Why History Needs Software Piracy

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Your honor, I wasn't pirating software...I was preserving it for the future of mankind. Why are you laughing? I am being serious. Wait, are those handcuffs?

It may seem counterintuitive, but piracy has actually saved more software than it has destroyed. Already, pirates have spared tens of thousands of programs from extinction, proving themselves the unintentional stewards of our digital culture. Software pirates promote data survival through ubiquity and media independence. Like an ant that works as part of a larger system it doesn’t understand, the selfish action of each digital pirate, when taken in aggregate, has created a vast web of redundant data that ensures many digital works will live on.
 
This is very true. There are some programs that are not available through any other means, unless you find a copy at a flea market. Even some developers don't even have the original media or source code anymore.

That, and floppies may not even work anymore due to age...
 
Pros of piracy in the big picture:

  • Spreads the knowledge of human kind, broadcasting ideas so that they may teach and inspire future generations
  • Puts more information in more hands, helping ensure continued preservation so that our cultures may look back on it and draw knowledge and inspiration
  • Gives even poor people access to knowledge, adding 4+ billion minds to the pool of cultural contributors and inventors
Cons of piracy in the big picture:

  • It is illegal because someone felt they should own an idea for more than a lifetime


Seriously, after watching James Burke's Connections, I realized that every major technological advancement in human history is based on someone else's ideas or inspired by someone else's work. I cannot condone the stifling of knowledge for any reason other than five-year patents and copyrights to encourage new things to be created.
 
Like an ant that works as part of a larger system it doesn’t understand, the selfish action of each digital pirate, when taken in aggregate, has created a vast web of redundant data that ensures many digital works will live on.

E'ffing priceless! Made my Friday. Thanks Steve!
 
Look how many old Doctor Who episodes were lost, in the dark days before piracy, when the BBC mistakenly destroyed the originals. Some old episodes are only still around because stations who were suppose to send them back or destroy them kept them instead, in violation of copyright laws.
 
My paper copy of 1984 will still be on my shelf for decades - long after Amazon erases the eBook version of it from everyone's Kindle.

I know that's not quite the same, but that does help illustrate the dangers of having a purely digital product - especially nowadays with DRM and digital distribution giving publishers (or other powerful organizations with an agenda) unprecedented power to control who, how, and where their media is being used.

Remember: right-holders care about making profit, not preserving their works as cultural "artifacts". Some may rather see their work destroyed than preserved while others don't care and don't bother to remove the DRM.
 
Pros of piracy in the big picture:

  • Spreads the knowledge of human kind, broadcasting ideas so that they may teach and inspire future generations
  • Puts more information in more hands, helping ensure continued preservation so that our cultures may look back on it and draw knowledge and inspiration
  • Gives even poor people access to knowledge, adding 4+ billion minds to the pool of cultural contributors and inventors
Cons of piracy in the big picture:

  • It is illegal because someone felt they should own an idea for more than a lifetime


Seriously, after watching James Burke's Connections, I realized that every major technological advancement in human history is based on someone else's ideas or inspired by someone else's work. I cannot condone the stifling of knowledge for any reason other than five-year patents and copyrights to encourage new things to be created.

Except most piracy today occurs well before it gets to halfway through someone's lifetime. Software piracy for instance is almost instantaneous. Kind of puts a huge hole right in the middle of your theory here...
 
Except most piracy today occurs well before it gets to halfway through someone's lifetime. Software piracy for instance is almost instantaneous. Kind of puts a huge hole right in the middle of your theory here...

Would you have the pirates wait until the software is lost before they copy it?
 
with SOPA, PIPA, ACTA, etc, I'm really getting pushed into the corner where my mindset is rapidly changing to "Fuck you, I buy a copy, it's mine to do with what I please, I am not buying a license, there is no legal basis behind me clicking 'I Agree' on a computer screen, I can do whatever I want with my copy, and yes I do mean whatever"
 
If lawmakers want to "crack down" on piracy, they should at the same time loosen up these ridiculous copyright laws. Why isn't the consumer's best interest ever considered?

Although I don't pirate current games, I like that people still host torrents for old games from ten years ago that are no longer made.
 
Pros of piracy in the big picture:

  • Spreads the knowledge of human kind, broadcasting ideas so that they may teach and inspire future generations
  • Puts more information in more hands, helping ensure continued preservation so that our cultures may look back on it and draw knowledge and inspiration
  • Gives even poor people access to knowledge, adding 4+ billion minds to the pool of cultural contributors and inventors
Cons of piracy in the big picture:

  • It is illegal because someone felt they should own an idea for more than a lifetime


Seriously, after watching James Burke's Connections, I realized that every major technological advancement in human history is based on someone else's ideas or inspired by someone else's work. I cannot condone the stifling of knowledge for any reason other than five-year patents and copyrights to encourage new things to be created.

