Windows 7 Battery Notification Messages

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Steven Sinofsky, president of Microsoft’s Windows division, made a blog post today explaining all the talk about Windows 7 so-called battery problems.

Several press articles this past week have drawn attention to blog and forum postings by users claiming Windows 7 is warning them to “consider replacing your battery” in systems which appeared to be operating satisfactorily before upgrading to Windows 7. These articles described posts in the support forums indicating that Windows 7 is not just warning users of failing batteries – as we designed Windows 7 to do this – but also implying Windows 7 is falsely reporting this situation or even worse, causing these batteries to fail. To the very best of the collective ecosystem knowledge, Windows 7 is correctly warning batteries that are in fact failing and Windows 7 is neither incorrectly reporting on battery status nor in any way whatsoever causing batteries to reach this state. In every case we have been able to identify the battery being reported on was in fact in need of recommended replacement.
 
My girlfriend's old HP laptop gets this error. Considering her battery didn't even last 30 minutes under Vista, I would say the failure warning is probably accurate.

IvHMP.gif
@ people thinking 7 *caused* their crappy batteries to fail
 
My girlfriend's old HP laptop gets this error. Considering her battery didn't even last 30 minutes under Vista, I would say the failure warning is probably accurate.

IvHMP.gif
@ people thinking 7 *caused* their crappy batteries to fail

Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim
 
Nothing in that comment indicates that 7 "killed" his battery. At worst, it possibly indicates that 7 isn't charging the worn battery. Learn to read. Sinofsky himself stated that Windows does not, cannot write information to the battery. If you want to grab your tinfoil hat and believe he's lying, be my guest. I've personally installed 7 on several old laptops with batteries of varying quality and every time I've seen this message, the batteries were in fact crap, and generally didn't last more than half an hour regardless of OS. Oh and by the way, they still charged up to their limited capacity just fine in spite of the error ;)
 
Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim

its hard to say but does windows really "stop" the battery from charging? all the laptops i've had the battery will charge even when the laptop is powered down. Sounds to me like something else is wrong with his laptop. notice how he doesn't say my "formerly dead better is now again working fine in my laptop"

there also isn't any word on if his wife's battery works in his laptop.
who knows but its a little far fetched to think the OS has anything to do with blocking the hardware from charging the battery.
 
I got this error on my HP 8530w laptop. When looking at the battery under HW monitor, it clearly showed that my battery was badly degraded. My max battery life had fallen from 3 hours to 30 minutes since I got the laptop in Dec 2008. This is normal with li-ion laptop batteries. All Win 7 did was report that my battery was crap. It still would charge it and I still got my 30 minutes out of it.
 
I have a Lenovo T61 that i received this error on from my win7 pro install. It IS accurate. My battery would not last more than 30 minutes at this point.
 
Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim

There's a hole in your theory. The part where the OS doesn't control the battery charging. If your battery doesn't charge the problem is your battery or your laptop. Charging should work even if you have no HD in the system.
 
Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim

its hard to say but does windows really "stop" the battery from charging? all the laptops i've had the battery will charge even when the laptop is powered down. Sounds to me like something else is wrong with his laptop. notice how he doesn't say my "formerly dead better is now again working fine in my laptop"

there also isn't any word on if his wife's battery works in his laptop.
who knows but its a little far fetched to think the OS has anything to do with blocking the hardware from charging the battery.

This, or it's just a microsoft hater trolling (poorly). You believe everything you read on the internet?
 
Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim

As mentioned by another user, laptops can charge their batteries when they are powered off, meaning no OS has the power to prevent a laptop from charging its battery. A 3 year old battery is old, and may have started to exhibit signs of a dead battery that a laptop would refuse to charge.

My laptop at work just went through this- my two year old battery was very worn, but then one day, the latptop just refused to charge it. I booted in to Windows (XP), and was told that my battery had failed. When I shut off the computer, it still wouldn't charge. The battery itself was dead, and Windows didn't cause it. Its possible that if I took the battery out, waited a while, then put it back in, maybe the computer wouldn't recognize it as the dead battery and would attempt to use it again, but it would only be a matter of time until it failed again. Just bite the bullet- laptop batteries are consumables and need to be replaced on a periodic basis.
 
Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim

Lenovo has it's own power monitor bundled with their ThinkVantage software suite. You didn't have to deal with Win7's problem. Btw, an OS doesn't keep your battery from recharging. Even if you think it did, you could've simpy turned it off and leave it plugged in overnight.
 
As mentioned by another user, laptops can charge their batteries when they are powered off, meaning no OS has the power to prevent a laptop from charging its battery. A 3 year old battery is old, and may have started to exhibit signs of a dead battery that a laptop would refuse to charge.

My laptop at work just went through this- my two year old battery was very worn, but then one day, the latptop just refused to charge it. I booted in to Windows (XP), and was told that my battery had failed. When I shut off the computer, it still wouldn't charge. The battery itself was dead, and Windows didn't cause it. Its possible that if I took the battery out, waited a while, then put it back in, maybe the computer wouldn't recognize it as the dead battery and would attempt to use it again, but it would only be a matter of time until it failed again. Just bite the bullet- laptop batteries are consumables and need to be replaced on a periodic basis.

this true. they are consumable. my gripe is they are way too expensive. I'd be happy to buy new batteries if they cost me 50 not 100-150
 
this true. they are consumable. my gripe is they are way too expensive. I'd be happy to buy new batteries if they cost me 50 not 100-150

laptop batteries do cost about $50-ish. Just have to watch where you buy it from.

I buy batteries for our company at http://www.laptopbatterystore.com/

They have great prices and their batteries have always been great. They're fast with their deliveries too.
 
laptop batteries do cost about $50-ish. Just have to watch where you buy it from.

I buy batteries for our company at http://www.laptopbatterystore.com/

They have great prices and their batteries have always been great. They're fast with their deliveries too.

I trust you've had no quality related issues? lol that's the only concern I have about buying batteries for the price I think they should be.
 
I trust you've had no quality related issues? lol that's the only concern I have about buying batteries for the price I think they should be.

So far so good! LaptopBatteryStore's been around for quite awhile.
 
Then explain this response in the blog:

"My wife and I both have the Lenovo X61.

I got the battery error message last week and my battery refused to charge. I tried everything to get it to work but it seemed like it was completely dead.

Then I took my wife's battery and swapped.

Once I powered up her Lenovo, my "dead" battery started charging.

It's been a few days now and my formerly dead battery is working fine on her Tablet PC.

The battery is old, 3 years but it's definitely not dead. This is a software problem with the OS, not the hardware."
Monday, February 08, 2010 8:31 PM by Another Battery victim

Ahhh i have had this problem to.

My Wife and I did have the same D520 Dell's till i got an upgrade to the D630

My laptop had the battery won't charge in Vista and 7. Easiest fix ever. Unplug the laptop and remove the battery. You can swap if you want to. But it's not nesscary.

Kept the battery out for oh 2 min or so. Poped it back in powered on, and there it goes charging the battery.

Only had the problem once.
 
I've had to replace motherboards because it wouldn't charge a brand new battery correctly.

People are too quick to blame MS for everything that is hardware related. It's easier to point fingers, than to research and understand why it happened.
 
i am fine with windows not trying to charge a worn out battery that is potentially explosive if forced to charge when it cant handle it.
 
this :D

all laptops should have extended batteries by default. the quest for slimness is ridiculous if it can't hold any charges :cool:

i am fine with windows not trying to charge a worn out battery that is potentially explosive if forced to charge when it cant handle it.
 
Batteries aren't perfect technology, but I'd bet by what I've noticed across 2 laptops on win7 and numerous on XP that it is pretty accurate. Obviously they're are going to be some false positives.

I have a high end laptop that the battery lasts maybe 2 hours on, doesn't ping me on that. My HP (which is under the recall) got a failing battery message after about 6 months while using win7. Guess how long my battery lasts? ~30 minutes.

Perfect technology? No. But it's probably right more often than not.
 
This happens on my wife's DV9000. BatteryBar, which I downloaded later, confirmed why: wear is at 58.6% since it was replaced in 2008.

