Why 3D Printing Is Overhyped

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Here's an article explaining why 3D printing is overhyped, written by a guy that does 3D printing for a living.

The mentality now seems to be that, in the future, we'll be able to download our products or make them ourselves with CAD programs, apps and 3D scanners, then just print them out, either at home, or in localized print shops. Which in turn will supposedly decentralize manufacturing, bringing it back to the West. But like the cupcake, Daft Punk’s latest album, or goji berries, 3D printing is severely overhyped — and I should know, because it’s what I do for a living.
 
Why the guy who wrote the article is an idiot.

#1 We don't expect to make cars with them. If anything, statues, very generic items like cloths hanger hooks, and certain simple pieces or parts. We don't expect to get really good 3D printers at first, but we do expect to get something good enough to make a Warhammer toy.

#2 The materials will get better. I'm sure the plastic we'll get at first will be weak and only good enough to expect it to break. When there's a market for this, the quality of the materials will get better. Who knows, eventually we maybe able to print metal components at home.

#3 The price will drop. Once every home must have a 3D printer, the prices will come down. We know they're very simple machines, so it's not like they need to cost a lot.
 
Why the guy who wrote the article is an idiot.

#3 The price will drop. Once every home must have a 3D printer, the prices will come down. We know they're very simple machines, so it's not like they need to cost a lot.

I can probably count on one hand in my lifetime how often I've needed something so minor that it could be printed. Look, if I wanted cheap shit made out of plastic, I'd order it from some Chinese importer and get some cheap shit made out of plastic with no cost other than shipping.

For people that want to print figurines, model parts, or for engineering, sure It'll be a household item. But for even the average person, won't ever be. It's like an expensive Stand style mixer. Sure everyone *could* use one, but very few people really do, and those that do would buy one.
 
Look at how we've gone from dot-matrix printers to the beautiful poster size glossy photo prints we can do now at Kinkos.

It won't be right away, but I am confident that as the technology progresses we will be able to make bigger items that will be more durable. And you can create very big items if you break it into pieces that can be connected.

And the potential for 3D printing is to eventually very much exceed the strength to weight ratio that is possible with injected molded plastic.

The reason is simple, you can create solid hollow shapes with a 3D printer, something that is not possible with casting where you can only make half and then have to join the pieces which weakens and or makes the structure heavier.

Its not overhyped at all, as long as you have the expectation that this will be revolutionary in 2023, not 2015.
 
#3 The price will drop. Once every home must have a 3D printer, the prices will come down. We know they're very simple machines, so it's not like they need to cost a lot.

Not gonna happen any time soon. If I need a 25 cent refrigerator magnet, I'll buy a 25 cent refrigerator magnet instead of printing one(hell, I just have plan old magnets on my fridge).

You mention being able to print something good enough to work as a warhammer figure. Sure, I agree there's a use for that. However that's one hell of a small niche that actually shows a reduced overall cost once you factor in materials plus the printer compared to just buying warhammer figures and models.

Until we're printing food, diapers, and other every day needs at an extremely low cost without needing to be used for 10+ years to see the savings over buying completed products at retail, these will remain a niche and simply not be a mainstream in-home item.

Yes you can print warhammer figures. Yes you can make RC car parts. You can also make crappy guns, crappy toys, little plastic widgets like tablet and phone stands, etc. but none of that is stuff needed or even wanted by the general public.
 
we have some high end fridge side 3d printers here and it takes a day or more to complete a building model, and they are quite fragile...not a perfect process yet, still a ways to go for that
 
it's like making your own ice cream or bread.

Some people make it home while others would rather pay to have it done for them.
 
For people that want to print figurines, model parts, or for engineering, sure It'll be a household item.
Especially as laser scanners become cheaper. Need to make a 120% exact replica of your dong as a valentine's present to your loved one on short notice? No problem, scan and print! The possibilities are endless, and the instant-gratification of rapid production immensely appealing.
 
