When VPN is not Private at All

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
The Register is reporting that PureVPN is rolling over on those that it is saying that it is protecting.


And that's where the surprise came in – at least for those who believed a VPN is a complete protection: “Significantly, PureVPN was able to determine that their service was accessed by the same customer from two originating IP addresses,” claim the Feds (allegedly, those IP addresses were at Lin's work and home addresses).

If you are going to go with a VPN, make sure you go with one that does not keep any records.
 
I guess purevpn should change their privacy policy.
"We Do Not monitor user activity nor do we keep any logs."
 
This should not be a suprise, right on their site they have this as also mentioned in the article.

Information Sharing and Disclosure
PureVPN specifically chose Hong Kong (HK) for its headquarter because there are "No Mandatory Data Retention Laws" in Hong Kong
We are therefore, not legally obliged to store user data and share it with anyone. Since PureVPN is committed to freedom, and doesn't support crime, we will only share information with authorities having valid subpoenas, warrants, other legal documents or with alleged victims having clear proof of any such activity. It goes without saying that we will only do so in the best interest of our customers and our company. When and if a competent court of law orders us or an alleged victim requests us (that we rigorously self-assess) to release some information, with proper evidence, that our services were used for any activity that you agreed not to indulge in when you agreed to our Terms of Service Agreement, then we will only present specific information about that specific activity only, provided we have the record of any such activity.

Source:
https://www.purevpn.com/privacy-policy.php
 
Honestly, you can't say "We aren't legally obliged to store user data and share it with anyone" then flip that around and say "we will only share information <for some reason>" - that's a bit ridiculous.

If they're not storing any user data then they wouldn't have anything to share in the first place, or did they not seem to grasp that aspect of the situation? And then go so far as to point out "used for any activity" then counter that with "specific activity only," geez, do these people even comprehend the stuff they're putting in these agreements to begin with? :D

I get that some people will nitpick it to say user data and user actiivity aren't the same thing but since the two aspects are intrinsically combined they are literally the same thing in this kind of situation. If it's data of any kind that can lead directly back to a given user then it's user data by definition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HoffY
like this
Honestly, you can't say "We aren't legally obliged to store user data and share it with anyone" then flip that around and say "we will only share information <for some reason>" - that's a bit ridiculous.

If they're not storing any user data then they wouldn't have anything to share in the first place, or did they not seem to grasp that aspect of the situation? And then go so far as to point out "used for any activity" then counter that with "specific activity only," geez, do these people even comprehend the stuff they're putting in these agreements to begin with? :D

I get that some people will nitpick it to say user data and user actiivity aren't the same thing but since the two aspects are intrinsically combined they are literally the same thing in this kind of situation. If it's data of any kind that can lead directly back to a given user then it's user data by definition.
suppose its a time frame issue? started keeping records after being compelled?
 
Then they - meaning the VPN provider - would be legally obliged to report that and change their terms of service, at least that's my opinion on it. I know some actually lawful orders come with a gag on it to not reveal it's in place, like during an active investigation, but after that if the provider goes back and does "business as usual" then I think that's somewhat two-faced personally and if I found out about it happening then obviously I wouldn't be a customer and I'd make it known as far and wide as I could.

Of course, we all know full well that VPN providers are getting hammered with such legal requests all the time so again, none of them are fully trustworthy in this day and age for many of those reasons.
 
From reading TFA, the feds really wanted this guy.

"However, the complaint revealed, he made a fundamental error by using a work computer for some of his campaign, and even though he'd been terminated and the OS reinstalled on the machine, there were footprints left behind for investigators to associate Lin with the 16-month campaign against Smith."

Sounds like they did a full forensic recovery on the computer and examined his former employer's network logs as part of the investigation.

If he did what he is accused of doing, glad they caught him.

Important safety tip: Don't use work resources to conduct your illegal activities.

2nd safety tip: Fully examine your VPN TOS and PP.
 
