Which processor to get??

StArGaZeR

Weaksauce
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
119
I'm building a new computer soon and I want to here some thoughts you guys have on what I have narrowed it down too. These 2 systems are basically the same except for motherboard and processor. I plan to run Vista Ultimate on whichever one I build, so should I go with the AMD model or the Pentium?? Thanks.

AMD Model

CASE: Hot New! X-Cruiser Mid-Tower 420W Case W/ WINDOW, MultiMeter Display & Control (Silver Color)
CPU: (Socket AM2) AMD Athlon™64 3800+ CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology
MOTHERBOARD: (Socket AM2)MSI K9N4 SLI-F nForce 500 SLI Chipset DDR2/800 SATA-II RAID MBoard w/ Dual 16x PCI-Express
MEMORY: 1 GB PC6400 DDR2/800 Memory (Corsair Value Select or Major Brand)
VIDEO CARD: NVIDIA GeForce 7300 GT 256MB 16X PCI EXPRESS (Major Brand Powered by NVIDIA)
HARD DRIVE: Single Hard Drive (80GB SATA-II 3.0Gb/s 8MB Cache 7200RPM HDD)
Optical Drive: (Special Price) 18X DVD±R/±RW + CD-R/RW DRIVE DUAL LAYER (BLACK COLOR)
SOUND: HIGH DEFINITION ON-BOARD 7.1 AUDIO

Pentium Model

CASE: Hot New! X-Cruiser Mid-Tower 420W Case W/ WINDOW, MultiMeter Display & Control (Silver Color)
CPU: (Sckt775)Intel® Pentium® D 945 Dual-Core CPU @ 3.4GHz 800FSB 2x2MB L2 Cache EM64T
MOTHERBOARD: ECS 945P-A I945P Chipset LGA775 1066FSB DDR2/667 SATA Dual 16X PCI-Express Platform W/7.1Audio, GbLAN, &USB2.0
MEMORY: 1 GB PC6400 DDR2/800 Memory (Corsair Value Select)
VIDEO CARD: NVIDIA GeForce 7300 GT 256MB 16X PCI EXPRESS (Major Brand Powered by NVIDIA)
HARD DRIVE: Single Hard Drive (80GB SATA-II 3.0Gb/s 8MB Cache 7200RPM HDD)
Optical Drive: (Special Price) 18X DVD±R/±RW + CD-R/RW DRIVE DUAL LAYER (BLACK COLOR)
SOUND: HIGH DEFINITION ON-BOARD 7.1 AUDIO
 
You're aware that you can get a core duo e6300 for the same price as that pentium D right? pentDs are hot, power hungry, and overpriced for their performance.
 
OK I just did a little research on the AMD processors. Here are the 2 I looked at:

AMD Athlon™64 3800+ CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology
and
AMD Athlon™64 X2 4000+ Dual-Core CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology

What I read says that these both operate at 2.4 GHz. I'm not sure how or why one is better than the other or why either of them would be better than a Pentium 4 running at 3.4 GHz ??
 
Clock for clock, Core2duo is more efficient than the Athlon 64 X2 which is more efficient than the Pentium 4 / D.

Pentium D is terrible for the price. Buy a Core2duo E6300 or E6400, and you're set.

Also, I recommend a reputable Boutique integrater vs the shitty ones. It'll cost more, but ti will pay itself off in no time flat.

Ditch the "420w" psu and pick up a good quality unit. Seasonic is a good choice.
 
OK I just did a little research on the AMD processors. Here are the 2 I looked at:

AMD Athlon™64 3800+ CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology
and
AMD Athlon™64 X2 4000+ Dual-Core CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology

What I read says that these both operate at 2.4 GHz. I'm not sure how or why one is better than the other or why either of them would be better than a Pentium 4 running at 3.4 GHz ??

3800+ A64 is single core, 4000+ X2 is dual core and has 1MB L1 cache as well. Either will process more efficiently than a P4, but C2D will process more efficiently than any of them.
 
Ok so let me get this straight...

This processor: Intel® Core™ 2 Duo E6300 CPU @ 1.86GHz 1066FSB 2x1MB L2 Cache EM64T

is better, stronger, faster than any of these processors...

Intel® Pentium® D 945 Dual-Core CPU @ 3.4GHz 800FSB 2x2MB L2 Cache EM64T
or
AMD Athlon™64 3800+ CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology
and
AMD Athlon™64 X2 4000+ Dual-Core CPU w/ HyperTransport Technology


if that is the case, then the speed listed in GHz isn't always better if it's higher??
I guess I'm having trouble understanding how a 1.86 GHz is going to out perform a 3.4 GHz
 
GHz as a factor of CPU performance no longer applies. It's more of a marketing ploy than anything else. I don't know what it's at these days, but a few years ago AMD XP did 9 operations per clock cycle and Intel P4 had 6, so if you used two CPUs with the same clock speed the AMD was actually processing more efficiently. Core clock speed still helps you determine which processors will run faster, but it's not a good gauge of which processor will run better.