Especially as laser scanners become cheaper. Need to make a 120% exact replica of your dong as a valentine's present to your loved one on short notice? No problem, scan and print! The possibilities are endless, and the instant-gratification of rapid production immensely appealing.

With gift ideas like these, I'm disappointed that it's not yet possible to print a new significant other who has better gift ideas. o_O
 
it's like making your own ice cream or bread.

Some people make it home while others would rather pay to have it done for them.

More like printing your own photo's at home instead ordering the prints on line or printing them out at some store.

As for making your own ice cream that's different. Home made ice cream is actually better than what you buy in the store :)
 
hating on 3d printing is like hating on imagination imo.
like how can u not see the potential in literally creating something into the third dimension from a mere pixelated idea?
maybe im being harsh actually, but i mean.... mannn all i kno is, once u got a sample u can always cast that and use another material. SCIENCE!~!@!#!$!@#!@
 
As an Architect, I can safely say this guy doesn't think beyond 3-4 years. Just imagine 30 years from now what 3D printing is going to evolve to.
 
well 3d printers have been around a long time, I think most of what he says is correct unless there's some breakthrough in plastics which I don't see happening any time soon.
 
As an Architect, I can safely say this guy doesn't think beyond 3-4 years. Just imagine 30 years from now what 3D printing is going to evolve to.

Giant ones you can print buildings and cars on. it wont just be printing guns, it will be printing tanks and drones! :eek:
 
As an Architect, I can safely say this guy doesn't think beyond 3-4 years. Just imagine 30 years from now what 3D printing is going to evolve to.

as an engineer think what other processes can evolve to in 30 years :eek::eek::eek::eek:

3D printing is absolutely amazing but buy a 3D printer to print out a clothes-hook seriously?

situation a
Printer is cheap but plastic is expensive
End result?
Cheaper to get a mass produced injection moulded part

situation B
Printer is expensive but plastic is cheap
end result
Cheaper to get a mass produced injection moulded part
 
I can probably count on one hand in my lifetime how often I've needed something so minor that it could be printed. Look, if I wanted cheap shit made out of plastic, I'd order it from some Chinese importer and get some cheap shit made out of plastic with no cost other than shipping.

People said the same thing about the computer 35 years ago too. You don't need it it will never be anything more than a fad etc. 3D priniting IMO is in the same stage where it is big, bulky or not cost efficient but down the road it is quite possible for it to become more of a household item. Broke your spatula? You have a 3D printer that pops one out in 20 minutes.

While it might not get there the possibility is that if it becomes cheaper, easier to use, and use better or even multiple materials the growth of it is quite possible.
 
People said the same thing about the computer 35 years ago too. You don't need it it will never be anything more than a fad etc. 3D priniting IMO is in the same stage where it is big, bulky or not cost efficient but down the road it is quite possible for it to become more of a household item. Broke your spatula? You have a 3D printer that pops one out in 20 minutes.

While it might not get there the possibility is that if it becomes cheaper, easier to use, and use better or even multiple materials the growth of it is quite possible.

I'm pretty sure computers are a fad. They'll get replaced by something better sooner or later just like we replaced fires with ovens and ovens with microwaves. They're just a longer running sort of fad. 3D printing is pretty similar in that sense. It'll get replaced by something else like *cue sci fi moosic* nanofabrication!!!!
 
Criticizing a technology in its infancy for not being ready for the big leagues. Fucking moron.
 
More like printing your own photo's at home instead ordering the prints on line or printing them out at some store.

As for making your own ice cream that's different. Home made ice cream is actually better than what you buy in the store :)

Didn't the chef/cook who used to work at Google say they used the 3d printer to make noodles?
 
I see 3D printers kinda like a drill press or a lathe. Not everyone will have one but people who need one will have one because they'll be affordable. I can see them being very useful for people into robotics for example. you can design things like gears, arms etc and other robot components.
 
hating on 3d printing is like hating on imagination imo.
like how can u not see the potential in literally creating something into the third dimension from a mere pixelated idea?
maybe im being harsh actually, but i mean.... mannn all i kno is, once u got a sample u can always cast that and use another material. SCIENCE!~!@!#!$!@#!@

If you're casting a mold from the printed part and making the final part with another material, you aren't 3D printing anymore are you? That was pretty much the point of the article. 3D printing is good for prototyping, not for mass production.
 
