Why Linux on the Desktop Isn't Dead

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This must be one of those "good cop - bad cop" things. You get one guy to post a "Linux is teh sux article" and then you follow it up the next day with a "that other guy is an idiot" article. Thanks to Dennis Deveaux for the link.

I can only speculate as to the authors' motives for making these weary proclamations, because they're nothing if not light on real information. What I can do, however, is point out a few small problems with their arguments.
 
Sry but you should sometimes filter the stuff that is getting here, especially because not everything that contains words like linux, PC, facebook, internet and so on is really worth of mentioning on this highly specialized forum. Those bloggers suck, so I don't know why we should bring any attention to them, especially when the most discussed subjects don't tell anything, don't mean anything and overall are about nothing, just like this dead linux thing and so on. Sorry for being harsh, but I had to say that because this is not first time something like this is around here and there is nothing to be said about such subjects really.
 
Oh blah blah linux has its place in the server and programmer world. it looked like they were going to have a market in the netbook market but tablets such as apple and android shat on that idea. but desktop no way, poor support for productivity and graphics software, games, unintuitive ui and lack of customer support. all this leaves linux distros a bad joke for mainstream desktop users. even software install can be difficult for your lay user. but keep trying i'll be bored again and keep loading a nix distro every few years to see if its worth using.
 
Frankly I never got the attraction other than price for desktop users, free is always good. I've tried several different flavors over the years and even have a copy of Lindows around here somewhere from some time back. It's just not there yet and I doubt it ever will be. If I wanted to revert to a CLI every time I wanted to do something I'd still be using DOS v6.22. The KDE has gotten better but is still lacking and not very intuitive.

I'm sure someone will be thinking ole scooter is simply too dumb for linux. Certainly a possibility. I'm not claiming to be the sharpest pencil in the box. However, I've been banging on PC's and OS's since the 80's and I'm the guy who fixes all my friends and families pooters. If Linux cannot sell me on a desktop OS for free, it sure as heck are not going to win over those who I support.

IMHO linux will stay well under Apple's market share for the foreseeable future... which for all intents and purposes reinforces the original article authors premise that Linux is dead for the desktop. IIRC 1.5% is within the statistical margin of error. :p
 
Yep, posting this from my Fedora Linux desktop, Linux on the desktop is completely dead.

posting this from Linux as well, I even have LibreOffice open!
Linux is growing... hopefully it can gain more marketshare sometime soon.
 
I love that guys comment about his experience with Vista and then trying to put XP on a laptop made for Vista and bitching because it didn't have default drivers for a laptop made many years after XP was released.

I swear, some Linux centric people are dumber than Apple fanatics.
 
Seemed there was more of a debate/discussion going on in the original article (or at least the Linux users were trying to defend the platform a lot more). :)

I personally don't think Linux is really meant to compete with Windows or Mac OS X, so from the viewpoint of a standard computer user, Linux is dead on the desktop. From an enthusiasts viewpoint though (as in, one who understands Linux and is comfortable making it work the way they want it to), then Linux isn't dead on their desktops. Linux is definitely more customizable than Windows, but the out-of-box experience isn't nearly as polished as Windows or Mac.

I've tried running Linux several times, and each time ran into some roadblocks that I couldn't resolve even after searching online for solutions. Things like getting a fingerprint reader on my laptop to work, or getting video drivers working correctly. OK, maybe I expected too much when thinking the fingerprint reader could work, but there were other little things as well. I'm more than willing to learn a new way of doing things, but it's always great to have something that "just works" out of the box that can be tweaked after the fact.

With Linux, I found that you typically have to tweak things to get them to work in the first place, then tweak some more to customize things the way you like. That to me seems to be the biggest problem. Office support? I can always run a VM (or use OpenOffice or something else that can read/write Word & Excel files.
 
It sucks ... no really it sucks i have tryed to be fair over the years but it just does not cut it. if all i did was internet,email and some office stuff then sure but i don't so it sucks. I like my OS to be fire and forget.
 
Was it ever really alive?

no, not on the desktop. Sure, some people use it, but the numbers are very, very small. It's a pain in the butt to use, even on the server side.

I can get a Windows machine (2003, 2008, 2008 R2, or even 8) up and running as a DHCP, DNS, and router is under 20 minutes these days. it takes me weeks just to get the DHCP and DNS working on Linux, and then router duty is still impossible. (Sure, there are directions all over the internet to get those working, and I could link to them all, but they're all different from what I find. None of them seem to be accurate. I would love to get a Linux machine up as my router, but it's just not possible.) Windows just beats Linux down for ease of use, in all arenas except smartphones.
 
It sucks ... no really it sucks i have tryed to be fair over the years but it just does not cut it. if all i did was internet,email and some office stuff then sure but i don't so it sucks. I like my OS to be fire and forget.