PureVPN is crap anyway. When I went to Australia recently I tried to use their phone vpn so I could safely use unsecured wifi for pictures etc. The client was terrible, would always pick US servers and not Aussie servers. I called support and basically they showed me how to manually pick an Aussie server by manually using the VPN client built into my Pixel phone. All in all a terrible service. I switched to VyperVPN and they are fantastic.
 
This isn't the mob. You're not "rolling over" when you get a big ass legal nuke tossed your way by the feds. That's what they get for keeping logs.

And even if they didn't keep logs, if they're a US company (or one that operates in a nation with cooperative law enforcement) they will start logging when a judge rolls up and tells them to. Because the moment the cops figure out the only thing standing between them and they guy they're trying to catch is some anonymizing service? Yeah. Good fucking luck with that.

Simply put: you can't use a VPN to hide from the feds. And the guy in this case? Fuck that guy creepy ass doxing stalker assklown.
 
I don't use VPN's for privacy, but I do use VPN's so that websites show I'm from so-and-so location. You can't hide from whatever and whoever wants your data. However, you can give them vast amounts of fake data, making whatever data they collect pretty much useless.
 
suppose its a time frame issue? started keeping records after being compelled?

Perhaps, but that does have a certain vibe to it. Imagine getting an order to start keeping records on your neighbors, business associates, or friends.
 
I would probably restate that as saying if you choose to use any VPN make sure that when you do realize that none of them are truly secure and your info is always susceptible to compromise or being revealed. I don't fully trust any VPN service of any kind, never have, never will, but they do serve some purposes (region block work-arounds, etc) - if anyone ever thinking they can get away with basically anything using a VPN without there being consequences later, those people should be paying more attention to what's going on around them.

That's why you need to VPN your VPN .. like a VPNception!


But seriously. If you're up to illegal things where the FBI might be issuing warrants to try and track your identity, you should probably be a tad bit more thorough in your obfuscation than just a VPN.
 
VPN is pointless if you go about and use your normal accounts to do anything else. If you checked your email through a VPN there is a log at your email server that has you checking it from a VPN even if the VPN doesn't store it's logs someone can find you were on that VPN and what address was assigned to you at that time. Any website you visit will log you came from a particular VPN provider. Then it's a simple matter of connecting the dots.

Don't believe any company that says they don't keep logs. They all have to have logs, the question is really how long do they keep them for. A VPN might not keep them long, but if you are law enforcement you only need to do is get a court order to make them retain the logs then wait for the suspect to do what it is you think they are doing again and then work backwards and you can trace them. A VPN service is just like any other business, once compelled to by court order they will be required to keep logs for law enforcement for as long as needed. So they are not lying when they say they don't keep logs, but they do clearly state in most ToS that they fully comply with law enforcement and court orders.
 
I researched PureVPN when I first went VPN shopping.

I decided against using them because they were Hong Kong based and way too close to China Telecom for my liking.

This is the problem with VPN's. It's a matter of putting your trust in what they say without much to back it up.

I use PIA today. They claim they don't keep any logs, but I have no way of verifying that. My only source of comfort comes from the fact that any VPN service that is found to violate the trust of their users will wind up losing users hand over fist, so it is in their best interest this doesn't happen.
 
I guess purevpn should change their privacy policy.
"We Do Not monitor user activity nor do we keep any logs."

Nothing about forwarding activity/logs to a third party for monitoring and storage.
 
I don't use a VPN to do illegal stuff. I use it so that when I'm on a public network (hotels, airports, public wi-fi) my shit isn't subject to collection by that system and possibly others, since you never know if an app is encrypted or not. As for this guy, I can only say that i"m glad they caught him. As for those saying they use them to get across country lines, I have a soon to expire sub to VPN unlimited and that never works for me. If I'm out of the country, there's no way for me to access U.S. Netflix content from there, though I can typically renew downloaded subs. Now I could finish setting up my router/phones/tablets to use my home router as a vpn, and I think that'd work, but I haven't tried it yet. The plus side of being somewhere else is that if you watch network TV, there's a decent chance that your favorite show is on Netflix outside of North America.
 
