Which 3800+ X2?

BlackTigers91

2[H]4U
Joined
Nov 4, 2005
Messages
2,620
Okay, well I was looking forward to grabbing an e6300 and a new board, but thats not in my budget right now. So, I'm just gonna grab a 3800+ X2 in the AM2 flavor. But, I'm a tad confused.

The egg has a 65W version and a version that isn't 65W, I'm going to guess 89W? Well, which one of the two should I get? They both run within a buck of each other, and are both brand new, never used. I'm going to guess the 65W, but I'm not 100%. Thanks!
 
Get the 65W version then. It supposed to run cooler, as it consumes less power too run, which means better OC!



:)
 
they'll probably be about the same. in theory, the 65w one will be better, but due to the number of normal wattage chips amd ships, the normal version may be a better choice for a good overclocker. it's really up to you, just pick whichever one makes you and your wallet most happy ;)
 
You do realise that the E6300 is only £10 more than that X2. A good motherboard might be too much for you though :rolleyes: .
 
It's about $35 more, which in itself isn't bad, but I'd be looking at tossing another $100+ that I don't have into a board.
 
BlackTigers91 said:
It's about $35 more, which in itself isn't bad, but I'd be looking at tossing another $100+ that I don't have into a board.
wait for it then, the upgrade isnt really worth it to an X2 at this point... Sell youre current board and proc :)
 
A gigabyte DS3 is only $135 at the egg right now, I'm not sure what board you were considering for AM2 that would've been significantly cheaper than this to make the upgrade not worth it.

You always want to get the most for your dollar. Even when we're talking tight budget, C2D is still the way to go. I'm not an Intel or AMD loyalist, I just buy what's best every 1-2 years.

E6300 + DS3 = best for your money imho.
 
I have an AM2 board.... And a decent one.

I can't afford to spend $170 over my current budget, in any way shape or form. And I already know that a C2D will perform better, that I am fully aware of. But I made this thread specifically to know which one of these processors are better. The 65 or the 89W. Thanks!
 
i'm sure you can afford a c2d after a pricedrop follwing the quad core release.
 
If you have the extra $175 to lend me to get it, then so be it. I'll take your cash, and I'll buy a C2D. But at this point in time, in which I have the opportunity to get a new CPU, I cannot afford a new board and CPU.
 
I have not used or seen either of these in use but common sense would tell you the 65w version of a processor will be better than a 89w of same processor. You will have less heat output and less power consumption. I would get the 65w version IMHO
 
(cf)Eclipse said:
guys, read what he posted. he said he can't afford a c2d, so drop it :rolleyes:
Seconded. Stick to the topic please, there's a reason the OP posted in the AMD Processors subforum..
 
OP, you are gonna love your dual core.

To all the people out there that are still saying dual core isn't worth it...BAH!!!!!!
 
LOL... I'm surprised no one suggested a MAC. :p

I don't get why people are so pushy about the C2D. I'd love to have one too, but other things are more important at this point in time so I'll stick with s939 until budget allows.

to the OP: You already have an AM2 board? Do you also have DDR2 ram? Is it running right now (with a different AM2 processor)? Understandably, if you already have an AM2 board (and DDR2 memory), the logical upgrade (cost effective) would be an AM2 processor. Had you owned an older system (slower than PC3200 DDR), a C2D system would be the better bang for the buck. The logic that fails me is if you already had the mobo (and ram), why don't you have a CPU for it already? Buying the "CORE" system components (CPU/MOBO/RAM) at different stages probably costs more in the long run. If you already have a CPU? is it rated slower than the 3800 X2?

In my case, I wasn't ready to dump the platform yet (s939), even though everyone who owns a Conroe keeps telling me it's dead. If I had a lesser system and needed new RAM anyway, I would have gone C2D instead of staying with s939.
 
My system is in the sig, but for those of you with sigs disabled...

3200+ Orleans AM2
MSI K9N Platinum
2GB DDR2-800 (4-4-4-10)

So, I have the processor, board and RAM, I'd just like a little speed bump. I figure a dual core will give me one, so the 3800+ X2 it was. :).
 
i was curious why you didn't look at the 4200? Places like ZipZoomFly, are offering free shipping on it, and its $179.... its just a tiny bit over your budget, but even faster.

