Why I hate Dell (more reasons)

THEREALJMAN

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 23, 2004
Messages
72
/Start Rant
I work at a large insurance company and we have roughly 12,500 Dells in the organization. We struck a deal with Dell a few years ago to start using their computers and we would offer them various services. I tried my hardest to prevent this from happening. I showed service history’s from several companies who thought Dell was a good choice and learned the hard way Dell had nothing but headache to give. I talked to every person involved in the purchasing and tried to sway them. I had no luck. Now we have Dell firmly entrenched in our organization.
So here is why I hate Dell - We currently are in a round of re-imaging PCs to update them to current standards and 83% of the motherboards fry on re-image. We are using 100% approved Dell imaging services and our current image is certified by Dell. We are ordering new motherboards 300-400 at a time! It's absolutely insane.
Atleast I can feel justified in my strong feelings to keep Dell out of my company.
/Done Rant
 
I don't disagree that Dell has taken a long fall over the past few years, but I'm not seeing how a re-imaging process is killing motherboards. That's a software thing. I would certainly hope your not removing drives or anything like that during a re-image. If your opening the computers up for a re-image, then you need to use something else, like Ghost or Altiris. If not, something besides the process is killing boards. Software doesn't destroy hardware.
 
dude, "YOUR GETTING A DELL", if anyone says that to you

step one -> start to cry
step two -> scream out "F&$@ You Go To HEll"

dell's are nothing but problems, the company i work for also has many of them, every day i find my self haveing to deal with stupied mobo problems, or inferior workman ship, ie some retard at dell does not have the strenght to plug in a IDE cable all the way, this might sound funny but thoes dell AC77's are really freeking hard to open got to take out 10000 screws just to pop the sucker open.... i hate DELL!!!!!
 
If 83% of the computers are failing during re-imaging, you need to have a little talk with your Dell Corporate account rep. Someone with 12,500 machines will get answers.

As an aside, who do you think would be better? You want someone who can reliably ship hundreds of machines a month, who will image the machines the way you want, and provides a long term growth path.

Or is this a rhetorical bitch, i.e. you don't really want or expect answers, you just want to vent :)
 
I'm really curious how reimaging a machine is frying the mobos. I'd bet something else is cauing the problems. Are you upgrading RAM/HDDs at the same time?
 
I'm guessing that the re-imaging is done over the network?

Sounds probably like the network driver you are using to do the networking is probably causing the problem, since the network driver is the only software being used during the reimage process.

As mentioned before, I would get in contract with the Dell reps, pause the reimaging process, and solve the problem before continuing and frying all those boards (and thus costing both companies a shitload of dough).
 
The Dell's I work on for my school (Yes, I do majority of my school's IT work) run fairly smooth. The only problem I have with them is that some of them will BSoD when you insert ANY type of external media (USB HDs, thumb drives). On top of that, they act funny when the devices finally work (usually the device works after the comp reboots from BSoD)
 
Name any big company I.E. (gateway to hell, dell-eted , e-mashit)
thats doesn't suck ass? You dont hear about these kind of gay ass problems with companys like falcon northwest and alienware. Why? B/c they stick to what they do assemble PC's they dont try and make there own MOBO's and bios and shit. When stuff gets all proprietary it turns to shit

also i am intrested 2 on how a drive re-imageing could kill a mobo but with dell i can't claim to be suprised:rolleyes:
 
Originally posted by iNsAnE_crAzY
Name any big company I.E. (gateway to hell, dell-eted , e-mashit)
thats doesn't suck ass? You dont hear about these kind of gay ass problems with companys like falcon northwest and alienware. Why? B/c they stick to what they do assemble PC's they dont try and make there own MOBO's and bios and shit. When stuff gets all proprietary it turns to shit

That's one of the biggest loads of crap I ever read. Why do you think you hear about OEM PCs and problems more than others? Probably because they sell a few million more PCs a year? Could that be it? Oh, and other than Dell PSUs and Dell mobos, I'm not away of any PC clones that don't use standard parts. Our HP and Compaqs are all standard. Our mobos are made by Asus, Abit, and MSI. You really should learn, then post...in that order.
 
damm were useing over 400 dells at my work, for the last 4 years, there have been no major problems...best part is, every 2 years we just trade them in for free and continue the lease.