Also, keep in mind that 1.86GHz is the speed per core. I'm not for certain but I don't believe they used this labeling scheme for the D line.
 
Well you can blame part of that misunderstanding on Intel.

Yes the Ghz does not matter much. It's the architecture, efficiency and effectiveness of the CPU that matters.

Best do some research on Wikipedia about CPUs.

Oh and what is your budget?
 
It used to be a good benchmark that an AMD 3400+ would run about as fast (or faster) as a P4 3.4ghz. Ghz nowdays doesn't really mean anything though, unless you are comparing chips from the same exact line. For instance, a core 2 duo 1.83 ghz is slower than a core 2 duo at 2.16ghz. However, a core 2 duo 1.83ghz is faster than a P4 3.0ghz. Look for benchmarks and superpi scores rather than gigahertz, and you'll see the differences immediately. Core 2 Duo is the fastest proc on the market right now, and like others have said, the Pentium D series is worthless.
 
I'm trying to stay under $1000 as far as budget goes. I can see where a C2D at 1.86 GHz per core would out perform a P4 3.4GHz, if in fact that is the way it works. I think I can switch to this mobo and processor combo, leave everything else the same, and still stay under budget....

Intel® Core™ 2 Duo E6300 CPU @ 1.86GHz 1066FSB 2x1MB L2 Cache EM64T
and a
MSI P965 Neo-F P965 Chipset LGA775 Supports Core 2 Duo CPU FSB1066 DDR2/800 Mainboard w/GbLAN,USB2.0,&7.1Audio
 
You can build a much better system for under $1000-

Intel Core 2 Duo E6300 - $187.00
GIGABYTE GA-965P-S3 Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express - $108.99
G.SKILL F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ 2 x 1GB 240-Pin DDR2 800 RAM - $184.99
SAPPHIRE 100176L Radeon X1950PRO 256MB PCI-Express - $184.99
Seagate Barracuda 7200.9 160GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s - $57.99
NEC Black DVD Burner - $29.99
XCLIO GOODPOWER 500W ATX 500W Power Supply - $51.99
COOLER MASTER Centurion 5 CAC-T05-UW ATX Case - $49.99
-----o
Total: $855.93 without tax and shipping.

All of these parts are the best bang for the buck parts out there. In the build I suggested, you get a better motherboard that is great for overclocking, 2 gigs of DDR2 800 Ram, more robust and stable power supply, better graphics card, and bigger hard drive compared to your build.
 
Everything you said is true but my budget also includes Vista Ultimate, which is why I have to go with lesser hardware in most instances.
 
Everything you said is true but my budget also includes Vista Ultimate, which is why I have to go with lesser hardware in most instances.
Danny's build is still better than your original choices. His build totals out to $856, and you also want Vista Ultimate, which is $200, putting you overbudget. So, since your original vidcard choice was a 7300GT and Danny's was the X1950Pro, dropping down to either a 7300GT or 7600GT ($100AR) should still put you under budget.

Dropping to 1GB puts you at:
$200 - Microsoft Windows Vista 32-Bit Ultimate DVD - OEM
$187 - Intel Core 2 Duo E6300 Conroe 1.86GHz
$109 - Gigabyte GA-965P-S3 Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express
$100 - G.Skill 1GB (2x512MB) DDR2-800 F2-6400CL5D-1GBNQ
$100 - eVGA 256-P2-N550-T2 GeForce 7600GT 256MB ($120 - $20MIR)
$58 - Seagate Barracuda 7200.9 ST3160811AS 160GB 7200 RPM SATA300 8MB Cache
$52 - XClio GoodPower 500W ATX 500W
$50 - Cooler Master Centurion 534 RC-534-KKN2-GP Black
$31 - NEC 18X DVD±R DVD Burner 7170A-0B
=========
$887 + tax and shipping (after rebates)

But if you can afford it, go for this 2GB kit instead:
$185 - G.SKILL 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2-800 F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ

And if you really want the 7300GT instead, then go for it:
$70 - evga 256-P2-N443-LX GeForce 7300GT 256MB
 
Everything you said is true but my budget also includes Vista Ultimate, which is why I have to go with lesser hardware in most instances.

Well if you buy an OEM version of Vista Ultimate at $199, you will only be $50 over budget.

To save $65, just go with this graphics card -
eVGA 256-P2-N615-TX GeForce 7600GT 256MB PCI-Express - $124.99

Now you are just under $1000.

If you want to save $14, then go with this power supply -
XClio 450BL ATX 450W Power Supply - $37.99

To save an additional $9, go with this CPU -
Intel Core 2 Duo E4300 - $177.99
 
Back
Top