Why Windows Live Mail is Better than Gmail

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
PC Mech has an article on why the author thinks Microsoft’s Windows Live Mail AKA Hotmail is better than Google’s Gmail. I personally use both services and each one has its’ pros and cons. If you ran from Hotmail before it changed to Live Mail, you may want to check this article out and see if it’s worth giving MS another try.

Name an e-mail service - any e-mail service - that offers both a web interface and a mail client, by the same company, that syncs mail, address book, calendar, instant messenger, and allows you to connect it directly to your domain, all for free. …Microsoft and its Live Services is the only one.
 
I went to try the new hotmail after not using it for a few months and found that if you leave your account inactive for while they take the liberty of deleting everything.

I'll stick with Gmail.
 
gmail rocks. I only use it for mail, so who cares about other features....

When i need a calendar, i'll just use outlook anyways...
 
I don't need any contact syncing or anything special - I just need email - email without a ton of spam. Gmail does very well filtering out all the spam for me and thats all I really care about. I use a vanilla Thunderbird install to get my mail from my multiple accounts.

I'll also be sticking with Gmail.
 
I have found that Live Mail or Gmail has nothing to do with spam levels. It's all in your email address and how careful you are when giving it out. My Live Mail address is a word, another word with an unusual spelling, and a three-digit number. That address simply never gets spam - less than one spam message per month.

Based on this experience I seriously doubt anyone who claims that Live Mail users get a lot of spam. Sure, Gmail may have a really nice spam filter, but you don't need one if your email address isn't your first name followed by a number.
 
the problem with microsoft products is that they give people the ability to do a bunch of sh1t that no one needs. meanwhile, microsoft will try to convince everyone that we do in fact need them. die.
 
the problem with microsoft products is that they give people the ability to do a bunch of sh1t that no one needs. meanwhile, microsoft will try to convince everyone that we do in fact need them. die.

I agree. It's that GD "more must be better" mentality. Why can we have clean, uncluttered, sleek and simple?
 
I've not gotten much spam with my hotmail account at all.

Hotmail usually blocks out all spam (for example, stuff with obvious forged addresses) and doesn't even show it to me, unlike gmail which throws it in my spam folder.
 
What I always wondered was why emails for websites are never as good as the free alternatives. For example, my web host uses Squirrel Mail and Horde, both of which are way worse than Gmail in terms of GUI/features.
 
Gee, the big banner ads and cluttered interface really do outperform Gmails's offerings.

Er, wait...
 
Gee, the big banner ads and cluttered interface really do outperform Gmails's offerings.

Er, wait...

I don't see any of that, personally I like both, if they looked the same I couldn't give a shit, how ever I have been with hotmail for a long time, had a Gmail account and never re-checked it, fairly sure its gone now.

Either way, I dont' see any of them being superior to the other and Hotmail definetly isn't bad at all, I'd like to see one real good comment on why its bad and this thread has yet to give a factual one.
 
I prefer Gmail over all the other free webmail available, but oh how I wish they would give up on the tags idea and let us use some proper folders :(
 
Don't care. The Hotmail of old left such a bitter taste in my mouth that I'd never consider going back. I couldn't go back anyway, since the great client he talks about doesn't work on Mac OS X. Google Apps for Your Domain all the way, baby!
 
Gmail - free POP3, free IMAP, no ads (with Greasemonkey), conversation view, virtually unlimited space, honestly WTF more do you want?! It's just email!
 
Aren't they about to scramble Hotmail by altering the protocol? So even Outlook Express can't read it? I used a Hotmail address for alot of random stuff, I'd hate to have to try and change to something else for all that. Any chance someone will hack the new protocol so either OE or Thunderbird can read the new format?
 
does live mail ax your account after inactivity? I know I lost my hotmail account because of that.

I like gmail because i can have my account inactive for ages and it still works.
 
The only thing I don't like about hotmail right now is the fact that no matter what I do, I keep getting "updates" about what's new with it.

Things that I honestly don't give a damn about. And I cannot opt out to hear about this bullshit that doesn't concern me. I don't care if I can fit the Library of Congress in my inbox. I barely used what space there was prior to the Windows Live Mail changeover. The email address is strictly so my family can keep in touch with me, and that if I need an email address for business/work related things, I have one.
 
Gmail spam filter is better and interface is better. That makes gmail better in my book as I dont need anything more. I love Google apps with gmail, works so well. And their spam filter is much more accurate than hotmails in my usage and findings.

Hotmail is nice, but the interface is Sloooooooooowwww if you are not on a really good connection (and even then it is a bit slow). The spam blocker is also not as nice IMO. The integration is nice, but I just personally do not need those features.
 