And by "knowledge" you mean games, movies and music? :p
 
This is very true. There are some programs that are not available through any other means, unless you find a copy at a flea market. Even some developers don't even have the original media or source code anymore.

That, and floppies may not even work anymore due to age...

This is true in my case. I still have copies of Doom 2 on a floppy disk, but they work. I do have a floppy drive to read them, but they simply don't work. I wanted the files to play Doom 2 on my cell phone. What am I to do, buy another copy? Piracy has also found a number of extinct games that I really wanted to play again.

Oddly enough, back then one floppy was bad and ID software had no problem replacing the disks.
 
I still can't find my sweet ass star trek screen saver I bought for windows 3.1 ~ hopefully it didnt go extinct....gotta be out there....
 
Except most piracy today occurs well before it gets to halfway through someone's lifetime. Software piracy for instance is almost instantaneous. Kind of puts a huge hole right in the middle of your theory here...
We have laws against murder, yet there will always be murder.
We have laws against piracy, yet there will always be piracy.

The rape of the public domain, however, is permanent. We are slowing down the advancement of civilization by a hundred years or more with long copyrights.

And by "knowledge" you mean games, movies and music? :p
Yes. Art and science benefit from and inspire each other. How could you not know this?
 
NICE! ....but i'd bet its lies....lol peerblocker lists that HTTP as ISPrimeinc(Trojan infested)

One day....
 
Although I don't pirate current games, I like that people still host torrents for old games from ten years ago that are no longer made.

If the product hasn't been actively sold for a few years (and I'm not talking about buying it used on ebay), then it should be legal to copy it for person use.
 
My paper copy of 1984 will still be on my shelf for decades - long after Amazon erases the eBook version of it from everyone's Kindle.

I know that's not quite the same, but that does help illustrate the dangers of having a purely digital product - especially nowadays with DRM and digital distribution giving publishers (or other powerful organizations with an agenda) unprecedented power to control who, how, and where their media is being used.

Remember: right-holders care about making profit, not preserving their works as cultural "artifacts". Some may rather see their work destroyed than preserved while others don't care and don't bother to remove the DRM.


The DRM-free Epub I have of 1984 will remain stored in my network and on my tablets for decades too.
 
Yes. Art and science benefit from and inspire each other. How could you not know this?

Seriously? Yes, art benefits from a community and exchange. You see this in art schools going back centuries, or if video game studios callaborate on a game, or how one studio will get ideas from another.

Science also hugely benefits from the internet, I've been working as a researcher for the past couple of years and have downloaded (by my guess) hundreds of articles and papers. I agree if those papers were made more freely available it'd be great, as there's no way I would have read all I've read if it weren't for the fact my University pays subscriptions, which a backyard researcher couldn't do (that said, my research also relies on thousands of dollars worth of supercomputing resources and a water channel that has probably cost in the millions, so I wouldn't exactly be doing it in my backyard anyway). Hell, half the articles I've read are so obscure you wouldn't be able to find pirate versions of them even if you wanted to, except for getting it from a friend who has already got it. It'd be awesome if more major publications of articles were available freely to the general public.

However, that's a different kettle of fish completely. If you believe that some little nerd in his Mum's basement downloading movies, music and games is actually producing some sort of progress in the industry, all I can say is you need to smoke less weed you hippy :p There's no "exchange" or "development" of ideas, there's people who spend their time and money developing a product for a bunch of people to freely pirate it. Its all a one way street. The actual "artist to artist" sharing of games and movies is really quite removed from mainstream piracy.
 
The actual "artist to artist" sharing of games and movies is really quite removed from mainstream piracy.
You seem to be under the impression that pirates are not and cannot be intelligent and creative human beings. This "us vs. them" mentality, where "they" are a bunch of basement dwelling leeches who could never possibly contribute anything to art and science, is troubling to me.

Nobodyknows who the next Einstein or Kepler is. Nobodyknows that the next big technological advancement is or where it will come from. Uncorking that information (and not burying it behind a paywall) is essential to the advancement of our species.

We have this incredible tool in the internet, where all human knowledge can be passed back and forth, and we have a few elites who seek to control this ocean of knowledge. It's a losing battle for the media companies; they don't have the funds or the manpower to enforce the monopoly of all the information produced by billions of people.
 
You seem to be under the impression that pirates are not and cannot be intelligent and creative human beings. This "us vs. them" mentality, where "they" are a bunch of basement dwelling leeches who could never possibly contribute anything to art and science, is troubling to me.

