Why install HSF while MB is in the case?

courtney01

Gawd
Joined
Nov 25, 2008
Messages
619
It says in the MB manual to install the HSF only when the MB is in the case. Is that necessary and what's the reason for doing so? I installed a HSF outside of the case on a cardboard box. That shouldn't be a problem right?
 
its probabaly to make sure u are grounded so you dont "shock" the board which might cause problems. I would suggest u ground urself by touching the metal case and the take the mb out and and up the hsf
 
its probabaly to make sure u are grounded so you dont "shock" the board which might cause problems. I would suggest u ground urself by touching the metal case and the take the mb out and and up the hsf
Thanks.
 
If I have a new board, I install the heatsink before putting it in the case, and have never had any problems. If I am just changing the cpu (and not having to add/change a backplate), then I leave the board in the case.
 
With some of the Intel pushpins, I have no idea how you'd install it once it was already in the case.
 
i have about 7 cuts on my hands from installing my xigmatek s1283 while mobo was in case, then again its a tight case but moral is push pin system sucks
 
I cut my right index finger a lot installing a Freezer 7 on my Q6600 inside the case. The push pin design makes me miss the AMD clip.
 
I think it's nice to be able to inspect to see that all 4 pushpins have clipped by looking at the bottom of the board.
 
I agree that it's easier to install outside the case when first putting together a build. ALWAYS use an antistatic wristband - well worth the couple of dollars.

You also get a chance to make sure there is not warping (or need for a backplate) and that the cooler is seated correctly.

Of course if you are merely switching CPUs or coolers I wouldn't go through the trouble of unscrewing the mobo from the case. :cool:
 
It makes life a lot easier with the motherboard out. Like what's been stated, you always want to be grounded. You can do this buy using an anti-static mat, wrist band, or putting on of your hands on the case.

For the first time install, especially using the stock heatsink or just one with push pins, I'd suggest the mobo out. Complete pain in the butt otherwise.
 
I think it is because there is quite a bit of flex in most MBs. If you have it out of the case it is not supported and if you press down, you are flexing the board and also pressing the back side of the MB where the solder points are onto whatever surface the board is sitting on, static or not (a lot of people sit the board on the plastic static bag, but the static bags only work if they are completely sealed and the item is inside). A 775 socket also doesn't use a retaining bracket on the front and with push pins the force is straight on the PCB. I used the optional Thermalright retention bracket and spring screws which is well worth the $10.
 
Wow....so all you guys actually throw a mobo and CPU in a case without benchtop testing it first? :confused:
 
What's required to set up a test bench? I just set my motherboard on the cardboard box it came in and plugged everything else into it and set it on the desk around the board. Am I doing something dumb? :)

-Fin
 
What's required to set up a test bench? I just set my motherboard on the cardboard box it came in and plugged everything else into it and set it on the desk around the board. Am I doing something dumb? :)

-Fin

Nope, that's how it's done. But I personally don't have the space to have all my parts laying around, nor the ability to really set up a test bench layout due to how my desk is designed.
 
Wow....so all you guys actually throw a mobo and CPU in a case without benchtop testing it first? :confused:

Sure, I enjoy the work. If it doesn't post and I RMA I just pull it out. Its only like 9 screws and a few connectors. Not like when I replaced the heater fan blower in my 240 volvo and had 5 hours of dashboard disassembly, or the AC compressor. Those are tough.
 
Nope, that's how it's done. But I personally don't have the space to have all my parts laying around, nor the ability to really set up a test bench layout due to how my desk is designed.

Good. I'm glad to hear it's a space constraint on your side and not a brain power constraint on mine ;-)

-Fin
 
Back
Top