Windows 7 Beta Taking Unusual Development Route

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
ComputerWorld reports that Microsoft is taking an unusual (for them) path in bringing Windows 7 to the masses. They’re moving straight from the single beta release that was made available in January to a release candidate. Is this acceleration of the development process another admission to Vista’s shortcomings or a preview of the more agile schedule MS would like to use?

Microsoft usually runs its operating systems through multiple betas and multiple release candidates. It delivered two betas and two release candidates for Windows Vista, for example, during that operating system's trouble-plagued development. But Microsoft has been adamant about speeding up the development process.
 
I hope they aren't jumping the gun by going straight to RC, if it needs more time to become more mature I'd rather they get it right first out of the gate rather than a rushed product. Vista was rushed, look what happened.
 
I hope they aren't jumping the gun by going straight to RC, if it needs more time to become more mature I'd rather they get it right first out of the gate rather than a rushed product. Vista was rushed, look what happened.

qft. However; Polishing a turd is possible, but it takes a long time

The Beta is working pretty well for me.

Exactlly. Other than some slight issues with drivers, and such. The Beta is just as stable, and much faster than Vista ever was for me. I say bring on the RC!
 
Technically if you look at the road map... we had Beta, Next comes RC, then RTM. So its not like they shrink wrap the RC necessarily. Plus just like all other modern windows.. there will be windows updates available by the time its on the shelf....they aren't rushing it in my opinion. The Beta has the code for every single feature the are releasing in final so it was code complete basically.
 
Why? W7 uses Vista drivers. :rolleyes:

there are a few anomalies still

for example my g15 screen goes blank when my computer is left idle for a while and my monitor shuts off.

and for some reason i don't get shadows even though they are on in lotro in dx10 mode, in part on turbines side i'm sure, but still.

i'd like to see them get it really solid before they put it out, a few more months of prep work is worth the payoff i think, even though i'm very excited to have a final version.
 
Well they can move more quickly with 7 because it's built on Vista. I'm glad though, after playing around with the beta, it's a pretty slick OS, and I'm sure I'll upgrade ASAP.
 
Why? W7 uses Vista drivers. :rolleyes:

Unfortanetely not all drivers from Vista work with Windows 7. My laptop is a good example of that. I have a Lenovo T61 Thinkpad and anything built on the Thinkvantage technology such as Active Protection and the finger print reader do not work yet in Windows 7. Software installs fine, just cant find the devices.
 
Unfortanetely not all drivers from Vista work with Windows 7. My laptop is a good example of that. I have a Lenovo T61 Thinkpad and anything built on the Thinkvantage technology such as Active Protection and the finger print reader do not work yet in Windows 7. Software installs fine, just cant find the devices.

I have an R61, and my fingerprint reader works fine...
 
Unfortanetely not all drivers from Vista work with Windows 7. My laptop is a good example of that. I have a Lenovo T61 Thinkpad and anything built on the Thinkvantage technology such as Active Protection and the finger print reader do not work yet in Windows 7. Software installs fine, just cant find the devices.

Fingerprint reader works fine on my T61...haven't triedthe other stuff.
 
Service packs don't require that much development time compared to an OS. This is to be expected.
 
Fingerprint reader works fine on my T61...haven't triedthe other stuff.

What did you do? As I mentioned, I get the software to install, it just wont take the driver. Are you running 64bit or 32bit Windows 7? Im running the 64bit edition.
 
I'm not surprised at this. 7 is hardly as much a ground up release as Vista was (well as ground up as an MS OS can be). I bet all they did was get the Vista development team going again soon after it was released and kept them at it.

Vista has been the beta to a degree. I'm quite happy with a tidied up Vista version in 7.
 
I don't see it as a surprise that MS isn't going to go with multiple betas like was done with Vista. First of all, Win7 is built off Vista and most of the work was already done obviously. Next, the current public beta has been running really really well for most people. Yes, there are glitches and bugs but that is to be expected when talking about a beta OS. I used betas of Vista and it wasn't anywhere near the shape of the current Win7 beta. Considering how well the current beta runs, I see no reason to waste time with another beta just because that's what people are used to seeing. Sure, it's a good idea to run multiple betas when you have a lot of stuff wrong, but if you don't have a lot of stuff wrong, what's the use of not moving to a release candidate? It's not like the RC won't have a few more things fixed and tweaked before being RTM.

 
What did you do? As I mentioned, I get the software to install, it just wont take the driver. Are you running 64bit or 32bit Windows 7? Im running the 64bit edition.

I did it a while ago so I could be wrong, but I think I had to use winrar to extract the lenovo exe and manually install it via device manager. I can check later on tonight when I'm on my laptop.
 
I hope they aren't jumping the gun by going straight to RC, if it needs more time to become more mature I'd rather they get it right first out of the gate rather than a rushed product. Vista was rushed, look what happened.

Vista was rushed? they were working on it for years...?



another admission to Vista’s shortcomings or a preview of the more agile schedule MS would like to use?

