Why the Megapixel Race Needs to End

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Wired’s Gadget Lab wants the megapixel race to end and explains their position nicely. I don’t know anything about digital photography other than I can never get a decent low light shot. There’s no shortage of photo nuts in our forums so chime in regarding this blogger’s points.

Aside from this list, a slowdown in the megapixel arms race would leave the technicians at Canon and Nikon to concentrate on new ways to make the cameras better for the photographer, instead of laboring to squeeze yet more dots onto their chips. Unless you are actually printing your photographs, and blowing them up to the size of posters, the camera in you pocket has all the sensor you need.
 
The GPS and raw mode entries were only related tangentially to pixel counts, but the first part of the material is golden. Pixel quality counts more than quantity!

Real photographers have been bitching about this forever... I hope marketing one day recognizes this.
 
You, sir, are a special case. Come see how the other half lives, and feel the pain of a 12MP sensor crammed into the size of a dime!
 
I have an old 2 megapixle camera that is better than most 4 megapixle. I took it to Brazil with a friends 5,1 Sony and my Pics were sharper and better, unless you blow them up above 8x10, or look at them on a screen above 1600x1200 resolution. Not many people do either.
 
i still love my canon 1d... 4.1MP and ive blown up the pictures to poster size without issue...

rather have nice glass than more dots :)
 
Megapixels will be a selling point as long as there are people who think it's really important. The camera companies are not out there to educate the masses on what makes a good camera, they are out there to make money. For the people that do know a thing or two there are the [drool] Mark III's or D2X's [/drool]. I had some guy laugh at my XT one time because his XSI has over 4 more megapixels so the XSI will always take a better picture. Of course when I asked him what size sensor the XSI had he couldn't tell me. When I told him the XT and XSI had the same size sensor he said "No they aren't". Idiot.
 
Im a Nikonian and love their cameras to death.. but I have to agree.. More megapixels does not always equal better. I would trade a 13mp Compact with Sub-Par IQ for an 8mp Compact with DSLR Quality in the same size package...
 
making the pixels more consistent (reduce noise) would help. increasing the amount of pixels does that by averaging, but at the expense of memory. if the chips themselves were made better instead of "good enough" but look we have more of them!!

its not the storage space so much these days thats the bother, (although more megapixels sells more memory cards)
its the speed of transfer even on the fastest card reader and previewing etc on your computer.
 
Megapixels are so in grained into consumer's heads that even if companies wanted to they wouldn't be able to get the point across that high megapixel counts don't make good pictures. My coworker can't figure out why my 5MP Canon G5 takes better pictures than his 12MP cheap point and shoot even after repeated attempts to explain it to him. As far as the consumer is concerned megapixels are king and they always will be.
 
i have been saying this for years now but nobody would listen, ok most people would not....my Fuji S5100 (4MP) takes extremely nice pictures once you learn how to use all the features including the RAW file format...i never have and never will be blowing my pics up poster size, thats not what i bought my camera for, at the time i did my research i found out i could get a lot nicer camera if i went with a 4MP instead of the uber elite 8MP which had no real optical zoom or RAW support
 
I'm still waiting for a Foveon X3 sensor 14MP camera to drop to $500 at a legitimate store. :(
 
Okay, I'm really just starting to learn all of this... and admittedly I thought pixel count was at least very significant if not important factor in deciding which camera to get. Since I just got my Canon S5 a couple months ago, how does it rank in all of this? I personally think it's a really good camera, but like I said, I'm still just learning.
 
Ive been saying this for like 2 years now, especially for DSLR's. We have enough freakin pixels, they need to start refining 5-6mp cameras so they can make them a lot cheaper. DSLR's should NOT cost $800 still, thats ridiculous when you can pick up a film SLR + a decent regular digital camera for less than the cost of just one DSLR. When DSLR's first came out everyone was saying they will dramatically drop in price as technology becomes cheaper, but camera makers arent allowing technology to become cheaper since they keep upgrading it to the point that it retains its old price but has more features.

Ive been wanting to get a DSLR for a long time now, but they just cost way too much. I dont want amazing quality or poster sized prints, but I do want complete manual control. They could make a killing if someone would release a cheap DSLR to compete with the crappy compact cameras.

