What makes nForce so special?

InorganicMatter

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Oct 19, 2004
Messages
15,461
I don't understand what makes nVidia's nForce boards so special. Besides the fact that the new ones support SLi, what makes them so special?
 
:) I'm trying to decide on my next purchase, and I would like to know beforehand what I am buying. So....thanks, but that doesn't help.
 
nothing 'special' about it exactly. they do have nice sata controller implementation (with a few weird bugs)

the nforce boards tend to have lots of nice integrated features; sata, hardware firewall, gbit ethernet, etc.
 
I think the reason most poeple really like the nforce boards is simply because they aren't VIA...a lot of people have had some pretty bad experiences (myself included) with older via boards and they're drivers. The nforce drivers are usually seen as being more stable.

Given that reason, and the fact that the performance is almost identical between the chipsets with the a64, is why most people really like the nforce boards.
 
gmkmay said:
I think the reason most poeple really like the nforce boards is simply because they aren't VIA...a lot of people have had some pretty bad experiences (myself included) with older via boards and they're drivers. The nforce drivers are usually seen as being more stable.

Given that reason, and the fact that the performance is almost identical between the chipsets with the a64, is why most people really like the nforce boards.


yup yup. i'll never buy a VIA board ever again.
 
nForce is 'special' because it typically outperforms the VIA chipset (which is the other popular, stable chipset) in almost all applications, particularly gaming. When coupled with an nVidia GPU-based video card, the performance gap widens even further.

You also get an arguably better SATA/RAID and software IDE controller, as well as an onboard hardware firewall (with nForce 3 250-Gb) which is a feature that I really like.

One might also argue that nVidia updates and optimizes their chipset drivers much more often than VIA, albeit at the expense of some bugs in some implementations.
 
Thats strange, I have a MSI K8N Neo2 Platinum and an ABIT AV8 and all the benchmarks I ran with the AV8 were higher(3dMark, DooM 3,UT2k4). About a 400pt difference in 3dMark 2k3 and a 5fps difference in DooM 3.
 
Via boards are much better than they used to be but still they occasionally have an issue, recent problems with an AGP/PCI lock that didn’t work springs to mind, they used to be a royal pain.
Sis board are pretty darn good recently... Some interesting designs and there was an ECS SIS board that was legendary for cheap good performance just before NF-2 came out and blew everyone away.


But, 2 years ago, if you were an AMD fan (and I am one), the NF-2 boards came out and set new standards in overclocking with some vendors, Abit in particular in the early days, with overclocking options not normally seen before. First to market on the AMD side with duel channel memory didn’t hurt either. It was cheap, it worked well and it would run like a scalded cat. There is nothing like getting a 133 MHz fsb processor to run at 200 fsb to make a lasting impression.

So I can’t say for anyone else, but I love them for the fact that they are relatively cheap, dependable, typically overclock well if the vendor made any effort at all, and have a proven track record. However removing soundstorm has annoyed me, being a cheap SOB I don’t want to pay for a sound card but want onboard sound that I can pipe through my stereo without the speakers tossing their cookies. So while I am biased to nForce from past experiences (damn ABit and their crappy bios upgrades) I am pretty open minded as I look at my AMD 64 upgrade but all things being equal would go with Nforce based on my personal past good experiences with them.

Oh and the fact they came out of nowhere and blew everyone away for a couple of years on the graphics side (God I wish I had bought stock) didn’t hurt their reputation in my opinion.
 
There are basically only two main choices for AMD processors. VIA and NVIDIA. I owned two VIA chipset motherboards. Both were made by ASUS, so you would expect them to be of high quality. I guess I didn't learn the first time. My friend bought an ASUS VIA board for his Pentium III. LOL. It was junk too. I will never buy a VIA board again. NFORCE is more stable, has better features, better support, better overclocking, better overclocking features, better drivers, and generally higher performance. IMO, Nforce is the best in every way and it was a defining moment in AMD's history when it was introduced because for the first time AMD was on equal terms with Intel when it came to reliability, compatibility, and stability. Nforce. There is no substitute. :)
 
The last Via based board I used was a 133A. I will never again use a Via chipped motherboard, period. The issues with their old Athlon chipsets, and their inability to fix them through several chipset generations, lost them a customer. The USB, PCI, and data corruption problems ensured that.

I've had no problems with the NForce chipsets. I'm also looking forward to what ATI can produce for AMD processors, too.
 
Joining this conversation late but I just have to add this: Why in the hell do I have to run Rivatuner and fiddle with low level system settings (hello, AGP fastwrites?) to get an nForce 3 chipset (Gigabyte K8NS in this case) and an Nvidia 6800GT to get along in DirectX apps?

Does this not strike anyone else as retarded? Not to mention the fact that I cant even run World of Warcraft in DirectX without weird "hangs" that do not present themselves if I switch over to OpenGL mode.

Ya, nForce is cool and has a nice feature set but I am very VERY seriously considering yanking this mobo out and replacing it with a VIA chipset for my A64 for better directx compaibility. Just FYI
 
Bop said:
Thats strange, I have a MSI K8N Neo2 Platinum and an ABIT AV8 and all the benchmarks I ran with the AV8 were higher(3dMark, DooM 3,UT2k4). About a 400pt difference in 3dMark 2k3 and a 5fps difference in DooM 3.

There's some odd benchmark differences between VIA K8T800pro boards and NF3 250 boards... Anandtech has been documenting these lately. VIA boards tend to overperform ever so slightly in games and 3dmark yet the results don't hold up in other benchmarks where the NForce3 scores better. NF3 scores particulary better on the HD benchies, not that it has anything to do with this...

Either way I don't think the small performance gap is anything you should base your desicion on. Heck, between these two I wouldn't even base the desicion on the chipset alone but on the specific manufacturer implementation as well (be it MSI, Abit, ASUS, etc.). Sometimes that counts a lot more towards stability than the actual chipset...

Via does have a notoriously shaky past, their drivers seem to have matured extensively but it's hard to shake their storied history. NVidia's driver teams have always been an asset, both for their mobos and vid cards. Without it they wouldn't be where they are.

P.S. AGP/PCI locks on A64s were a problem for both NVidia and VIA early on. Hence NF3 150 -> 250 and K8T800 -> Pro.

P.S.S. mantmax1, I don't know all the particulars of your dilema here but I think Gigabyte may be more at blame than NVidia in this case...
 
this might be pointless mostly because nforce is now all 939 and doesnt have this issue but with the 754 boards the nforce had the advantage in its north to south bridge communication (something like one chip to manage it instead of two i cant remember its been a while) but it seems like the nforce 4 boards are just sexy as hell and ive always been happy with nvidias support (with the exception of adding macrovision support to their newer video card drivers)
 
Actually, there are still NF s754 boards coming out... Even NF3 ones, 'least Abit's is (they're always late to the party, lousy sense of timing imo :rolleyes: ). Think there's a few s754 NF4 boards coming out too though, not sure what the incentive is but anyway... I mean, they do add PCIe to S754 but the price premium of S939 procs is like what, $10 over S754 now?
 
sac_tagg said:
I don't understand what makes nVidia's nForce boards so special. Besides the fact that the new ones support SLi, what makes them so special?
Because Nvidia is well known for their good drivers and hardware :p I had an Nforce 2 chipset with my first AMD CPU setup. Absolutely trouble free from start to finish. There goes the compatibility problems with non-intel motherboard/cpu myth :p This time I tried VIA and they're pretty good and match the Nforce line. But when I finally make the jump to PCI Express, I am going back to Nvidia because their chipets have tons of added features which I like.
 
Back
Top