I love our newest PCs the optiplex GX 270's and 300's
 
Originally posted by iNsAnE_crAzY
Name any big company I.E. (gateway to hell, dell-eted , e-mashit)
thats doesn't suck ass? You dont hear about these kind of gay ass problems with companys like falcon northwest and alienware. Why? B/c they stick to what they do assemble PC's they dont try and make there own MOBO's and bios and shit. When stuff gets all proprietary it turns to shit

also i am intrested 2 on how a drive re-imageing could kill a mobo but with dell i can't claim to be suprised:rolleyes:


HAHAH, mabey you dont hear about all of falconorthwest problems because they probely only sell a few thousand computer a year... Dell sells millions, with todays MFGing you are probaly looking at 1 out of 500 parts will be bad.. And this is dell fault? all i know is that every PC part we have go bad here at work, i get it replaced by dell for free in 3 days. I call them, they send part, i send bad part back in same package.....Plus we have 3 backup PCs that are free of charge to us for hot swap replacement, then we send the whole bad PC back to them. (that our deal though not many get that) there well over 20K PC's in the corp.

And who tell hell pay $3500 for a $1800 system from falcon anyway? Hopefully no one at [H]ard, when all the knowledge to build your own better cheaper PC is here.
 
We have all dells at work doing work for Anthem.com from gx150 to the newest ones gx270 all the gx150 are going thru tech refresh and getting retired. We haven't had to many problems just in our Mason II building we have over 2600 dell desktops that doesn't included all the new D600 we are getting for the managers we are refreshing the c610 they are using now.

No on a personal note I love my Ibm notebooks my wife likes her Dell inspiron but she doesn't carry anywhere.

That is just my 2 cents jumps off soap box
 
Easy, easy djnes. Deep breath.... Happy place..... :cool:

What I really want to know is where the hell is THEREALJMAN? He started this rant, and now he doesn't come back! Coward.

Personally, I think we would all like a little more info about the re-imaging killing the mobos. That seems strange, must be more to it.

As far as Dell goes, since Dell is so ubiquitous, alot of people have had contact with them, so there are lots of opinions. Not saying they are right or wrong, just expected. I still would like an answer to my original question about who THEREALJMAN thinks would be better, and why.

BTW, whats up with the ALL CAPS user name?
 
Yeah, I'm still trying to figure out how re-imagining is damaging motherboards. And not just one or two.....83%?


as they say, this thread os moving more and more into the realm of "shens" until there is a reply on how software is killing motherboards.
 
Yeah, I'm still trying to figure out how re-imagining is damaging motherboards. And not just one or two.....83%?
Yeah, me too. I was sitting here trying to imagine a way, and it is a tough one for sure...assuming that it is really happening.
Maybe too much load is causing the southbridge to overheat? Go figure.
 
Originally posted by djnes
Yeah, I'm still trying to figure out how re-imagining is damaging motherboards. And not just one or two.....83%?

Me too. And exactly which person, on frying the first 300 machines (SOMEHOW), goes ahead and does the same thing to the next 300 or so. Thats like a Simpsons joke.

Welcome to the wild wild world of BS.
 
Originally posted by iNsAnE_crAzY
Name any big company I.E. (gateway to hell, dell-eted , e-mashit)
thats doesn't suck ass? You dont hear about these kind of gay ass problems with companys like falcon northwest and alienware. Why? B/c they stick to what they do assemble PC's they dont try and make there own MOBO's and bios and shit. When stuff gets all proprietary it turns to shit

also i am intrested 2 on how a drive re-imageing could kill a mobo but with dell i can't claim to be suprised:rolleyes:

Dell and HP are companies who have gotten this large because they put out lots of decent products. Comparing Falcon Northwest to Dell is like comparing Lexii to Geos. They do not compete directly. When is the last time you heard of a large business using anything but Dell/HP/etc?
 
Dell is the best big pc mfg imo. Gateway has gone downhill the last 4 years, and I don't like hp/compaq. I've got 1100 at work and have a few problems here and there but thier always resolved.
 
Well if you dont think they suck you can kiss my ass! lol

The things i don't like about there mobo's comes from the huge lack of features, not to mentions you ever been in the bios of a dell lol thats a funny thing

The reason i dont like HP/compuke or any others is b/c of the bull shit installed(aol and crap you almost need to do a reinstall out of the box) on them. also they are so untweaked it makes me sick look how long they take to boot in maximum pc the newest ones take like 60+ seconds. i boot in 13 using some hardware not as good as their's they have had raid o arrays w/ the new 10,000rpm raptors that take over a min to boot that is ludacris.
 
