Why Xbox Might Be Microsoft’s Future

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Xbox 360 and the upcoming Kinect are the future of Microsoft? Wired seems to think so.

Craig Mundie, chief research and strategy officer at Microsoft, told Computerworld on Thursday that Kinect “portends a revolution in the way people will interact with computers.” Bill Gates suggested something very similar at the D5 conference in 2007: The real transformation of the desktop metaphor for the PC would come through innovations in three-dimensional imaging.
 
There must be some kind of extreme practical use for 3d interactivity that im not seeing. I mean maybe someday when were all wearing eye monocles for computers and they have some kinda shutter system built in, combined with augmented reality. I could see it being passively entertaining.
 
I like some of the non-gaming stuff I've seen demonstrated, scrolling through movies / UI, voice commands, etc. etc. and I can easily see that as being huge for an HTPC or the likes too.
 
The guy must have been paid by MS to write that. MS has lost billions in the console market. The Xbox was a huge mistake.
 
Sure, the XBOX is going places, and is arguably the best console out there in sales, but you can't ignore the amount of PC gamers out there, and the amount of copies Win7 and Office have sold. Not to mention, with all the aftermarket parts out there that are almost exclusively compatible with Windows builds (Macs aren't known for their upgrading knack), you can't tell me that Microsoft isn't getting backdoor money from companies like that. The money MS makes in the computer market is staggering.
 
The IT media is all about trying to hype the next bus thing and they don't have any more of a clue than you or I. Instead of trying to predict the future with their iBall they need to understand the technology of TODAY. They write about stuff they've used for a day and have NO idea what they are talking about so much of the time it's showing just how ignorant these people can be.

They keep predicting the death of the PC and yet more are sold now than ever. Sure we have smart phones and iPads but those devices simply don't replace PCs. You might be able to 90% of what you normally would use a computer for and then bam, gotta print something, create a document, educate yourself, scan some photos, etc. PCs are still simply too useful and nothing out there replaces this functionality even if the device isn't used as much by some as in days past.
 
The guy must have been paid by MS to write that. MS has lost billions in the console market. The Xbox was a huge mistake.

Yup. Biggest mistake ever with, what was it last time? 12 million XBL subscribers and counting?

Everyone knows if you can't beat WoW subscriptions, you haven't done anything worth doing!
 
ignore that above post. It's not any relevent information, since it never signifies gold or not :eek:
 
Yup. Biggest mistake ever with, what was it last time? 12 million XBL subscribers and counting?

Everyone knows if you can't beat WoW subscriptions, you haven't done anything worth doing!

Microsoft has created a compelling gaming experience with XBL and if there were no hardware involved the XBox experience would be very profitable. But high-end consoles have HUGE subsidization costs which are tough to overcome.

I guess the question is did Microsoft need to build its own console hardware in the first place and instead have relied on regular PCs customized to be XBox gaming rigs. I think that it could have made more sense for Microsoft to partner with one of their partners to simply create a standard but locked down PC which is what an XBox is but that model would have had it's own problems.
 
Where can I read up about that?

The original Xbox was a huge loss for Microsoft, but the 360 is profitable. Xbox cost Microsoft $4 billion in 4 years.

http://www.joystiq.com/2005/09/26/forbes-xbox-lost-microsoft-4-billion-and-counting/

Xbox 360 is making them money, but it took them a while to do that. Remember when Microsoft was losing $126 per Xbox 360?

http://www.gamespot.com/news/6140383.html

I can't see Xbox being Microsofts future, cause it's getting harder to justify the cost of gaming. It wasn't a problem for me to own a Sega Genesis and Super Nintendo, as those consoles were usually $100 per machine. Nowadays you have Wii, PS3, and 360 and they don't cost $100 each. Plus, new games are $60 each, not the $50 from the previous generations.

I'm not a fanboy, I just wanna play the games I love to play. The problem is the games are too spread out on consoles. I'd rather have it all on one machine, like PC gaming.

If Microsoft and Sony were to make another game console, they'd end up bankrupt. Every new console seems to be released with a junk game library, that costs way too much.

Microsofts future is in their past, and that's PCs.
 
It wasn't a problem for me to own a Sega Genesis and Super Nintendo, as those consoles were usually $100 per machine. Nowadays you have Wii, PS3, and 360 and they don't cost $100 each. Plus, new games are $60 each, not the $50 from the previous generations.

Not sure where you were buying your Genesis and SNES, but I'm pretty sure I paid about $250 for a Genesis and at least $200 for SNES. Add in inflation and I'm sure those are close to what 360/PS3/Wii cost today, if not more.
 