You have to wonder who the hell they think needs 10mp+, professionals got by perfectly fine with just 6mp 4 years ago since advertisers dont need anything more for print ads. Usefulness beyond 10mp's is when you get into massive fine art prints and huge set pieces that cost thousands of dollars just to PRINT, I'm sure grandma would love to spend $3,000 to print her 10mp image of her grandkids.
 
Okay, I'm really just starting to learn all of this... and admittedly I thought pixel count was at least very significant if not important factor in deciding which camera to get. Since I just got my Canon S5 a couple months ago, how does it rank in all of this? I personally think it's a really good camera, but like I said, I'm still just learning.

try these sites for info, just at a glance 12x optical zoom and 8MP sounds like a nice camera, but thats just two specs at a glance

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canons5is/

http://www.steves-digicams.com/2007_reviews/canon_s5is.html
 
try these sites for info, just at a glance 12x optical zoom and 8MP sounds like a nice camera, but thats just two specs at a glance

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canons5is/

http://www.steves-digicams.com/2007_reviews/canon_s5is.html

Well, I've already got the camera, and I've pored over reviews and specs for quite some time before I finally jumped on it. But this just makes me doubt everything I thought I'd learned. To me it's takes really nice pictures, and the more I learn the better they get. However, I'm coming from cameras built into cell phones, so my perspective is likley to be quite lacking.
 
I'm still using my 3.2 mp canon. I probably wouldn't blow up any into posters, but the pix are fine for just regular use.
 
Gotta agree with the article. I picked up my Dads old Canon 10D in trade for the home theater system I put together, and have been having a blast with it's comparatively low 6.1MP. Once you actually put the time in to get acquainted with the features on the Camera, the pictures are astoundingly good. I just wish decent lenses were more affordable...
 
Well, I've already got the camera, and I've pored over reviews and specs for quite some time before I finally jumped on it. But this just makes me doubt everything I thought I'd learned. To me it's takes really nice pictures, and the more I learn the better they get. However, I'm coming from cameras built into cell phones, so my perspective is likley to be quite lacking.

more MP are not necessarily bad alone, the thing is the combination of the manufacturers obsessive need to have the biggest number means they sacrifice quality in order to keep costs down, think of it like buying a Kia Rio with a much larger than necessary motor, sure it boasts impressive numbers, but the rest of the car was not built to take advantage of it......

so instead of spending time improving all the manual controllable features or spending time making a much higher quality 6MP CCD, they decide to build a lower quality 8MP CCD and skimp on the other features in order to put 8MP on the specs.....

in reality that camera will likely do anything you want it to do with a lot of reading, practice, etc.....it's the compact cameras with 12MP and almost no other really good features that suffer the most, but again, in reality, those cameras will likely do what the consumer intended it to do, take decent pictures and fit in a shirt pocket or small purse
 
Im a Nikonian and love their cameras to death.. but I have to agree.. More megapixels does not always equal better. I would trade a 13mp Compact with Sub-Par IQ for an 8mp Compact with DSLR Quality in the same size package...

I used to have a sony (1.4 MP?) camera back in the day that I used alot, it died so I purcahsed an Elf camera, which is a good camera and the only reason it got it was because it was on sale for $120, I didn't care about the 7.1mp.

What alot of people have to realize is the zoom on these will always suck, how ever auto corrective configurations needs to work better, the picture doesn't clear up bright flashes or "red eyes" any better then my 7 year old camera and I've only had my new camera for 2 years! I wish they could find a way to fight the MP fight and work on auto corrective features that really bring in truely awsome pictures!

One thing I hate is my camera likes to auto un-select the detect-motion option that takes alot of the blur out, I don't need to take 5 photos a seconds and I don't care about absolute max quality but it seems cameras have hit their bank, they can't sell their $1500 camera if their shitty pocket digital camera can take comparable photos either.

I just want a better camera!
 
Think of how digital audio used to be XXXoversampling a zillion bits delta sigma blah blah blah and then there was some company that made "1 bit" decoding (pwm) and it wasnt bad at the time, so that bs finally went the way of the dodo.

eventually some camera will have something which proves to be better than zillions of pixels, and everyone will go for that instead.
 
What alot of people have to realize is the zoom on these will always suck, how ever auto corrective configurations needs to work better, the picture doesn't clear up bright flashes or "red eyes" any better then my 7 year old camera and I've only had my new camera for 2 years! I wish they could find a way to fight the MP fight and work on auto corrective features that really bring in truely awsome pictures!