Okay, let's call a timeout for reason and logic?

Who are the primary customers of HP/Compaq/Dell/Gateway, etc? The 99% of the computer users who don't know what a BIOS is, much less how to tweak it. I personally don't buy prebuilt systems from an OEM, because am a DIY'er like most people.

But nothing is more ignorant and unfounded than calling OEM's shitty for making great products for 99% of their audience. I have had the opportunity to use many of our new HP and Compaq machines. I would have absolutely NO problem recommending them to most people who ask my advice for a new computer. Only a very small amount of people can handle a custom built machine. A lot of people on here need to step back and taken some lessons in business to understand why companies do the things they do.
 
Originally posted by iNsAnE_crAzY
Name any big company I.E. (gateway to hell, dell-eted , e-mashit)
thats doesn't suck ass? You dont hear about these kind of gay ass problems with companys like falcon northwest and alienware. Why? B/c they stick to what they do assemble PC's they dont try and make there own MOBO's and bios and shit. When stuff gets all proprietary it turns to shit

also i am intrested 2 on how a drive re-imageing could kill a mobo but with dell i can't claim to be suprised:rolleyes:

Don't rip on eMachines. They have the best bang-for-the-buck laptop at the moment, and all their new systems (new company, really) are all off the shelf componants (MSI, Western Digital, Corsair).
 
Originally posted by djnes
Okay, let's call a timeout for reason and logic?

Who are the primary customers of HP/Compaq/Dell/Gateway, etc? The 99% of the computer users who don't know what a BIOS is, much less how to tweak it. I personally don't buy prebuilt systems from an OEM, because am a DIY'er like most people.

But nothing is more ignorant and unfounded than calling OEM's shitty for making great products for 99% of their audience. I have had the opportunity to use many of our new HP and Compaq machines. I would have absolutely NO problem recommending them to most people who ask my advice for a new computer. Only a very small amount of people can handle a custom built machine.
true very true
 
Originally posted by lopoetve
Don't rip on eMachines. They have the best bang-for-the-buck laptop at the moment, and all their new systems (new company, really) are all off the shelf componants (MSI, Western Digital, Corsair).

well then im proud
 
Originally posted by valve1138
Does the reimaging include a BIOS update or something?

I was wondering that as well... seems like the only rational cause.
 
Tell ya what:

I work at one of the largest hospitals (heart hospital too) in the U.S., and there are IBM computers in every nurses station and in other areas. There are Dell computers in Cat Scan, Radiology, I think MRI, and most likely other ancillary units.

If a hospital can rely on them, then I sure as hell can. I've always been a fan of IBM. They're the pioneers. They made Bill Gates the rich bastard that he is! My college has a zillion Dell computers and they seem to work fine. I don't work in the IT department or anything but anytime I've used them, they've run fine, even when using extensive programs like AutoCAD, complex math equation programs, and image editing.

'eh, my only complaint with Dell is the prices, but they do have good stuff. I want a 20.1" LCD monitor. Who's buyin'?
 
Originally posted by djnes
I don't disagree that Dell has taken a long fall over the past few years, but I'm not seeing how a re-imaging process is killing motherboards. That's a software thing. I would certainly hope your not removing drives or anything like that during a re-image. If your opening the computers up for a re-image, then you need to use something else, like Ghost or Altiris. If not, something besides the process is killing boards. Software doesn't destroy hardware.

It's a bios issue - and yes software can kill hardware. We image thousands of PCs a day we have the proccess down and proven. Dell knows it's an issue hense they are replacing the MBs.
Please know what your talking about before you comment.

*EDIT*
The specific model is GX150 and the issue is spontanious reboot. All of our methods and images are Dell aproved. The only way to get Dell to replace the MB is to have a broken product. That's the reason they keep getting imaged. That's Dells position. Our purchasing managers are working with Dell on getting all the units replaced but that's a lot of PCs and Dell is pushing back.
 
I have an older Dell dual Xeon workstation on my desk at work, with a gig of RDRAM.....:D

I've tried to hate it, but the truth is that for what I do at work (Schematic capture / PCB CAD / circuit simulations and the usual Office stuff)......it runs great. Like a good truck; nothing flashy, but just gets it done without fanfare or hassle. Threw a CDRW and a second hard drive in it and it's really a good workstaton.

