Why A High-Quality PSU Is Essential

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Corsair Cinema is showing a video today that clearly demonstrates the need for a high quality power supply. What you see in the video is exactly the reason behind our extensive testing process for every PSU that comes across our test bench. So how well do Corsair’s PSUs stand up to our tests? See for yourself.

Buying a cheap PSU is a false economy. Buying a high quality PSU from an industry-leading manufacturer such as Corsair is the only way to ensure that the product performs as advertised, and it is the only way to ensure that a PC will operate stably and reliably. This video shows why.
 
Not that I disagree about buying a quality PSU, but there are a couple things I noticed:

- The PSU probably wasn't getting proper air flow with half the casing off.
- At the end it says "Guaranteed not to dramatically explode". I'm sure the budget power supplies came with a warranty as well...
 
While I don't doubt the test results because I have seen first hand how bad most budget psu's are, I think it would of been nice had they shown a little more then just the psu. This way those who don't know don't think the psu was rigged.
 
I'm willing to bet that the lab that these tests were run in with the cover off tends to be colder than ambient temps a user would actually USE this product in. Most labs are kept at 16c (60F) in order to keep systems from overheating. To be fair, I've been to the Corsair Labs and it feels like the arctic in the lab.

I'd like to see a shot of the load tester though just to prove to others that these PSU's were not subjected to something out of the ordinary with regards to load.
 
A few things here
1st. Corsair is trying to sell me something
2nd. It just happens to be in their labs hooked up to their equipment.
3rd. all six died within 2 mins??? wtf are they doing to make all 6 die within two mins?
4th. Something just doesnt sound right... and did anyone see that coolmaster box in the end?
 
6/6 failing in 2 minutes? I've seen plenty of generic PSUs, the claim of 100% failure is obviously bullshit. Just another advertisment.

I'm not saying you should buy the no-name piece of crap, but there are plenty of mid ranges supplies that work perfectly.
 
I dunno, seeing some of the results from the test where [H] took power supplies from Best Buy, this doesn't sound like too far of a stretch. Some of those power supplies would barely output half of their rated capacity.

Either way, the video gave me a laugh :D
 
6/6 failing in 2 minutes? I've seen plenty of generic PSUs, the claim of 100% failure is obviously bullshit. Just another advertisment.

I'm not saying you should buy the no-name piece of crap, but there are plenty of mid ranges supplies that work perfectly.

I could see this being true. Look at the reviews here were a powersupply is labbeled for one rating but not able to do 75% of that load. Just get 6 of those and all 6 would die if you give them all the same 75% load.

Now like said though, they are trying to sell you something so of course they probably searched and searched to find a model that they knew would die like that.
 
I liked it, but I dunno, something doesn't seem right. I have built rigs before on a budget, where I didn't pick the components mind you... but I think I had 2 PSU's fail in a row, all cheap ones. I haven't had a PSU fail like that though.
 
Though I agree that Corsair PSUs kick ass, there was definitely not enough info shown/given. Loved the Cooler Master box in the corner.
 
6/6 failing in 2 minutes? I've seen plenty of generic PSUs, the claim of 100% failure is obviously bullshit. Just another advertisment.

I'm not saying you should buy the no-name piece of crap, but there are plenty of mid ranges supplies that work perfectly.

100% failure at 75% load. I'm the one who did the testing in the lab. The PSU we purchased is rated like this:

+3.3V@28A,+5V@34A,+12V@21A

We tested it with the 12V at 18A, the 3.3V at 20A, and the 5V at 10A on our load testers.

Ideally we'd have been able to test a better balance, but this 12V heavy load we figured was more realistic in real world usage.

There are a lot of mid-range supplies that "work perfectly". But this is definitely not the cheapest/worst PSU available. It's also not from a complete no-name brand. It's about half the cost of the VX450 right now on Newegg, and the VX450 (and, indeed, many of our competitor's supplies) have no problem running 100% load.

We just happened to find this one which explodes within 2 minutes at the loads indicated above, and thought it was amusing.
 
I noticed a coolmaster box after second explosion. Not saying they cheapos where coolmaster PSUs (do they make them?) but kind of makes you wonder.
 
Let's not forget that Corsair doesn't actually make PSU's and it is thanks to Seasonic that they have good qaulity PSU's with their name on it. Just as the Antec NEO and PC P&C Silencer series are Seasonic too.
 