If you have to do it, prepaid visa card for a private server to do as you please... never your own box, never your connection. Get a throwaway box from goodwill and crack some wifi the use your server for whatever.
 
I don't use a VPN to do illegal stuff. I use it so that when I'm on a public network (hotels, airports, public wi-fi) my shit isn't subject to collection by that system and possibly others, since you never know if an app is encrypted or not. As for this guy, I can only say that i"m glad they caught him. As for those saying they use them to get across country lines, I have a soon to expire sub to VPN unlimited and that never works for me. If I'm out of the country, there's no way for me to access U.S. Netflix content from there, though I can typically renew downloaded subs. Now I could finish setting up my router/phones/tablets to use my home router as a vpn, and I think that'd work, but I haven't tried it yet. The plus side of being somewhere else is that if you watch network TV, there's a decent chance that your favorite show is on Netflix outside of North America.

At this rate you don't know if your VPN provider inspects that same traffic you are trying to protect from being potentially accessible on a public network. If you're primarily not using it for circumvention of region blocks and such you definitely want to host your own VPN server in which case at least you know what's going on with it. I think some custom router firmware have VPN support or use something like pfSense for VPN (or all around firewall, router, vpn, etc).
 
At this rate you don't know if your VPN provider inspects that same traffic you are trying to protect from being potentially accessible on a public network. If you're primarily not using it for circumvention of region blocks and such you definitely want to host your own VPN server in which case at least you know what's going on with it. I think some custom router firmware have VPN support or use something like pfSense for VPN (or all around firewall, router, vpn, etc).
You're always trusting someone (assuming it's not HTTP/SSH/SFTP). In theory Comcast, TWC, Verizon or AT&T are trustworthy, but in practice you can't be sure. I worked at a telecom and like all telecoms, we keep a ton on customers (calls, locations, data sessions and so on), just in case the local, state or federal officials send us a subpoena for data.

However, we didn't always require a subpoena, and I heard a co-worker tracking someone in his family and there's nothing that'd prevent someone from doing that for stalking purposes. What's more, in other places, they can probably track all of your SMS and MMS (i.e. text and picture messaging). I don't think we kept voice mail once deleted, but that's beyond the scope of what I'd see. I can't remember if we could pull up the sites of where a customer browsed, but I'm pretty sure it was in the CDRs, so it'd get sent to a database for however long the law requires (gotta be at least 18 months, but don't know the law).
 
You're always trusting someone (assuming it's not HTTP/SSH/SFTP). In theory Comcast, TWC, Verizon or AT&T are trustworthy, but in practice you can't be sure. I worked at a telecom and like all telecoms, we keep a ton on customers (calls, locations, data sessions and so on), just in case the local, state or federal officials send us a subpoena for data.

However, we didn't always require a subpoena, and I heard a co-worker tracking someone in his family and there's nothing that'd prevent someone from doing that for stalking purposes. What's more, in other places, they can probably track all of your SMS and MMS (i.e. text and picture messaging). I don't think we kept voice mail once deleted, but that's beyond the scope of what I'd see. I can't remember if we could pull up the sites of where a customer browsed, but I'm pretty sure it was in the CDRs, so it'd get sent to a database for however long the law requires (gotta be at least 18 months, but don't know the law).

Yeah, amen to that. With ISP we kind of know they have the data and logs so it'd be foolish to assume it is secure but if you have a secure tunnel between say websites, at least they won't have the communication. Of course they will at minimum know which sites you're going to. Though IMO I'd trust my ISP more than some random VPN service which is not even hosted in the USA. All the NSA spying crap aside, outside the country they can do whatever the heck they please with your data. Obviously if you're doing something criminal then this is something desired but otherwise I'm not sure sure. So I still think given the choices it's best to run own VPN server if you need secure communication when using public networks if you really have to.
 
Back
Top