One thing I hate is my camera likes to auto un-select the detect-motion option that takes alot of the blur out, I don't need to take 5 photos a seconds and I don't care about absolute max quality but it seems cameras have hit their bank, they can't sell their $1500 camera if their shitty pocket digital camera can take comparable photos either.

I just want a better camera!

Some of those issues are just too darned hard to solve on a tiny pocket cam.

As long as the flash is as close to the lens as it is on that type of camera, you'll have red-eye; learn to fix it thru software, it takes no time at all and it'll probably always come out better than any internal auto-fix... Some of those issues are just usability quirks that will always plague certain cameras, 'specially at the low end where not as much research goes into improving the interface/etc...

I'm not saying there isn't stuff they should rather be working on rather than upping the pixel count... Just saying most of the other real problems there are to tackle are either A) costlier to overcome obviously or B) stuff that will always linger at a certain price point... So upping the pixel count will probably remain a sales pitch for a while longer 'till the average consumer realizes it doesn't mean a whole lot (probably around the time their phones start toting the amount of pixels their first/second digital camera did :p).
 
ISTR reading, many years ago, that a 16Mp camera would be the equal in useful resolution to 35mm film (with a few saying it would need to be 32Mp). Looking at what my 2Mp camera can do and looking at what newer 6-8Mp cameras do, I wonder if that is an overestimate.

Having taken up photography in the early '70s, I find it odd that this attitude is coming up today. In those days, photographers (advanced amateurs, not pros) insisted on having ultra-super-duper resolution lenses. I figured this would translate today into screams for gazzillion pixel digital cameras.
 
I love it when ignorant people put the word "only" in front of megapixel count. Yet another consumer that has bought into the megapixel wars that are absolutely meaningless. I have 2 MP pictures that look great. Afterall, most people take a 10 MP picture and look at it at 1024x768 which is .786 MP; not even a full megapixel. Then they might print it out as a 4x6 which you can do just fine with a 2 MP picture. I fell for the MP war back when 4 MP was the highest. But I've wised up.

On a second note, what I wouldn't give to have a Canon 1Ds Mark III at 21.1 MP. That's full frame however and 8 grand.
 
My phone, an N78 with 3 megapixel camera, will tag photos with gps. The problem is, it can take a while for the gps to lock on, sometimes several minutes. Once it does, every photo will be tagged. It's nice, but you can't just pull it out, snap a few pics, and expect them to be geotagged. You've gotta wait.
 
What universal problem that the people on these boards need to realize....the vast majority of people are as dumb as a pile of rocks. Do you think that a vast majority of people can actually be educated on what is a good camera vs a bad camera...I mean "really educated". So...cameras companies will continue to do one thing...more pixels.

If you really want to end the megapixel wars for the average consumer, there has to become a changing benchmark standard for the "automagic" group. Bascially, a company like Consumer Reports needs to have a set of stock photo conditions that change every six months (to stop companies from optimizing) that all cameras are put through. These photos are then made publicly available. People will then begin to judge the picture for the picture. However, this might bring on a new war of "in camera photo chopping".

But sorry...education isn't going to happen. The average person who owns a computer now is not as smart as the average person who owned a computer 10 years agao. It is sad as hell.
 
I think the 8MP of my eos30d is a nice sweet spot for photography. If you want more resolution than that you should really be investing in a medium format or a genuine pro level dslr like the top end nikons and EOS1 series. An 8MP image is quite huge, and unless you're printing out poster sized pictures you don't need more. It does however give you alot of room to crop good stuff in the pictures without needing to enlarge stuff. I'm still using a 3Mp compact as a carry-around camera and the image size has never been a concern, the inability to shoot quality pictures in low light and slow autofocus is.
 
1) On a good camera with a good sensor and optics, 7-8 megapixels is enough for the regular family photographer, it's a good measure of "film quality" when printed at film size in my experience. Megapixels mean jack after that unless you're in the pro league and can put Hasselblad H3D and the like to good use, or find a bridezilla who wants a $1k photographer for her wedding who demands wallpaper size prints. What matters and what most builders miss is optics to sensor size. Too much information in a too small sensor is bad, shit optics on any sensor is bad. Ever try to get something good out of an old credit card sized camera? They're a bit better nowadays but try to find a compact camera without purple fringing or abbreviation. That's why old early DSLR as low as 3-4 megapixel beat the snot out of modern compacts, optics and sensor size. Shooting RAW helps too.


