What keeps you from using Vista RC2 full time?

Zorn

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
452
Well, given that we are at the last build before RTM, when people will actually be expected to use the OS day in and day out, and that not much will change now, what are the main things that keep you from switching to Vista full time?

For me the clear answer is no SLI support in nVidia drivers, since Vista sees my 7950GX2 as one card with 512MB RAM, and gives away 271 MB of my system memory to the video card. I can't put it on my Media Center PC because there is no driver support for the nVidia DualTV MCE tuner card that came out 6 months ago. Considering that the number of TV tuner cards that are actually in popular use is pretty small, it's sad the Microsoft/nvidia have not felt the need to write the driver.
 
lack of compatible software and drivers,especially PVR card drivers that work.This should change rather quickly as launch date for business is very near unless it's delayed.
 
BIGDADDY51 said:
lack of compatible software and drivers,especially PVR card drivers that work.This should change rather quickly as launch date for business is very near unless it's delayed.

This should have changed over the very long and open beta phase. I guess these companies seem to think its fine to beta test their driver when the OS goes final, instead of during the testing phase so a polished, ready driver could be released at RTM.
 
Too lazy to install it on my backup system.....
Main system will stay xp till it goes final and I test it on said backup system....

With me I just haven't had time to really sit down and mess with it much. Also xp is stable so I'm not worried about it. The only time I've even used a beta os as my main system was with windows 2000. I was running nt4/98se dual boot at the time and 2000 was just so much better then both of them. Hall all the new features of 98 and was stable like nt4.
 
Zorn said:
Well, given that we are at the last build before RTM, when people will actually be expected to use the OS day in and day out, and that not much will change now, what are the main things that keep you from switching to Vista full time?

For me the clear answer is no SLI support in nVidia drivers, since Vista sees my 7950GX2 as one card with 512MB RAM, and gives away 271 MB of my system memory to the video card. I can't put it on my Media Center PC because there is no driver support for the nVidia DualTV MCE tuner card that came out 6 months ago. Considering that the number of TV tuner cards that are actually in popular use is pretty small, it's sad the Microsoft/nvidia have not felt the need to write the driver.

You sure about that giving system memory to the card? Because you know your XP is doing that too with AGP Aperature size. Just doesnt flat out say it. Try turning down aperature size and see if it goes down. It should
 
Flyboat said:
I agree. Vista doesn't support lot of old hardwares.

old? i was talking about new stuff
most aps that use drivers like deamon tools and Alcohol120%

and oh sound card , and video dirvers are missing things and AA doesn work right

i do know this a beta but once you get the point of RCs one would think there should be nearly fully working drivers for this stuff


but back to the aps that use drivers look at deamon tools it every other build breaks it
then theres stuff like Nero not working but yea

bottem line

drivers
 
I've been running XP 64 bit at work for the past year, and these comments sound exactly like those in the 64 bit forums. The difference is XP 64 bit was always a niche OS, not for the casual user (although many like me have adopted it and use it very productively after working out hardware issues). Vista (at least 32-bit) OTOH is expected to be adopted by millions out of the gate. Having been in public beta for months now, you'd think manufacturers would be on it... unless, for some reason, they're expecting you to buy new stuff to go with your new OS. Legacy support isn't going to make them as much money as forcing you to upgrade your hardware.
 
Laziness :p

I installed Vista RC2 on my main PC as dual-boot but I still needed to find the sound card driver and install the usual apps I use under XP...

At work, I wanted to install on my PC but I cannot since it doesn't support the Novell client32 software to access the corporate network. And the sucker is that Novell will release one only 60-90 days after Vista is officially released. If we want to give Vista to business users by November, it would be mandatory to have at least a working networking client since many of the businesses use Novell as the networking standard like here.
 
The question would be, what makes you use it as your primary OS? It's still in beta, with a finite usage period. Drivers aren't even close to beng final, nor is app compatibility. Furthermore, you would have had an OS previous to using RC2, that's going to waste. It's just silly at this point to run a beta OS as your primary. That's not what beta testing is all about. I have it running on a spare machine, and it's much better than before, but why even consider it.
 
djnes said:
The question would be, what makes you use it as your primary OS? It's still in beta, with a finite usage period. Drivers aren't even close to beng final, nor is app compatibility. Furthermore, you would have had an OS previous to using RC2, that's going to waste. It's just silly at this point to run a beta OS as your primary. That's not what beta testing is all about. I have it running on a spare machine, and it's much better than before, but why even consider it.