Forgot to say, Gmail does delete inactive accounts as well, but the time limit is longer as I recall.
 
the problem with microsoft products is that they give people the ability to do a bunch of sh1t that no one needs. meanwhile, microsoft will try to convince everyone that we do in fact need them. die.

Spot on. Their products would be so much better if they spent more time focused on streamlining interfaces and feature lists. There is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to features used and number of steps needed to get the job done.
 
Try to avoid yourfirstname.lastname@gmail.com, I set one up for future needs, maybe a business, something to put on a business card etc.
I've never used it for anything. When I created it, I got about a dozen junk mails right off the bat. I constantly get a few every once in a while when I decide to check my account.

Which brings me to something odd, try hitting the blue handicapped symbol on their login page! It's some weird gibberish, I can't make anything out of it, is it just me?
Someone try it, it's weird! I just hit it cuz I was scratching my head trying to figure out my password, as I rarely check the account.

update: now it's saying, error please try again later.
 
I personally have both. I think hotmail's spam filiter is 100% better than Gmails, though the live version's gui can be a pain to load on a slow connection. I get 1 spam a month and thats not even spam lol, its something i signed up for. and Gmail Idk why but I get 100+ a week and I dont even use the acct lol. I like hotmail and I will stick to it. People just stick to what you like.
 
For those who wants real synchronization, get a friend who has access to Microsoft Exchange. He can pop-3 your gmail for you ;-) [that's what I got]. I got my win mob dev synched to my email [gmail and many other pop3 accounts]
 
Gmail needs to get their act in gear and get out of beta status and stop breaking things.

Their emails always work, but features keep breaking. Right now threading is broken and that's a big game stopper for me. I need to keep daily emails from the same person together.

I only have a Hotmail account because it used to be required for MSN Messenger (now Live Messenger) long before Microsoft Passport existed.
 
Gmail = WIN

all the space you need, and as a bonus 100MB of free unlimited traffic webhosting space.
 
I have multiple gmail accounts and the imap access with Thunderbird works rather well for me. I never use the webmail portion of it and only use my email client to deal with my email so the interface doesn't mean a damn thing to me. Then again, I generally avoid messing with email unless it's actually necessary.

 
I personally have both. I think hotmail's spam filiter is 100% better than Gmails, though the live version's gui can be a pain to load on a slow connection. I get 1 spam a month and thats not even spam lol, its something i signed up for. and Gmail Idk why but I get 100+ a week and I dont even use the acct lol. I like hotmail and I will stick to it. People just stick to what you like.

100+ a week? In your Inbox? I get 500 a month, and it all goes in the Spam folder. If it's in the spam folder, it's not spam. It's stuff marked as spam that you'll never see unless you're curious.
 
microsfot puts ads in the bottom of each email... i dont think gmail does... these ads live.com then get blocked by spam filters when you were not sending spam to many servers like imail... thats not a nice feature.
 
100+ a week? In your Inbox? I get 500 a month, and it all goes in the Spam folder. If it's in the spam folder, it's not spam. It's stuff marked as spam that you'll never see unless you're curious.

Umm, 500 a month is more than 100 a week...
 
microsfot puts ads in the bottom of each email... i dont think gmail does... these ads live.com then get blocked by spam filters when you were not sending spam to many servers like imail... thats not a nice feature.

No, they do not put ads in the emails. I just tested it out myself.
 
I personally have both. I think hotmail's spam filiter is 100% better than Gmails, though the live version's gui can be a pain to load on a slow connection. I get 1 spam a month and thats not even spam lol, its something i signed up for. and Gmail Idk why but I get 100+ a week and I dont even use the acct lol. I like hotmail and I will stick to it. People just stick to what you like.

Its because you dont use it. If you start using it, the spam filter gets much much better.

I get around 25-50 spam emails a day that gmail catches, I rarely have spam email that gets into my inbox, maybe 1 or 2 a month if that.


Gmail also has the threading layout that is pretty much unique to gmail, really neat once you get used to it.
 
it might be random... watch out for live.com links ocationally in your emails... i've seen it land in spam and had to remove live.com from a url blacklist that imail had place it on... maybe they changed since last fall
 
I get way more spam in google than I get in Yahoo, and ive never used my google email to sign up for anything. only a handful of people have it. I use my Yahoo email as a spam bucket, to sign up for accounts, forums, etc, and 99% of spam gets caught and auto-bulked.

I got sick of hotmail, I got more spam from Microsoft than anyone else.
 
Back
Top