Why is my RAID5 so slow?

yegor

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 31, 2007
Messages
153
raid5sucks.gif


Downloading at 10MB/s constantly gives me messages saying that its downloading faster than it can write to disk.

Does this look normal for a RAID5 array? Its through the Asus Maximus Formula motherboard.
 
Does this look normal for a RAID5 array? Its through the Asus Maximus Formula motherboard.

No, this should not be normal behaviour. Can you provide us with more details of the setup? What disks are in the array (number, capacity, manufacturer and model if you can). What is the system spec of the machine (CPU/RAM etc). How much CPU usage is there when you're writing to/reading from the array? The more details you can provide the more likely someone will be able to provide a solution.
 
If its the system in your sig then there is definately a problem. My first reaction is one of the drives is not doing so good and is affecting the array. So I would run the manufactures Diagnostics to make sure.

If the drives are good recreate the array and see if that helps.

Your CPU usage is only at 9% during that test which isnt much. But since its really jagged methinks that something else is trying to access the array during the same time as well.
 
Yah its the system in my sig (just different mobo).

Not sure what it could be, I turned off everything that could be possibly accessing it.
 
I know you would hate to do it, but rebuild the array with 3 disk and benchmark it again. Rotate 1 disk out and try again. It may be a failing disk.
 
The read speed really should be higher but write speed on most software raid I have seen is pretty low 10-30 MB/sec so I could understand downloading @ 10 MB/sec getting disk write too slow errors.
 
I know you would hate to do it, but rebuild the array with 3 disk and benchmark it again. Rotate 1 disk out and try again. It may be a failing disk.
You are right, I would hate to do that. If I cut it down to 3 disks, Im gonna lose data because its nearly full. :(

The read speed really should be higher but write speed on most software raid I have seen is pretty low 10-30 MB/sec so I could understand downloading @ 10 MB/sec getting disk write too slow errors.
Is a RAID5 array slower than a single Raptor? I got no errors when downloading to that.
 
raid5 (software raid5, not hardware) typically has write speed which are less than a single drive so yes, write speeds lower than a raptor would be expected. If you need better than mediocre write performance then you should get a hardware controller.
 
Looks pretty typical of onboard raid5 to me. Do some SMART analysis of the drives and individually test them to rule any other problems out first though. But if you go with a dedicated raid controller, I'm guessing you'll see really good increases. Hell, even my PCI Highpoint RocketRAID 1740 in RAID5 gets over 60MB/sec consistently. It's only around $100.
 
I really do want to get a dedicated RAID controller, but I dont have any PCI x4 slots that are free. I would have to get a new mobo.... and if I do that, Im probably have to upgrade to i7 and DDR3 and thats gonna be another grand at least, on top of the RAID controller :(
 
Well, if you ruled out your drives and sata controller drivers not being a problem, then you don't have many options. You could just get a simple PCI slot raid controller like I mentioned in my post. It has a chipset for assisting raid calculations and data transfer, so it gets much better speeds than most onboard software garbage does. You'd only spend ~$100. It won't get you insane speeds like a 100% hardware raid top of the line controller, but it will make it very tolerable for you.
 
Looks like obnboard to me. I would go with a hardware raid solution. Also, you should consider backing your information up as you can lose your r5 array.
 
Do you have any x1 slots available?

Highpoint makes a 4 port raid card for pciex1
 
I had the same problems with onboard software raid 5 with the ICH series with 4 500gb drives. My reads were about what you get just a tad less jumpy. My writes to it would top out at about 10.7mb/s. It also would only write to 5 1tb'ers in raid 5 at 10 megs. So i ended up getting an Adaptec 51645 card to create my so far 5 drive raid 5 with 1tb drives (ones on rma atm). My write speed is not above 300 with just the 5 drives and going to add to that spindle count spoon. But seeing as you don't have an open 4x or 8x slot to get a hardware card you are in a little bind. do you sonstanylt download to the drives at 10 megs or can you cashe it to the raptor and then copy it over to the raid 5 when you go to bed or something till you can upgrade to i7 and hw raid card? only thing i can think of short of doing the upgrade.
 
Yah I thought about those 1x RAID controllers, but it would be a temp solution, and just a waste of money. x4 or bust.

I guess I'll wait a few months and build a new PC with an extra x4 slot....

Thanks for the help
 
The 4x cards will work in a 16x slot too. I don't know if you knew that already or not. You don't need a motherboard with a 4x slot.. those are pretty rare.
 
The RAID5 I used to run on my areca 1210 was insane with the speed. I must note for my purposes of gaming. It was like night and day over a single 400gb seagate I was using previously.
 
The 4x cards will work in a 16x slot too. I don't know if you knew that already or not. You don't need a motherboard with a 4x slot.. those are pretty rare.
This is the one of the benefits of PCI-E that doesn't get talked about as much. It's a very nice feature.
 
The 4x cards will work in a 16x slot too. I don't know if you knew that already or not. You don't need a motherboard with a 4x slot.. those are pretty rare.

I realize this. Im still gonna need a mobo with more than 2 pci x16, since I use 2 video cards.
 
ah, ok. I know what you mean though. It takes some strategy finding the right motherboard to run all the components you want in it, especially if you're doing crossfire/sli with dual slot cards.
 
I was in the same situation as you yegor. Found me and MSI p7n sli several weeks ago. Was able to put my RAID card int eh 3rd pci-e slot and run my (2) 8800gt in the first two Pci-e slots.. I'm in heaven now.. Everything is running fine.
 
Back
Top