It's actually simple... Making it a primary OS give a chance to test more stuff than if you are using on a spare computer. The only thing we should know is that we must be ready to reformat and reinstall when the OS get released and that we have a official RTM/Gold DVD. Personnally, I wouldn't mind it but to avoid the hassle, that's why I made it dual-booting so I can nuke Vista when testing is no longer relevant.
 
ATi catalyst didn't work for me unless i disabled one of my CPU cores (AMD X2).
 
Xilikon said:
It's actually simple... Making it a primary OS give a chance to test more stuff than if you are using on a spare computer.
Why wouldn't you be able to test out your environment properly on a test machine? How do you think these things are tested in the IT world?
 
djnes said:
Why wouldn't you be able to test out your environment properly on a test machine? How do you think these things are tested in the IT world?

I'm speaking from a home setup... in the corporate world, I know how testing works and it involve testing computers indeed. We have 2 atm and it's basically useless without that damned Novell client !
 
I was speaking from a home setup as well. I understand not everyone has a second machine that's powerful enough to run Vista, or no second machine at all, but that's where swapping hard drives, or dual-booting comes into play. You never want to destroy your production environment for the sake of testing.
 
I would say the only reason I don't use it full time is because it's still Windows . . . (I'm a Mac guy :D) but honestly, on my server, drivers and little things like USB stuff. Whenever Vista wakes from sleep, it won't recognize my USB KBM until 10 mins later. How weird is that?
 
djnes said:
I was speaking from a home setup as well. I understand not everyone has a second machine that's powerful enough to run Vista, or no second machine at all, but that's where swapping hard drives, or dual-booting comes into play. You never want to destroy your production environment for the sake of testing.

Vista isn't my primary OS, but I think one reason one might want to make it the primary is to better learn the OS. I can't speak for others, but I don't use vista that much, because it's on my main machine (dual boot and I always seem to have something running that I don't want to stop so that I can play around with Vista.

I think you can have it as your primary (home) OS and still have your old OS sitting there just in case something goes wrong. That said, without better video drivers, I'd probably hae to reboot back to XP just to play EQ, so I'm better off running XP. Now if I could run Vista from inside XP, I'd be set :)
 
Nero drivespeed, in my HTPC the DVD drive is the loudest component, really annoying.

Unless anyone has an alternative that they would like to suggest?
 
I am using RC1 full time on my dell Insprion 9100 laptop since it came out, it has ALL drivers for everything in this sucker, wireless included!

using

Office beta 2
Netop
MSN
Trillian
Nero 7.*
F@H
MySQL Admin tools
Winamp
Divx
Quicktime
some poker clients for work

Windows it's self has been flawless, no b.s.o.d's or crashes, the only thing that gives issues once in a while is outlook, but that is to be expected. I had Aero on, but got bored of it so turned it off and the system is running as smooth and fast as XP did.
 
I haven't got any real reason not to be running it as my main desktop os at home. At work is another story.
 
I Tri-Boot it with WinXP Pro SP2, and Fedora Core 6 Pre-Release x64.

I like Vista, it works pretty well, but FC6 and my MacBook running OS X are nicer OS' in my opinion, and WinXP has that game/app compatibility for the retail stuff that OS X and FC6 don't supply (like, games I mean). I haven't tried to game on Vista because of lack of support for SLI, but that's on it's way and it isn't MS' fault either, it's the companies that are making the drivers. Creative sucks at this too, 2.1 reproductive drivers suck and they time out on me in like 2 more weeks, screw that Creative, I want to test Vista, not worry about my drivers.

I like Vista a lot, it's smooth, it's pretty, but I still like OS X better full time, and when I want to feel like I'm using OS X on my Desktop, I use FC6, when I want to game I use XP, when I want to learn and test I use Vista.
 
djnes said:
I was speaking from a home setup as well. I understand not everyone has a second machine that's powerful enough to run Vista, or no second machine at all, but that's where swapping hard drives, or dual-booting comes into play. You never want to destroy your production environment for the sake of testing.