Nobodyknows who the next Einstein or Kepler is. Nobodyknows that the next big technological advancement is or where it will come from. Uncorking that information (and not burying it behind a paywall) is essential to the advancement of our species.

We have this incredible tool in the internet, where all human knowledge can be passed back and forth, and we have a few elites who seek to control this ocean of knowledge. It's a losing battle for the media companies; they don't have the funds or the manpower to enforce the monopoly of all the information produced by billions of people.

And you seem to be way too idealistic. I totally agree with you in that information should be more freely available. Where I draw a difference in what is "information". Science articles and journals, better distribution of text books, that sort of stuff, yeah I totally agree.

But things like games and movies being pirated could only be described in the same manner in the loosest sense you could imagine. I don't see the flow of information or knowledge involved when 5 million people pirate Avatar or Call of Duty or the latest pop song. They aren't just "ideas" and "knowledge" being exchanged, they are a form of entertainment that someone put many hours into developing, someone else put lots of money into creating, someone else put many hours and dollars into marketing so that the public knows about it and they need to be adequately compensated, that compensation comes from people PAYING for it.

Peoples' time is not free, if you want professionally produced movies and games and music, you pay for it, with money. Hell, you go to a bar and if you like the music you'll put money in the tips jar so the artist doesn't starve to death and can continue to pursue their life of entertainment and art.

Hell, even me as a researcher, I'm contributing to the pool of knowledge, I'm absorbing knowledge from other people who have come before me and are working alongside me, but the money still has to come from somewhere, as much as I love what I do, I sure as fuck wouldn't be doing it for free.
 
it's Pirating, come on we can have freaking 100 million robots running the world for free of charge and we'll have everything for free, we'll still have pirates (well they'll pirate unlocked Robots in the future)

i will bet $1 to anyone who can tell me when the pirating will be over and hack they can give me time frame of 10 years and if they are right i'll give them this $1 without saying anything (well yes i'll say congratulation but that's it)
 
However, that's a different kettle of fish completely. If you believe that some little nerd in his Mum's basement downloading movies, music and games is actually producing some sort of progress in the industry, all I can say is you need to smoke less weed you hippy :p There's no "exchange" or "development" of ideas, there's people who spend their time and money developing a product for a bunch of people to freely pirate it. Its all a one way street. The actual "artist to artist" sharing of games and movies is really quite removed from mainstream piracy.

Most children eventually become young adults. Some of these young adults will go on to have jobs in those very industries. The memories of the experiences they had growing up will stay with them.

Ask John Carmack if he payed for every video game he ever played before writing Doom.

Ask Paul McCartney if he ever listened to a bootleg album before writing his songs.

Your letting something as trivial (yet destructive) as the concept of currency cloud your judgement.
 
it's Pirating, come on we can have freaking 100 million robots running the world for free of charge and we'll have everything for free, we'll still have pirates (well they'll pirate unlocked Robots in the future)

i will bet $1 to anyone who can tell me when the pirating will be over and hack they can give me time frame of 10 years and if they are right i'll give them this $1 without saying anything (well yes i'll say congratulation but that's it)

Its your perspective of the word that is wrong. If we lived in a world with no currency, piracy would be extrememly rampant. But only because the desire to have new experiences would be unhindered by the limitations of the currency. Currency ONLY exists to limit people. For 1 person to be rich, many must be poor. "Poor" is a relative term, but it will always mean those who have limited access. Think about it. If everyone had ample amounts of money, money wouldn't work. Its why we will never solve these things like world hunger so long as there is money in the world.
 
Pros of piracy in the big picture:

  • Spreads the knowledge of human kind, broadcasting ideas so that they may teach and inspire future generations
  • Puts more information in more hands, helping ensure continued preservation so that our cultures may look back on it and draw knowledge and inspiration
  • Gives even poor people access to knowledge, adding 4+ billion minds to the pool of cultural contributors and inventors
Cons of piracy in the big picture:

  • It is illegal because someone felt they should own an idea for more than a lifetime


Seriously, after watching James Burke's Connections, I realized that every major technological advancement in human history is based on someone else's ideas or inspired by someone else's work. I cannot condone the stifling of knowledge for any reason other than five-year patents and copyrights to encourage new things to be created.


So you think it's ok that if someone pours hundreds if not thousands of hours and dollars into a game that he/she get's NOTHING, NOTHING in return. It's OK for people to just download this for free and use it whenever they want while he/she gets absolutely nothing in return. Good logic there. I am guessing you don't have a job if you think it's fine for people to work for no money.
 