Microsofts future is in their past, and that's PCs.

That's a VERY interesting way to put it as I believe the same. I think that PC hasn't even begun to scratch the surface of it's potential and in this day and age where people seem to be calling on the death of the PC, they seem to become more and more capable literally everyday. And yes, I to love the PC because its a single platform that pretty much does it all. I really have no desire to replace all this power with a bazillion disposable devices and I don't think that the market is in a hurry either. Close to 200 million copies of Windows 7 in a year? I think people still want PCs and its simply a matter of Microsoft investing in the platform to continue to give it the ability to deliver compelling experiences.

Windows 8 will be perhaps that moment where we really have a good idea about the long term potential of the Wintel PC. Can Microsoft get full Windows on a low cost long battery life slate that people consider compelling? That to me, that and the phone are Microsoft's TOP priorities.

As you said, their future is indeed in their past. The PC only available in smaller sizes. It's CRITICAL for Microsoft. And actually Intel as well. Their futures are almost inextricably tied to achieving the goal of an attractive, low cost, long battery life and snappy touch AND pen enabled slates and slate-like devices IMHO.
 
I wonder how long it would take Microsoft to get sued for utilizing Apple's super-profitable "You-can't-run-OSX-on-anything-other-than-these-handful-of-computers-we-build-ourselves" business model? Cuz THAT'S where the real money is at!
 
I wonder how long it would take Microsoft to get sued for utilizing Apple's super-profitable "You-can't-run-OSX-on-anything-other-than-these-handful-of-computers-we-build-ourselves" business model? Cuz THAT'S where the real money is at!

About three seconds. Really that model just wouldn't work for them I don't think anyway. Remember, Mcirosoft still makes a good bit more money and is more profitable. People are always calling for Ballmer's head and while I do think he moves too slow he's making more for the company and shareholders. But maybe he is holding Microsoft back too much. If he doesn't get Windows 8 right with features and modularity to work on slates though even I will be calling for his head.
 
Microsoft makes money based on the fact that nearly 100% of people who use a computer have used Microsoft Windows, and at LEAST 95% of people who use productivity software have used Microsoft Office.

When you build a "brand recognition" for yourself that strong, over that many years, people automatically buy your product. Think about this: If you hand an XP user (non-technical) Windows Vista or 7, they might complain about a few different things, but by and large, most of the main functions still work like they have since basically Win98, with a lot of improvements and interface beautification.

When the first computer a child uses at age whatever is a Windows machine, and all they grow up using is Windows, and they use Windows in high school and college, and at work, they buy Windows at home because it's what they're familiar with.

Windows works for Microsoft because people are tethered to it and because it's usually all they ever use. It works on any x86 PC, which is over 90% of the market, and it interfaces well with people. Linux might work on 99% of the market, but a lot of users are turned off by the complexity and lack of auto-config options (spending hours and hours making wireless work, anyone?), even for something like Ubuntu.
 
The problem is people expect Microsoft to repeat their success in OS and Office productivity market; that is anything less than a 90% of market ownership is somehow a failure for Microsoft. I think despite the losses the Xbox will be a good investment for Microsoft if they manage to leverage their Xbox Live members into Windows Phone and build a content platform around it. The only other content platform that has a chance of competing with iTunes vast content store is Xbox Live and Microsoft better get it right when it comes to Videos and Music as well

Truthfully considering today's markets I doubt any one company will ever be dominant in one market like Microsoft made it with Windows and Office; It was Microsoft being smart plus lots of contributing factors. Those factors have changed which makes it difficult to gain 90% marketshare
 
The problem is people expect Microsoft to repeat their success in OS and Office productivity market; that is anything less than a 90% of market ownership is somehow a failure for Microsoft. I think despite the losses the Xbox will be a good investment for Microsoft if they manage to leverage their Xbox Live members into Windows Phone and build a content platform around it. The only other content platform that has a chance of competing with iTunes vast content store is Xbox Live and Microsoft better get it right when it comes to Videos and Music as well

Back when Windows 95 was released I thought Microsoft was the best company in the world. I thought they were genius, and they could nothing wrong. Then they began making upgrades to their OS's, and that was good. Windows 98 was better then Windows 95, and Windows 2000 was crash proof. Then Windows ME showed up and nobody had any respect for Microsoft. Windows XP came along and fixed all that, and lasted for a good long time.