I'd really love to get into 3D printed parts for my own inventor side. I have dozens of ideas for tools/etc.

Calling up a place to get a prototype of the most simple thing made when using injection molds is around $5,000.00 min tooling and $10,000 min order. And thats China.
 
3D printers have been around for quite a while so kinda funny they've hit this critical mass in pop media presumably because of printable gun parts - which have also been around for a long time.
 
I see 3D printers kinda like a drill press or a lathe. Not everyone will have one but people who need one will have one because they'll be affordable. I can see them being very useful for people into robotics for example. you can design things like gears, arms etc and other robot components.

this, there will be consumer 3D printers but not everyone will have one, to the guy that said Criticizing a technology in its infancy for not being ready for the big leagues. Fucking moron.

do you have any idea how long 3D printing has been around for? its not really in it's infancy any-more, you don't seem to understand that there are fundamental issues regarding 3D printing that simply cannot be resolved. one does not simply print out a 3D sculpture, you actually need the 3D cad file, someone needs to make that and 3D modelling takes time to do and to learn. Are you really going to spend 5 hours designing and modelling that clothes hook and then spend another 5 hours printing it out when you can buy it for at the dollar store?
 
The more hype, the faster the end-goal replicator comes to be.

The applications surrounding 3D printing are still very new ground, over hyped? Intangible.
 
Who ever said 3d printing has to stay limited to plastic?

Well, what other materials do you want to print?

Wood: Kind of difficult since it has to grow from living things. Maybe if you want to glue sawdust together with a resin?

Paper: What's the point if you could?

Metal: That's what we really want, right? The melting point of steel is about 1370C. Aluminum is about 660C. Sure, you can use a powdered form - which is messy, but then you have to heat it until it fuses. That means an industrial laser or plasma arc. Hot and dangerous process. Not going to happen in your living room, and even if you do 3D print it, it's not as simple as that. There are many types of steel - carbon, stainless, alloys of all kinds, and same with aluminum. You won't ever see the strength from forging for certain, and because you're basically welding metal powder onto the resultant solid, the thermal variance is likely to cause varying placement of soft and brittle spots. Not all alloys could work with this kind of process, some melt at higher temperatures, and all have to be heat treated if you want to have any semblance of even hardness and temper, which means you'll need a kiln. You'd be better off with a milling machine.

Now if they can find a way to effectively print carbon fiber cheaply that will change things, but right now it's not viable. That pretty much leaves plastic for the short term, along with all its shortcomings.

Bottom line: Give it some time. 3D printing is great for custom prototypes or one-of-a-kind small parts. The technology needs to advance before more sturdy stuff can be made with it.
 
I see 3D printers kinda like a drill press or a lathe. Not everyone will have one but people who need one will have one because they'll be affordable. I can see them being very useful for people into robotics for example. you can design things like gears, arms etc and other robot components.

Yea I'd agree with the above although I'd say even less market appeal as it will have a higher learning curve.

Well, what other materials do you want to print?

Wood: Kind of difficult since it has to grow from living things. Maybe if you want to glue sawdust together with a resin?

Paper: What's the point if you could?

Metal: That's what we really want, right? The melting point of steel is about 1370C. Aluminum is about 660C. Sure, you can use a powdered form - which is messy, but then you have to heat it until it fuses. That means an industrial laser or plasma arc. Hot and dangerous process. Not going to happen in your living room, and even if you do 3D print it, it's not as simple as that. There are many types of steel - carbon, stainless, alloys of all kinds, and same with aluminum. You won't ever see the strength from forging for certain, and because you're basically welding metal powder onto the resultant solid, the thermal variance is likely to cause varying placement of soft and brittle spots. Not all alloys could work with this kind of process, some melt at higher temperatures, and all have to be heat treated if you want to have any semblance of even hardness and temper, which means you'll need a kiln. You'd be better off with a milling machine.