Pros of piracy in the big picture:

  • It is illegal because someone felt they should own an idea for more than a lifetime

You mean, a lifetime + 70 years, then Congress can give them extra copyright time, when they wish.
 
So you think it's ok that if someone pours hundreds if not thousands of hours and dollars into a game that he/she get's NOTHING, NOTHING in return. It's OK for people to just download this for free and use it whenever they want while he/she gets absolutely nothing in return. Good logic there. I am guessing you don't have a job if you think it's fine for people to work for no money.

This is an extreme example of reality. The reality is that many people will pay the price, if its a good game.

So now the question flips, as an artist would you prefer that people not experience your creation unless it improves your life. Or would you prefer that as many people as possible experience your work and improve their life.

Have you ever helped a family member do something? Helped a friend? Helped someone "upgrade" their computer when they couldn't quite afford it? Or do you believe these actions to be inappropriate? Why do we help those we know without compensation, but then charge those we do not? Is there something else at play other then the concept of money?
 
So you think it's ok that if someone pours hundreds if not thousands of hours and dollars into a game that he/she get's NOTHING, NOTHING in return.
Where did I say that? Show me where I said it is impossible to make money on science and art. The bottled water industry is successful, and yet they sell a product that people can get for next to nothing. Why can't media companies be half as creative?

It's OK for people to just download this for free and use it whenever they want while he/she gets absolutely nothing in return.
Again, where did I say they got nothing in return? Show me right now. Otherwise your argument is devoid of any merit, because you're arguing against something I did not say. That fits the very definition of a strawman argument.

People can make money out of creative works without the government imprisoning people, draining their life savings, and branding them felons for life. Creativity existed before copyright, and creativity will exist after copyright is dead and gone.
 
"Currency ONLY exists to limit people. For 1 person to be rich, many must be poor. "Poor" is a relative term, but it will always mean those who have limited access. Think about it. If everyone had ample amounts of money, money wouldn't work. Its why we will never solve these things like world hunger so long as there is money in the world."

Congratulations. You have just written the single stupidest thing on teh internetz this week. Currency (money, dosh, scratch, bread, etc.), both fiat and specie, is a unit of stored value, nothing more nothing less. Also, life IS NOT a zero-sum game; 1 person gaining wealth DOES NOT make another person poor. Please check out Carden's Economics On One Foot (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvJVhlNl1FA) and Hazlitt's Economics in One Lesson (http://www.fee.org/pdf/books/Economics_in_one_lesson.pdf)
 
Where did I say that? Show me where I said it is impossible to make money on science and art. The bottled water industry is successful, and yet they sell a product that people can get for next to nothing. Why can't media companies be half as creative?


Again, where did I say they got nothing in return? Show me right now. Otherwise your argument is devoid of any merit, because you're arguing against something I did not say. That fits the very definition of a strawman argument.

People can make money out of creative works without the government imprisoning people, draining their life savings, and branding them felons for life. Creativity existed before copyright, and creativity will exist after copyright is dead and gone.

You didn't put it as a "con of piracy" so it's safe to assume you didn't give a shit if the person who developed the product made money or not.

Lets take a great example, The Witcher 2. They made it so there is no DRM(later on anyways) so that the gamers who bought it wouldn't be screwed over, that still got pirated tons. Is that supposed to be good for the developers? Is that really helping them?

You think most pirates give a shit about what they pirate, they don't. They do it because they can. You could also read reviews/check other areas for information about a product rather than pirating it. I still don't understand why people find that they MUST pirate. If you don't have the money for it then don't get it. Just like if you don't have the money for a Lamborghini, you just don't buy it. I guess self-control is difficult these days.
 
Remember classic arcade games? Thanks to piracy of the ROM data that makes up those, an immeasurable amount of arcade game PCBs live today, even I have burnt a few EPROMS to rescue old boards.

I bring that up because classic arcade games were actually fun, unlike what the kids pirate today..
 
You didn't put it as a "con of piracy" so it's safe to assume you didn't give a shit if the person who developed the product made money or not.
I also did not list "the sanctity of life" as a con of piracy. Would you conclude I also condone murder? Putting words in my mouth and knocking all these strawmen out of the park isn't helping your argument, friend. My point still stands: Creativity existed before copyright, and creativity will exist after copyright is dead and gone.

Face it, copyright law slowly going the way of the dodo, because most of society thinks that going to prison for listening to an unlicensed song is pretty much bullshit. The numbers of people who have used a creative work without authorization grow every day; the well-funded propaganda that pirates are scumbag freeloaders doesn't resound with many anymore.
 