The problem begins with Vista and Windows 7. I know lots of people praise the crap out of these OS's, but they add nothing for me over Windows XP. I've used them, and currently use Windows 7 X64. I can't say anything about Windows Vista or 7 that's made my life easier, cause it hasn't. There isn't a single feature in Vista or 7 that makes me grateful for having it.

I feel things like FireFox, Ccleaner, Klite codec pack, and VLC have given me more then Windows Vista or Windows 7 has, and those applications are totally free. It's sad really, and worst yet Microsoft expects money for these so called OS's.

It's nice that Microsoft can tie all their franchises together, but that's going to force consumers to buy Microsoft only products. I have more faith in services like Steam, which has already made effort for a Mac version, and soon even a linux version.
Truthfully considering today's markets I doubt any one company will ever be dominant in one market like Microsoft made it with Windows and Office; It was Microsoft being smart plus lots of contributing factors. Those factors have changed which makes it difficult to gain 90% marketshare
Nobody wants a company like Microsoft to dominant anything 90%. It's called a monopoly, and it's bad. When Microsoft dominated browsers with IE, they got lazy and left it alone. Then FireFox, Chrome, Opera, and Safari popped up and took their market from under there nose.

Same happened with Windows Mobile. Windows Mobile 5 - 6.5 were all the same practically. Suddenly iPhone shows up and kicks its arse, and now you have Android.

Course now Microsoft is frantically trying to make up for lost ground with IE9 and Phone 7, but nobody is going use that crap. Despite what people think about the sales of Windows 7, Windows XP is still the #1 OS. In the process of trying to make Xbox 360 sales, they're shitting on Windows and PC gaming in general. Would it be so difficult for them to release Halo titles for both Xbox 360 and Windows at the same time?

Microsoft is fairly prolific at destroying their work, for the chance to earn higher profit.
 
If Kinect is the future for the mainstream then Microsoft Bob must be what we are all using right now.

Mouse and keyboard 4eva lol.
 
Course now Microsoft is frantically trying to make up for lost ground with IE9 and Phone 7, but nobody is going use that crap. Despite what people think about the sales of Windows 7, Windows XP is still the #1 OS.

Microsoft is fairly prolific at destroying their work, for the chance to earn higher profit.

No one is going to use IE9 or Windows 7 Phone? You won't, plenty will. Windows 7 Phone is going to be the smart phone for the rest us. Zune on that thing is the best music service on a phone right now period. XBL done write could be the most compelling games setup as well, but there's just little known about XBL at this time. This phone is just cleaner and more stright forware than the iPhone and Droid and it's going to apeal to peole that just want to use their phone, not conduct scientific experiments on it.

But that last statment is precious. So they'll destroy their work to make more money. Well if that's true who wouldn't?:confused: Yeah, let's do cool stuff and go broke!:p
 
If windows 7 doesn't have any features that don't make your life easier vs. XP, than you don't use your computer for very much.
 
If windows 7 doesn't have any features that don't make your life easier vs. XP, than you don't use your computer for very much.

+ A bunch. Libraries and Homegroups, these two features in conjunction are simply amazing and make moving from machine to machine practically seamless. If you have more than one computer the amount of time and power these two features alone provide make Windows 7 with it. Just a power and simple solution for peer to peer home networking.
 
There must be some kind of extreme practical use for 3d interactivity that im not seeing. I mean maybe someday when were all wearing eye monocles for computers and they have some kinda shutter system built in, combined with augmented reality. I could see it being passively entertaining.

I've watched one of their concept videos, long before i heard about natal. Basically, people were interacting with their equipment without using keyboard. One held up her PDA up to an electic whiteboard and a copy was saved on it. A lot of the interaction needs the computer to track what the user was doing. Since the computer already knows what devices are in the room (RFID, Bluetooth, Wifi, tags, etc.) and associated with each person. No more need for extra gadgets or tracking system to be worn, the computer can now extrapolate what you're trying to do. MS Surface was cool. Being able to do that in 3D, without using cybergloves or head trackers would be even better.
 
No one is going to use IE9 or Windows 7 Phone? You won't, plenty will. Windows 7 Phone is going to be the smart phone for the rest us.
Who's us? iPhone has a cult following of scary proportions. Android is for an open cheaper alternative. What gap could Phone 7 possibly fill? Go visit xdadevelopers and you'll see how many die hard Windows Mobile fans are left. Pretty much every phone has Android running on it.

