Why Chrome OS Will Fail, Big Time

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
InfoWorld has an article posted today that explains why they believe Google’s Chrome OS will fail…big time. I had a feeling we’d see articles like this after watching that underwhelming webcast yesterday.

The bottom line is that while there is virtually nothing that you'll be able to do with the Chrome OS that you won't be able to do equally well with Windows, there are literally millions of things that you can do with Windows today that you'll likely never be able to do with the Chrome OS.
 
I mostly agree with his points. The success of ChromeOS has little to do with google, and more to do with people's willingness to live in cloud computing.

I for one, have no use for it, as with most people I know.
 
well we all know chrome OS is just another linux operating system.. so its common sense that we know it wont be able to do everything windows can do.. but the one thing we can be guaranteed is that it will be a hell of a lot more stable then windows ever will be and can be.. while at the same time being completely open source allowing for better programs, upgrades, and addons to the operating system..

the problem with magazines, website, magazines, etc.. is that the majority of them dont know shit about linux because most of them are to scared to try using it..

then on top of that i love how they say in the article that googles just dumping the OS on the open source community.. everyone knows the open source community is far more efficient then a company that only has maybe 10-20 people working on the OS to begin with.. i mean hell how do you think linux and all of its distrobutions got to this point.. its all been done by the open source community.. even ubuntu was done by the open source community..

like risqu3 said.. lets wait til it comes out since its not slated til mid 2010 to be released..
 
but the one thing we can be guaranteed is that it will be a hell of a lot more stable then windows ever will be and can be.. while at the same time being completely open source allowing for better programs, upgrades, and addons to the operating system..

I'm not trying to nitpick, but this portion of your post really stood out to me.

First, let me say I've been a longtime Windows user, but I work in a lab that uses ONLY Linux systems and I have 3 Linux installs at home, one of which is always on.

Just being open source does not at all equal "better," in my opinion. A strong example of this is Open Office. OO is a "good" program, but Microsoft Office is far and away better for general use. Specifically, OO Calc vs. Microsoft Excel. Excel wins hands-down every time. As I just said, making something open source does not automatically add any value to the program.

As far as Windows stability, I'd be willing to bet that if you took a poll of the [H], you would find that MOST people, in day to day use, have not had a blue screen (exceptions allowed for overclocking, since that's a HARDWARE issue) since pre-SP2 Windows XP days. XP, Vista, and 7 are EXTREMELY stable. The only time I've ever had a bluescreen on 7 (none on Vista) was when I installed RAM and clocked it too high (my chipset wouldn't handle 8GB @ DDR2-833, since the chipset was only rated for DDR2-800, I was overflowing its max bandwidth).

Whereas, on my Ubuntu install, I can't get the ATI drivers to install without completely breaking my X server. xorg.conf completely craps itself after installing the ATI drivers and I have to go with VESA drivers or the open source X ATI drivers, neither of which will drive my display at 1920x1200 without shimmering b/c of a low refresh rate.

I will say this: Almost any MODERN operating system will not have issues on its own. Linux, Windows, OSX, whatever. If the user does not screw something up, you'll be hard pressed to find an OS that breaks itself. I've actually seen it happen MORE with the RHEL installs at work. Yum upgrade has broken more things for us than anything else.

Stability isn't really a valid argument either, in my opinion.
 
Chrome OS is a dumb terminal. Every single time someone has tried to push such a thing for home use it fails.
 
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1034936806 said:
I'm not trying to nitpick, but this portion of your post really stood out to me.

First, let me say I've been a longtime Windows user, but I work in a lab that uses ONLY Linux systems and I have 3 Linux installs at home, one of which is always on.

Just being open source does not at all equal "better," in my opinion. A strong example of this is Open Office. OO is a "good" program, but Microsoft Office is far and away better for general use. Specifically, OO Calc vs. Microsoft Excel. Excel wins hands-down every time. As I just said, making something open source does not automatically add any value to the program.

As far as Windows stability, I'd be willing to bet that if you took a poll of the [H], you would find that MOST people, in day to day use, have not had a blue screen (exceptions allowed for overclocking, since that's a HARDWARE issue) since pre-SP2 Windows XP days. XP, Vista, and 7 are EXTREMELY stable. The only time I've ever had a bluescreen on 7 (none on Vista) was when I installed RAM and clocked it too high (my chipset wouldn't handle 8GB @ DDR2-833, since the chipset was only rated for DDR2-800, I was overflowing its max bandwidth).