2) Ever read about the Sigma DP1? Compact piece with one 4 megapixel sensor per colour, effectively interpolated to 12 or something. It doesn't sell because of the megapixel count and the price, but it has the best freaking colour quality of all non-SLR digitals on the market. Foevon or something is the image sensor, read up on it. Even the videos from it are great.


3) All owners of Canon Ixus or PowerShot cameras who want more from them and better quality, I highly recommend going to http://chdk.wikia.com/wiki/CHDK and doing a completely risk-free non-warranty-ruining hack of your camera to enable RAW mode and so much more. Including a few ways to fix broken pixels. I picked up an S2 IS with broken pixels for $75 and made it perfect through this.
 
I want to see a digital camera that does 300+ DPI.
A 300dpi 5x7 print only requires 3.17MP. 8x10 @ 300dpi is 7.2MP.

It goes back to the quality of the pixels (sensor, lens, etc), as someone pointed out above. I sometimes miss my old 4MP camera over my newer 7.1MP camera because the quality of the lens was much better before. But I wanted something smaller and it still works good enough.
 
I bought a Canon PowerShot A80 in November 2003, up until the day it died in June 2007 (which was about time considering everything it went through, lots of fall damage) it beat the snot out of any new compact camera my friends picked up and had it compared with.

Except in recording video and audio.
 
I've got a Canon 20D (8.2 megapixel). I'd like to upgrade, but frankly I don't print anything larger than 8x11. I don't NEED to upgrade, but this is [H] and we do things just because we can.

There really aren't a lot of photo afficionado's here. I do know of a couple. Obviously cameras are tech gear just like any other (maybe a little more expensive if you go dSLR). Photography is my other hobby and we could stop the megapixel race now and just focus on newer functions. OR they could focus on figuring out how to make the high quality lenses cheaper. I could easily spend 4 to 10K on the lense upgrades that I want to make.

 
iv got a 10mp compact i just by casio
but i got it because its tiny and it takes pretty damn good quality video..and when i need to take pictures it takes solid ones. but i dont take them @ 10mp..more like 4-6mp
 
Wow that was one short article for one big topic...

The race will slow down between 20 and 30 megapixel imo.

Someone mentioned they had a 30+ megapixel camera. Is this the model from Hasselblad?

and seriously, I am in no camp here but being able to shoot at 6400 ISO on Nikon's latest model in no way justifies the comment that Canon is in a position to hurry and play catch up.

For sure there is more technology that will be present in the camera that will increase the quality of images barring any increase in megapixel count. So the article states focus on the new tech, I say why not focus on both.
 
The highest megapixel count in a digital camera available to the (rich) public is the Hasselblad H3D-50, 50 megapixel

http://www.hasselblad.se/promotions/50-promotion.aspx



Would Joe Public care about changing ISO? Does he even know what it is? I know a few photographers who make disgusting amounts selling prints every week who can't tell a bus stop from an f-stop. Maybe some really intelligent automatic mode would teach people about ISO usage. Bring back Clippy, "It looks like you're shooting fast moving objects, would you like me to increase your ISO so that you can increase your shutter speed and capture said object better, at the exchange for a little bit more noise in the image?"
 
A 300dpi 5x7 print only requires 3.17MP. 8x10 @ 300dpi is 7.2MP.

I keep thinking that 3-4 Mp in a cell phone camera is stupid. But then I remember the time I wanted to copy a page of a magazine in a library. I used my phone's 1Mp camera but it was too blurry. I realized that a 3 or 4 Mp camera would do an 8.5x11 page sharply enough to be able to read it quite well. This does of course require a lens that can do decent macro focusing and the sensor operate adequately under room lighting.

The recently announced 8 Mp cell phone camera is definitely just a sales gimmick.
 
Agreed... enough pixels already, now make the damn thing more usable, longer battery life, figure out how to make a small camera with replacable lenses, how about bigger video viewfinders. How about wireless fiberoptic gun-camera hockups for the troops.

Dont you camera manufacturer people support the troops? :eek::rolleyes::p
 
Regarding the SLRs and the Hasselblads: the real question isn't really about the number of pixels as such. It's about pixeldensity. The compacts are really suffering from cramming to many pixels into a far too small sensor with not good enough glass. Pro cameras still have room to grow a bit.

I'd love a compact with just 4-6Mpx if it was in the 3/4-sensor format instead of a pin point...
 
Back
Top