Zune on that thing is the best music service on a phone right now period.
Yet, somehow iTunes is more succesful.
XBL done write could be the most compelling games setup as well, but there's just little known about XBL at this time.
And it's only for Xbox 360, unlike Steam which is already gunning for multiple platforms.

This phone is just cleaner and more stright forware than the iPhone and Droid and it's going to apeal to peole that just want to use their phone, not conduct scientific experiments on it.
I thought most iPhone owners just download stupid fart apps all day long? Android is pretty much the same thing, but with porno.
But that last statment is precious. So they'll destroy their work to make more money. Well if that's true who wouldn't?:confused: Yeah, let's do cool stuff and go broke!:p
For the CHANCE to make more money. Doesn't mean they're actually making any more money.

+ A bunch. Libraries and Homegroups, these two features in conjunction are simply amazing and make moving from machine to machine practically seamless. If you have more than one computer the amount of time and power these two features alone provide make Windows 7 with it. Just a power and simple solution for peer to peer home networking.

We're talking about a house with more then one computer running Windows 7? How many people you know have this setup? I doubt Joe six pack would be concerned about such a thing.

Now try moving from a Windows machine, to a Mac, then to a Linux box. Not so seamless now is it? Good news, there's this thing called Xmarks that allows me to move from machine to machine with at least my bookmarks. Even better, I share folder with my pictures, videos, and music so that I'll never have this problem. Also yes, I do have a Linux box, Mac, and Windows machines in my home. Even better, they all use XBMC cause it's cross platform.
 
Back when Windows 95 was released I thought Microsoft was the best company in the world. I thought they were genius, and they could nothing wrong. Then they began making upgrades to their OS's, and that was good. Windows 98 was better then Windows 95, and Windows 2000 was crash proof. Then Windows ME showed up and nobody had any respect for Microsoft. Windows XP came along and fixed all that, and lasted for a good long time.

The problem begins with Vista and Windows 7. I know lots of people praise the crap out of these OS's, but they add nothing for me over Windows XP. I've used them, and currently use Windows 7 X64. I can't say anything about Windows Vista or 7 that's made my life easier, cause it hasn't. There isn't a single feature in Vista or 7 that makes me grateful for having it.

I feel things like FireFox, Ccleaner, Klite codec pack, and VLC have given me more then Windows Vista or Windows 7 has, and those applications are totally free. It's sad really, and worst yet Microsoft expects money for these so called OS's.

It's nice that Microsoft can tie all their franchises together, but that's going to force consumers to buy Microsoft only products. I have more faith in services like Steam, which has already made effort for a Mac version, and soon even a linux version.

Nobody wants a company like Microsoft to dominant anything 90%. It's called a monopoly, and it's bad. When Microsoft dominated browsers with IE, they got lazy and left it alone. Then FireFox, Chrome, Opera, and Safari popped up and took their market from under there nose.

Same happened with Windows Mobile. Windows Mobile 5 - 6.5 were all the same practically. Suddenly iPhone shows up and kicks its arse, and now you have Android.

Course now Microsoft is frantically trying to make up for lost ground with IE9 and Phone 7, but nobody is going use that crap. Despite what people think about the sales of Windows 7, Windows XP is still the #1 OS. In the process of trying to make Xbox 360 sales, they're shitting on Windows and PC gaming in general. Would it be so difficult for them to release Halo titles for both Xbox 360 and Windows at the same time?

Microsoft is fairly prolific at destroying their work, for the chance to earn higher profit.

I'm in agreement with you regarding no company should have a monopoly in any market especially technology where innovation is the key and I'm postivie that we wont see that kind of dominance (90% marketshare) in any future from any company

As for Windows XP, it is no surprise that it is number one in terms of marketshare. It was released in 2001 and thanks to the delays of Windows Vista and netbook market it had been selling steadily well till 2009. But looking at Windows 7 and how fast it is getting adopted by businesses and consumers alike, it wont that long before Windows 7 comes increasingly close to Windows XP

Xbox brand still has ways to go before one can call it a failure. While the loss has been great, Xbox Live as a content platform can be very critical for Microsoft and the integration of it in their products. If they can pull it off, it may pay off
 
minorityreportui.jpg


I'm assuming the article is referring to future interaction with computers in this manner, of course without the magic gloves.
 
I don't see how anything developed for the Xbox can revolutionize computers. It's a game machine,and an inferior one at best compared to PC's. If anything,Microsoft seems more intent on killing the PC gaming market.
 
Who's us? iPhone has a cult following of scary proportions. Android is for an open cheaper alternative. What gap could Phone 7 possibly fill? Go visit xdadevelopers and you'll see how many die hard Windows Mobile fans are left. Pretty much every phone has Android running on it.