Whereas, on my Ubuntu install, I can't get the ATI drivers to install without completely breaking my X server. xorg.conf completely craps itself after installing the ATI drivers and I have to go with VESA drivers or the open source X ATI drivers, neither of which will drive my display at 1920x1200 without shimmering b/c of a low refresh rate.

I will say this: Almost any MODERN operating system will not have issues on its own. Linux, Windows, OSX, whatever. If the user does not screw something up, you'll be hard pressed to find an OS that breaks itself. I've actually seen it happen MORE with the RHEL installs at work. Yum upgrade has broken more things for us than anything else.

Stability isn't really a valid argument either, in my opinion.

Tis true. I have never had a blue screen or instability issues with Vista and 7. Linux is good too but harder to deal with for setting things up.
 
Chrome OS is a dumb terminal. Every single time someone has tried to push such a thing for home use it fails.

Chrome OS is what a lot of startups are waiting for. Big companies can develop their own OS for their own products. However, Chrome OS will allow much smaller companies to develop solid cloud based appliances with a MUCH smaller insertion cost.
 
Chrome OS is a web browser for netbooks & free.. for.. goodness... sake... stop... complaining.
 
Chrome OS is a web browser for netbooks & free.. for.. goodness... sake... stop... complaining.

Nobody wants to have to buy a netbook to play with it. I think a lot of our complaints are valid - Google should allow us to install it on existing note/netbooks.

It's obviously not free if they're only letting us have it buying a new netbook. Sounds to me like Google's getting a percentage of the netbook sales this way.
 
I think these people fail to understand the target market of Chrome OS, or at least as I understand it from the information provided by Google, and it seems pretty obvious. The target machines that this will go on are going to be internet devices, be it netbooks, tablets, lower end desktops that are only used for internet. Not to say it might not be able to do more than that, or what might change between now and release but it doesn't seem to me that this is trying to replace Windows or major Linux distro's but rather be a more convenient OS for companion systems and the low end desktop for the "i just want their email, facebook and youtube" users that dont want to pay the insane price of Windows or fight with the troubles of the standard Linux distro.
 
With a little "easy, secure, virus-free surfing & email" marketing it just might get the "good for grandma" seal of approval.
 
To be fair it's not meant for desktops.

To be honest I stopped reading after the author started to rant about Linux's hardware incompatibilities...that is so blatantly wrong with today's Linux distros I started to laugh!

First off most people bitching don't understand that this is for netbooks and portable devices......and yes it will have offline capabilities. Down the road as it evolves it may be useful on the desktop...or not.

And the ones that keep saying "I don't do everything on the web" are the first ones to bitch and scream if their internet is down..."I can't get anything done since my internet is down :rolleyes:"!
 
yeah I complete agree , open source does not mean perfect stability, sometimes its the latter, especially if someone developing something suddenly looses the urge to continue to improve the program. there is a good marketing to it though, saying its open source catches alot of people's attention since, a large percentage believes that open source = more stable :D
 
People will try it cause it is google, that is my thought, people use google for everything, so why not try the OS.
 
Chrome OS will fail? Since when does Google fail at anything?

I can't really think of anything besides gaming that I can't do on the web.
 
Chrome OS will fail? Since when does Google fail at anything?

I can't really think of anything besides gaming that I can't do on the web.

Record TV. Record and edit video and audio beyond VERY basic stuff. Real time alternative interface such as handwriting and speech recognition. Watch a Blu Ray quality movie. The list goes on.

Now sure you COULD most of this stuff on the web but without a FAST network connection you really wouldn't want to.
 
With all of the animus against M$ and the ubiquity of Google.com, it may work.

Web based word processors and various office applications, etc. Think about it.
 
but the one thing we can be guaranteed is that it will be a hell of a lot more stable then windows ever will be and can be.. while at the same time being completely open source allowing for better programs, upgrades, and addons to the operating system..

If all Windows did was support running a browser then it wouldn't be any less stable than Chrome.

And as far as open source allowing for better programs and updates honestly we have a good history with open source OS'es now and this has by NO means be the easily provable case.