Windows Vista doesn't show the error, thought BatteryBar still shows the wear.
 
This happens on my wife's DV9000. BatteryBar, which I downloaded later, confirmed why: wear is at 58.6% since it was replaced in 2008.

Windows Vista doesn't show the error, thought BatteryBar still shows the wear.

I am pretty sure that is a new feature of windows 7 where it will let you know that your battery is warn out, that is why Vista doesn't tell you that
 
I just wish the people who are hating on the pop ups to would learn how to use the basic features in win7 or any of their OSs .
They could turn off any of the notifications they find irritating ...
Right click on the icon , choose turn system icons off ... scroll down to the icon you want off ... hell you can even customize the notification ... :|

I typically tell my users / client who have laptops to pop out their batteries when they are running off direct power and when they are at home or remote to work directly off of their battery whenever possible and to try and drain the battery before plugging in.

oh well some people will bi tch even if you hung with a new rope... err something like that.
 
id also be all these people run there batts to totaly dead great way to kill Li-po or leave them with no or full charges for to long also good ways to kill a li-po

7 is just better at telling when a batt is about to die people are just greedy and stupid and dont want to know but complain when there batt only last 10 min >.>
 
I'd say its pretty darn accurate.
On my XPS M1210 on battery power after a full charge:
With Win XP:
Boots to desktop, then shuts back down. After a reboot on AC, I have ~10% left.
With Vista:
Starts to boot, then shuts off.
Win 7:
Boots to desktop, then shuts back down. After a reboot on AC, I have ~10% left.

I'd be okay with Win7 telling me "You're battery blows big donkey ****" or something of the sorts.
Every time I boot up and get that error, I tell my laptop to tell me something I didn't already know.

For the (in)frequency I use the laptop, I just need a portable desktop.... Wherever I go, I usually have AC around, so I don't want to spend ~150 on a new battery.
 
My girlfriend's old HP laptop gets this error. Considering her battery didn't even last 30 minutes under Vista, I would say the failure warning is probably accurate.

IvHMP.gif
@ people thinking 7 *caused* their crappy batteries to fail

Lots of talk of three year old batteries here. Those are old and definitely need to be replaced. That said, Windows mobile performance is no secret, Anand has gone over this several times.

http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3582
http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3435&p=13&cp=7
http://www.anandtech.com/mobile/showdoc.aspx?i=3540&p=10
 
Lots of talk of three year old batteries here. Those are old and definitely need to be replaced. That said, Windows mobile performance is no secret, Anand has gone over this several times.

http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3582
http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3435&p=13&cp=7
http://www.anandtech.com/mobile/showdoc.aspx?i=3540&p=10

1) Those tests are hardly scientific
2) Anand is in LOVE with Macs for the last year or two, so intentional or not, his potential bias has to be questioned
3) Macs are highly proprietary, and generally, yes, they are going to get better battery life than the average PC. This is NOT indicative of a Windows problem. It's indicative of a PC lack-of-standardization-and-crappy-OEM-hardware problem.
 
I haven't noticed anything weird with the battery and Windows 7 on my Acer but the damned this always wants to hibernate after I close the lid and then open it again. Its supposed to hibernate when I close the lid but it doesn't... it stays on until I open the lid again... THEN it decides to hibernate...so I have to sit there waiting for it to do its thing and then wait for it to come back to life. Annoying as hell.
 
1) Those tests are hardly scientific
2) Anand is in LOVE with Macs for the last year or two, so intentional or not, his potential bias has to be questioned
3) Macs are highly proprietary, and generally, yes, they are going to get better battery life than the average PC. This is NOT indicative of a Windows problem. It's indicative of a PC lack-of-standardization-and-crappy-OEM-hardware problem.

Re: 3, the fact that the MBA and Lenovo x300 that he tested yielded nearly identical battery life results running Windows on what is essentially the same internal hardware tells me that Microsoft can do a lot to improve their battery life. I completely agree with you on crappy OEMs, but that's sort of beside the point when crummy notebooks are all most people buy. Spend more, get more.

That said, to the dude that is complaining about the performance on a three year old battery, get a new one. :)
 
Back
Top