which one would you go with?

Jzabi

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 25, 2007
Messages
104
Not knowing what your plans are for the board, the second board would be my choice. My reasoning is minimal price difference, dual and triple channel memory capability, added JBOD raid function, and more onboard USB ports.

All in all, both boards are extremely similar.
 
DFI seems like a solid board and you can run the RAM in triple channel (6 slots). In that price range, you might also want to take a look at the ASUS P6T.
 
Also (just to make sure). It does do 3 way SLI, right? Because I would love to put three GTX 285's in here eventually.
It does indeed. In fact, it says so right beneath the name when you look at that Newegg page.
 
lol I see now. I am just so used to going straight the the specs tab, and I didn't see it there.
 
Ah, I was probably thinking about the Deluxe.
The P6T Deluxe does not support 3-way SLI altogether due to the slot spacing. All X58 motherboards support a maximum of 16/8/8 without the NF200 chip, and 16/16/16 with it. There is no such thing as a 16/16/8 tri-SLI configuration.
 
The P6T Deluxe does not support 3-way SLI altogether due to the slot spacing. All X58 motherboards support a maximum of 16/8/8 without the NF200 chip, and 16/16/16 with it. There is no such thing as a 16/16/8 tri-SLI configuration.

My Gigabyte X58-UD5 supports 16/16/8...
From Newegg:
3 x PCI Express 2.0 x16 (x16, x16, x8)
 
My Gigabyte X58-UD5 supports 16/16/8...
From Newegg: 3 x PCI Express 2.0 x16 (x16, x16, x8)

All that tells you is that there are 3 PCI-E 2.0 slots of types x16,x16 and x8. Doesn't tell you what happens when you have 3 cards plugged into the slots. Most boards that support Tri-SLI/Crossfire, do x16-x16 in two way SLI, and then x16-x8-x8 when three cards are used. Its an X58 chipset limitation, which is why the nf200 was mentioned.
 
All that tells you is that there are 3 PCI-E 2.0 slots of types x16,x16 and x8. Doesn't tell you what happens when you have 3 cards plugged into the slots. Most boards that support Tri-SLI/Crossfire, do x16-x16 in two way SLI, and then x16-x8-x8 when three cards are used. Its an X58 chipset limitation, which is why the nf200 was mentioned.

So running 2 cards will allow for speeds of x16 and x16, but three cards are x16, x8, and x8? 3-way SLI lowers the speed of the second slot from x16 to x8?
 
So running 2 cards will allow for speeds of x16 and x16, but three cards are x16, x8, and x8? 3-way SLI lowers the speed of the second slot from x16 to x8?

Correct, unless you have an NF200 in the path way, which is a whole different ballgame and doesn't make much of a difference with current video hardware.
 
So running 2 cards will allow for speeds of x16 and x16, but three cards are x16, x8, and x8? 3-way SLI lowers the speed of the second slot from x16 to x8?
The x58 chipset has 36 PCI-E lanes, so there is only enough for 16/8/8 operation in tri-SLI mode. 16/16/8 would require 40 lanes, and 16/16/16 requires 48 lanes (the NF200 provides the extra 16 lanes by splitting one of the 16x slots into two 16x slots).
 
The x58 chipset has 36 PCI-E lanes, so there is only enough for 16/8/8 operation in tri-SLI mode. 16/16/8 would require 40 lanes, and 16/16/16 requires 48 lanes (the NF200 provides the extra 16 lanes by splitting one of the 16x slots into two 16x slots).

Thanks for the explanation. Learn something new every day. I haven't any experience with SLI/Crossfire so it's good to know. :)
 
I personally don't like Gigabyte, mainly because they often offer a crippled BIOS (don't know if they changed on that with the X58 chipset). But, I do trust ASUS for excellent motherboards with decent BIOS options. Since I bought the Asus P6T Deluxe V2, I can safely say that it is one big notch better and more solid than my previous buy, which was a DFI Lanparty NF4 Ultra (which was TOP at the time). The only thing I don't like about the P6T that I have is that I didn't find a way to set my two WD drives in RAID 0 while keeping my two Samsungs in their regular NON RAID setting. I think it's something that the ICH10R controller can't do, but maybe it's ASUS that don't offer to support SELECTIVE RAID setups. But otherwise, I love the ASUS, it's a very solid board, worth the money paid for sure.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131365
 
Last edited:
I personally don't like Gigabyte, mainly because they often offer a crippled BIOS (don't know if they changed on that with the X58 chipset). But, I do trust ASUS for excellent motherboards. Since I bought the Asus P6T Deluxe V2, I can safely say that it is one big notch better and more solid than my previous buy, which was a DFI Lanparty NF4 Ultra (which was TOP at the time). The only thing I don't like about the P6T that I have is that I didn't find a way to set my two WD drives in RAID 0 while keeping my two Samsungs in their regular NON RAID setting. I think it's something that the ICH10R controller can't do, but maybe it's ASUS that don't offer to support SELECTIVE RAID setups. But otherwise, I love the ASUS, it's a very solid board, worth the money paid for sure.

I mix and match drives using a RAID config on the ICH10R (P5Q Pro). I haven't had a problem with it seeing non-member discs and member discs together.
 
I mix and match drives using a RAID config on the ICH10R (P5Q Pro). I haven't had a problem with it seeing non-member discs and member discs together.

Thanks for the tip, I'll see what I can do about this. :p
 
I personally don't like Gigabyte, mainly because they often offer a crippled BIOS (don't know if they changed on that with the X58 chipset).

This makes zero sense.


OP, I'd go with the first link if your budget is 200$.
 
I personally don't like Gigabyte, mainly because they often offer a crippled BIOS (don't know if they changed on that with the X58 chipset). But, I do trust ASUS for excellent motherboards with decent BIOS options. Since I bought the Asus P6T Deluxe V2, I can safely say that it is one big notch better and more solid than my previous buy, which was a DFI Lanparty NF4 Ultra (which was TOP at the time). The only thing I don't like about the P6T that I have is that I didn't find a way to set my two WD drives in RAID 0 while keeping my two Samsungs in their regular NON RAID setting. I think it's something that the ICH10R controller can't do, but maybe it's ASUS that don't offer to support SELECTIVE RAID setups. But otherwise, I love the ASUS, it's a very solid board, worth the money paid for sure.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131365

My trust for Asus was shattered with A8N-SLI Deluxe. Gigabyte has had excellent bios based overclocking and there was nothing wrong with their bios. If you have to hit a key to get to hidden settings, that's not crippled. You overstated the issue greatly.

The Gigabyte UD3R simply has more bang for buck value. Costs significantly less and offers up the same feature set and easily matches the P6T for overclocking.
 
My trust for Asus was shattered with A8N-SLI Deluxe. Gigabyte has had excellent bios based overclocking and there was nothing wrong with their bios. If you have to hit a key to get to hidden settings, that's not crippled. You overstated the issue greatly.

The Gigabyte UD3R simply has more bang for buck value. Costs significantly less and offers up the same feature set and easily matches the P6T for overclocking.

I found this GA-EX58-UD3R thread, for anyone who's interested: http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1378776
 
The A8N-SLI wasn't that great of a board. Their intel boards are much better IMO.
 
Back
Top