I tried using Linux even just for internet, thats it, I didnt care about any of its downfalls. But even just staying connected to WIFI, it could not do. No matter what driver I used or what config file I edited etc... it just wouldn't keep a connection.
 
It sucks ... no really it sucks i have tryed to be fair over the years but it just does not cut it. if all i did was internet,email and some office stuff then sure but i don't so it sucks. I like my OS to be fire and forget.

It wasn't long ago that windows suffered from that same ailment. I recall doing a lot of .ini tweaking in winXP =P Then there was drivers, windows updates and inevitable fuckups.

The biggest issue with linux is still market share. Unfortunately the easiest remedy to increasing market share is a dominant market share... Catch-22
 
no, not on the desktop. Sure, some people use it, but the numbers are very, very small. It's a pain in the butt to use, even on the server side.

I can get a Windows machine (2003, 2008, 2008 R2, or even 8) up and running as a DHCP, DNS, and router is under 20 minutes these days. it takes me weeks just to get the DHCP and DNS working on Linux, and then router duty is still impossible. (Sure, there are directions all over the internet to get those working, and I could link to them all, but they're all different from what I find. None of them seem to be accurate. I would love to get a Linux machine up as my router, but it's just not possible.) Windows just beats Linux down for ease of use, in all arenas except smartphones.

Linux is easier to manage once it's up though. Backups etc are as simple as copying files around. Windows embeds everything weirdly in it's own proprietary ways making backup/restores more involved, usually needing 3rd party tools to do it. If there's one thing Linux IS better at, it's servers because the "engine" part of it is just simpler.

We had 2 DCs at a place I worked and they both had a split scope DHCP. To add exeptions we had to manually do it on both. In Linux you'd do it on one and could write a script to copy the file over to the other and automate it. Linux is just so much better in that respect, you can automate more stuff easily.

As for desktop, I more or less agree though, it's just not usable for most people. I want to give it a try some time, but I don't see myself sticking to it. When it comes to a desktop I just want something that works out of the box. Windows more or less does this. All my files and other stuff stays on the Linux server but the front end experience is in Windows.
 
It wasn't long ago that windows suffered from that same ailment. I recall doing a lot of .ini tweaking in winXP =P Then there was drivers, windows updates and inevitable fuckups.

ini edits in windows? Last time I did that was windows 95 /98 maybe... That was all but killed off since about 2000 plus unless you where monkeying with some super legacy windows apps.

Now lets compare windows driver issues from Windows XP present with, trying to find a fully accelerated 3D driver with HDMI support for your current video card in Linux?

Or getting a multi-function home scanner printer running in Linux, or lets pop in a Blueray movie and watch it on our laptop...

O yes laptops, which chipset is your wifi adapter? can you actually connect to a WPA2 access point with the current included driver...

Linux is awesome at specialization and customization, but terrible at general desktop.
 
$200 a license for LEGITIMATE retail non-OEM Win 7 vs free. Hmmmmmm.

For a dev machine working on a product built on the LAMP stack, linux is fine. I'd need a lot more RAM to run our environment on a Windows machine because everything would have to sit on a windows VM host (eeeeeewwwwwww). You can't run KVM on windows anyway, you're stuck with VM or Virtualbox.
 
One thing people have sort of missed and overlooked...

Android *IS* Linux (at the kernel level) -- just with the Android stack running on top of it (though, with effort, you can get glibc/busybox/etc. running on it).

So as more tablets become dockable and more capable and more and more apps are available, an Android based desktop certainly isn't out of the question.

So, the answer may be that desktop Linux is just around the corner -- it's just going to be called Android.
 
Linux is easier to manage once it's up though.

No its not. Just no.. no no no no... my server 2008 r2 hasn't had to be touched since i loaded it.. whenever anything inevitably fucked up in linux it was a real chore to get it up again..
 
For a dev machine working on a product built on the LAMP stack, linux is fine. I'd need a lot more RAM to run our environment on a Windows machine because everything would have to sit on a windows VM host (eeeeeewwwwwww). You can't run KVM on windows anyway, you're stuck with VM or Virtualbox.

since when does this have anything to do with an average desktop user? Nothing.
 
One thing people have sort of missed and overlooked...

Android *IS* Linux (at the kernel level) -- just with the Android stack running on top of it (though, with effort, you can get glibc/busybox/etc. running on it).

So as more tablets become dockable and more capable and more and more apps are available, an Android based desktop certainly isn't out of the question.

So, the answer may be that desktop Linux is just around the corner -- it's just going to be called Android.

rofl... so is mac.. thats hardly the point.. linux will never be just around the corner in its free open state..
 
$200 a license for LEGITIMATE retail non-OEM Win 7 vs free. Hmmmmmm.

