbook is my guess. Since Microsoft is practically giving away XP for netbooks, from Microsofts side of it that's probably not a big overstatement. Niche markets though small are usually very profitable. Now granted Microsoft want to put 7 on netbooks know but still those 7 license are going to be on the low end of the cost scale. Microsoft can't price itself out of the netbook market, because that's were the real growth is these days,

If Microsoft launches 7 and the touch stuff is flaky it'll be all over the media. The media does everything it can to undermine Microsoft. I'm not trying to sound like a guy who needs aluminum around my head, but I know you see the crap that comes out about Microsoft that often just a guy whose never even seen what he's talking about using Slashdot and Wikipedia (have you ever read the Wiki on Vista? Couldn't be more biased than if Steve Jobs had written, and know that I think about he might have).

This is where you are wrong.

It's not Microsoft that is at fault or has to get it right here. The ONLY thing Microsoft can do is give the developers more time.
Like I said, that's RTM. Most developers aren't going to try to write their drivers on a Beta OS. So delaying RTM delays everything.

In this bad economy, one of two choices:
1) Some other company with sense enough to write good drivers will step in and steal all of your market.
2) You'll crash and burn because Dell, HP, etc aren't going to be putting your incompatible hardware in their machines.


Microsoft has nothing to do with it. Again, the only thing Microsoft can do is offer more time. And again, Vista proved that even with ample time that manufactures fail to act.

Delaying release delays everything. Period.

This is just a time for Microsoft to be ultra paranoid. Apple would be happy to use a Windows 7 slip up in a new campaign of commercials. Maybe I am overstating the bias I see against Microsoft, but I don't think by much. I remember looking at some netbooks at a couple of Best Buys and having the blue shirts tell me how much better the Linux versions were. Seriously, I was like, wow. Never bothered to ask me if I actually was thinking about installing, oh I don't know, some Windows software on it maybe.

If you are right about pushing out sooner rather than later, then so be it. I might be wrong about that. I just see that something happens and the first thing that comes out is that Microsoft rushed 7 out the door to cover up Vista. You know that's exactly what would happen.

And it doesn't matter if a partner is the one who dropped the ball. All fingers will point at Remond. Microsoft doesn't need any bad PR around the 7 launch.

So I'll say it again, Microsoft just get it right!:)
 
Now that had a lot to do with bad custom applications but still, no matter what the fault, when something related about Windows goes wrong, Microsoft fairly or not gets the blame.
But as someone who understands the Vista driver and compatibility issue, you should realize this isn't anything Microsoft could have done differently.

Either they had to jump now or later. They opted for sooner rather than later.

This maybe a niche market but I'll say it again, tableteers are among the most loyal mostly because NO ONE has this freeking awesome technology, not even Apple, the innovator of all things that someone else did ten years ago.

Microsoft can't price itself out of the netbook market, because that's were the real growth is these days
I don't disagree with the fact that it's an area that needs support.
Delaying the entire OS because of a VERY SMALL MINORITY just is bad business sense. As device manufacturers release new hardware and get more people on board, the problem does correct itself.

Also, the fact that most Vista drivers work on 7 makes that very small minority almost vanish into nothing.


If Microsoft launches 7 and the touch stuff is flaky it'll be all over the media.
I really doubt that. Even if it did, who would care?
Very small minority... 95% of people could care less about.
This is just a time for Microsoft to be ultra paranoid. Apple would be happy to use a Windows 7 slip up in a new campaign of commercials. Maybe I am overstating the bias I see against Microsoft, but I don't think by much. I remember looking at some netbooks at a couple of Best Buys and having the blue shirts tell me how much better the Linux versions were. Seriously, I was like, wow. Never bothered to ask me if I actually was thinking about installing, oh I don't know, some Windows software on it maybe.

If you are right about pushing out sooner rather than later, then so be it. I might be wrong about that. I just see that something happens and the first thing that comes out is that Microsoft rushed 7 out the door to cover up Vista. You know that's exactly what would happen.

And it doesn't matter if a partner is the one who dropped the ball. All fingers will point at Remond. Microsoft doesn't need any bad PR around the 7 launch.

So I'll say it again, Microsoft just get it right!:)
 
And it doesn't matter if a partner is the one who dropped the ball. All fingers will point at Remond. Microsoft doesn't need any bad PR around the 7 launch.