But - at home, it's home made [H]ot rods, to be sure....:cool:

FWIW - B.B.S.
 
My Inspiron 8500 is a beautiful laptop..its my 2nd dell machine, and i had a gateway before, and all three were good. If i ever had a problem, i pulled the part out and sent it back, no questions asked.
 
and yes software can kill hardware.

The only software I've ever heard of killing hardware are firmware/BIOS updates and a few viruses like CIH which tried to corrupt the BIOS with junk code (which usually failed because it was encrypted.) It did kill some very old machines like 386's etc that had unprotected BIOSs. I've heard that there was a virus that can kill a modem but this was years and YEARS ago and I have seen no evidence that this was actually true.

Now if you have a bad shipment of MBs that doesn't reveal itself until it's re-imaged - that I can see. Remember ages ago when Photoshop would uncover a bad cap on the mamaboards? Everything seemed fine until they ran Photoshop. Photoshop didn't kill the board it simply exposed the bad part. Is this what is happening?

Regardless, I'm very interested to hear how this software destroys the hardware. If you nail it down, please let us know.

On a side note, I believe that Dell has some of the best OEM products available. Each to their own I suppose.
 
Hardware wise, compaq and dell are OK. Its the other 90% of bs they do to customers that piss me off.

An example "399 PC! (200 dollar aol mail in rebate)"

The cheap ass plastic cases they use. (compaq and dell.)

Offering gf4mxs in their "gaming machines" Yes, someone had a 2.4 p4 with a gf4mx...Because he told them he wanted to play games.

Those damn cd holders that break off so easily.

Cramped cases, which arent all that bad. But when you know your customer base are in the real world with dust, smoking etc. you need to design based around that.

All the pre-insalled software on under spec machines. Win xp with 128 megs of ram is not effectively enough to begin with, then you decide to install diagnostic programs and whatever other programs they have laying out. (yes the requirement says 64 megs, but 128 isnt adequete, 256 imo is minnimum. )

Sure you can say "well its not compaqs job to educate the public" No its not, but we're talking about their overall product. Im just writing a short overall review :p

Outsourcing tech jobs to india. No this isnt a "crime" But it does anger customers. Ive been told a few times they simply hung up because they couldnt understand the guy.

How they throw their emblem everywhere. Thats like buying a car that says Chevy on the top, sides, windshield etc.

The length of time it takes to get those fancy rebates back. Ive heard anywhere from 2 months to over a year.

Yes im done at least for now :)
 
Originally posted by Spyder
dude, "YOUR GETTING A DELL", if anyone says that to you

step one -> start to cry
step two -> scream out "F&$@ You Go To HEll"

dell's are nothing but problems, the company i work for also has many of them, every day i find my self haveing to deal with stupied mobo problems, or inferior workman ship, ie some retard at dell does not have the strenght to plug in a IDE cable all the way, this might sound funny but thoes dell AC77's are really freeking hard to open got to take out 10000 screws just to pop the sucker open.... i hate DELL!!!!!

Um. .. or you could just get the Optiplex line. . . clamshell design, 0 screws, standard 3 yr parts and labor on the GX270 line. Looks like you guys just picked the wrong ones.
 
Originally posted by THEREALJMAN
It's a bios issue - and yes software can kill hardware. We image thousands of PCs a day we have the proccess down and proven. Dell knows it's an issue hense they are replacing the MBs.
Please know what your talking about before you comment.

*EDIT*
The specific model is GX150 and the issue is spontanious reboot. All of our methods and images are Dell aproved. The only way to get Dell to replace the MB is to have a broken product. That's the reason they keep getting imaged. That's Dells position. Our purchasing managers are working with Dell on getting all the units replaced but that's a lot of PCs and Dell is pushing back.
GX150s? Spontaneous reboot on reimage?

Does it display a "STOP 0x0whatever" BSOD? If so, I might be able to help.
I've dealt with a similar problem at my school. We reimaged a room of about 30 Dells (I think they were GX1s), and 20 or so did the spontaneous reboot. Turns out the motherboards that Dell uses actually vary within a specific model. Anyway, the IDE driver that Ghost uses isn't entirely compatible with one type of motherboard, but there is a fix.