Windows 7 was a tremendous update at least in terms of PR. And FAR more native programs than Linux still.
 
If there is good driver support, I don't see why it wouldn't work. It has the "power of google" behind it which Ubuntu doesn't, and if you can get a netbook for $50 cheaper because you're not buying a Windows license, some people will bite.
 
Nobody wants to have to buy a netbook to play with it. I think a lot of our complaints are valid - Google should allow us to install it on existing note/netbooks.

It's obviously not free if they're only letting us have it buying a new netbook. Sounds to me like Google's getting a percentage of the netbook sales this way.

Bingo. They are touting the "free" aspect of Chrome OS but overall it isn't free because they're going draconian on the hardware just like Apple does. If I can't download the ISO and install it on whatever the hell I want then it isn't "free".

I agree with everything the article on InfoWorld stated. Chrome OS has no hope of succeeding in Google's current plan.
 
With all of the animus against M$ and the ubiquity of Google.com, it may work.

Web based word processors and various office applications, etc. Think about it.

This isn't the first attempt at web based office apps. Microsoft now has its own web based office apps in beta that you can run on your on hardware if you so choose.

As far as the supported animus against Microsoft I don't think its any worse than its historically been, in fact with good product releaseds like Windows 7 people have been more positive towards Microsoft lately.

And don't think there isn't a GREAT deal of animus towards Google having ALL of your apps and data on THEIR servers.
 
Chrome OS will fail? Since when does Google fail at anything?

I can't really think of anything besides gaming that I can't do on the web.

Google has failed a few things for being redundant and unpopular:
http://news.cnet.com/8301-17939_109-10143245-2.html

Chrome OS has some use for business, yet I question what large company would feel safe giving Google access to such data, communications, and business transactions. Any such company would use their own servers not Google's. That is not what Google wants, they want people to use thier apps so they get tied to Google and stuck there.

Chrome OS is nothing more then a web browser. Yes Chrome OS has uses, but is that type of product going to end up on anything more then a few cute gadgets that the average person uses?

Personally I would like to see Chrome OS on a tablet with a screen suitable for reading like the Kindle has. That is the only place I would ever use Chrome OS.
 
And don't think there isn't a GREAT deal of animus towards Google having ALL of your apps and data on THEIR servers.

THIS!!! is so true. There's nothing more ubiquitous than being owned/pwned by the almighty Google. I fear Google now... :eek:
 
I think that calling it an OS is a bit of a stretch. By definition, operating systems include things
like support for storage and file systems. And it's just another Linux based OS, move along, nothing
to see here. Might as well just run regular Linux.

Seriously, this wasn't meant for the desktop, it's for small computers, thin clients, and mobile
devices. A stripped down OS with a small footprint, minimal power requirements, and far less code
and compatibility issues to support as a result. Some people will try it, find it does everything they
need, and use it on their desktops, or maybe use it for a friend or relative who has minimal computer
needs, but it's not really for us. There are more of them then there are of us. So, it's hard to say, it
could be a big hit, or it could be a total flop. My gut feeling is that if your broadband is fairly reliable
and always on, then a web app approach might not be so bad. TBH, I don't think the average
consumer thinks about whether their apps are local or remote, just so long as it works, they will
be satisfied.
 
I think that calling it an OS is a bit of a stretch. By definition, operating systems include things
like support for storage and file systems. And it's just another Linux based OS, move along, nothing
to see here. Might as well just run regular Linux.

Seriously, this wasn't meant for the desktop, it's for small computers, thin clients, and mobile
devices. A stripped down OS with a small footprint, minimal power requirements, and far less code
and compatibility issues to support as a result. Some people will try it, find it does everything they
need, and use it on their desktops, or maybe use it for a friend or relative who has minimal computer
needs, but it's not really for us. There are more of them then there are of us. So, it's hard to say, it
could be a big hit, or it could be a total flop. My gut feeling is that if your broadband is fairly reliable
and always on, then a web app approach might not be so bad. TBH, I don't think the average
consumer thinks about whether their apps are local or remote, just so long as it works, they will
be satisfied.

The problem with the Google model is that you then have EVERYTHING on their servers and don't think that people are so stupid as to think that not aware of this and that this won't become a bigger and bigger issue.