I dunno, seeing some of the results from the test where [H] took power supplies from Best Buy, this doesn't sound like too far of a stretch. Some of those power supplies would barely output half of their rated capacity.

Either way, the video gave me a laugh :D

I had some fun like that too, if I may be permitted a cheap plug: http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php?name=NDReviews&op=Story&reid=71

The casing being together wouldn't have made a whole lot of difference. No transient filter to speak of. Very anemic secondary side. Looks like a Deer, actually, and even if it isn't it's about that same quality.

It blew out on the primary side every single time, which means it didn't have the capacity in the first place to supply the weak secondary side. It might have waited a couple seconds longer to die with the cover on, but I don't see it doing the full 450W for even a second.
 
Let's not forget that Corsair doesn't actually make PSU's and it is thanks to Seasonic that they have good qaulity PSU's with their name on it. Just as the Antec NEO and PC P&C Silencer series are Seasonic too.

qft, seasonic is teh win.


As for this article, I think it's quite biased, there are many cheap brands out there that will be 100% functional for the life of the computer and not fail... there are also brands out there that will never see 75% load. Lets face it, even at 50% load, I don't think we will see much of that in budget computers, they simply do not draw that much power.
 
Let's not forget that Corsair doesn't actually make PSU's and it is thanks to Seasonic that they have good qaulity PSU's with their name on it. Just as the Antec NEO and PC P&C Silencer series are Seasonic too.
We use Channelwell as an OEM for part of our product line also.
 
6/6 failing in 2 minutes? I've seen plenty of generic PSUs, the claim of 100% failure is obviously bullshit. Just another advertisment.

I'm not saying you should buy the no-name piece of crap, but there are plenty of mid ranges supplies that work perfectly.


And as this points out, there are plenty that don't.
 
Wow, some of you guys are amazing. I am going to keep your quotes handy because the next time you have a peice of hardware that will not do what is advertised, I am going to ask you why you extend a different measuring stick for PSUs. Weaksauce.
 
...its marketing.

Never overlook a psu, if you need a good one then there's a price to pay.
 
335W total load from a 450W is quite a lot actually, so 100% failure at that load is what I would have expected from one of those ultra cheap PSUs. Many of you guys who use 700W PSUs are probably only using them to maybe 50%.

If you look at the [H] review of the 4870X2 (http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTUzMSw5LCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==), you can see that this is about what their test system used with a GTX260 installed. The PSU Corsair tested was probably one of those "ultra cheap" ones.. if you buy such a PSU and use it in a Quad-core machine with a GTX260 or 4870, you deserve to see some sparks flying :)

Corsair are one of the few companies that still produces "quality" PSUs below ~600W, which is great for those of us building low-end and mid-range systems.
 
Wow, some of you guys are amazing. I am going to keep your quotes handy because the next time you have a peice of hardware that will not do what is advertised, I am going to ask you why you extend a different measuring stick for PSUs. Weaksauce.

Kyle,

Not only have I read your website for years, but I do so daily. I'm not sure who you are directing this comment towards but I agree with most of them. Kyle, the very reason we come here is for a third party point of view and non-biased test results. This video is nothing more than a marketing ploy, and outright attack (IMO) on Cooler Master.

I have no respect for Corsair and their practices and the video makes me hate them even more. Maybe I should have made a video of their shitty RAM that was RMA'ed twice because 4 out of the 6 I purchased did not work. Maybe I should also dig up the disrespectful email that their tech support sent me and make it public too? I spoke with my money, I'll never buy their over priced, over hyped shit products again.

Consumers speak with your dollars. Corsair go belly up, so I don't have to shop around you anymore.
 
Corsair power supplies are top notch and I have no qualms whatsoever recommending them to clients and family members.

However, several questions arise regarding this video.

- Are these power supplies only single rail units?
- Why weren't the other molex power leads connected to the test equipment?
- Why wasn't the load tester shown in the video?

Sorry guys, but without the above information I lend no creedance to this video.
 
All my PSU's over the last few years have been Seasonic. Every one of them have been solid as a rock. (I didnt know that Seasonic create the Corsair PSU's as well which is useful)

I also over buy slightly... so right now my 600W Seasonic rated PSU has enough bandwidth in power to cope with more equipment and it means generally my whole PC runs at less loading % on the PSU.

Dont skimp on the PSU!
 
Nice to see the Corsair guys getting involved in the discussion.

Lets see, Raidmax 450W Model: RX-450K, that fits your specs.