I forget the link, but there's an article in the Microsoft Knowledge Base that discusses it. Basically, there's a big block of code that contains instructions for loading all IDE drivers, that you have to merge into the registry right before sysprepping your image. Try searching for the STOP code if that's the case.

If it is just showing you the first POST screen, going black then returning to the POST screen, I can't help you
 
Originally posted by THEREALJMAN
It's a bios issue - and yes software can kill hardware. We image thousands of PCs a day we have the proccess down and proven. Dell knows it's an issue hense they are replacing the MBs.
Please know what your talking about before you comment.

I could easily rip apart that post, but I won't. Software doesn't kill hardware...end of subject. My Dell rep that I remain in contact with cannot find anything about that model having any type of problems with re-imaging. Nor, can he find any problem with a massive motherboard failure. I think you should:

A) Don't post ridiculous BS and then tell other to get a clue
B) Switch jobs immediately to a company with an ounce of knowledge.
 
Yea I don't think your imaging "thousands" of computers a day when what you said you had 12k total? What you reimage every week? Got a ton of IT guys doing all of this? Hell and a gx 150 has got to be almost 3 years old...your lucky its under warranty.

The only problem I've ever had imaging dells was a problem with ghost not supporting a new onboard nic in the GX270s but thats been fixed.
 
Software doesn't kill hardware...end of subject.
While I generally agree there are exceptions to this rule (exceptions prove the rule, though). 1. Overclocking software can permanently destroy the processor (esp thinking of all those really neat OCing tools for video cards). 2. BIOS updates can destroy the chip they are updating, rare, but possible. 3. Virii trying to emulate these programs with intent on creating damage. Way back when, I heard of a virus that would try to refocus the guns on a monitor to a single point to fry the monitor. I wouldn't take that one to the bank, though, and even back then it supposedly wouldn't work on newer monitors. It was some thing I 'heard' and never really cared to look it up.

Like I said, I mostly agree with the statement, especially in this case where re-imaging is 'causing' the failure. But don't make such a blanket statement... end of subject. ;)
 
Your right. I should have been more specific. Normal everyday software, especially that of a re-imaging process, would not kill hardware. I shouldn't have said it was impossible. Maybe just impossible in this example.
 
Originally posted by Spyder
dude, "YOUR GETTING A DELL", if anyone says that to you

step one -> start to cry
step two -> scream out "F&$@ You Go To HEll"

dell's are nothing but problems, the company i work for also has many of them, every day i find my self haveing to deal with stupied mobo problems, or inferior workman ship, ie some retard at dell does not have the strenght to plug in a IDE cable all the way, this might sound funny but thoes dell AC77's are really freeking hard to open got to take out 10000 screws just to pop the sucker open.... i hate DELL!!!!!
DITTO!!!...HAHAHAH

i tried "upgrading" my friends dell....it is the WORST computer to work with.... the dell mobos must use dell heatsinks, etc...everythin comes from dell so if you wanna keep your computer, you must buy parts from dell

we ended up just buying new parts for his computer and only keeping the p4 processor and cd drive and harddrive....

DELL SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
So if this is the reboot issue jagec noted, Dell and you are wasting your time replacing mobos for a registry setting. Funny.

and yes software can kill hardware. We image thousands of PCs a day we have the proccess down and proven.
Some software can, yes, but not imaging software. If you had the process down proven you wouldn't be replacing mobos, and Dell doesn't always know what they are talking about. You know that certification process they have? I was one of their FIRST customers to have custom images loaded at the factory and worked a lot with their "certiifcation" process. It's not that impressive... While it will get the average dell tech saying OK once you tell them you installed an image, it doesn't mean it's a perfect image. Basically too many customers were getting the 'sorry I can't help' answer when they told the techs they had reinstalled the load as soon as they received the machine (common at most corps. to load their image instead of OEM crap). Since this was not making their corp. customers happy, they came up with a process to 'certify' them. It's mostly something for the dell techs, so they don't refuse warr. calls, nothing more.
 
i tried "upgrading" my friends dell....it is the WORST computer to work with.... the dell mobos must use dell heatsinks, etc...everythin comes from dell so if you wanna keep your computer, you must buy parts from dell

we ended up just buying new parts for his computer and only keeping the p4 processor and cd drive and harddrive....

Well no shit sherlock. You don't buy dells to try to upgrade them or move the parts out. I'm amazed at all the people on this board trying to mod thier dells.
 
Back
Top