Which 500GB drive to get?

plasma

Gawd
Joined
Apr 6, 2004
Messages
647
I'm going to order a 500GB hard drive, and was wondering what you recommend? I've pretty much narrowed it down to these:

WD RE2 5001ABYS

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136205

WD AAKS

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136073

Seagate 7200.11 ST3500320AS

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148288

or the ES.2 version for a few dollars more

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148294


I'm really leaning towards the the first one since the RE and RE2 series drives have a 5 year warranty from what I understand, and the RE2 is rated for 1.2 million hours. I know the Seagate ES.2 is very comparable, but it's slightly more expensive, and reviews seem to claim the seagate is louder:confused:
 
I'd go with Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 ST3500320AS 500GB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA-300 Hard Drive - OEM

Segate will give you a refurbed drive if you RMA one. Thats the only issue I have w/ Segate.

I have WD's, Segates and other drives as well. I have been happy with WD also.

The segates have 32MB cache and the WD's have 16MB. I'd prefer 32, but on the other hand I'd buy WD.

Overall, go with the WD's unless you want the 32MB cache. Thats the bottom line.
 
If you're going to be RAIDing, I'd get the WD RE drives. I use Hitachi T7K500s and a WD 5000AAKS for my 500 GB drives.
 
I like this one.

Hitachi's are good, too (runs colder than Seagates).

ive got the same samsung, its a nice drive, supposedly very quiet (i wouldnt know, mine is sitting right next to two maxtors, a 120mm fan, and a noisy ass rest of a computer, but the addition of the samsung didnt add any noise)

my next hardware purchase is most likely a 750 GB F series samsung :D

back when i bought this samsung i read up on some tests, turns out this samsung isnt the best performer in any scenario, but its a damn good all-rounder and quiet too
 
I just got two of the 7200.11 500 gig AS model Seagate drives and both are working just fine. I don't really notice much performance increase over my 7200.10 250 gig and 320 gig Barracudas. I haven't done a lot of transferring of files back and forth but what I have done seems a little quicker, but it's hard to tell. Writing to the drives seems a bit faster than the 7200.10 models but again, it's hard to tell.

I don't know about noise since I have enough systems running that the noise adds up. I haven't heard the drives at all inside my Antec P182 but as I said, I have a good bit of other noise around.

Temps on them seem to be decent. They aren't hot and I don't have a fan blowing directly on them, just a 120mm fan behind them pulling air. It seems enough to keep them cool.

Overall, they seem a bit quicker than the previous generation of drives from Seagate but with how little disk intensive activity I do it's hard to get a real assessment.

I can't compare them to any other drives as the last non-Seagate drive I purchased was a WD 120gig with 8 meg cache several years back. Since then I've gotten 2 160 gig IDE Barracudas, a 250 gig SATA Barracuda, 320 gig SATA Barracuda and the 2 500 gig Barracudas. I was impressed with the 160 gig drives and ended up switching from WD to Seagate for my storage needs.

Personally, I don't think you can go wrong with the Seagates. The other drive in your list I think I might go for is the WD AAKS drive. It seems to have gotten some good reviews and has good overall performance. My latest preference for Seagate and the 32 meg cache on the Seagates is what pushed me to them.

 
So is the Seagate 500gb 7200.11 32mb cache drives much faster than the 16 mb WD raptor drives? because i have heard that the 32mb cache of the Seagates are faster than the 16mb WD raptor. But also whats the best HD for a OS. I was thinking about getting the 36gb RAptor X for Windows vista home premium 64 bit. but I'd like your opinion.

Thanks,
Mark
 
Back
Top