Once again, a simple straight forward phone thats task oriented, not app oriented. Or reminiscent of Jehovah's Witnesses. The phone market is a BILLION unit a year industry. There's room for more than two smart phones. Even five or six.

Yet, somehow iTunes is more successful.

And Windows is more successful than OS X. Which one's better?

And it's only for Xbox 360, unlike Steam which is already gunning for multiple platforms.

And multiple platforms in desktop gaming means Windows XP, Windows Vista and Windows 7. Macs LOST market share on Steam just one month as release: http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/ We've been talking about gaming on Macs and Linux for a 100 years. Ain't nothing happened. The only chance for gaming on Macs and Linux is OnLive.

I thought most iPhone owners just download stupid fart apps all day long? Android is pretty much the same thing, but with porno.

Like I said and plenty others agree, WP7 is just different and simpler approach to smart phones with own its strengths. The goal here for Microsoft is to make a compelling product so that enough people will buy it to turn a profit, I think they have done that but only time will tell. I have Zune Pass so this phone is perfect for me along those lines.

For the CHANCE to make more money. Doesn't mean they're actually making any more money.

That's not what he said. What he said simply wasn't logical and that was my point. At any rate if you can teach a course on how to destroy something with only the CAHNCE of making money you could retire tomorrow.

We're talking about a house with more then one computer running Windows 7? How many people you know have this setup? I doubt Joe six pack would be concerned about such a thing.

With about 200 millions copies sold higher than you can count. And why do people around here think that non-techies are ALL stupid? Sure some are but some will surprise you every time. And no matter how many people use its still useful as hell.

Now try moving from a Windows machine, to a Mac, then to a Linux box. Not so seamless now is it? Good news, there's this thing called Xmarks that allows me to move from machine to machine with at least my bookmarks. Even better, I share folder with my pictures, videos, and music so that I'll never have this problem. Also yes, I do have a Linux box, Mac, and Windows machines in my home. Even better, they all use XBMC cause it's cross platform.

Xmarks, been using that for years, web based bookmarks, gee who doesn't do that, there a million ways to do it now. Try sharing your handwritten notes and searching on them with a Mac and Linux across a network. So Joe Six pack won't use Homegroups and Libraries but he's going to do all this? My point was that Homegroups and Libraries are simple and powerful. Mixing Windows, Linux and OS X will be anything but simple for Joe Six Pack.
 
I do not see Kinect being anything more than a fad. Mainstream gamers will probably not buy it. I haven't touched my Wii in months for the same reason. Microsoft needs to learn that gamers are ultimately lazy. Why would I want to wave my hands around and talk to my TV to change channels, volume, etc when I can just push a button? It may have a few cool games but gamers will stick to using a controller.
 
I do not see Kinect being anything more than a fad. Mainstream gamers will probably not buy it. I haven't touched my Wii in months for the same reason. Microsoft needs to learn that gamers are ultimately lazy. Why would I want to wave my hands around and talk to my TV to change channels, volume, etc when I can just push a button? It may have a few cool games but gamers will stick to using a controller.

Read the article. :eek:

Gamers aren't the consoles' only market. We sure as hell know (based on launch pricing in comparison to bluray players of the time) gaming was not Sony's only target, and since the Natal was merely a culmulation of technologies MS is developing (remember the 6-8 camera setup that generated limited 3D images partially based on parallax? Several years back), to merely connect to the xbox. And with NetFlix, Zune, ESPN (soon? Hulu?) we surely can assume by now Kinect isn't soley for gamers.

People are willing to spend just as much on mega remotes, and now there is potential to obliterate that need.
 
Back when Windows 95 was released I thought Microsoft was the best company in the world. I thought they were genius, and they could nothing wrong. Then they began making upgrades to their OS's, and that was good. Windows 98 was better then Windows 95, and Windows 2000 was crash proof. Then Windows ME showed up and nobody had any respect for Microsoft. Windows XP came along and fixed all that, and lasted for a good long time.

The problem begins with Vista and Windows 7. I know lots of people praise the crap out of these OS's, but they add nothing for me over Windows XP. I've used them, and currently use Windows 7 X64. I can't say anything about Windows Vista or 7 that's made my life easier, cause it hasn't. There isn't a single feature in Vista or 7 that makes me grateful for having it.

I feel things like FireFox, Ccleaner, Klite codec pack, and VLC have given me more then Windows Vista or Windows 7 has, and those applications are totally free. It's sad really, and worst yet Microsoft expects money for these so called OS's.