How is it an admission, considering how much WIndows 7 and vista are alike, Windows 7 doesnt need alot of change done like Vista was from XP, this is why they can get it out faster, they took vista, tweaked it and are selling it as a new OS with some new additions to it... it should be a service pack really!
 
Vista was rushed? they were working on it for years...?





How is it an admission, considering how much WIndows 7 and vista are alike, Windows 7 doesnt need alot of change done like Vista was from XP, this is why they can get it out faster, they took vista, tweaked it and are selling it as a new OS with some new additions to it... it should be a service pack really!

Well it would appear to be a big enough change to warrant a new OS release as opposed to a service pack. After all, the visual tweaks are quite a bit far from what Vista originally looked like.
 
How is it an admission, considering how much WIndows 7 and vista are alike, Windows 7 doesnt need alot of change done like Vista was from XP, this is why they can get it out faster, they took vista, tweaked it and are selling it as a new OS with some new additions to it... it should be a service pack really!

Ummmm, except this is a perfectly normal 2 year release cycle. Vista was simply in development for a huge period of time.
 
... Last time I checked Vista had the longest development time of any Windows OS.

Because they decided to scrap everything and start from scratch halfway through.

Vista was a great OS, Windows 7 is coming along nicely because Vista was so well done in the first place. I find it funny that all the Vista haters love 7 when it has nearly identical performance to Vista.
 
What do you expect. All Win7 is just Vista all fixed up. Not going to take much to bring it to market. Most Vista drivers work for Win7, Most hardware vendors are already working on Win 7 native drivers. I've got Win 7 on both my main desktop and laptop and have ZERO problems with it expect for a app here and there. But I blame that as bad-programming on the apps side not Microsoft's.

For one. I fully expect a RTM by August at the latest. I would not be surprised to see an RTM after just one CR.
 
I went back to XP 64 to get a feel for the comparison in operating speed and I was horribly dissatisfied with XP 64 in general, Windows 7 has been a very clean and enjoyable OS to use. As you probably figured, I promptly reinstalled 7.
 
Going from only 1 beta to RC doesn't mean much. By taking in a lot more beta users, their analysts may have discovered they are ahead of schedule. Perhaps they plan to only skip Beta 1, and go to RC1. If MS plans to have larger pools of public testers, they may discover a much more variety of hardware and users who have different software configurations that put their OS in a real life performance & demonstration mode. To be honest, I prefer MS to switch to such a technique, especially if it results in an OS ready to go out of the box.
 
I consider all Microsoft operating systems in Beta until the release of the second service pack ;)
 
While have little doubt that Microsoft would love to get 7 out sooner rather than later given the issues with Vista I really doubt they are going to rush it. Vista to 7 is a much smaller transition technically than XP to Vista so it's probably not a big deal as long as the OS is feature complete and the vendor support is there.

From a SDLC standpoint what would be the major difference between one beta and two RCs versus two beats and one RC? I guess at the RC stage the code isn't altered in any way?
 
I consider all Microsoft operating systems in Beta until the release of the second service pack ;)

There is some truth to this, but I think it lies in the vast problem of testing all that there is in the Windows ecosystem. Plenty of people with the right combination of things hit the ground running on day one with the initial release of a Microsoft OS.

This really is a problem unique to Windows. Mac's are closed and Linux doesn't have anywhere near the deployments. I'm not saying that this makes Windows better but its one hell of technical challenge.
 
It works for me pretty well. I'm running an AMD Penom II 920 with 8 gigs o ram and it runs like a dream. I also installed it on an Athlon 2000+xp with 256 megs -o- ram and it ran fine like that too. They seem to have a winner on their hands here.
 
Be thankful for vista, it laid the path to 7. The vista environment was much too new to release when it did. The time it's been out now and matured has allowed 7 to be what it is.

Evolution my friends!
 
Eventually. When Vista started out, it was total crap.
Now it's a decent OS.


Don't start with the stupid OS wars, it doesn't get anyone anywhere...

Vista worked just as well for me when I got it (within two days of it's earliest release) as it does now. So you can keep up your argument as well - as it will take us nowhere, because Vista seemed to work for some, and not quite work for others, it just depended on your specific situation.
 
The Beta seems to be going fairly smoothly for alot of people..bring on the next step. I'm quite happy with the this first beta, despite a couple non-MS software issues...which aren't Microsoft's responsibility.

Vista is a crap even now

Most would disagree.
 
Vista worked just as well for me when I got it (within two days of it's earliest release) as it does now. So you can keep up your argument as well - as it will take us nowhere, because Vista seemed to work for some, and not quite work for others, it just depended on your specific situation.

Absolutely. You can be a Mac fan or Linux head and deny reality but Windows OS simply FORMALLY supports an order of magnitude more hardware and software than both platforms combined. This is the main reason that Windows isn't going away anytime soon. It's beyond human ability to test the combination of every piece of software and every piece of hardware that is supported by any OS let alone Windows.
 
Back
Top