+3.3V@28A,+5V@34A,+12V@21A,-12V@1.0A, +5VSB@2.5A

They aren't no a no name company, but are cheap and I could see them doing this.
 
Kyle,

Not only have I read your website for years, but I do so daily. I'm not sure who you are directing this comment towards but I agree with most of them. Kyle, the very reason we come here is for a third party point of view and non-biased test results. This video is nothing more than a marketing ploy, and outright attack (IMO) on Cooler Master.

I have no respect for Corsair and their practices and the video makes me hate them even more. Maybe I should have made a video of their shitty RAM that was RMA'ed twice because 4 out of the 6 I purchased did not work. Maybe I should also dig up the disrespectful email that their tech support sent me and make it public too? I spoke with my money, I'll never buy their over priced, over hyped shit products again.

Consumers speak with your dollars. Corsair go belly up, so I don't have to shop around you anymore.

They aren't Coolermaster power supplies they are Deer or Youngyear or Leadman OEM'd units from a company that does make cases that blew the primary switching transistors all of which are OEM's not used by Coolermaster. The box is a Coolermaster case box from the angle in the video.
 
I'd be interested in hearing why those PSU's explode so easily. I'm assuming it's partly because they use cheap caps and their circuit design sucks. My knowledge is pretty limited to basics (mostly from changing out caps in tube amps).

I switched from cheap PSU's to a very high quality PSU (one that did awesome on [H] reviews) and I noticed a huge difference. While the cheap ones didn't blow up, my overclocks soared and system stability was night and day. Spending the extra money on the PSU allowed me to reach a higher overclock with a cheaper CPU. ...as oposed to spending more on a CPU and getting a lower overlclock with a poor PSU.
 
They aren't Coolermaster power supplies they are Deer or Youngyear or Leadman OEM'd units from a company that does make cases that blew the primary switching transistors all of which are OEM's not used by Coolermaster. The box is a Coolermaster case box from the angle in the video.

It shouldn't be in the video then, it gives false impressions that the box is what is on the table.
 
It shouldn't be in the video then, it gives false impressions that the box is what is on the table.

Watch the video again it was not meant to be in frame and was only caught accidentally there when the videographer was jumping back from the last transistor blowing. There are no false impressions there.
 
I'd be interested in hearing why those PSU's explode so easily. I'm assuming it's partly because they use cheap caps and their circuit design sucks. My knowledge is pretty limited to basics (mostly from changing out caps in tube amps).

I switched from cheap PSU's to a very high quality PSU (one that did awesome on [H] reviews) and I noticed a huge difference. While the cheap ones didn't blow up, my overclocks soared and system stability was night and day. Spending the extra money on the PSU allowed me to reach a higher overclock with a cheaper CPU. ...as oposed to spending more on a CPU and getting a lower overlclock with a poor PSU.

It was becasue the primary switching transistors were undersized for the unit.
 
I was already gonna get a Corsair PSU, but the music and effort put into this video made my laugh on the inside.:D:p
 
Watch the video again it was not meant to be in frame and was only caught accidentally there when the videographer was jumping back from the last transistor blowing. There are no false impressions there.

I'd have to agree, it was an accident that a brand name was caught on tape. Even then -- even if it was a cooler master power supply box, it still doesn't mean it was used in the tests. The power supply being cooler master is pure speculation.
 
Watch the video again it was not meant to be in frame and was only caught accidentally there when the videographer was jumping back from the last transistor blowing. There are no false impressions there.

This is exactly right. In fact I barely noticed that the Cooler Master box was in the video. We use a few Cooler Master cases around here (Stacker 830 and Cosmos) when we build systems to take to shows like Cebit, Computex, CES, etc. The box just showed up in the video because I ran away from an exploding power supply like a frightened schoolgirl.

So under no circumstances was this intended to show that this was a Cooler Master PSU. It's not a Cooler Master PSU. I have never seen a Cooler Master PSU fail like this one did.

We intentionally hid the name brand of this PSU because we didn't want to get into a brand war of sorts. There are a lot of good PSUs out there, Corsair is the best in my opinion, but of course it would be - I work there, and I'm the guy who is in control of the PSU line from a technical standpoint.

I made this video to share some direct results of one of the more spectacular failures we've seen in the lab. Usually when products fail they just blow a fuse or trip the OCP or temperature protection circuits and shut down. This one is noteworthy because it's actually NOT the cheapest PSU you can buy, and yet still fails pretty impressively. I thought you guys would be interested.