Exactly! When FREE gets you 1% of the market it's very telling. In this day and age if you cannot get people to use your product for the price of the download your issues are not marketing... it's the product. :p

For a dev machine working on a product built on the LAMP stack, linux is fine. I'd need a lot more RAM to run our environment on a Windows machine because everything would have to sit on a windows VM host (eeeeeewwwwwww). You can't run KVM on windows anyway, you're stuck with VM or Virtualbox.

The article was commenting on the desktop market.. not developers. No one is arguing the value for devs. ;)
 
One thing people have sort of missed and overlooked...

Android *IS* Linux (at the kernel level) -- just with the Android stack running on top of it (though, with effort, you can get glibc/busybox/etc. running on it).

So as more tablets become dockable and more capable and more and more apps are available, an Android based desktop certainly isn't out of the question.

So, the answer may be that desktop Linux is just around the corner -- it's just going to be called Android.

Linux at its core is just a unix operating system that uses the Linux kernel. That's it. I think a lot of people forget that.

Obviously most users embrace the FOSS spirit, but that doesn't mean you can't make $$ off it. Hell, take a look at Red Hat or Google. Enterprise versus personal and they both make money off linux. Stating linux won't somehow fit into the desktop space is pretty ridiculous if you consider that it'll have a far easier time growing into desktops than windows will have slimming down. Windows 8 is an epic disaster. Windows does one thing well, and that's desktop. You just can't mold windows the way you can linux, which is why everything from your cable box to your ISP's servers and routers and your car use a linux OS. I personally think it's far more believable to see linux on desktops than it would be to see windows anywhere but the desktop.
 
Sry but you should sometimes filter the stuff that is getting here, especially because not everything that contains words like linux, PC, facebook, internet and so on is really worth of mentioning on this highly specialized forum. Those bloggers suck, so I don't know why we should bring any attention to them, especially when the most discussed subjects don't tell anything, don't mean anything and overall are about nothing, just like this dead linux thing and so on. Sorry for being harsh, but I had to say that because this is not first time something like this is around here and there is nothing to be said about such subjects really.



Sometimes we post things so that our readers are aware of them, giving them the option to comment on the article in question and, in turn, voice their opinions to the author of the article in question.

Sometimes we post things because they are ridiculous / click bait / trolling by the author. Has we not posted a link to it, you wouldn't have known it was there and you wouldn't have had the opportunity to let the author know your thoughts.

Sometime we post things because it is just going to spark a healthy debate.

Sometimes, I post things so that our OWN readers will have something to complain about. *cough* not anyone here of course *cough* ;)

All in all, I think it is safe to say we have a pretty good grasp on how to run our site but I do appreciate the input.

Thanks!
 
rofl... so is mac.. thats hardly the point.. linux will never be just around the corner in its free open state..

Mac is not Linux based -- it is based on the Mach kernel which has it's roots in NetBSD/FreeBSD via it's heredity from NeXTSTEP (courtesy of S. Jobs).

I never said that desktop Linux would necessarily be "free & open" -- just that it may still be coming sooner than we think.

And, honestly, ICS is still open source and the development tools are free and open -- as are many of the apps. Part of the problem, historically, with Linux was getting people to write applications for it -- as it was hard to find a way to actually sell them and make money at it (and even more difficult to do without having the GPL tied to your app like a ball & chain forcing you to give away the source to your application). With Android and the Android/GooglePlay Market (and Amazon Android Appstore, etc) there are now lots of apps available for the Android-based Linux kernel, a mechanism through which to sell the applications, and widely accepted license (Apache 2.0) that allows reasonable control of your source, while still allowing you to leverage existing technology.

I think someone SHOULD take ICS as the starting point for a true desktop distribution -- all the necessary building blocks are there -- and so are the apps to run on it.
 
Believe me it's still alive. Especially with Windows 8 giving it opportunity to try and get more people interested. Once WINE is able to play Windows games and applications nearly flawless, there will be little reason to go back.

gladoslinux.jpg
 
Believe me it's still alive. Especially with Windows 8 giving it opportunity to try and get more people interested. Once WINE is able to play Windows games and applications nearly flawless, there will be little reason to go back.

I definitely agree that Windows 8 and Metro will give people a lot more impetus to move to ANYTHING else, at least on the desktop. On an HTPC with a Kinect interface though, Win 8 and tiles works quite interestingly. That said, it still will likely drive at least a few people to Linux.

However, WINE is not the answer -- and at this point, it likely NEVER will be.

WINE is a lot better than it used to be -- but it still has issues. I have played with it many times over the MANY year it has been around, and I have grown to accept that trying to emulate Windows is a fools errand. I actually did a LOT of playing with the WINE source many years ago and made a few minor contributions and did some experimenting with DirectX compatibility. The fact that this was circa 1994 -- almost TWENTY YEARS ago, should sort of clue you in as to WINE's development cycle. V1.0 of WINE wasn't even released until 2008! DNF had a shorter development time!
 