Sorry if the cloud becomes tied to ONE company with EVERYTHING then its no longer the cloud. It's has the potential to be a bigger monopoly than Microsoft.
None of this stuff is new. We've had free alternatives to desktop apps for a long time and they never have taken off. Now maybe this time will be different. But at the same time Microsoft is offering the same capability but one that you can host on your OWN hardware. That to me is a COOL option. And its easier to move stuff to different places.

As long as Microsoft can be cost competitive and now that Office 2010 will have a basic free edition as well a a free web based version, Google docs might very quickly become a red headed step child. If you're an Office user and want to go the the cloud, you're probably be following Microsoft to the cloud as well.

But I seriously don't get the point of Chrome OS. Microsoft could easily do the same thing based on a Windows core. If it's just for running a web browser that ain't a big deal.

The Why is is going to be a HUGE issue with the Chrome OS.
 
If there is good driver support, I don't see why it wouldn't work. It has the "power of google" behind it which Ubuntu doesn't, and if you can get a netbook for $50 cheaper because you're not buying a Windows license, some people will bite.

Really? Look at what happened to more full featured Linux distros than Chrome on netbooks. $50 just isn't a lot of money when it relates to getting work done.
 
One thing they missed...

will you ever be able to get Windows 7 legally for free?

Free is a very compelling thing...
 
Really? Look at what happened to more full featured Linux distros than Chrome on netbooks. $50 just isn't a lot of money when it relates to getting work done.

And of course some of us will argue that $50 is a lot of money if it *doesn't* related to getting work done. I don't want the windows license.

Hopefully what ChromeOS will do is start to convince people that there are other real alternatives to getting their work done that aren't tied to Microsoft.
 
I was going to post earlier about the ability to use lower spec'd machines. A win7 install took me about 12-15GB of space recently on my laptop. The chrome OS could probably let us bust out those celeron 300As that we have laying around, and if have them OC'd to 450MHz, they may just be able to run Chrome OS. Lolz...

But really... If a bunch of old cronies had to type www.word.com or something like that and have their documents tracked by cookies, then it could be easier than trying to find documents in their My Documents folder. Granted, security/privacy would be out the window, but I don't think the masses care about that. They only scream when hit by a virus and lose all their shit. Google could offer them the "security" by having their stuff on their servers. If Google charges for it, then the average consumer would have a field day suing them too! However if it were free, constituting a donative promise, then Google will be free of any liability, but they would be able to disseminate the users documents and put Google sponsored ads. Yay... No thanks for me, but maybe for Grandma!

We can't really look at the rest of the world with the same power user mentality. I mean, shit I've got so many work documents on my office lappy that I have to use the search function now. And I don't want to have drawings of my prototypes accessible by Google search. hahahaha....
 
One thing they missed...

will you ever be able to get Windows 7 legally for free?

Free is a very compelling thing...

So compelling that Linux has made huge inroads on the desktop over the past ten years..

Oh wait, no they haven't. People would rather buy an OS they can use.

I'll stick to using Linux for servers and security work, but it will not replace Windows on the desktop.
 
I think it lacks foresight to declare this OS dead. It's not so much about the OS as it is the idea of the web as a platform for everything.

Something like this won't get going overnight, or within the next few years. Something like this would need time to attract business attention. If businesses buy into the web-os platform, then it's only a matter of time before your doing gaming, and everything though something like Chrome-OS.

It's pretty absurd that in an industry where imagination and cutting edge ideas relay into revolutionary products, that so many want to discredit something before it even gets started, or because they only considered it's usefulness in the here-and-now of what they do with their PC's today.

The only thing I don't like is the requirement for "Chrome-OS" supported hardware.
 
I find the very idea that any serious business would buy into this as ridiculous. Businesses have to control their information for a variety of legal, competitive, compliance, and other reasons that sharing it all with Google would be unthinkable.
 
If google can push tech away from windows only and move towards open standards like OpenCL, OpenGL and such.

World would be a better place for consumer.

thats the thing, directX is not supported on linux or unix and bsd.
Opengl is supported everywhere, so why not use it i say.

if games use opengl, the port to linux is rather simple, and if its supported in linux, or chrome os, or macos its easy... very easy to port.
 
OpenGL is a mess, like most typical huge OS projects it takes them years to agree on any significant changes, if they come to an agreement at all. How is that better for the consumer?
 
Back
Top