You'll NEVER EVER avoid that situation. This happens every single day. Other people's stuff goes bad and Microsoft gets blamed for it.

It's nothing new.
 
I really doubt that. Even if it did, who would care?
Very small minority... 95% of people could care less about.

Normally I would agree, its simply that Microsoft is making an issue of touch and against the context of the iPhone it'll be a bigger deal than it would be for the market share.

I can see the Slashdot, Wall Street Journal, INQ headline now, "Microsoft can't touch Apple" or some such drivel.
 
I can see the Slashdot, Wall Street Journal, INQ headline now, "Microsoft can't touch Apple" or some such drivel.

Let them. What's it do?
When Apple starts failing, as they have been (passing Windows in security vulnerabilities two years running... two minute hack... numerous other examples), and Microsoft releases a great OS like Windows 7, what does it do?
Suddenly Microsoft looks pretty darn good.

Without negative press the public won't know good until it slaps them in the face.
 
... Last time I checked Vista had the longest development time of any Windows OS.

No, that would be Windows XP.

Microsoft had been planning the merging of the consumer OS line and the NT line back as far as 1994. It took them until 2001 to finally deliver.
 
Let them. What's it do?
When Apple starts failing, as they have been (passing Windows in security vulnerabilities two years running... two minute hack... numerous other examples), and Microsoft releases a great OS like Windows 7, what does it do?
Suddenly Microsoft looks pretty darn good.

Without negative press the public won't know good until it slaps them in the face.

Technically Microsoft has been executing pretty well even with Vista. But this business like all others starts to become more about perception than reality. Right now I know a lot of people who think the iPhone was the first touch screen phone, yeah they did multi-touch on the phone first but we know that Windows phone predate the iPhone about four years. And Apple has been so arrogant about security that if they had the install base of Windows they'd be the new laughing stock of secuity.

Where Microsoft has been less than stellar is with the hype and PR machines, and though everyone says they hate all of that crap, the importance of good PR can't be overstated.

I just think that Microsoft needs to just be careful is all that I am saying. I know they know that and I just don't want them to shoot themselves in the foot. Plus my on bias has me wanting to see the touch stuff woking on my tx2z before I give Windows 7 my blessing. I know that doesn't mean anything to anyone but me, but I've been using 7 since the day it went public beta and while its solid at its core, I'm finding a lot of loose ends. I've been sending feedback and I have found about a 12 issues that on the tx2z and another 10 or so on my old test desktop. Nothing big and better than any other beta from MS, its just that fit and finish is very critical to this release and I'm seeing too many simple things that make me think just take your time and let it bake.
 
hehe, i dont tweak settings untill i have a stable install. the only thing why vista runs so poorly on my rig is because it was the very first edition that came out, no service packs. is that a possibility?
 
hehe, i dont tweak settings untill i have a stable install. the only thing why vista runs so poorly on my rig is because it was the very first edition that came out, no service packs. is that a possibility?

I didn't really notice a big jump in performance going to SP1 but you should definitely have SP1 installed by now.
 
The only reason people are calling this OS a quick release is because everyone is still so used to sitting on XP for so damn long. :p

I'm looking forward to it. My Vista Ultimate is damn nice but I could always use a speed increase.
 
Then it's not the fault of the OS, but the device manufacturer, in which case I would be looking for a different product from a better, not so lazy manufacturer.

wow, lol. who was it that changed the operating system to require new drivers be written? i suppose you would say the manufacturers. haha

as i said before, windows 7 = vista SP2. except we will have to pay to get this new service pack. all you get is a minor tweak to the gui interface. this time schedule is appropriate for a service pack. nothing unusual here, folks, move along. :p
 
wow, lol. who was it that changed the operating system to require new drivers be written? i suppose you would say the manufacturers. haha

as i said before, windows 7 = vista SP2. except we will have to pay to get this new service pack. all you get is a minor tweak to the gui interface. this time schedule is appropriate for a service pack. nothing unusual here, folks, move along. :p

Well if the device doesn't have a Vista driver by now, it's probably an old device that will never get a Vista driver anyway, so you can still blame the manufacturer. XP just isn't the OS that Windows 7 is, and it never will be. Windows 7 has been working much better, and for the record, the security holes that XP has, most if not all of them have been patched up or are non-existant in Windows 7. And XP is in it's third service pack, so all of these comparisons that people are making are pointless, but I'd say 7 is doing pretty well for a BETA. :rolleyes:.
 