Mac is not Linux based
Correct, it is actually a UNIX-based OS.

Nice article, Linux on the desktop is certainly not dead, but it has a very tiny user-share compared to the others.
That other article was full of fail, and I'm sorry, but one does not learn any Linux OS in 30 days, especially to give it a full and proper review.

OS X and Windows however, can easily be learned in 30 days, but that does not necessarily make them better, just different.
 
Actually, the DirectX (DirectDraw specifically) stuff I did with WINE was in the '98-99 time-frame. The stuff I did in '94 was aimed more at trying to implement some Win32 API calls so that some NT apps I had would run properly.
 
Lol Linux is far from dead on the desktop - it just isn't as popular. It was never meant to compete anyways. Do some fucking research you clueless asshats.

The real issue is OEM distributors... if Micro$hit didn't have such dominance and lockdown on PC OEMs, the playing field would be A LOT more evened out.
 
Lol Linux is far from dead on the desktop - it just isn't as popular. It was never meant to compete anyways. Do some fucking research you clueless asshats.

The real issue is OEM distributors... if Micro$hit didn't have such dominance and lockdown on PC OEMs, the playing field would be A LOT more evened out.

That's not entirely true anymore either. Something like 70% of Dell notebooks shipped in China have a linux distro on them and they're not the only ones. Lenovo does much the same. Linux is actually quite big in eastern Asia and that's mainly due to licensing costs and the clamping down on pirated software.
 
Yep, posting this from my Fedora Linux desktop, Linux on the desktop is completely dead.

I think "dead" is the wrong word. It's certainly not DEAD, but it is extremely unpopular (under 2% of desktop PCs). Let's put it this way; Windows Phone has a higher market share of smartphones than linux does on desktop PCs, and most people consider Windows Phone a failure.
 
Why does anyone care if Linux is dead or not? Im sure most linux users dont give a shit, Im surprised at the amount of windows users who do.

I think however Linux doesnt get as much credit as it deserves, and windows gets too much. Thanks to windows the majority of computer users can now use a pc and the internet and communicate with each other, and the amount of these people that have the inteligance of a sunday morning turd is astounding. Thanks to windows the internet and computing world is full of morons, people who dont care how it works, they just care it works for them whilst they bitch on facebook. Thanks to windows, we have overweight teenage boys putting themselves on youtube to releive thier own narcicism and fantasies about being Britny Spears. . Thanks to windows not a day goes by without hearing about some internet troll wanting to dance the belero on the graves of the recently deceist. These internet undesirables are windows users (and now probably Ipad/iphone/android/blackberry users, but windows started it)

Some would then argue, these people have been able to what they do becuase windows just works. They would be right, except for win 3.0, 3,1, win95, win98 Nt3.5, NT4.0, Windows 2000 which all have screwed up on millions of people, probably at the worst time. I didnt mention Milllenium or Vista becuase im pretty sure this was Microsofts attempt at virtualising shit and seeing if they could sell it.

WinXP and Win7 are pretty good at what they do and it has been years since I have had a real problem with windows becuase of these.

More to my point, when a Windows PC goes down, when it crashes or freezes the first thing out of a windows users mouth is "Fucking Windows, peice of crap". Go Figure????????

Linux, I cannot say has not to my knowledge been the cause of any such social ills that windows has. Sure Ive had my problems with it, but all linux users have, there is a learning curve thats no reason to hate it.

Im not saying all windows users are stupid (Far from it, I have friends that use windows..... No seriously I do) in fact some windows users are some of the nicest people you'll ever meet. But I guarantee you that if you go on the internet and meet someone who has the intelligence of squashed jelly, they will be using windows and most probably it wont be up to date with updates and the virus scanner will be out of date, which they cant update becuase the antivirus is provided by norton or maccaffee and it wont update or uninstall and the whole system probably needs a rebuild (This is the storey of my life).

Linux may have issues, but Windows has a whole set of different ones.
p.s Thanks for reading this quite pointless post.
I know its a shit argument
 
Why does anyone care if Linux is dead or not?
Because it isn't true.
That would be like someone saying "Windows is dead" when that obviously isn't true, it tends to annoy users.
 
Lol Linux is far from dead on the desktop - it just isn't as popular. It was never meant to compete anyways. Do some fucking research you clueless asshats.

The real issue is OEM distributors... if Micro$hit didn't have such dominance and lockdown on PC OEMs, the playing field would be A LOT more evened out.

Several companies have tried selling linux desktops. Problem is, there was little reason to continue with the trying. :p
 
posting this from Linux as well, I even have LibreOffice open!
Linux is growing... hopefully it can gain more marketshare sometime soon.

People have been saying that for how many years now?

It's isnt growing and with less and less people buying desktops and laptops and tablets taking over with android and apple, the "year of linux" is becoming less and less likely.
 
Back
Top