Which Hard Drive for NAS/Home Server?

Jesse B

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
May 30, 2010
Messages
1,631
I'm planning on building a computer this summer to act as a home server/NAS/etc. combo. I'm wanting to store all of my movies, plus other files, on this server, and have them accessible from any of the computers on my network. I'd also like to be able to stream video/music to my PS3.

I've got the motherboard, CPU, and RAM already. I'm ordering a case and PSU pretty quick here as well. The last thing I need is Hard Drives. I plan on running software RAID from within Linux at this point in time. I will also be upgrading to a gigabit network shortly.
I don't need a whole lot of space, but I'd like no less than 1TB; 2 would be better. I don't have a lot of money right now, so I'd be fine with whatever I can get.

There's a ton of HD's out there these days, and I just can't keep track of which is for what. WD alone has the Green, Blue, Black, and AV drives. I've read that the AV drives aren't intended for use in Desktops or Servers, so I'd assume they're out of the running. I've heard rumors that the 1.5TB and 2TB drives aren't the most reliable things out there? Is this true? They seem appealing due to their excellent gigabyte-per-dollar ratio, but if I will need to be constantly replacing them, then forget it.

For these drives, performance is much more important that energy efficiency. Reliability is my top concern.

Any suggestions are welcome. I'm open to any brand. I'd prefer the drives to be available from either www.newegg.ca, www.infonec.com, or www.ncix.com.

Thanks,


- Jesse
 
Two drives in a RAID1 is what I'm guessing that you wanna do. I've read good things about HITACHI's 2 TB drive for RAID setups. Mixed reviews about WD black series - stay away from green series for RAID. Dunno about Seagate's offerings in the 2 TB size.
 
Two drives in a RAID1 is what I'm guessing that you wanna do.

Yeah, I was going for either RAID1 or RAID5 with 3 disks. But again, just wasn't sure, as it kinda depends on the size and cost of the drive.

I've read good things about HITACHI's 2 TB drive for RAID setups. Mixed reviews about WD black series - stay away from green series for RAID. Dunno about Seagate's offerings in the 2 TB size.

Heard anything about Samsung drives? The one I was looking at had pretty decent reviews and was pretty cheap, but none of the reviews were really long-time owners. I'll have to look at some Hitachi drives; never really struck me as a reliable brand, but lately I've been hearing lots of good things about them. I've heard of a fairly high failure rate for the blacks, and the greens just don't seem right for this setup. I was looking at the Blue drives if I went with WD. Seagate seems to have really bad reviews on their newer drives, don't know what's up with them.

Thanks for the input :)
 
Which PSU? Which case?

I was just looking at a cheap-o Rosewill for the case. It's mATX, looks decent, 2x 120mm fans, good reviews overall, and cheap. It's gonna be tucked out of the way, so the fact that I can just put 2 fans in there with tons of airflow, and fit up to 4 internal 3.5" HD's, I'm pretty happy with what it has to offer.
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811147112

As for the PSU, I was gonna go with a Corsair 400CX most likely. Seems to be the cheapest low-wattage PSU I can find that's still reliable.

Oh and go with the Hitachi or Samsung drives.

Alright. Any specific models, or are they all pretty much good?

Thanks,


- Jesse
 
Alright, I looked at some Hitachi and Samsung drives, and have it narrowed down to a few.

Hitachi Deskstar 7K2000:
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822145298
$129.99

HITACHI Deskstar HD32000:
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822145276
$149.99 + $20 MIR

SAMSUNG EcoGreen F3 HD203WI:
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822152202
$139.99

I'm liking the Samsung, because it has great reviews and is nice and cheap, but the 5400RPM worries me a bit. How will this affect my performance? How does the performance between these 3 drives vary? Any suggestions?

Thanks,


- Jesse
 
The 5400RPM will affect your performance but not as much you think: That Samsung drive performs just as fast as many older 7200RPM drives circa 2008. So despite the lower RPM, the better and newer design of the Samsung allows it to have pretty good performance.
 
The 5400RPM will affect your performance but not as much you think: That Samsung drive performs just as fast as many older 7200RPM drives circa 2008. So despite the lower RPM, the better and newer design of the Samsung allows it to have pretty good performance.

Hmm, well in that case the $140 2TB Samsung drives seems to be the winner for my system. Thank you very much.
 
Back
Top