Just a thought.

Good luck and enjoy your purchase!
 
Frys Electronics runs a deal every 2 weeks or so for a e6300 at $149. Last week they had it at that price... keep your eyes peeled they should be selling it again in a week or so. $149 also includes the crappy ECS mobo but you can just buy an aftermarket motherboard.
 
BlackTigers91 said:
My system is in the sig, but for those of you with sigs disabled...

3200+ Orleans AM2
MSI K9N Platinum
2GB DDR2-800 (4-4-4-10)

So, I have the processor, board and RAM, I'd just like a little speed bump. I figure a dual core will give me one, so the 3800+ X2 it was. :).

Then why did you give your thread that lame assed title? It's not C2D but the motherboard that you're cryin' about. Why not just title it "Is 3800+ a good Move?", "Which one's better, 65W or 89W 3800+?". "Funds limited to Processor only for an upgrade" and or etc.........................? Note, I'm looking at a 4200+ to upgrade from my 3500+ in system #2.

OT, get the 65W version, don't risk buying the lesser of the two with Overclocking being the Reason for doing so. How high you can overclock is a gamble, which will give off less heat and use less power is NOT. The 65W version also have minor errata fixes according to one of my AMD buds. Also wait a couple of weeks for the 65nm versions.

Please make your posts AMD centric and you don't get folks defending Intel? That leads to you getting the info you really need quicker. If that's the intent of your post.
 
I really didn't want to see you in here, Donnie. I stated that I couldn't afford one and I was wondering which AMD to buy. Which, by the way, is clearly in the first post. At least you gave an on topic response in your post, though.

Well, it looks like I'll be going for the 65W version.
 
BlackTigers91 said:
I really didn't want to see you in here, Donnie. I stated that I couldn't afford one and I was wondering which AMD to buy. Which, by the way, is clearly in the first post. At least you gave an on topic response in your post, though.

Well, it looks like I'll be going for the 65W version.


I would like to take this opportunity to apologize on behalf of our species for their constant stupid, ignorant bullshit in your thread.

You will richly enjoy your 65W X2 3800+ I'm sure. Have fun!
 
nullzero said:
but you can just buy an aftermarket motherboard.
The Fry's deal would be good if he could A) wait for it again, B) lived near a fry's or knew someone that did that could pick it up for him. However, your last suggestion of getting another mb would put him way over his budget.

....unless he did more saving while waiting for that fry's deal...but when you have the itch it gets hard to wait ;)
 
BlackTigers91 said:
I really didn't want to see you in here, Donnie. I stated that I couldn't afford one and I was wondering which AMD to buy. Which, by the way, is clearly in the first post. At least you gave an on topic response in your post, though.

Well, it looks like I'll be going for the 65W version.

I wasn't trying to be a jerk or anything and your question didn't need to mention of Intel IMHO. BTW, you're welcomed:) Even if you had to, its the Processor and Motherboard you can't afford, not just the processor as you said.

Let's try it this way? What if the thread went like; "Hey guys which would makes more sense? I have limited funds or about $175. So my upgrade is limited to getting a X2. I can't afford C2D and Motherboard. Should I get the 65W or 85W 3800+?"
Then you get NO posts like the ones defending C2D's value or etc..

I'm not in NO WAY trying to jump you here. I'm well aware of my rep here as well. You asked a good question and the thread also deserves a better title since many folks ask me that same question. I think I told something like 12 out of 15 to stick with their AMD rig if money was tight. The other 3 I advised to get a better video card. NONE of them were told to get an Intel system. Surprised?
 
If you want to overclock, get the 89W one, as reviews I've seen have shown that even though they run cooler, the 65W ones have to have their voltages raised a lot, and quickly lose their energy efficiency advantage. If you'll never overclock, might as well get the 65W one.
 
If you want to overclock, get the 89W one, as reviews I've seen have shown that even though they run cooler, the 65W ones have to have their voltages raised a lot, and quickly lose their energy efficiency advantage. If you'll never overclock, might as well get the 65W one.

That's what I read as well, all the Brisbane preview/review articles said the 65W parts were inferior overclockers. If you're going to stick to stock speeds then they have advantages, otherwise if you're going to OC go with the 89W.
 
Back
Top