It's nice that Microsoft can tie all their franchises together, but that's going to force consumers to buy Microsoft only products. I have more faith in services like Steam, which has already made effort for a Mac version, and soon even a linux version.

Nobody wants a company like Microsoft to dominant anything 90%. It's called a monopoly, and it's bad. When Microsoft dominated browsers with IE, they got lazy and left it alone. Then FireFox, Chrome, Opera, and Safari popped up and took their market from under there nose.

Same happened with Windows Mobile. Windows Mobile 5 - 6.5 were all the same practically. Suddenly iPhone shows up and kicks its arse, and now you have Android.

Course now Microsoft is frantically trying to make up for lost ground with IE9 and Phone 7, but nobody is going use that crap. Despite what people think about the sales of Windows 7, Windows XP is still the #1 OS. In the process of trying to make Xbox 360 sales, they're shitting on Windows and PC gaming in general. Would it be so difficult for them to release Halo titles for both Xbox 360 and Windows at the same time?

Microsoft is fairly prolific at destroying their work, for the chance to earn higher profit.

The is absolutely beyond absurd.
 
Read the article. :eek:

Gamers aren't the consoles' only market. We sure as hell know (based on launch pricing in comparison to bluray players of the time) gaming was not Sony's only target, and since the Natal was merely a culmulation of technologies MS is developing (remember the 6-8 camera setup that generated limited 3D images partially based on parallax? Several years back), to merely connect to the xbox. And with NetFlix, Zune, ESPN (soon? Hulu?) we surely can assume by now Kinect isn't soley for gamers.

People are willing to spend just as much on mega remotes, and now there is potential to obliterate that need.

I realize it is not just for gaming. Again, I just can't see many people wanting to control their home theater by waving their hands around and/or talking to it as if it is the LCARS computer on Star Trek. I'll take my Harmony remote over flapping my arms around to change the channel any day. People are lazy that way.
 
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1036012824 said:
When you build a "brand recognition" for yourself that strong, over that many years, people automatically buy your product.
More or less. It's like Apple and the iPod. iPod has become a term synonymous with portable media players just as Windows has become synonymous with desktop operating systems (for most). Microsoft could sit on their hands for a decade or longer without significantly impacting their OS's market share.

I think it's telling that OEMs are trying to market Aero Snap as a highly compelling reason for their customers to upgrade to entirely new machines. It really says something about how slow OS advancement has become recently. Not just Windows advancement, but OS advancement in general.

I feel things like FireFox, Ccleaner, Klite codec pack, and VLC have given me more then Windows Vista or Windows 7 has, and those applications are totally free.
Why would you use VLC and a codec pack?

If windows 7 doesn't have any features that don't make your life easier vs. XP, than you don't use your computer for very much.
Or he doesn't use it in a manner in which Windows 7's feature set is advantageous. Not everyone wants to organize their files into libraries, drag windows to the side to 'snap' them and so forth. Some features just don't appeal to certain groups of people and end up going largely unused.

And Windows is more successful than OS X. Which one's better?
Neither.

The goal here for Microsoft is to make a compelling product so that enough people will buy it to turn a profit
Was that not Microsoft's goal with the Kin?

I realize it is not just for gaming. Again, I just can't see many people wanting to control their home theater by waving their hands around and/or talking to it as if it is the LCARS computer on Star Trek.
The button is a novel method of interaction that has yet to be surpassed in terms of basic usability. I can appreciate motion response controls, free-form gesturing and surface gestures, but at the end of the day, I'm always going to come back to the button for being the most fundamental, most direct means of interaction.
 
I realize it is not just for gaming. Again, I just can't see many people wanting to control their home theater by waving their hands around and/or talking to it as if it is the LCARS computer on Star Trek. I'll take my Harmony remote over flapping my arms around to change the channel any day. People are lazy that way.

It's an option. Much like how digital pens, MS Surface, touchscreens, voice recognition, etc. are alternative ways of input. A system which allows the computer to track the user as he moves around the room and predicting what he's trying to do based on his body language. Is he pacing around the room? Is he sitting in front of the computer? When he holds up his PDA/Phone/Zune while facing the screen, does it connect with the device (Which you can then browse using the remote)? What is his position relative to the screen? Is the room empty?

The argument is similar to the others criticism with Microsofts efforts on voice recognition. It is NOT meant to replace the keyboard or mouse, it's meant to be used alongside it.
 
Back
Top