They're trying to cover up that big black eye they have from Vista. Public perception of Vista is still awful, and most enterprise still haven't converted. Win 7 is poised to garner better public perception, they fixed most of what consumers hated, but it's definitely a consumer oriented OS and I have a hard time believing enterprise adoption will be any better this time around.
 
They're trying to cover up that big black eye they have from Vista. Public perception of Vista is still awful, and most enterprise still haven't converted. Win 7 is poised to garner better public perception, they fixed most of what consumers hated, but it's definitely a consumer oriented OS and I have a hard time believing enterprise adoption will be any better this time around.

You might actually wrong about this I think. Vista's biggest problem in the enterprise was application compatibility. Lots of stuff just broke. That's getting a lot better. Really, 7's security is just way ahead of XP and XP is getting long in the tooth. While business adoption will be slower than MS would like, it will be a lot better than Vista's.
 
wow, lol. who was it that changed the operating system to require new drivers be written? i suppose you would say the manufacturers. haha
Look at it this way... Either they put forth the effort to maintain compatibility with a modern OS or they can't get Microsoft's seal of approval, thus resulting in a ton less sales.

As far as applications go, it's sloppy and lazy writing that caused the majority of software issues in Vista.
The VAST majority of developers who followed Microsoft's recommended programming guidelines had no issues.

as i said before, windows 7 = vista SP2.
You truly show how ignorant you are of the Windows world by this statement.
Vista SP2 is already a planned thing that's actually going to get done.

You might actually wrong about this I think. Vista's biggest problem in the enterprise was application compatibility. Lots of stuff just broke. That's getting a lot better. Really, 7's security is just way ahead of XP and XP is getting long in the tooth. While business adoption will be slower than MS would like, it will be a lot better than Vista's.
I'd agree.

XP is really showing its age, especially with Windows 7.
I'd dump it right now if Windows 7 were available and I had all my domain issues worked out with Vista :)
 
XP is really showing its age, especially with Windows 7.
I'd dump it right now if Windows 7 were available and I had all my domain issues worked out with Vista :)

XP looks like ass to me now. The Start Menu is crap. I have no idea why people like the exploding menu from hell mess with no intelligent way to navigate it. Aero is clean, crisp and sharp. Everything just looks sharper and better defined especially text on a LCD monitor.

According to this we should have Windows 7 RC1 in April: http://windowsitpro.com/Articles/Index.cfm?ArticleID=101398&feed=rss&subj=0 That was my guess and Paul Thurrott usually has good info on MS products. I guess at that point I'll have to try it out on my sig rig on a fresh drive and see what it can do on a fairly powerful piece of hardware.

I'm still a little concerned that things are being rushed but April is still two months away so by then the verdict should be in and if things hold up 7 could be Microsoft best release ever. Unfortunately against this economic back drop things may be a little dampened.
 
XP looks like ass to me now. The Start Menu is crap. I have no idea why people like the exploding menu from hell mess with no intelligent way to navigate it.
Exactly. On my XP machine at work I find myself hitting the Windows key then typing something in... and then getting mad when it doesn't launch my applications.

So instead you've got to go Start- All Programs- Adobe.... etc

Only things holding me back from Vista in my domain:
1) Logon script won't run
2) Roaming profile won't load


I'm still a little concerned that things are being rushed but April is still two months away so by then the verdict should be in and if things hold up 7 could be Microsoft best release ever
Has the Beta even been a month? I mean most all of the issues are worked out by now.
The #1 thing I want to see in the RC is turning UAC on ALL THE WAY by default.
 
XP is really showing its age, especially with Windows 7.
I'd dump it right now if Windows 7 were available and I had all my domain issues worked out with Vista :)

I'm pretty sure the beta is still available from their website.
 
I am gonna say this. Having Frequented Hard forums for years, but never posted. I work for a medium sized internet based company. One of our writes was tasked with the preview of Windows 7 beta. So, being an IT, and a registered Partner, prior to the public release, we installed "7" on a small Dell Optiplex Gx620, SMFF. It has a single core Intel Penium D 2.8Ghz processor, 1Gb of RAM and Integrated Video. Some of you may bash the OS, but I was actually rather surprised by its performance. For one thing, with Vista's beta, I had absolutely no driver support, wheras "7" I didnt have to put my Dell Driver disc in at all, device manager showed zero bangs. We installed FF 3.0, Flash and MS Office 07 and it performed exceptionally well. In fact, I was suprised by the fact that "7" loaded Word and Excel faster than my workstation pc, sporting a quad core CPU and 4 GB of RAM. Photoshop elements 6 installed flawlessly, and also loads faster than my workstation.