For those of you guys saying it's Marketing - of course it is. Every company out there is trying to sell their products - we're no exception. But it's also true and funny. Marketing isn't synonymous with lying.
 
The video is quite believable, any of you who bother to do this test can reproduce it yourself if you doubt! Grab a Raidmax/etc and put the load on it. It's fairly irrelevant if the power connectors or other aspects of the load are seen, this is exactly what you can expect in a normal test as they described.

The failure was from the primary side switching transistors, they overheated and shorted so quickly because Corsair's test left the cover off to cause inadequate airflow. A mere 10F cooler lab environment, if present, would not be nearly enough to counter the effect of this. These are poor PSU which would fail eventually though with the cover on one might power a modest low end system for a year or two if you're lucky.

However, this mainly means you should avoid that specific PSU and others built very similar, you cannot assume this will happen with many other budget PSU, especially not with the cover off.

If you left the cover off the Corsair and loaded it to 75% it would probably fail too, though likely taking more than a couple of minutes to do so.
 
Corsair's increased quality and resultant increased fan following has less to do with one-sided propaganda videos (I enjoyed watching the cheap PSU spark, you always hear about the dangers of including an inferior PSU in your rig, but it certainly wasn't hard core evidence) and more to do with the comprehensive tests and reviews of Corsair PSU's by the [H] crew. I'm going to listen to the consumer reports versus the used car salesman any day of the week. For all I care Corsair could show the inferior PSU sparking, creating a black hole and sucking the universe into oblivion, I'm going to disregard those claims until this web-site concurs with the data in their own findings. /salute [H]
 
Kyle,

Not only have I read your website for years, but I do so daily. I'm not sure who you are directing this comment towards but I agree with most of them. Kyle, the very reason we come here is for a third party point of view and non-biased test results. This video is nothing more than a marketing ploy, and outright attack (IMO) on Cooler Master.

I have no respect for Corsair and their practices and the video makes me hate them even more. Maybe I should have made a video of their shitty RAM that was RMA'ed twice because 4 out of the 6 I purchased did not work. Maybe I should also dig up the disrespectful email that their tech support sent me and make it public too? I spoke with my money, I'll never buy their over priced, over hyped shit products again.

Consumers speak with your dollars. Corsair go belly up, so I don't have to shop around you anymore.


With all du..no, with all credulity, Kyle's comment is directed at the posters whom seem to be missing the forest through the trees.

Sure, Corsair is a company, like many others, even just like [H]OCP (In a sense, as in it's a brand) and like all companies (and people) there will be bias... But to make light of the subject matter (exploding transistors and caps) because of one's personal adage is admittedly boasting your own stubborn ignorance.

For instance, I've used corsair products for nearly 6+ years, and I know my father has used them since, well since they started in the biz. I also know friends and coworkers who have used their products for a long time. I've used a swath of products names, types, price ranges over the years: such as OCZ, Kingston, Silverstone, Hyper, among others and some of these "budget-brands". In my experince, it's not worth skimping on any component, but least of all the power source.

When it comes to my personal equipment there are certain brands I stick with because of past experince (the basis for all prejudice) and the sum of my experince with their staff. I've personally had to RMA 2 Corsair products in the time I've done buisness with them, and both have been returned expediently--what I found more than odd is that the two which needed to be RMA'd were bought from Brick&Mortar as opposed to etailers, which itself suggest foul-play at the stores. But such is the buisness of hardware components, it's going to happen--what matters from then on out is how the situation is handled. And in mine and many others experince Corsair likes their customers and likes their customers to keep doing buisness. After all, what company doesn't?

Now tell me, even though I've had a great experince with Corsair, what does any of the last 200+ wordshave anything to do with the fact: There ARE PSU makers/vendors who have been caught rating their goods much higher than the equipment can withstand?

Absolutely Nothing...Nada...Zilch.

Way to turn a funny video/experince into your personal campaign against a long-lived and reputable company...

Epic Fail.
 
I'd be interested in hearing why those PSU's explode so easily. I'm assuming it's partly because they use cheap caps and their circuit design sucks.

The whole PSU is junk but only three things caused it, the combination of all 3 actually, if any of the following were improved it would have a better result.

Undersized transistors
Thin heatsink
Cover off allowed this combination to overheat more, and more rapidly.

A shorted capacitor could do it, but you wouldn't generally find that happening with the PSU so new else it wouldn't have turned on (actually I mean stayed on more than ms) at all if it were defect rather than degraded caps over time.
 
Back
Top