Its your perspective of the word that is wrong. If we lived in a world with no currency, piracy would be extrememly rampant. But only because the desire to have new experiences would be unhindered by the limitations of the currency. Currency ONLY exists to limit people. For 1 person to be rich, many must be poor. "Poor" is a relative term, but it will always mean those who have limited access. Think about it. If everyone had ample amounts of money, money wouldn't work. Its why we will never solve these things like world hunger so long as there is money in the world.

you are right but my point wasn't towards being rich/poor/things for free, it was clearly at 'no matter how hard you or me or anyone tries we'll always have piracy.' i know it won't happen, but by any luck it did (things being FFA), we'll still have people pirating things like games/movies and stuff before they are suppose to be available.
 
forgot the point i wanted to make.

the reason people are making/keeping money, stealing money/other items of value is because no longer one person is happy just doing what he wants without paying some kind of price. you must pay to do things you like to do. i paint a little just to take my mind of things and just to have fun and what i paint i give it away to friends and families. but when it comes to fix their computer or other stuff i charge them cause that costs me and i must pay to have food twice a day and roof over my head at night.
 
My paper copy of 1984 will still be on my shelf for decades - long after Amazon erases the eBook version of it from everyone's Kindle.

I know that's not quite the same, but that does help illustrate the dangers of having a purely digital product - especially nowadays with DRM and digital distribution giving publishers (or other powerful organizations with an agenda) unprecedented power to control who, how, and where their media is being used.

Remember: right-holders care about making profit, not preserving their works as cultural "artifacts". Some may rather see their work destroyed than preserved while others don't care and don't bother to remove the DRM.

I think the opposite? You have 1 copy of 1984. That 1 copy might at any time have an accident that you cannot possibly forsee. IE, a water pipe burst above your bookshelf. How can you really prepare for that contingency? Sure, wrap your entire bookshelf in plastic. A rat makes a whole in the plastic. Book ruined again, ok double pastic with electric current running through wire out outside to kill ran/insects instantly. Ok, electric current makes bookshelf go on fire during thunderstorm. Alternatively, air plane crashes into your home completely destroying the book.

Your book is gone. Never to be returned/restored/fixed. On the other hand, I can have my copy of 1984 on my hdd in my pc die and go 'Oh well, I have an external backup with all my ebooks' and have that external backup die and go 'Oh well, I have it uploaded to amazon.com's digital store and my microsoft skydrive'. Say a plan crashes into all three of those places at the same time(yeah right) while I am on vacation in Mexico. Oh well, I have it on my ebook + on my laptop. If I am super worried about emp fields from the sun someday whiping all my magnetic storage, I could even burn a copy to archival quality dvd!

When any of those devices are replaced (pc hard drive, amazon data center rebuilt/microsoft data centre rebuilt), I can simply re-distribute my ebook collection to keep it 'safe' from all but the most unlikely scenarios.
 
What I'm about to say will come to pass eventually, unless an asteroid destroys us all.

This copyright war is just the beginning, it is important that we stand to combat the ridiculous regulations but it won't change what will come. When 3d printers become mainstream they will work at a nano scale, it will no longer be about software, but about actual items that people will be able to recreate.

Eventually it will come to pass that it is impossible to control this, by that time the singularity will be near, this must not be controlled by one country or corporation, and probably never could be. Winter is coming, and anyone alive within the next 30 years will see it happen. Can't believe it's Newt's crazy ass that sees the writing on the wall.
 
the well-funded propaganda that pirates are scumbag freeloaders doesn't resound with many anymore.

Except all the "white knight", high-horse douchebags around here who think piracy is grounds for execution. :rolleyes: :p

Agree with everything you're saying, BTW.
 
This copyright war is just the beginning, it is important that we stand to combat the ridiculous regulations but it won't change what will come. When 3d printers become mainstream they will work at a nano scale, it will no longer be about software, but about actual items that people will be able to recreate.

LOL yeah, that's why the TPB guys want development to go even faster, so that "You wouldn't download a car" would just be a ridiculous piece of failed propaganda.
 
Back in the Apple ][ days piracy was rampant, but without it, we probably wouldn't be here talking about it today. And look, companies are still making their money, there is a much larger software presence in the world, with the US still being the major innovator and we are still talking about how piracy 'steals' billions. Piracy is free advertising. It's the cost of doing business, they know it, we know it. Perfect example, Autocad was one of the most pirated pieces of software on earth and if it wasn't for that, Autodesk would have been out of business. Look at Autodesk now. Tell me piracy for them hasn't been successful. Or EA or any other software company. Let's start to be honest about what it is and how is really losing.
 
Back
Top