Now if they can find a way to effectively print carbon fiber cheaply that will change things, but right now it's not viable. That pretty much leaves plastic for the short term, along with all its shortcomings.

Bottom line: Give it some time. 3D printing is great for custom prototypes or one-of-a-kind small parts. The technology needs to advance before more sturdy stuff can be made with it.

Agree with the above. You go have some wood filament mix now but I don't see it getting much better.

As far as people talking about the future I have to think of some other big changes that came out before this. Look at cnc mills and laser engravers with the cnc machines being older. You don't see them crossing over to more mainstream setups for home users although options do exist for them. I remember in like the late 90's the hobby market talking about the laser engraver's/ cutting tables.

Don't get me wrong, I'd love to buy a 3d printer to tinker with. If I had the space I'd love a 2 axis cnc or laser cnc machine too. I personally think that 3d printers will remain out of reach for your standard end user for a very long time.
 
I agree some folks need to calm down and take a step back but yes it will improve.

I remember a time when blank CD-Rs cost nearly $8 a go and 9 times out of ten you ended up with a coaster.
 
My employer recently purchased a 3D printer and gave it to me. This is not a cheap printer either, it cost about the same as a small-mid size vehicle and it has a layer resolution of 0.0100. While I believe it is a very amazing device it does require a certain skill set to be able to model, print, and troubleshoot 3D models and the printer itself. Your average Joe six-pack is not going to have the expertise to operate a high-quality 3D-printer.

A lot of 3D models out there are complete garbage, and although they may look great visually they will be chalk full of reversed normals, zero-thickness geometry and missing faces.

Case in point: I recently found a great looking 3D model of a Timber Wolf / Mad Cat Mech online. Sure it looked great but it took me 4-5 hours just to fix the problems with the model to get it to a printable state. I first printed a 3-inch test print which took 8 hours, and then I printed the 6 inch model which took 22 hours. The large model took another 8-10 hours in a wash station to remove most of the support material.

Here is a pic of the printed mech:
6 Inch Mech
 
Yeah its amazing how many people lose all enthusiasm for actually testing their stuff. All in such a hurry.

Testing is boring but looking an incompetent moron is even worse I believe.
 
I have to admit, having used several stratasys printers over the past years in school and in industry, I do think they are overhyped. Sure, there is potential for advancement, but as it is, its great tool for rapid prototyping and scaled model manufacturing. It is almost always more cost and time effective to use another means of producing parts in small quantities and most definitely on large quantities. Printing cars and buildings and other multi-material large scale items is just plain ridiculous.

And for printing using metal, as far as I can tell, that has also been around for some time now. I have seen stents and joint replacement cup bushings made from the process, but never the machines themselves.
 
This is like how the studios want to ban dvd burners. #D printers can make mickey mouse heads so disney will try and ban them.
 
This is like how the studios want to ban dvd burners. #D printers can make mickey mouse heads so disney will try and ban them.

But if I can buy the real deal for $5 rather than go to the trouble and time of asking someone to make me one on a 3D printer.....you know their time to design it, test it, spend the hour or two to print it, finish it, paint it.....Great mine for $300 and it doesn't look as good as the one made in China for 0.20c!

You see how folks have got this all wrong?

3D printing is for single prototype mock-ups not cheap mass-production. Sure you can make a shape to then create a mold for mass production but that's only a small part of the process.

I don't think Disney are too worried at this stage.
 
I'd really love to get into 3D printed parts for my own inventor side. I have dozens of ideas for tools/etc.

Calling up a place to get a prototype of the most simple thing made when using injection molds is around $5,000.00 min tooling and $10,000 min order. And thats China.
Getting molds or dies made for a prototype is unwise for many many reasons.

Look into cnc machining centers for prototyping. Flexible, cheap, shorter cycle times and not limited to any particular material.
 
"Daft Punk’s latest album..... is severely overhyped... I'm sure he mistakenly meant AWESOME!!!
 
Back
Top