From a developers perspective, I can see where there may be some complaints. However, from an ITs sight, I see it like this:

Vista had a bad reputation long before even Release Candidate 1. There was minimal at best Driver support. The 64 bit version had literally no support at all. Coders had to write their own drivers. So everyone who beta tested Vista had nothing but bad things to say, and once release, word of mouth had spread to the point nobody wanted to upgrade to Vista. I use Vista SP1 now on my workstation, and have little or no problems, though my gaming rig still runs XP pro. I have even heard people say they will never go to Vista, and when you ask them have they ever used it? They reply with "no". Goes to show that word of mouth can destroy something for someone even if they haven't seen or used it.

Granted, Vista is a resource hog. Terrible resource hog. "7" however, I am pleasantly surprised at its performance on such a low power box. My feeling of Vista is that it feels heavy when you use it. Those of you that dont nerd like I do, won't understand that, but it just feels heavy when using it compared to XP. Now "7" has the feel of XP with a Vista like interface. Seems like a 98 to ME feel. Catch the drift:
95=XP, 98=Vista, "7"=98ME

I have enjoyed the "7" experience. I have gamed on it, and it outperformed Vista in every aspect. It is a little on the Video laden side, but that can be changed. I just like the XP feeling with a Vista touch.

Thats my take.
 
Great article on Ars: http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2009/02/windows-7whats-the-rush.ars

Highlights:
This condensed release schedule is a result of a new development methodology. Underlying this is Microsoft's new commitment to what the company calls "quality." "Quality" is kind of a vague term—after all, it's not as if the company wants ship something low-quality, even if it might not always seem that way. In this case, it means six things: device compatibility, application compatibility, performance, reliability, battery life, and security. These are not the only areas of concern for the new OS—things like the user experience and documentation quality are still important, but these six are viewed as fundamental. Windows 7 is intended to raise the bar in each of these areas and, to achieve that, Microsoft has used a new development process for this release.
In this light, the decision to not have a second beta or Release Candidate makes a lot more sense. These broad releases are still important—not least because they allow all the third parties that don't have a close relationship with Redmond to get on board the Windows 7 bandwagon—but this time around, Microsoft doesn't need the betas to tell it if the OS works.

With all that said, I have to wonder if it's a good idea to hurry this release. Now, we all know why there is a desire to get Windows 7 out sooner rather than later. Windows Vista's reception has been lukewarm at best and, although this probably isn't entirely fair—Vista is much better than people think it is—it continues to hurt Microsoft's marketing efforts. It doesn't appear to have actually hurt software sales or seriously impeded Windows' market position, but it could. Especially for home users, Apple's platform is an increasingly attractive alternative to Windows.

Given that these problems will remain—that being the price of progress—Microsoft needs to make sure that Windows 7 succeeds on every other front. Annoying glitches of the kind that Vista had (for example, slow network performance during media playback, slow file copies in Explorer) aren't acceptable this time around.
 
Exactly. On my XP machine at work I find myself hitting the Windows key then typing something in... and then getting mad when it doesn't launch my applications.

So instead you've got to go Start- All Programs- Adobe.... etc

Only things holding me back from Vista in my domain:
1) Logon script won't run
2) Roaming profile won't load



Has the Beta even been a month? I mean most all of the issues are worked out by now.
The #1 thing I want to see in the RC is turning UAC on ALL THE WAY by default.

My logon scripts work fine
All roaming profiles must die. I hate that shyte with a passion. PC guys love it, network guys hate it.
 
My logon scripts work fine
All roaming profiles must die. I hate that shyte with a passion. PC guys love it, network guys hate it.

Can you PM me a copy of yours? I can't get my printer mappings to work, and I do mine based off group membership so if I could compare maybe I'll find something wrong with mine.

I hate roaming user profiles from a network standpoint as well, but it's less overhead on the basic helpdesk stuff when a user switches job responsibilities or something and you don't have to copy it around.
 
Back
Top