I fully agree with this statement... What I meant is that I use Vista as primary but I have 2 backup ways in case something wrong happening and this is the dual-boot XP Pro on my main and a 2nd PC (media/file server) running XP Pro as well with full access.

Using Vista as the sole OS on a single PC would be foolish unless you do basic stuff like internet surfing, word processor or light gaming (flash/solitaire/etc...).

The meaning of "Primary" was lost during our discussion and I wanted to restore the definition there ;)
 
For me, driver compatibility and because I don't trust it until people have a serious look at all the integrated DRM. XP Pro runs like a champ for me at this point and for me, stability is where it's at. I've just been through hardware hell and back recently and have no desire to be working on getting my primary machine stable again with new software.
 
Well for me VISTA RC2 is perfect. There is no problem with Drivers or any thing.

I have my HDTV Wonder installed by using Kram Drivers, RAID 0 is not a problem, Video card is not a problem, Ani-Virus is Free :D.


I mean it is perfect, i don;t see any reason why not. I have it install on my Laptop and Desktop both have Core 2 Duo Processors in it.

Trust me it is as beautifull as it can get. Windows never looked better than this :D
 
RC2 works great for me but there are a few relatively minor issues still..

Driver:
No Nvidia control panel for Vista (cant overclock or adjust graphic settings at all)

Games:
EQ2 randomly exits to desktop without errors or anything.. debuggers indicate probably a memory access attempt that isnt allowed in vista bit its hard to say for sure.

SWG - runs great but humanoid faces are displayed with a garbage texture instead of the correct one (technicall a driver issue also)


Overall it tends to have more stable FPS in my games.. I do set it to disable Aero Themes and Desktop Composition when it loads a game though.
 
I run it as my primary OS at home ..and have installed on a dozen comps on my "gaming" computers in the little comp lab I run at a school for troubled teens .. so far so good ..

on home comp tho .. onboard sound drivers for my An832-SLi deluxe mobo work , but I dont have have 5.1 surround anymore ..

 
It's beta. It's not finished yet.

Would you drive a car across country with a prototype brake system on it?

I have enjoyed testing Vista, and I think it's somewhat exciting to get a peek at what the future has in store for us, but the fact is, it's beta.
 
No PDF printing with either PDF995 of PDFCreator, on the desktop or the tablet. Really, really bad sound drivers on the desktop. General software incompatibilities. Niggling hardware incompatibilities with certain buttons/features on my Tablet. Vista's a great OS, but everything just works in XP.
 
Dual booting killed my last hard drive and i havent tried vista since(beta 1 and i was happy with that!).


I was thinking of dual booting again but..

In vista ALL of my drives are labeled different letters than in XP, it gets very confusing and throws everything off for me. Anyway to solve it?
 
LstOfTheBrunnenG said:
No PDF printing with either PDF995 of PDFCreator, on the desktop or the tablet.
Try CutePDF. Also free and it seems to be working for me on RC2


Headbust said:
In vista ALL of my drives are labeled different letters than in XP, it gets very confusing and throws everything off for me. Anyway to solve it?
Except for the boot drive (for obvious reasons) you can change the drive letters freely in the Disk Manager. Right click "Computer"=>Disk Management. Right click the drive you want to change and click "Change drive letter and paths". It's the same as WinXP basically.
 
RC2 is my main OS with only 1 problem, torrents shut down my internet. Other then that I dont have any other issues. Games runs smooth and all my trading programs work great.
 
I find it fascinating how I've been fortunate enough to avoid all the issues people have had with torrents and Vista. For some reason everything just works fine for me with uTorrent and RC1/RC2 =)
 
There really isn't a whole lot of reason for me not to use it. Digitally signed drivers in the x64 version isn't entirely cool though. . . otherwise, all my hardware was detected (including my Theater 550 Pro tuner). I have run it for 3 or 4 days at a time, but its still not set up perfectly like my Windows XP installation is, so I don't bother with it.
 
Back
Top